- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3(+1)
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2(+1)
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This submission studies whether LLM agents can learn to increase/decrease beneficial/malign behavior via action. The authors proposes operant conditioned learning and classify the results from the action into four parts.
During experiments on Qwen3-0.8B, Gemma3-1B-1T, OLc-C are better than traditional scaler RL. The core insight would be: using the operantal changes as structural feedback would be an effective way to train LLM agents.
Critical strengths
The paper is closely related to psychological ideas/practices, and might provide insights for the RL practice when designing reward systems. Yet it is hard for me to grasp the idea behind the submission.
Critical weaknesses
- (still confusing/not consistent across the paper structure) Overall the paper's idea and organization is hard to absorb. The introduction is not clear during introducing the task, and the motivation. Also Figure 1 is abstract for me to comprehend: what does resource/burden means in the example?
- For the term operant, what is the differences between conditional generation? For auto-regressive transformer-based LLM decoding, single-sequence/multi-round interaction/long-horizon agentic task are all based on conditional generation. Previously generated tokens, actions will inference the activation status and the next token probability.
- (optimized) For the experiment, I think the baseline is not clear. For 'operant conditioning', what is its strength to current LLM+harness + standard decoding strategy? I failed to understand the experiment settings.
Questions for authors
-
The author mainly experimented with skill-aquisition, which is abruptly switched to in line 60. Could the authors explain why skill-aquisition task is picked, but not other math reasoning/coding/agentic tasks? (Generalizability concerns, and I cannot catch the link between OCL and these specific task)
-
What is the critical challenge in improving LLM's performance in skill-aquisition?
-
Why persuing a none-scaler task-reward loss? From loss to gradient, methods like GAE would help estimate the advantages and
I am open to discussions and would adjust my assessments.
7 comments
**Explaining Skill Acquisition, Baselines, and the Agentic Task Datasets**
This comment addresses parts of:
- W1 (what do resource and burden mean and how are they relevant to each task?)
- W3 (why is operant conditioning interesting or helpful for solving these tasks?)
- Q1 (what is skill acquisition?), and
- Q2 (what makes this challenging?)
Q1. Skill acquisition.
Here we mean "learning to complete an interactive task reliably through a sequence of actions." Both tasks (TextWorld and Telecom) are agentic tasks. Learners are given a text-based representation of the current state, choose an action, observe the change in the environment, and then proceed. We chose these tasks because their state transitions allow us to measure what each action adds, removes, damages, makes unavailable, etc. This creates a controlled test of consequence-based learning before testing on coding, mathematics, or more abstract assessments.
Q2. Why these tasks are challenging, and how they test operant behavior.
The critical challenge here is “credit assignment.” Task rewards (Scalar RL) are delivered at the end of an episode, so the learner must figure out which of its actions produced which consequences. An action can help in one context but hurt in another.
Some benchmarks allow for task completion regardless of unintended consequences or collateral damage. Agents might be allowed to complete a task in a way that causes harm, wastes an opportunity, or loops over actions that no longer have benefit. OCL uses intermediate consequences to modify the probability that a certain action will happen. We then measure task success ("skill acquisition") and whether consequences are able to move action probabilities in the predicted directions.
For example, when assessing behavior, does a punished action become less likely? Does a rewarded action become more likely? Our intuition might tell us "yes, of course," but our ablations show that the only methods to exhibit such behavior on average in all tested situations were "OCL-C no scalar" and its "no scalar proportional" ablation (newly uploaded manuscript, charts available on page 36).
W3. What exactly is the baseline? For each model—seed pair, Scalar RL and OCL share the task interface, action-selection procedures, and all start from the same calibrated policy. This “LLM + harness + standard decoding” protocol is used for each method. The only differences are what each method receives (consequences, rewards, punishment, burden, etc) and how each method uses that information (the math for policy construction and update form). Comparing Scalar RL (optimizing the policy to achieve task success) to OCL (additionally optimizing the intermediate behavior) helps to explain the difference in performance for how each method turns its experience into policy updates. We will share in later comments results from our new baselines that match OCL's information, in addition to ablations for OCL.
W1. Below, we explain each dataset's task.
Task 1: Telecom.
Models must learn to resolve a service problem in this modified τ²-bench task. Our simplified version gives the model a service problem and public state. Available actions include:
- inspecting the state,
- requesting a setting change,
- and finishing.
For example, the agent may choose an acton such as enabling or disabling a feature like "mobile data." Correct actions will lead to successful device configuration and, when possible, remove service faults. Wrong answers or state changes are violations. Success (or "skill acquisition") requires completing the task without violations within 15 actions. Verified configuration (intermediate success) grants the model resource. Service faults and violations cause the model to accrue burdens. As an example: repairing a service fault removes a burden, which might cause the learner to exhibit negative reinforcement.
Task 2: TextWorld.
Models learn to operate a relay station. Our TextWorld-inspired environment requires passing a POWER gate and a SAFETY gate. The POWER gate requires having "charge," while clearing the SAFETY gate will cause "damage" if active "contamination" remains in the environment. The agent sees:
- charge,
- contamination,
- credits,
- tool prices,
- gate order,
- and previous action feedback.
Its set of available actions include:
- four colored tools,
- advance,
- and wait.
