- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces hybrid reservoir augment the dynamics of the reservoir state to allow for discrete, event-triggered jumps that reset the reservoir state instantaneously, verified on two applications successfully.
Critical strengths
The correction via local linearization in Section 4.2.2 is a useful component.
Critical weaknesses
Experimental verification can be more solid, add SOTA comparisons e.g. with
Nóvoa, A., & Magri, L. (2025). Online model learning with data-assimilated reservoir computers. arXiv:2504.16767.
Chen, R. T. Q., Amos, B., & Nickel, M. (2021). Learning neural event functions for ordinary differential equations. ICLR 2021.
Gauthier, D. J., Bollt, E., Griffith, A., & Barbosa, W. A. S. (2021). Next generation reservoir computing. Nature Communications, 12, 5564.
Questions for authors
- Fig. 4 says 22 and 27 successful HRC runs, but Fig. 8 says 17/30 and 29/30. Which one is right?
- Eq. 9 has no , but Table 2 tunes them. What kind of jump map did you actually use?
Official Comment by Authors
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of the local linearization correction introduced in Section 4.2.2 and for suggesting additional comparisons with state-of-the-art methods. To facilitate the revision process, the changes in the manuscript are colored blue and the sentences referring to them are colored bold in this response. Now we address reviewers’ comments and concerns:
We have implemented Next Generation Reservoir Computing (NG-RC) [Gauthier et al.,2021] as an additional baseline. We have also extended the experimental evaluation to include noisy measurements in Experiment 2. The additional NG-RC results provide a further point of comparison with an alternative reservoir computing architecture. Nevertheless, the proposed Hybrid Reservoir consistently outperforms NG-RC in terms of predictive performance. We are also exploring the implementation of the approaches proposed by Nóvoa and Magri (2025) and Chen et al. (2021). Because of the limited time, we have not completed them for the revised version, but will work towards including them in the final version if the paper is accepted. We believe that the additional baseline and the experiments with noisy measurements provide further validation of our approach and address the reviewer’s concerns regarding experimental evaluation
We thank the reviewer for pointing out this discrepancy. The revised manuscript corrects the typo and ensures consistency across all figures. The reported numbers have also changed following the expanded grid-search strategy suggested by Reviewer whiJ.
We thank the reviewer for pointing out this discrepancy. We used different connectivity and bias matrices for the jump set as stated in Table 2. We corrected the typo in Eq. (9) in the revised manuscript and added a brief clarification in the main text to ensure consistency with the jump map parameters reported in Table 2.