- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Kinematic Transition Control (KTM) for training-free online human motion control with unseen objectives. KTM predicts residual accelerations from the exponentially damped extrapolated past accelerations. The residuals are estimated with K latent conditioned Gaussian transitions from a zero vector. During control, residuals are optimized by 8-time L-BFGS with regularization. KTM enable online human motion control by bypassing the feedback propagation from the network. KTM also incorporates unseen objectives as far as it is differentiable and within 8-frame horizon. The experimental results show the superiority of KTM under two conditions: 3D end-effector control and waypoints.
Critical strengths
- The control procedure is simple and computationally attractive. The learned networks are evaluated a fixed times per cycle, independent of the optimization. All objective-dependent computation is confined to a lightweight analytical map.
- On the authors' benchmark, KTM attains a high success rate while staying close to the uncontrolled model in ARD.
- The target setting is practically relevant: continual online human motion control and unseen objectives.
Critical weaknesses
Baseline fidelity cannot be verified, and no established protocol is used.
- PRIMAL-G is constructed by authors, not a part of the original PRIMAL. Its collision rate is essentially identical to uncontrolled reference. It seems that the avoidance term is not effective.
- DART-RL, retrained for this task, has a collision rate (35.04%) worse than the uncontrolled reference.
- The experimental setups like guidance strengths, step schedules, gradient paths, RL rewards, observations, and training budgets are not reported.
- Established protocols with public code exist. DART's waypoint goal reaching and path following, and WANDR's original 3D goal reaching (reported there as SR 32%, DTG 24.8 cm).
Missing comparison with existing training-free online methods
- A training-free method: DART's latent noise optimization is not evaluated. It is feasible that optimize DART-Noise online since it runs at 300 fps as the DART paper reported.
The "unseen objectives" claim is overstated.
- Non-differentiable objectives. The method requires a differentiable objective, which is narrower than recent training-free methods that handle criterion-based or black-box constraints[1].
- Conditioning on distant frames. Only an 8-frame window is optimized per cycle. Constraints beyond the window cannot be expressed.
- Perturbations. Robustness to external perturbations is not evaluated, although PRIMAL, a purely kinematic model used here as a baseline, demonstrates it.
Physics-based methods are excluded without adequate justification.
- Diffuse-CLoC[2] and BeyondMimic[3] steer a single pre-trained model toward unseen objectives through inference-time guidance in real time. The paper excludes them because they are physics-based. Being physics-based may justify not running their full systems on the authors' benchmark. It does not justify omitting them from the novelty discussion or from Table 1. The "underexplored setting" claim should be explicitly restricted to kinematic methods.
[1] Hui, Xiaofei, et al. "Training-Free Controllable Human Motion Generation Under Heterogeneous Constraints." European Conference on Computer Vision. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, 2026. [2] Huang, Xiaoyu, et al. "Diffuse-cloc: Guided diffusion for physics-based character look-ahead control." ACM Transactions on Graphics (TOG) 44.4 (2025): 1-12. [3] Liao, Qiayuan, et al. "Beyondmimic: From motion tracking to versatile humanoid control via guided diffusion." Science Robotics 11.117 (2026): eadx8924.
Questions for authors
I am ready to raise my rating based on author-reviewer discussions on these questions.
- Why was DART's latent noise optimization not evaluated, credited in Table 1 with supporting unseen objectives, and publicly available? Please report them with the iteration count capped to the real-time budget, and plot success rate and collision rate against latency.
- What motivated constructing PRIMAL-G rather than using existing training-free online controllers? Please provide full configurations for PRIMAL-G and DART-RL. Please also explain PRIMAL-G's ineffective collision avoidance and the speed gap between DART-RL and DART's reported throughput.
- Please report results on at least one established protocol (DART waypoint goal reaching or WANDR's original 3D reaching), with baseline numbers checked against the published values.
- How does KTM handle (a) non-differentiable objectives, (b) keyframes beyond the 8-frame window, (c) external perturbations to the history?
- What is the precise criterion for excluding Diffuse-CLoC and BeyondMimic, given that they provide inference-time guidance toward unseen objectives in real time? If they remain excluded, will the setting claim be restricted to kinematic methods?
10 comments
Weakness 1, 2 & Question 1, 3
W1 & Q3. Evaluation on established protocols
Thank you for suggesting the established benchmarks, which would strengthen our evaluation. To further validate our method, we additionally evaluate KTM on DART's original waypoint-reaching protocol (DART's Table 4) and WANDR's original 3D wrist-reaching protocol (WANDR's Table 1), using their published evaluation settings and metrics.