Tools add or remove charge or contamination, and their effects reverse between POWER and SAFETY contexts (i.e. - a tool might add contamination during a POWER gate, but remove contamination during a SAFETY gate). Charge is a resource; contamination is a burden. The agent must learn which tool produces which consequence, whether that consequence is currently useful, and when to stop working. Success requires completing both gates without violations and within 15 actions.
We agree that our submitted manuscript could have more clearly explained these tasks. We will add these explanations to the final paper.
Adding Detail to Motivations
We thank the reviewer again and briefly connect the 1st comment to the reviewer's Question 3 (why a non-scalar loss? why not use GAE to estimate advantage?).
Q3a. Motivation for a Non-Scalar Loss:
- In any situation where something (a tool, a stimulus, some sort of intervention) is added or removed, scalar-reward reinforcement learning can combine different consequences into a single number, obscuring their separate identities. Operant conditioning (and our method "Operant Contingency Learning") retains the typed consequence feedback in a mathematical form that allows for an agent to experience this nuance during the learning process.
- Adding the scalar task-reward loss to OCL lowered performance on Telecom (77.15% vs. 65.25% stochastic) and on TextWorld at 512 groups (62.8%/36.6% vs. 23.7%/21.8% greedy/stochastic).
- In our TextWorld ablation, the consequence operator was shown to be OCL's most important component. Without consequence information and only applying scalar rewards to the individual actions, the "No consequences" ablation scored 8.0% greedy and 6.0% stochastic success on the TextWorld agentic task at 512 groups averaged across 9 seeds and 2 models. With the consequence operator, OCL scored 62.8% greedy and 36.6% stochastic success. These results are significant, with a Holm adjusted p value of 0.008.
Q3b. Why Not GAE?:
- GAE uses a learned critic to estimate each action’s advantage from the scalar reward. It does not supply information about the consequences of an agent's actions in a given context or state from a behavioral psychology standpoint (addition or removal of resource, burden, tools, obstacles, etc).
- We did not run a baseline with a learned critic. Our closest baseline is "Own-decision Vector RL," which receives the scalar task reward as well as every consequence, each credited directly to its corresponding action. "OCL-C no scalar" outperforms "Own-decision Vector RL" on TextWorld at 512 groups (+43.7 / +16.4 points greedy/stochastic, Holm significant). Removing the consequences from OCL while keeping the reward information ("No consequences") performs like Scalar RL.
Additional Baselines:
- We have provided additional baselines in comments to reviewers Eyyy and 6Pqz: https://openreview.net/forum?id=GtgTdVqhqo¬eId=Tl9M0hwuCz
- We additionally ablate OCL's components, which you can find here: https://openreview.net/forum?id=GtgTdVqhqo¬eId=IcelU2M3eC
Entering into the end of the discussion period, we remain available to address any additional concerns you might have, or elaborate on any concerns that remain unresolved.
Briefly Expanding on Operant Conditioning
We would like to thank the reviewer for their thoughtful review and engaging with the material.
We provide below some examples and an intuition for understanding operant conditioning, which we hope will clear up any questions about the methodology before we share additional information about the method. Operant conditioning is often used in dog training. Here is an example and explanation for each of the 4 quadrants of operant conditioning (Figure 1):
Positive punishment: You are training your dog not to jump on people. You have your dog sit in front of you. You firmly place your foot on the leash. You wave your hands in its face, clap, make noise, and otherwise get your dog excited. Your dog jumps up and is quickly corrected by the leash, causing them to be forced back down.
Positive reinforcement: In the same situation as above, eventually and in most cases, the dog will stop jumping up while you are trying to make them excited. Once this happens, you are able to give your dog a treat. Giving your dog a treat for behavior you want to see is positive reinforcement.
Negative punishment: Let’s imagine we are playing with our dog at the park. They begin barking at other dogs or exhibiting otherwise unwanted behavior. We remove our dog from the park (put them in “time-out”) to communicate that their behavior is inappropriate.
Negative reinforcement: Negative reinforcement is often the trickiest to explain, but imagine we are teaching our dog to sit and that they already know, more or less, how to behave when we tell them to sit. We will lift up on the leash and add burden using pressure-based training and then give the dog the “sit” command. As soon as the dog’s butt hits the floor, we will release the pressure on the leash. A similar example is a car’s seatbelt chime stopping when you put your seatbelt on.
Important note: None of these would be examples of punishment or reinforcement without decreases or increases in the behavior that the intervention is designed to modify. E.g. - if the dog is no less likely to misbehave when removed from the park, that is not negative punishment. If we are no more likely to put on our seatbelt when the seatbelt chime stops, then that is not negative reinforcement. Punishment and reinforcement effects are exactly that: decreases and increases in exhibited behavior.
In all of these situations, scalar-reward reinforcement learning can combine different consequences into a single number, obscuring their separate identities. Operant conditioning (and our method "Operant Contingency Learning") retains the typed consequence feedback in a mathematical form that allows for an agent to experience this nuance during the learning process.
Conditional generation: All 3 methods we tested in this manuscript use conditional generation and choose actions based on context. “Operant” refers to the learning process, or what happens after actions are made. In OCL, the consequence of an action changes how likely the learner will choose that action again in the same situation in the future. This is not necessarily always going to be the case for traditional reinforcement learning.
We hope this illustration will be insightful and we are happy to answer any additional questions relating to general understanding of the topic. We will add these examples to the final manuscript so that readers may understand operant conditioning more easily. We will also follow up later in the discussion period to answer your remaining questions and provide additional results.