- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies how to use noisy task-fMRI to predict the language recovery after stoke. They used network reserve, which captures the diversity of regional response pattern across tasks, and measurement uncertainty into the prediction. They bound uncertainty from two aspect. First, they bound the reserve interval between overlapping brain regions. They also bound prediction error by training a monotone predictor against the worst-case error.
Critical strengths
- It incorporates measurements uncertainty into training and provided bounds for reserve from uncertainty task responses. I consider this as a novelty contribution of this paper.
Critical weaknesses
- The calibration prediction with looks like a hack in the prediction process. Since a positive will always let more prediction fall within the prediction interval and contribute little to the actual prediction accuracy.
- it is not clear how the author computed the MAE from the prediction , which is an interval. It is not very obvious how to interpret the model's performance given the ambiguity.
- Some concepts needs further explanation. For example, the phrase "gain quotient" is not properly discussed and introduced some level of reading difficulties. Some words used in the result section also needs further explanation especially the ones in Figure 5.
Questions for authors
- What are all the components in your Table 2. Contribution-specific ablation? What do they mean exactly?
- What did you use to compute the MAE?
- What is point reserve in Figure 5?