DART's waypoint-reaching protocol.
As shown in Table R5, KTM achieves 100% success rate, matching DART-RL while achieving lower foot skating (1.98 vs. 2.67 cm/s) and floor distance (2.11 vs. 2.24 cm), despite requiring no waypoint-specific training.
Table R5. Evaluation on DART's original obstacle-free waypoint-reaching protocol.
| Method | SR ↑ | Skate (cm/s) ↓ | Floor dist. (cm) ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|
| GAMMA | 95% | 5.14 | 5.55 |
| DART-RL | 100% | 2.67 | 2.24 |
| KTM (ours) | 100% | 1.98 | 2.11 |
Importantly, DART already achieves 100% success on this protocol, suggesting a ceiling in waypoint-reaching accuracy. This motivates our more challenging benchmark combining sequential waypoint reaching with dynamic obstacle avoidance, which evaluates the ability to satisfy multiple control objectives simultaneously.
WANDR's 3D reaching protocol.
As shown in Table R3, KTM achieves 82% success, 12.35 cm distance-to-goal, and 9.69% foot skating, substantially outperforming WANDR's published results despite requiring no reaching-specific training.
Table R3. Evaluation on WANDR's original single-target 3D reaching protocol.
| Method | SR ↑ | DTG (cm) ↓ | Foot skating (FS) ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|
| GOAL | 0% | 149.20 | 29.00% |
| WANDR | 32% | 24.80 | 16.00% |
| KTM (ours) | 82% | 12.35 | 9.69% |
Unlike the original single-target evaluation, our main reaching benchmark requires continually adapting to sequentially changing targets under limited time, making accurate control while preserving plausible motion more challenging.
Together, these results validate KTM on established protocols and motivate our more challenging online benchmarks, which evaluate our central contribution of flexible training-free control under changing and combined objectives.
W2 & Q1. Comparison with DART's training-free noise optimization
We thank the reviewer for suggesting this important comparison. We clarify that DART's latent-noise optimization is already credited in Table 1 as supporting unseen objectives. However, its reported throughput of over 300 FPS refers to motion generation, rather than noise optimization. In fact, DART reports approximately 74 seconds for generating 60 frames with 100 optimization steps (Appendix F). So we initially chose DART-RL as the real-time control variant. We are evaluating DART's noise optimization and will provide the results in the coming days as soon as they are ready due to our limited hardware availability.
Weakness 3, 4 & Question 4, 5
W3 & Q4. Scope of unseen objective and online control
We thank the reviewer for those insightful questions and clarify the following points:
Non-differentiable objectives. Our problem setting (Sec. 2) explicitly focuses on unseen differentiable objectives, where "unseen" means objectives introduced at inference without control-specific training. We acknowledge that MIC (Hui et al., 2026) supports broader constraints including non-differentiable criteria, but they mainly focus on offline motion generation rather than continual real-time online control. Additionally, our endpoint optimization (Eq. 7) is not inherently restricted to differentiable objectives. In principle, derivative-free optimization could potentially replace L-BFGS without modifying the learned model. However, our stated setting focuses on differentiable objectives to maintain efficient gradient-based control optimization under real-time constraints. Thank you for the thoughtful suggestion, we believe extending KTM to black-box objectives while preserving real-time efficiency would be an interesting future direction.
Short-horizon control. The 8-frame prediction horizon is a deliberate design choice for efficient and responsive online control following DART, rather than a restriction on the spatial range of objectives. For example, our reaching task includes distant targets beyond the prediction horizon, which can be gradually approached through successive control cycles. At each cycle, the current objective is evaluated over the predicted motion window, and the generated motion becomes the history for the next cycle. This enables continual progress toward distant goals while adapting to changing objectives. However, exact constraints specified at future times beyond the current window cannot be directly enforced, as acknowledged in our limitations.
External perturbations. Our KTM reconstructs the kinematic continuation from the updated motion history at each control cycle, allowing subsequent predictions to adapt to changes in the character's observed motion state. This mechanism naturally supports conditioning on the changed history, although it does not by itself guarantee recovery from arbitrary external perturbations. We note that our central contribution is training-free objective control during continual online generation, rather than physical perturbation recovery. Nevertheless, we appreciate that perturbation robustness is relevant to interactive motion synthesis, and we are conducting an additional experiment that applies perturbations during online navigation. We will hopefully provide the results in the next coming days.
