- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes AltTS, a dual-path framework for multivariate time series forecasting that separately models within-variable temporal dependencies and cross-variable dependencies through staged alternating optimization.
Critical strengths
S1,The proposed method is relatively simple, with a clear framework that is easy to understand and implement.
S2,The paper investigates multivariate time series forecasting from an optimization perspective rather than focusing on architectural design, providing an interesting research direction for coordinating different forecasting components.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Limited methodological novelty. The proposed method mainly combines existing components, including a linear predictor, cross-variable attention, and alternating optimization. The overall approach appears to be an incremental improvement over existing techniques.
W2. Insufficient comparisons with recent strong baselines. The experiments lack comparisons with recent competitive time series forecasting methods, such as SOFTS, DUET, FACT, GTR, and VPNet. Therefore, the current results are insufficient to establish the competitiveness of the proposed method.
W3. Insufficient justification of the core motivation. Gradient coupling does not necessarily imply harmful optimization interference, as both branches optimize the same forecasting objective. The paper does not provide sufficient evidence that the performance improvements of alternating optimization result from mitigating harmful gradient interference.
W4. Insufficient ablation studies. The individual contributions of key components, including staged initialization, alternating optimization, and block relaxation, are not adequately evaluated, making it difficult to identify the main sources of performance improvements.
Questions for authors
Q1. What is the core technical novelty of AltTS compared with existing model architectures and alternating optimization methods?
Q2. Could the authors provide comparisons with recent competitive methods, such as SOFTS, DUET, TimeFilter, FACT, GTR, and VPNet, under consistent experimental settings?
Q3. How can the authors demonstrate that gradient coupling indeed causes harmful optimization interference? Could the authors further analyze gradient behavior under different training strategies and its relationship with forecasting performance?
Q4. Could the authors provide additional ablation studies to evaluate the individual contributions of staged initialization, alternating optimization, and block relaxation, while ensuring a fair computational budget compared with joint training?