acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

IIHS: Innovation-Insulated Heat Splats for Single-Image Representation Learning

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Neural fields have become a dominant representation-learning paradigm: coordinate networks store an image in the weights of a continuous function, and Gaussian splatting uses explicit primitives that are fast to render and compact to store. Structural priors steer where these primitives are placed, but each primitive's footprint remains blind to image structure: an anisotropic Gaussian elongated along an edge still bleeds across it. We present Innovation-Insulated Heat Splats (IIHS), a single-image representation in which each source starts as a small Gaussian and spreads as heat through a medium that insulates at the innovations of the image, i.e., the discontinuities where it changes abruptly, so that its heat is held back at the boundary of its region. The decoder derives this medium from its own free-space render, so it costs no bits. Because the medium only needs the innovations, the same representation extends to degraded observations, where we read them with the annihilating-filter subspace of finite-rate-of-innovation sampling instead of the image gradient. At equal stored rate, IIHS is around  dB above the Gaussian-splat representations at low rates on Kodak-24 and DIV2K. When fitted to super-resolution and inpainting, it improves over them with the lowest LPIPS of all methods. Broadly, our work suggests that where a representation stops can matter as much as what it stores.

Primary area:
unsupervised, self-supervised, semi-supervised, and supervised representation learning
Keywords:
Neural field, Gaussian splatting, Image representation learning, Edge-aware rendering

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_B5oUOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Innovation-Insulated Heat Splats (IIHS), a method for single-image representation designed to address the issue of conventional two-dimensional Gaussian elements extending beyond image boundaries, which leads to colour blending and blurring of details. At its core, the method transforms Gaussian elements into heat diffusion sources constrained by the image structure: heat propagates within a region and is suppressed by soft ‘thermal insulation walls’ at image discontinuities, causing the shape of the element’s coverage to conform to the image boundaries. The decoder first generates a free-space Gaussian rendering based on the stored source, then estimates the discontinuity structure from this and constructs a heat-conducting medium; consequently, there is no need to store an edge map separately. For degraded observations, the method further utilises an erasure filter based on sampling with a finite innovation rate to estimate discontinuity information, and applies this to super-resolution and image restoration.

Critical strengths
  1. The core concept is easy to understand. The method directly incorporates structural constraints into the diffusion and rendering of primitives, ensuring that their coverage adapts to the boundaries, and offers a reasonable solution to the problem of standard Gaussian cross-boundary colour blending.By utilising boundary-guided transition and free-space fidelity loss, the method addresses the issue of unreliable rendering in the early stages, demonstrating the authors’ consideration of the practical optimisation process.

  2. A large number of quantitative and qualitative experiments. The authors carried out a large number of quantitative and qualitative experiments to demonstrate the performance of their method.

  3. The method possesses some potential practical value. The authors report an improvement of approximately 2 dB at low bit rates and have extended the method to super-resolution and image restoration, demonstrating its potential practical value.

Critical weaknesses

I have already outlined the main weaknesses above.

Questions for authors
  1. Does the performance improvement stem from enhanced representational capabilities, or from a more costly optimisation process?

  2. Could the author provide more details on the specific improvements in the qualitative presentation to support their claim regarding its applicability?

1 comment

We thank the reviewer for their time and feedback. We appreciate that the reviewer finds the core idea easy to follow and that the breadth of the experiments and the practical value come through. We answer the questions next.

