- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the problem of progressive accuracy degradation across agent handoffs in multi-agent long-video question answering (MAS for long-video QA). The core hypothesis is that textual handoffs can omit visual evidence and intermediate reasoning, thereby undermining the video understanding established by earlier agents. The authors propose ViLaMAS, a training-free framework that preserves and extends multimodal context for downstream agents through KV cache transfer, autoregressive latent continuation, and evidence-guided revisiting. They also introduce the SVI baseline and validate the method on multiple video understanding benchmarks, claiming it significantly narrows the gap relative to textual handoffs. However, the method is effective only in the restricted setting of a shared frozen backbone, and lacks theoretical guarantees as well as validation across heterogeneous models.
Critical strengths
-
The authors quantitatively verified, through controlled experiments, that text-based handoffs in multi-agent systems lead to progressive accuracy degradation, providing a valuable empirical observation for the field of multi-agent video understanding.
-
Through component-wise cumulative ablations starting from SVI, the paper reveals the marginal contribution of each module, which to some extent answers the question of "where the improvement comes from."
Critical weaknesses
-
The core components are combinations of existing techniques, more akin to engineering integration than fundamental innovation. KV cache reuse/transfer and the mapping of hidden states back into the input embedding space have already been demonstrated in prior work (e.g., LatentMAS and related latent-communication methods), and similar evidence-revisiting mechanisms also appear in VideoMiner. The paper fails to clearly articulate the operational differences between ViLaMAS and these existing works.
-
The proposed method can evidently only be applied to multi-agent scenarios with shared architecture and weights, imposing a significant limitation on generalization.
-
The main experimental results (Table 1) show that the multi-agent variants (ViLaMAS) consistently underperform SVI. The paper does not clearly explain the rationale for adopting a multi-agent system at all, given that it fails to outperform the single-system SVI baseline. The motivation and added value of the multi-agent design remain unsubstantiated.
Questions for authors
-
The paper needs a formal statement and proof of the equivalence between latent continuation after KV transfer and uninterrupted reasoning, and, where possible, an analysis of how error propagates (or is bounded) as handoff depth H grows.
-
How do we know the accuracy gain comes from preserving context itself, rather than from extra latent update steps, more revisited frames, or more total compute?
-
Do SVI and ViLaMAS differ significantly in inference FLOPs, latency, and peak GPU memory? This matters for pinning down the cost-benefit trade-off.
-
In Equation 2, , the definition and form of should be given at the point where it first appears.
-
The relation between ViLaMAS-Text and ViLaMAS should also be explained at first mention (line 187).
6 comments
Response to Reviewer h42S [2/4]
W #2 The proposed method can evidently only be applied to multi-agent scenarios with shared architecture and weights, imposing a significant limitation on generalization.
Response to W2.
Thank you for your suggestion. We clarify the framework's applicability from three perspectives:
W2-1 Backbone Flexibility: We acknowledge that Full-KV transfer requires compatible architectures and shared weights. However, this constraint applies to individual agent handoffs rather than the choice of backbone. ViLaMAS can be adapted to other compatible multimodal backbones. We conducted tests on different model backbones as shown in Table R4:
Table R4: Cross-Backbone Generalization of ViLaMAS on LongVideoBench.
| Backbone | SVI Acc. (%) | Text Handoff Acc. (%) | ViLaMAS Acc. (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen3-VL-8B | 66.0 | 47.5 | 61.8 |
| InternVL3-9B | 64.0 | 49.2 | 60.5 |
| LLaVA-NeXT-Video-7B | 61.3 | 45.7 | 59.0 |
W2-2 Controlled Evaluation:
We deliberately adopt a shared backbone to isolate handoff-induced degradation from differences in model capability, enabling controlled evaluation of communication mechanisms.
W2-3 Practical Applicability:
Shared-backbone collaboration is itself a practical MAS setting, allowing specialized agents to operate through different role prompts while reusing a common model. Most mainstream MAS architectures adopt the same model architecture which simplifies deployment within compatible multi-agent systems.
W #3 The main experimental results (Table 1) show that the multi-agent variants (ViLaMAS) consistently underperform SVI. The paper does not clearly explain the rationale for adopting a multi-agent system at all, given that it fails to outperform the single-system SVI baseline. The motivation and added value of the multi-agent design remain unsubstantiated.
Response to W3:
We appreciate this concern and we will explain from motivation and value these two aspects:
W3-1 Motivation and Rationale: (1) Collaboration benefits in MAS and handoff losses are two distinct considerations in MAS and we focus on the latter: mitigate information loss when agent handoffs are part of an existing workflow. Such collaboration may be motivated by role specialization, independent verification, or tool integration, where preserving upstream visual evidence becomes essential.
W3-2 Design Value of MAS:
The value of MAS extends beyond standalone QA accuracy. MAS enables role specialization, modular extensibility, and collaborative reasoning, allowing complex tasks to be decomposed into specialized stages through flexible agent and tool integration. Recent surveys highlight the growing interest in multimodal agent systems [1-3]. However, effective collaboration relies on reliable information transfer across agents. ViLaMAS is specifically designed to address this critical bottleneck, enabling more reliable multi-agent collaboration.
We hope that it can promote the development of the multi-agent field. Thank you for your insights and suggestions sincerely.
[1] Xie et al. Large Multimodal Agents: A Survey. Visual Intelligence, 2025.
