- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The proposed method predicts 2D heat flux in boiling conditions, with a separation into dry area, mu layer, and single phase spatial maps, based on masks that are available at training but not inference time. The network produces reasonable separation masks (though their evaluation was very unclear to me) and is able to reduce the overall prediction error vs a single method from 2015. Ablations are carried out. Some key information is missing/unclear. Better fit for publication in application-driven venue.
Critical strengths
The major strength of the paper seems to be the reduced relative energy error in fig 1a combined with the increase in speed reported in table 21. The overall approach seems reasonable; it's unclear if weaknesses below are true to the method or artifacts of poor communication. Note, however, that the contributions of this paper may be a better fit for a venue in the application area rather than a general ML conference.
Critical weaknesses
Very weak comparisons (vs 11 year old baseline and nothing else, key numbers missing e.g. oracle described but dropped from fig 1 and corresponding table, mask-sup dropped from fig 2), ablations suggest that alternatives to the presented method might outperform it on metrics of interest (fig 1 b). Key information missing, particularly the source and meaning (ground truth? helpful guidance?) of teacher masks. Dataset small and details unclear. Extreme use of puffery in language: "x rather than cosmetic y", "a deployable optical-only partition rather than z", etc.
My major gripe is that it was unclear throughout whether the separation into sub-channels was physically accurate or just helpful for the overall prediction, as the overall prediction was the only quantity for which ground truth was reported. The paragraph on line 360 suggests that this division was important, but neglects to mention that seg-reg and mask-sup also do this (and according to fig 1 b in fact do it better). It's also unclear why this wasn't more meaningfully quantified if it was the major contribution of the paper.
Questions for authors
Please address critical weaknesses, particularly around the status of the teacher masks and the primary target of the method.
3 comments
Thank you again for your review. We have uploaded the revised manuscript and updated Figure 2 to include Mask-Sup Cascade.
We also clarified the experimental reference construction, the mechanism metrics, and the five-method comparison. The revised discussion makes the distinction between integrated heat-flux prediction and phase-region alignment explicit, with the corresponding results and ablations.
We hope these revisions address the concerns raised about the evaluation and presentation. Please let us know if anything remains unclear. Otherwise, we would appreciate your reconsideration of the rating.
Thank you for your engagement in the review process. Many of my concerns remain, particularly with regards to clarity and fit to an ML audience, but I have made an important edit to my review: “The contributions of this paper may be a better fit for a venue in the application area rather than a general ML conference,” was included as a weakness because it was a concluding thought resulting from the other weaknesses, not because it was a weakness in itself. The authors are correct that applications papers are included in the ICLR call, but I continue to believe that this specific application paper is a poor fit. To better contextualize my intent with that statement, I am moving it to the strengths section.
The low confidence in the topic area across reviewers, as well as the uniform negativity of reviews, underscores my belief that ICLR is the wrong venue for this work. I hope that it enters the literature through a better-suited peer review mechanism, but I will retain my current score.
Thank you for the review. We clarify the measured targets, comparisons, and mechanism results using the reported experiments.
Q1. Baselines and figures
Ronneberger et al. (2015) is cited for the U-Net architecture. Figure 1 compares five methods trained on the boiling data, including two supervised segmentation–regression cascades.
Table 1. Held-out S9, three-seed means (Appendix Table 10).
PAPA-Net reduces held-out integrated error by 20.4% relative to Unguided, the next-best optical-only method. It runs at 0.97 ms/frame versus 2.09 ms/frame for the cascades (Table 21). The cascades have higher Dice and lower CErr, as Figure 1(b) already shows.
Figure 1 compares optical-only inference. The Fully Guided Oracle requires reference masks at test time and is reported in Figure 2 and Appendix Table 11. Mask-Sup is in Figure 1 and Tables 10–11; we will also include it in Figure 2.
Q2. Primary target and teacher masks
The experimentally reconstructed wall-to-fluid heat-flux field comes from synchronized IR thermometry. Phase-detection imaging identifies dry, microlayer, and liquid-contact regions using optical contrast and interference fringes [1,2]. These masks supervise training; PAPA-Net receives only optical images at inference.
The predicted heat-flux field and total heat transfer are
\qquad \widehat a_k\geq0, \qquad \widehat Q_t=\int_A\widehat q^{\prime\prime}\\,dA.$$ The experimental phase-region references are $$q_{k,\mathrm{ref}}^{\prime\prime}=m_kq_{\mathrm{IR}}^{\prime\prime}, \qquad c_{k,\mathrm{ref}}=\frac{\int_A m_kq_{\mathrm{IR}}^{\prime\prime}\\,dA}{\int_A q_{\mathrm{IR}}^{\prime\prime}\\,dA}.$$ These references quantify heat allocation over optically observed regions (§4.3, Fig. 3). The experiments do not separately measure every microscopic transport process. We will place this definition beside the main results. ### Q3. Mechanism validation Appendix A.7 defines Dice after phase-channel matching and CErr as mean absolute error in integrated contribution fractions: $$\widehat c_k=\frac{\int_A\widehat z_k\widehat a_k\\,dA}{\int_A\widehat q^{\prime\prime}\\,dA}, \qquad \mathrm{CErr}=\frac{1}{3}\sum_{k=1}^{3}|\widehat c_k-c_{k,\mathrm{ref}}|.$$ Active/Collapse measure branch usage. These are reported for all decomposition baselines over three seeds (Table 10). Table 2. S9 controlled ablations, single checkpoint (Tables 14–15). | Configuration | RelE ↓ | Dice ↑ | CErr ↓ | Collapse ↓ | |---|---:|---:|---:|---:| | Full PAPA-Net | 0.0336 | 0.8335 | 0.0180 | 0.000 | | No Factorization | 0.0354 | 0.8373 | 0.0350 | 0.000 | | No Teacher-Mask Guidance | 0.0357 | 0.2836 | 0.2025 | 1.000 | | No Energy Loss | 0.0352 | 0.8339 | 0.0177 | 0.000 | Removing factorization raises CErr by 94.4%. Removing mask-teacher supervision causes complete collapse; supervising 1% of masks restores zero collapse on S9 (Table 16). Removing energy loss increases RelE. The factorization and supervision effects are quantified separately from the five-way baseline comparison. ### Q4. Dataset and relevance to ICLR Table 3. Evaluation coverage. | Dataset | Operating coverage | Protocol | |---|---|---| | dT5 | 7 acquisitions; 0.493–2.172 MW/m² | 10,156 train / 1,792 IID val; 1,948 S9 held-out frames; 7 LOCO tests | | dT10 | 8 heat-flux steps; 48,000 frames | Frozen checkpoints; zero-shot transfer (§4.5) | The learning problem is determining spatial heat allocation from optical observations, measured total heat flux, and sparse phase supervision. Coupled supports, nonnegative amplitudes, and integrated-energy training are tested through the architecture and label-fraction ablations. The ICLR 2027 Call for Papers explicitly includes physical-science applications and physics-informed hybrid AI [3]. We will simplify the language highlighted in the review and present the mechanism definitions alongside Figure 1. References: [1] Kossolapov et al. (2021), *Can LED lights replace lasers for detailed investigations of boiling phenomena?* IJMF. [2] Aguiar et al. (2026), *On the nature of single-phase liquid heat transfer mechanisms in nucleate boiling.* IJMF. [3] ICLR 2027 Call for Papers, https://iclr.cc/Conferences/2027/CallForPapers.