W4 & Q5. Distinctions from physics-based control methods
We thank the reviewer for highlighting relevant works on physics-based control. We acknowledge that Diffuse-CLoC and BeyondMimic support inference-time guidance toward unseen objectives, as discussed in Appendix A. However, our work addresses a different setting of directly learning and controlling kinematic motion from motion-capture (mocap) data, rather than physics-based policy training or simulation. For example, Diffuse-CLoC uses a physics-based tracking method PHC+ to track and curate a subset of 54 AMASS motions in simulation with state-action data, whereas KTM learns motion transitions directly from AMASS sequences. This allows kinematic generation to leverage existing high-quality mocap datasets, without requiring extra physics simulation, motion-tracking controller, and data preparation requirements for physics-based policy learning. This distinction motivates our study of a practical reusable motion control prior that can be trained directly from existing large-scale mocap data such as AMASS.
Accordingly, Table 1 explicitly focuses on kinematic motion control methods, which directly generate motion sequences without relying on physics-based controllers during execution. While the physics-based approaches address related control objectives, they operate under different training and execution requirements and are not directly comparable within our kinematic generation benchmark. We will make this scope explicit in the setting discussion to avoid ambiguity. We also recognize the complementary benefits of physics-based methods, and incorporating physics-aware priors into our method is a promising extension, as discussed in our limitations.
Weakness 1 & Question 2
We sincerely thank Reviewer yNJx for their detailed and constructive feedback, and for recognizing the practical importance of our problem setting. We greatly appreciate your positive assessment of our computationally attractive control procedure and strong navigation performance while preserving motion plausibility. We would like to address the reviewer's questions and provide additional clarifications and experimental evidence below.
W1 & Q2. Baseline fidelity detailsWe thank the reviewer for noting these important details. Both PRIMAL-G and DART-RL are directly based on their official implementations, with only the adaptations necessary for our navigation task.
Baseline implementation fidelity.
For PRIMAL-G, we directly use PRIMAL's official code and released model with their default configurations, while only plugging our navigation objective into its classifier-based guidance (CBG) interface (the suffix “-G” stands for guidance). For DART-RL, we only adapt its original waypoint-reaching RL policy with an additional obstacle avoidance reward, while fully retaining the original model implementation. The obstacle avoidance reward is calculated as
robstacle=−∑fmax(0,,0.1−dmin(f))2,
where dmin(f) denotes the minimum signed distance between the character and nearby obstacles at frame f with a safety margin of 0.1. This encourages obstacle avoidance while preserving DART's original waypoint-reaching and motion-quality rewards.
Interpretation of collision rate.
Regarding collision avoidance, we clarify that collision rate should be interpreted jointly with waypoint success rate, because our navigation benchmark jointly evaluates waypoint reaching and obstacle avoidance. In our benchmark, obstacles are deliberately placed along the required waypoint routes to evaluate both objectives simultaneously. Methods that fail to follow these routes may encounter fewer obstacles, resulting in deceptively low collision rates. For example, the uncontrolled reference achieves only 7.63% waypoint success, so its collision rate does not indicate effective avoidance. Similarly, PRIMAL-G's collision rate alone does not establish that its avoidance guidance is ineffective, particularly given its substantially higher waypoint success (73.01%).
To further account for differences in obstacle exposure, we additionally report the proportion of obstacles approached during execution (App.) and the collision rate among approached obstacles (Coll./App.).
Table R2. Obstacle avoidance under online waypoint navigation. App. denotes the percentage of obstacles approached during execution; Coll./App. denotes the collision rate among approached obstacles.
The results show that PRIMAL-G (50 steps) achieves a substantially lower collision rate among approached obstacles than the uncontrolled reference (33.72% vs. 77.78%), despite their similar original collision rates. This clarifies why PRIMAL-G's original collision rate alone does not establish ineffective avoidance guidance. Furthermore, KTM achieves the highest waypoint success (89.19%) and the lowest collision rate among approached obstacles (20.52%), which further supports the effectiveness of our framework.
Runtime differences.
Regarding DART-RL's speed, the reported throughput is not directly comparable due to differences in evaluation settings. Our benchmark requires dynamic-obstacle scene processing and online control updates in addition to motion generation. Additionally, DART's official implementation enables mixed-precision by default, whereas our evaluation consistently uses full-precision floating point for all models. Our compared speed includes the complete online control cycle under the dynamic-obstacle navigation benchmark, rather than only motion-model generation. However, DART-RL still satisfies the real-time requirement under our benchmark.