- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Human motions are represented as a set of editable action words, each describing an action's content, style, body part, and timing. These words can be extracted from an existing motion clip, or generated from text. The editing adds, replaces, shifts, or removes action words before decoding the modified set back into motion. The evaluation experiments are mostly about whether the requested edits succeed while preserving other actions and maintaining motion quality.
Critical strengths
This paper gives individual actions an explicit, reusable representations, providing a useful interface for editing motion at the action level. The same representation supports both captured motion and generated motion through a shared decoder. The evaluation measures editing success together with preservation and physics quality. The insertion and replacement results support the befinits and practical usefulness of the action editing.
Critical weaknesses
I'm confused on whether editing regenerateds the whole clip, or preserves the original frames outside a local window. To my understanding, the default editing rules can affect more than the selected action. Move may shift other concurrent actions, while Delete may remove matching actions elsewhere in the clip. Currently I cannot find clear descriptions of whole-clip regeneration and preservation of the original frames outside an edit window. For deletion restricted to the selected time span, the paper reports lower success but does not provide the full preservation and motion quality results.
Questions for authors
I want to know which quantitative results and visual examples regenerate the entire clip, and which copy the original frames outside an edit window. For the existing span-only deletion variant, I want to see the report about editing success, preservation of other actions, boundary smoothness, or foot skating on clips with repeated actions. Such evaluations can better strengthen the practical usefulness of this method.