- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper derives fixed bilinear reservoir operators from functional connectomes, trains a RAVEN readout, and compares three processing stages with VLM representations using CKA/RSA. It claims structured alignment, correctness selectivity and biological specificity. Macro accuracy is 61.96% versus 57.37% for uniform-random wiring, with extensive structured and preprocessing controls in the appendices.
Critical strengths
S1. The control suite includes rewiring, ROI permutation, structured graphs and preprocessing ablations. Controls matching or exceeding accuracy are disclosed alongside remaining alignment differences (Table 13).
S2. CWR-TD exceeds vectorized reservoir baselines on all seven tasks (Table 8). Random-wired CWR also performs well, supporting an architectural contribution independently of biological attribution.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Central interpretations conflict with the displayed figures. Fig. 2's Qwen fusion RSA is , not the stated ; the Phi image title names 3x3Grid while its caption says Center. Fig. 3 shows higher raw CKA for error candidates on Center, contrary to its accompanying narrative, though this alone does not refute the reported across-task aggregate. Identical states do not establish an unconfounded -only test if VLM targets or instances differ. Random RSA in Fig. 4 and Null-Qwen CKA in Fig. 22a remain structured, making descriptions of undifferentiated or abolished alignment too strong. Nonzero raw CKA itself still needs a calibrated null reference.
W2. Biological specificity is not isolated. Each principal wiring matrix is fixed across seeds (App. K.4), and sparsity is selected using the biological-random gap (Table 3). Structured controls match or exceed accuracy while retaining lower CKA, and engineered signs outperform biological sign placement. These findings constrain, rather than eliminate, a connectome effect. ROI permutation also preserves the unlabeled graph while changing an order-sensitive preprocessing pipeline, so its effect does not alone identify a biological mechanism.
Questions for authors
- Figures: Please provide canonical stage labels and values for Figs. 2-4, resolve the Phi task mismatch, and reconcile the prose with the plotted ordering and residual alignment.
- Correctness: How are instances, distractors and VLM targets paired across conditions? Please give per-task correct-minus-error contrasts with uncertainty and justify localization to .
- Controls: In a focused setting, where does the empirical wiring rank among independently sampled nulls using identical preprocessing and independently fixed hyperparameters? Include shuffled-pairing or input-only alignment references.