- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
HyR-VSR combines a hybrid-attention architecture for one-step video super-resolution with Ry-DMD, a reward-guided distribution-matching distillation method. Most global attention blocks are replaced by local spatiotemporal attention while periodic global blocks remain. Ry-DMD estimates a reward-weighted teacher endpoint shift from a small number of rollouts using scalar rewards, without differentiating through the reward model. Experiments cover video quality and efficiency, OCR-guided VSR, text-to-image transfer, and a blinded preference study.
Critical strengths
- The efficiency evaluation is relatively concrete, covering long videos, multiple resolutions, and two substantially different hardware platforms. Reporting the RTX 4090 implementation with KV-cache offloading rather than spatial tiling also makes the practical inference comparison more meaningful.
- The reward-distillation method is compared with relevant alternatives and tested beyond a single video super-resolution configuration. Its application to both image-generation backbones and different sampling budgets suggests that the proposed formulation may have utility beyond the primary setting.
Critical weaknesses
- The human-preference evidence is difficult to assess. Table 1 reports 20 videos per method pair, but does not make the number of raters, agreement, or uncertainty of preference margins clear.
- Reward-guided VSR centers on a synthetic text dataset and OCR reward. The SDXL and SD3.5-M results also emphasize OCR prompts. This shows task-directed behavior, but not broad preference alignment on natural video. Multi-stage training cost should also be distinguished from inference savings.
Questions for authors
- How many raters evaluated each pair, how were ties and disagreements handled, and can the authors report confidence intervals or per-video preference statistics?
- Does Ry-DMD improve preferences on natural, non-text VSR with a non-OCR reward, or is the benefit currently specific to text-oriented objectives?
Thank you for the detailed response. The authors have addressed my concerns, and I will maintain my original score.