- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
MotionSCM introduces a motion generator with explicit, editable coordination rules between joints. A latent-conditioned structural decoder supports mechanism interventions, while gain constraints ensure bounded rollouts and intervention effects under stated assumptions.
Critical strengths
The explicit coordination rules provide an interesting way to control and study generated motion. The paper supports the design with theoretical guarantees, propagation controls, and structural ablations, while maintaining competitive generation quality across three datasets. The scope of its causal interpretation is clearly stated.
Critical weaknesses
The main cross-joint response is measured only over frames 6–25 of a 180-frame sequence (Sec. 4.2), and its magnitude depends on low-ROM filtering (Table A3), although action rankings remain correlated. Full-sequence results would help clarify how these effects develop over time. I consider this a limitation of the analysis rather than a major concern about the method.
Questions for authors
Why is the cross-joint response measured only over frames 6–25? Do similar response patterns persist over the full motion sequence?
3 comments
Thank you for the clarification and additional analyses. I will maintain my rating of 3.
Thank you again for your encouraging review and the helpful suggestion. We have uploaded a revised version with all changes marked in blue. We sincerely appreciate your time and kind feedback.
Response to Reviewer NMW2: Why frames 6–25, and does the response persist over the full sequence?
Thank you for your careful and encouraging review, and for your positive assessment of the method and its theoretical and experimental support. In short, we measure frames 6–25 because this window of four lag cycles covers the transition into the edited dynamics (Proposition 1). The edit's effect does persist to frame 180, as a constant shift in the other joints' mean.
Why frames 6–25. Appendix A.2.2 (paragraph "Intervention metrics", p. 20) defines this window, Wr, as the first 4k=20 solved frames after the k=5 seed frames. The four-cycle length follows Proposition 1 (Sec. 3.2). Under the same, possibly edited, solved operators and drive, the influence of the initial history is multiplied by at most gˉ every k frames, so at most gˉ4≈0.1 remains after four cycles. Empirically, on the same 2,400 pairs as Table A3, the RMS distance of the edited-minus-base difference from its steady level (its mean over frames 26–180) reaches the range it keeps over frames 26–180 by frame 25.
Over the full sequence. On the same pairs, we report mean ± SD over the 3 training seeds.
After frame 25, the edited-minus-base difference is almost entirely a constant shift in the other channels' mean, on top of their ongoing motion. Range of motion (max−min) is unchanged by a constant shift, so the late relative ROM change is small, while trajectory RMS, which we use alongside ROM (Appendix A.2.2), captures it. The per-action results of Sec. 4.2 (Fig. 5) are measured in frames 6–25, where the range of motion changes as the effect builds up.
Low-ROM filtering. As you note, excluding low base-ROM entries reduces the magnitude of relative ROM, while action rankings remain correlated (Table A3). The relative ROM column below restates Table A3. We add the trajectory RMS, which has no per-channel denominator, to check whether the size of the edit's effect also depends on these exclusions (lowest 10% or 25% of base-ROM entries, frames 6–25, mean ± SD over the 3 training seeds).
The trajectory RMS changes far less, so the size of the edit's effect does not hinge on the low-ROM entries.
We will add these tables to the appendix of the revised version, and we would be glad to discuss any remaining point. Thank you again for your valuable time and consideration.