- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2(−1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies latent collaboration in visual multi-agent systems and proposes V-Guide, a training-free framework. Agents can use a shared visual KV cache and communicate through latent reasoning states. V-Guide additionally extracts visual attention from each agent’s textual-prefix queries, applies Gaussian spatial smoothing, and constructs a geometric consensus distribution. This distribution modulates visual Value states during final answer generation. Experiments cover four multimodal backbones, five benchmarks, and sequential and hierarchical collaboration architectures. The results show consistent accuracy improvements over pure latent collaboration while retaining efficiency advantages over the evaluated text-mediated systems.
Critical strengths
- The improvements are consistent across backbones and collaboration architectures. As shown in table 1 and 5 covering three Qwen3-VL scales and InternVL3-8B, V-Guide improves all five benchmark scores over the corresponding Latent-VMAS baseline in every configuration. This consistency strengthens confidence in the method’s effectiveness and transferability.
- The training-free design has practical value. V-Guide requires neither an additional trained module nor extra visual tokens. It operates through visual-cache reuse, existing query states, and Value modulation. Figure 3 reports 1.7×–4.4× end-to-end speedups and 32%–66% fewer generated tokens relative to the implemented Text-VMAS, while maintaining efficiency comparable to Latent-VMAS.
Critical weaknesses
- The contributions of role specialization and latent reasoning are insufficiently isolated. Section 3.3 constructs agent attention distributions from textual-prefix queries rather than directly aggregating queries from latent reasoning steps. Although later prefixes can incorporate preceding agents’ reasoning, all agents share the same backbone and question. The ablations lack identical-role, redundant-role, or disabled-latent-reasoning controls. Consequently, the results do not clearly distinguish complementary-agent collaboration from aggregating correlated prompt-conditioned attention maps.
- Geometric consensus favors regions jointly attended to by multiple agents, while a low probability assigned by one agent reduces the corresponding consensus weight. The paper does not analyze cases where relevant evidence receives support from only a minority of agents, leaving unclear whether the mechanism adequately exploits specialist-specific information.
Questions for authors
- With comparable agent counts and computational settings, how does performance change when agents use identical role prompts, or when latent reasoning is disabled while prefix-attention aggregation is retained? Can these controls separate the contributions of role complementarity and latent reasoning?
- How does V-Guide perform when the decisive visual region is primarily attended to by only one agent?
Point-to-Point Response to Reviewer XoNx
We’re delighted that you appreciated V-Guide’s consistent improvements, training-free design, and efficiency advantages! Thank you for your thoughtful and encouraging review. We provide point-by-point responses below.
W1&Q1: Isolating the Contributions of Role Specialization and Latent Reasoning.
A1: Insightful comment!
i. Contribution of Role Specialization.
To isolate the contribution of role specialization, we compare three configurations: Distinct Roles (Ours), where agents perform complementary reasoning roles; Identical Roles, where intermediate agents use identical role prompts; and Paraphrased Same Role, where they share the same semantic role but use differently worded prompts. Only the intermediate agents' role instructions are varied, with all other settings held constant. We further evaluate each configuration with and without
consensus-guided visual Value modulation.As shown above, (1) Role specialization improves overall performance. Distinct Roles consistently outperform both same-role configurations, while identical and paraphrased same-role prompts achieve comparable accuracy, suggesting that the improvements cannot be explained by surface-level prompt variations alone. (2) Visual consensus is more effective with distinct roles. Incorporating visual consensus yields larger improvements with Distinct Roles (+5.76 on VStar and +3.27 on RealWorldQA), compared with +1.57–2.09 on VStar and +1.70 on RealWorldQA under the same-role configurations.
ii. Contribution of Latent Reasoning.
To isolate the contribution of latent reasoning, we introduce a No Latent Reasoning baseline that disables continuous latent reasoning (T=0) while retaining textual-prefix KV propagation, prefix-attention aggregation, and consensus-guided visual Value modulation. V-Guide outperforms this baseline on VStar and RealWorldQA, indicating that continuous latent reasoning provides additional benefits.
W2&Q2: Performance under Single-Agent Visual Support.
A2: Thoughtful question! To examine whether geometric consensus harms cases where the target visual evidence is supported by only one agent, we conduct an additional analysis on VStar using Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct. We select VStar because it provides ground-truth (GT) bounding boxes for evaluating visual localization. For each agent, we identify its top-3 attended regions from the visual attention distribution in Eq. (1), following the localization criterion in Appendix E.1. We focus on samples where exactly one of the four agents successfully localizes the GT region.
Among the 191 VStar samples, 12 (6.28%) satisfy this criterion. We compare Latent-VMAS and V-Guide on these same samples:
V-Guide corrects 5 predictions that are incorrect under Latent-VMAS, while only 1 correct prediction becomes incorrect, yielding a net improvement of +33.33 percentage points on these 12 samples. Although this subset is small, the results show that V-Guide can improve prediction accuracy even when only one agent successfully localizes the GT region.
This observation is consistent with our formulation. While geometric consensus assigns lower relative weights to regions with limited cross-agent support, it does not remove their visual information. Specifically, Eq. (4) applies bounded Value modulation with 1≤1+λwj≤1+λ, while leaving the visual Keys unchanged. Thus, minority-supported visual tokens may receive less enhancement but remain accessible to the final answering agent.
Together, these results suggest that consensus-guided modulation can remain beneficial even when the GT region is localized by only one agent, rather than necessarily suppressing such cases. We have incorporated this additional analysis and discussion into Appendix C.5 of the revised manuscript.
Thank you again for your thoughtful review! We hope our responses have addressed your concerns and would be happy to provide further clarification if needed.