- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This study proposes PRELUDE, which predicts landing spots using pre-contact information. It includes shuttlecock trajectories, player positions, arm movements, and shot types. This study introduces a physics-based method to generate labels.
Critical strengths
The experiments in this study are comprehensive. The comparisons with various baselines, ablation studies, and sensitivity analyses are complete and convincing.
Critical weaknesses
The practical application value is limited. While this study highlights the accuracy and low latency of landing-point prediction using pre-contact information, it doesn't explain why we need to do this task in the real world.
The Introduction lists some potential applications, but they are unclear:
- For broadcast overlays, why don't we use Hawk-Eye, which seems accurate and convincing.
- For training analysis, low latency is not so important. We could just do offline analysis to get the best performance, perhaps using video recordings.
- For robotic systems, it seems that full trajectory may be more important, as it influences how robots hit the ball or perform other actions.
There are a lot of promising experimental results, but I'm concerned about why we need to study this task.
Questions for authors
Could the authors clearly identify which scenario truly requires predicting the landing point using only pre-contact information?
2 comments
Thank you for your detailed response. I will keep my original score.
## Response to Reviewer EFCn
Thank you for asking which practical decision benefits from a landing forecast based on pre-contact observations. We appreciate your pragmatic perspective and agree that clarifying the exact operational necessity is critical.
1. The Core Motivating Scenario: Time-Critical Initial Positioning
The clearest motivating scenario is a robotic receiver choosing its initial movement under a strict physical deadline:
2. When Pre-Contact Information Matters (The Deadline Condition)
The practical necessity of this task is governed by a clear temporal condition:
Conversely, if a short-prefix outgoing flight estimate is already reliable by the movement deadline, the case for pre-contact cues is weaker. This distinction gives the problem a concrete operational purpose and defines a clear criterion for testing its real-world utility.
3. System Latency vs. Deployment Verification
Our current experiments evaluate landing-point accuracy under a contact-anchored protocol and report a processing critical path of 224 ms. In physical deployment, the total time from physical contact to prediction availability also depends on contact detection and frame-acquisition delays. Whether this forecast improves physical receiver positioning therefore remains an empirical system-level question—one that can be directly tested by comparing pre-contact and post-contact methods at the exact same movement deadline.
4. Clarification on Other Applications & Manuscript Revisions
We agree with your assessment of the other applications mentioned in the paper:
Planned Revisions: