- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes SCOPE, a curation pipeline that filters video by technical quality, texture and motion, then rebalances scene-subject categories, producing 27,351 training clips from about 0.6 million candidates. It also introduces GraCo-VSR, a one-step restorer with a distilled motion encoder and GT-supervised texture confidence. The paper reports improved distributional balance, benchmark comparisons, a data-pipeline ablation on a 0.1M OpenVid-HD subset, a model-component ablation, and a DOVE fine-tuning comparison between SCOPE-VSR and HQ-VSR.
Critical strengths
- SCOPE has a reproducible sequence of quality, foreground-motion, and hierarchical scene/subject selection steps. Its top three predicted topic categories account for 31.0% of clips, versus 49.4% for HQ-VSR and 46.5% for YouHQ under the same InternVideo2 labeling procedure.
- The paper attempts to separate data and model contributions: curation-stage ablations on UDM10, CLDC/RATE ablations with the same backbone and training data, and a DOVE fine-tuning comparison on SCOPE-VSR versus HQ-VSR.
Critical weaknesses
- SCOPE-test comprises only 40 videos taken from the same candidate collection and curation pipeline. They were left out through category-level rebalancing, and the LR degradation matches training (Sec. 4.1). The paper does not document source-level or near-duplicate separation from training. This test therefore gives limited evidence of transfer to genuinely new sources or degradations.
- The broad-performance claim is stronger than the tables warrant. On RealVSR, GraCo-VSR has 19.86 PSNR versus 22.16 for RealViFormer and 20.81 for PS-SR, on REDS30 its DISTS is 0.1969 versus 0.1600 for FlashVSR. In the data-only DOVE comparison, SCOPE-VSR improves perceptual measures but lowers PSNR on both YouHQ40 and REDS30. Per-category gains and uncertainty are absent, so the contribution of semantic rebalancing to rare categories remains hard to judge.
Questions for authors
- How were source videos, near duplicates, and shared footage excluded between SCOPE-VSR and SCOPE-test and between SCOPE-VSR and the external benchmarks?
- Can the authors report per-category test results and confidence intervals for the balance stage, with dataset size and training steps held fixed, and clarify data licenses and release terms for all five source collections?
Reviewer-author discussion period is ending. Please feedback.
Dear Reviewers,
Thanks for your time and effort in reviewing ICLR2027 submissions. As the reviewer-author discussion period will end very soon, please take time to read the author’s rebuttal and give your feedback. Your continuous engagement is highly appreciated.
Best regards,
Your AC