- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The manuscript investigates the temporal patterns of smartphone use and argues that current recommendation systems don't operate a low millisecond time scale hence do not capture users decision processes. The manuscript includes data from 35 andriod users colelcted over 15 days leading to 3.2 million touches with significant representation of short millisecond touch.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an interesting and practically relevant question about the temporal granularity at which recommendation systems should operate. The large number of recorded touch interactions could provide a useful empirical characterization of smartphone usage patterns across application categories.
Critical weaknesses
The authors argue to building new recommendation systems that account for this short time-scale touches on the mobile devices. It reads more like a position paper supported by data statistics. With that, in the manuscript's current state, I don't see how it would contribute to the ICLR and general ML/AI community. The work can be improved with a few exemplary tasks that this new data and insights help to solve, if indeed existing recommendation modesl fail at this temporal granularity (which has yet to be shown I believe).
Questions for authors
The work can be improved with a few exemplary tasks that this new data and insights help to solve, if indeed existing recommendation modesl fail at this temporal granularity (which has yet to be shown I believe).
The work seems to be a contribution heavily related to data. However, there is currently not a lot of details on how the data are recorded. How is the data handled, where is it stored, can it be reused? Without these information and the empirical tasks demonstration, the connection and value of short time-scale touches remain largely speculative.
As compared to 2022, the method in collecting the data remained the same as the authors claimed. So what was the conceptual novelty? It remains an open question what computational insights are gained beyond the descriptive stats.