- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies operator learning for pricing call options under a local volatility model. The model learns a rescaled offset relative to a carrier , defined as the Black–Scholes price with volatility frozen at the strike. It then applies a nonlinear monotone transformation (equation 2.5) to map the result into the no-arbitrage interval. In addition to introducing the methodology, the paper presents theoretical results on the asymptotics of the correction term, numerical experiments, and a section on Quantum-Compatible Realizations.
Critical strengths
- Operator learning for option pricing is an important topic.
- Incorporating prior financial structure into the model is a sensible approach.
Critical weaknesses
- Writing.
The paper is extremely dense and reads more like an audit log than a research paper. It introduces unexplained terms throughout, which makes it very hard to read, to understand, and to properly assess the contribution.
-
For example, Section 4 on numerical experiments begins as follows: Principal comparisons use pre-PP outputs (FI after FAL), FD Greeks and PDE diagnostics, and five-seed means; sample standard deviations are reported in Appendix C.2. Mechanism ablations use pre-FAL outputs; the PDE-loss factorial uses automatic-differentiation (AD) diagnostics. The text then jumps directly to Section 4.1 on benchmarks and metrics.
-
A second example, from the bottom of p. 7, is reproduced below. Similar issues occur throughout the paper. Fidelity and adaptation. QO reproduces parent predictions to numerical precision in idealized evaluation. At the selected C94 coverage, QDO roughly doubles global price error; near-strike price p95 changes little, Delta p95 worsens, and Gamma p95 improves (Table 2A,B). The selected C94 instance fails the fixed ID/OOD accuracy-preservation criteria (Appendix D.5). These synthetic evaluations use AD Greeks under a protocol separate from the principal FD study. In the three-seed matched C94 study, updating only substituted maps and their biases achieves almost all frozen-to-full error recovery (Figure 3a). Across paired C49–C99 configurations, mean price errors remain near without a monotone coverage trend (Figure 3b; Appendix D.6). The term C94 is used and discussed in detail without ever being properly introduced. The passage then refers to a three-seed matched C94 study, which is not introduced either. As a result, it is very hard to follow what is being evaluated.
-
Similarly, Section 4.1 refers to parameters , , and , which are only properly introduced in Appendix B.2. Only there does the reader learn that the local volatility functions were generated from a parametric family with these three parameters (see equation (B.1)).
-
Section 5 does not explain the role of the quantum component. It refers to QO and QDO without defining these abbreviations, and it does not explain why a quantum-compatible version is of interest for option pricing.
- Methodological inconsistencies.
The methodological choices made in the paper do not support the claim that an operator is learned (as stated in lines 139–140, Section 2).
- The paper formally uses a DeepONet, but all data are generated from a three-parameter volatility model (B.1). The network also receives these parameters as inputs. This makes the volatility input itself redundant and reduces the task to a standard feedforward regression problem.
- The local volatility functions in (B.1) depend on . This is inconsistent with how local volatility models are used and with the operator learning motivation: a single local volatility function should price options consistently across a range of strikes.
- Along the same lines, the carrier appears to be computed from the generating formula rather than from the sampled volatility functions (lines 152–156).
Questions for authors
- Could the authors evaluate the model without providing as inputs?
- Could the authors evaluate the model with the carrier computed from the sampled volatility functions rather than from the generating formula?
- What is the relevance of the theoretical results? Since they are asymptotic statements, how do they support the paper’s central claims?
5 comments
Response to Reviewer QUVa (Part 2/2)
Can the network price without ? (Q1).
Yes. We performed a matched 2 × 2 ablation within the submitted parameterized family. The first factor is whether the network receives the explicit generating parameters; the second is whether the carrier uses the generating formula or is reconstructed from sampled volatility. Each of the four configurations was separately trained with three paired seeds. The same 32 in-distribution (ID) and 320 same-family parameter-OOD price surfaces were evaluated:
Table 5: Direct input and carrier ablation; entries are price RelL2 in percent.
| Network inputs | Carrier construction | ID (%) | OOD (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parameters included | Generating formula | 0.0991 | 0.1539 |
| Parameters omitted | Generating formula | 0.1061 | 0.1668 |
| Parameters included | Sampled volatility | 0.0988 | 0.1445 |
| Parameters omitted | Sampled volatility | 0.1013 | 0.1593 |
ID: 32 surfaces; OOD: 320 parameter-shifted surfaces from the same family. Post-FAL/pre-PP outputs. Every OOD configuration uses exact terminal payoff at τ = 0, leaving positive-maturity predictions unchanged. Values are percentages, so 0.1013% = 0.001013 in dimensionless RelL2.
Without either generator inputs or the formula-based carrier, the model retains ID Price RelL2 0.1013%, close to 0.0991% for the fully generator-informed comparison; the matched same-family OOD values are 0.1593% and 0.1539%. Thus the explicit parameter shortcut is not required for accurate pricing on the tested family and sensor layout.
Can the carrier be reconstructed from sampled volatility? (Q2).