[2] Jiang et al. Towards Rationality in Language and Multimodal Agents: A Survey. NAACL, 2025.
[3] Chen et al. A Survey of Multi-Model Collaboration in Video Understanding. Data, 2026.
Response to Reviewer h42S [3/4]
Q #1 The paper needs a formal statement and proof of the equivalence between latent continuation after KV transfer and uninterrupted reasoning, and, where possible, an analysis of how error propagates (or is bounded) as handoff depth H grows.
Response to Q1:
Q1-1 Statement and Proof: Following your suggestion, we provide the formal statement and proof of the equivalence between latent continuation after KV transfer and uninterrupted reasoning as follows:
Proposition. Let denote the complete decoder-continuation state. Consider two executions of the same frozen decoder: uninterrupted continuation and continuation after KV transfer. Both append the same receiver prompt and perform latent updates using the fixed alignment map (Eq. A.3).
Assume that (i) the transferred state is exactly restored, including all-layer KV tensors, cache positions, and multimodal positional metadata; (ii) model weights, prompts, attention rules, positional conventions, and latent-update schedules are identical; and (iii) computation is deterministic and performed in exact arithmetic.
Then, for every ,
(h^{\mathrm{rest}} _{j,k},S^{\mathrm{rest}} _{j,k})=(h^{\mathrm{unint}} _{j,k},S^{\mathrm{unint}} _{j,k}). \tag{A.4}
Proof. Exact state restoration and identical deterministic prefill establish the base case:
Suppose the states agree at step . Since the alignment map is fixed, both executions produce identical next latent embeddings:
The deterministic decoder therefore receives identical embeddings and continuation states, yielding
By induction, Eq. (A.4) holds for all latent updates. The same argument applies successively to exact handoffs along an identical sequentially inherited trajectory. This proposition makes explicit the assumptions and inductive argument underlying the continuation property in Appendix A.2.2 (Eq. A.4).
Q1-2 Analysis: Regarding error propagation with handoff depth , Figure 6 provides an empirical analysis. As increases from 0 to 6, textual handoff accuracy drops from 76% to 66%, whereas Full-KV + LU maintains approximately 75% accuracy. This demonstrates substantially reduced degradation across successive handoffs. To further validate state consistency across handoff depths, we extend our experiments by comparing KV-restored and uninterrupted execution (Table R5).
Table R5: Accuracy Retention and Numerical State Consistency Across Handoff Depths on a Video-MME subset.
| Handoff Depth | Text Acc. (%) | KV-only Acc. (%) | KV+LU Acc. (%) | Relative Hidden-State Error (10⁻⁶) ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 76 | 76 | 76 | 0 |
| 1 | 72 | 77 | 77 | 1.8 |
| 2 | 71 | 75 | 76 | 2.5 |
| 4 | 69 | 74 | 75 | 2.3 |
| 6 | 66 | 72 | 75 | 2.1 |
Together, these analyses demonstrate that Full-KV + LU mitigates accuracy degradation as handoff depth increases (66% vs. 75% at ), while providing a direct assessment of numerical state consistency across successive handoffs. We add this clarification in Appendix B (revised version).
Response to Reviewer h42S [1/4]
We sincerely thank you for your time and valuable questions.
Response to W1:
Thank you for your feedback. We would like to clarify our methodological novelty and comparison with existing works:
W1-1 Innovation: Our work's novelty lies in integrating visual evidence directly into inter-agent communication and reasoning through latent-state updates, without reducing visual information to textual representations. The results of Table R1 support our innovation in integrating visual information into latent reasoning, bringing new capabilities. Meanwhile, Table R7 also demonstrates that we ensure inference efficiency while improving accuracy.
Table R1: Component-wise Accuracy Ablation on LongVideoBench (Qwen3-VL-32B).
W1-2 Comparison with LatentMAS: LatentMAS focuses on KV-based latent-state communication, but ViLaMAS focuses on addressing multimodal information loss across agent handoffs through effective visual evidence selection and its integration into subsequent latent updates. Table R2 provides detailed comparison.
Table R2: Comparison on LongVideoBench with Qwen3-VL-8B/32B. LatentMAS (SVI-based) denotes our controlled best-effort multimodal adaptation initialized from the SVI fusion state. 47.6/52.2 are new SVI-based adaptation with LatentMAS's framework.
We also conduct experiments to compare our method with conventional latent reasoning approaches across existing MAS workflows. As shown in Table R3, LU alone yields only marginal improvements across different MAS architectures. In contrast, selectively incorporating relevant visual evidence into latent updates not only enhances multimodal information preservation but also unlocks the potential of LU for mitigating handoff-induced information loss.
Table R3: LU and EGL ablations across representative MAS workflows on LongVideoBench. * means EGL w/o LU for LatentMAS-variant.
W1-3 Comparison with VideoMiner: ViLaMAS differs in two key aspects: (1) Evidence Localization: ViLaMAS targets visual evidence that distinguishes competing answer candidates after agent handoffs, rather than searching for question-relevant keyframes in a video hierarchy. (2) Evidence Integration: ViLaMAS incorporates newly retrieved frames into the inherited multimodal reasoning state through latent updates, enabling continuous reasoning and answer revision across agent handoffs.
We sincerely appreciate your constructive suggestion. As discussed above, our work offers practical engineering value while also making a fundamental methodological contribution to integrating visual evidence into latent reasoning.