Yes. For this ablation, we use 231 sampled volatilities on a 21 × 11 spatial–calendar-time grid, distinct from the 225 sampled variances used in the contract-independent test. Interpolation supplies the strike-line volatility, whose integrated square determines the Black–Scholes carrier:
=\int _{0}^{\tau}\widehat{\sigma} _{\mathrm{sens}}^{\\,2}(K,T-u)\\,du.$$ The sample-derived and formula-derived carriers differ by global relative L² of only 1.11 × 10⁻⁵ on 32 ID surfaces and 9.69 × 10⁻⁶ on 320 same-family OOD surfaces. With a sampled carrier and otherwise parameter-informed network, ID Price RelL2 is 0.0988%; removing explicit network parameters as well yields 0.1013%. Hence the analytic carrier can be constructed from the observed field, without accessing the generating formula, at the tested sensor resolution. **How the asymptotic theory supports the method (Q3).** Propositions 3.1–3.2 analyze the *exact pricing correction* $W=V-C^{\mathrm{ref}}$. Proposition 3.1 gives a conditional O(τ) value bound; Proposition 3.2 identifies the correction's moving near-the-money profile and associated derivative behavior under stronger assumptions. This directly motivates isolating the strike-line Black–Scholes carrier and learning the remaining scaled correction. The connection is exact at the representation level. Let $\chi=\tau/T$, let $R^{\ast}=W/\chi$ denote the ideal scaled correction, and consider the *pre-FAL* network output using the same exact carrier. Then $$V=C^{\mathrm{ref}}+\chi R^{\ast},\qquad \widehat V=C^{\mathrm{ref}}+\chi R _{\theta} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad V-\widehat V=\chi(R^{\ast}-R _{\theta}).$$ For fixed T > 0, the O(τ) result controls the magnitude of R* near expiry, identifying a mathematically natural target for residual learning. The independent-field pricing experiment shows that this theory-motivated representation can be useful on a specified *finite-maturity* task.I thank the authors for their comprehensive responses.
Presentation: The authors indicate that they intend to restructure the paper and improve the structure. In the absence of a revised manuscript, I cannot determine whether these changes would indeed address the readability problems, which are pervasive throughout the paper. The underlying question of why a quantum-compatible realization is relevant to option pricing also remains unresolved.
Operator learning: The authors acknowledge that the experiments in the submitted manuscript constitute a “controlled parameterized, per-contract pricing benchmark” and do not demonstrate pricing based on a contract-independent volatility field, which would be the practically relevant application. This was my primary concern, and it applies to every experiment presented in the paper. The new ablation demonstrates that the parameters can be excluded with only minor loss of accuracy. However, within a three-parameter family, the 231 sensor values essentially uniquely identify (σ₀, β, γ), meaning that the problem still amounts to regression over a three-dimensional manifold. This ablation therefore provides no evidence that a map defined on a function space has been learned. For the new fixed-field experiment, the field generator, training data, sensor layout and carrier construction are all left unspecified; it appears that the latency comparison against forward Dupire is measured not at equal grid size.
Relevance of the theory. The response still does not clarify how the asymptotic bounds translate into actual accuracy or learnability.
Based on these points, the rebuttal does not remove my fundamental concerns. I therefore maintain my original rating.
Response to Reviewer QUVa (Part 1/2)
Presentation, definitions, and the quantum component (CW1).
We will reorganize the discussion from the pricing problem and observed volatility function to the analytic carrier, the learned correction, and finally the numerical evaluation. In particular, the generator parameters (σ0,β,γ) and the strike-dependent benchmark formula will be introduced before the experiments, rather than only in an appendix. We will distinguish predictions before and after the Financial Admissibility Layer (FAL) from outputs following the optional post-processing (PP) step; finite-difference (FD) Greeks will be separated from automatic-differentiation (AD) diagnostics. The quantum section will first identify its representation problem and then define QO (idealized exact factorization), QDO (restricted diagonal–orthogonal substitution with adaptation), and C94 (the selected roughly 94% eligible-operation-coverage configuration) before showing their results.
Does the submitted benchmark test a genuine pricing operator? (CW2).
The reviewer correctly identifies a substantive modeling distinction: Eq. (B.1) of the submitted benchmark uses a coefficient generator that depends on the contract's strike K, and the network has access to the three generating parameters. Thus the original data describe a controlled parameterized, per-contract pricing benchmark; the observed parameter-OOD performance alone does not establish that a single, contract-independent volatility field supports pricing across independent K,T queries.
Our supplementary experiment targets precisely this distinction. Each field a(S,t) is generated before choosing contract terms, held fixed when K and T vary, and supplied to the network as 225 sampled local-variance values together with the contract query. On a pre-specified subset of 42 independent moderate/strong fields (three near-the-money strikes by four maturities per field, 504 queries, T ≥ 0.25 years), the comparison is:
Table 4: Fixed-field, contract-independent pricing test (price MAE).
The separately trained FI model reduces the carrier's MAE by 77.7%; the three-seed, field-paired 95% interval for MAEFI−MAEcarrier is [-0.0639,-0.0252]. The observed-field Dupire solver is more accurate, but the FI residual model improves on the matched neural and analytic baselines. The evidence specifically establishes function-observation-based, independent-contract pricing on the tested field class.