  • Q1. Representational capacity or costlier optimization? The representation, and we show this using extended experimental results. Appendix B.2 runs both directions on four Kodak images at the two Table 1 budgets: IIHS on the Image-GS schedule stays within 0.11 dB of its full result and is above every baseline even at a fifth of its iterations, while every baseline on schedules five to twenty times its official one gains at most 0.23 dB. Image-GS with its early-stopping rule disabled and all 25,000 iterations run gains 0.44 dB at the larger budget and stays 1.4 dB below IIHS. The capacity itself is the same as a Gaussian splat’s, eight floats per source; what differs is the footprint each source can take, and Figure 8 shows that difference directly by decoding the same stored sources with and without the medium.
  • Q2. Specific qualitative improvements behind the applicability claim. We have named the improvement in each qualitative figure and measured it. A new figure in the main text (Figure 4) fits one image at each budget at a matched number of sources and adds, under every decode, its error relative to IIHS and its edge F1, and a second one (Appendix D.2) does the same for the coded decodes of Figure 1: in both, the gain sits on the object outlines and the large regions. Figure 6 shows, from the same number of bits, the edges and thin structures that IIHS keeps and the other splats blur; Figure 7 shows, for super-resolution and inpainting, a per-pixel map of which reconstruction is closer to the original, blue along the edges and lettering where the classical reference blends the two sides; and Table 2 carries the measurements, with IIHS at the lowest LPIPS in every cell.
Reviewer_8sdsOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper is to create 2D image-specific representations from a physics-based inspiration of heat flow. The existing Gaussian splatting has limitations due to the restriction in the shape of the footprint, overlaps, boundary information leakages etc. As a solution, the Innovation-Insulated Heat Splats (IIHS), is introduced, modeling the image as a heat field. The Gaussian splats that act as sources in this heat field for information propagation. The information is allowed to diffuse in the image, but restricted using the properties of the medium derived using the decoder, where the edge boundaries provide insulation for the heat flow. This allows for adapting the shape of the Gaussian footprints based on the object boundaries, enables to learn the structure of the image. The experiments conducted for image representation, compression and restoration show that IIHS has promising improvements compared with the existing algorithms.

Critical strengths
  1. The development of the interpretation based on the inspiration of heat flow and medium insulation is intuitive, as shown in Figure 3. This has enabled the adaptation of the Gaussian splatting footprint to the image boundaries, rather than maintaining a rigid structure. In general, this intuition can be used to provide physics-based insights into the learning mechanisms encountered in this research domain.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Although the heat flow-based explanation is intuitive and illustrated with visual results as in Figure 3, the theoretical explanation is not sufficient. The learning dynamics of the network should be theoretically explained to ensure the intuitions are validated. For instance, the convergence behavior based on the footprint shape evolution and heat flow medium.
  2. The computational resource usage is comparatively higher according to Table 01. Here, the GPU memory usage of IIHS is more than twice that of the second-best model, Image-GS, while the representation improvement is very small. This may be a negative aspect when the algorithm is applied to high-dimensional signals.
  3. The claim in Figure 01 is not convincing enough. It is mentioned that the IIHS preserves the object boundaries despite showing at least the edge map. For example, by visual inspection, some of the sharp edges near the parrot’s eye are much clearer in JPEG than in IIHS.
  4. The paper has not compared the Lanczos algorithm for the super-resolution task under classical methods in Table 2. This should be included for the completeness of the results.
Questions for authors
  1. Provide some theoretical insights about the learning dynamics of the IIHS as mentioned in the weakness section.
  2. Provide a justification for the computational overhead compared to the image representation improvement in Table 01.
  3. To claim the performance of IIHS in boundary preservation that was intended in Figure 01, provide both qualitative and quantitative comparisons using edge maps.
1 comment

We thank the reviewer for their time and feedback. We appreciate that the reviewer finds the heat-flow and medium-insulation view intuitive, and for highlighting the physics-based handle on the learning mechanism. We answer the questions next.

  • W1/Q1. Theoretical explanation of the learning dynamics. We have added this in Appendix A.1. The properties of the diffusion scheme are stated and verified numerically on the fitting code: every step is a convex combination, so heat stays non-negative and bounded, and the scheme is stable for any medium; mass is conserved; in free space the footprint has exactly the mass and variance of the plain Gaussian; and the adjoint used for the gradient matches the forward chain. Fitting itself is non-convex and re-estimates the medium, so we characterize its dynamics by measurement: the fitting curves on all 24 Kodak images (Figure 9) and the tracking of single sources through fitting (Figure 10). Evidently, the footprints enlarge to take up as much space as possible as training proceeds; then the boundaries of the footprint get set by the insulation at render time, which helps alleviate the problem of footprints overflowing across edges.
  • W2/Q2. Computational overhead vs. representation improvement. The cost is in the render: every source is diffused through the medium on the pixel grid, with the adjoint on the backward pass, and the medium is re-derived every 100 iterations. We now state this as a limitation (Sec. 6), with the breakdown against Image-GS in memory, training time, and render time in Table 1 and Appendix B.2, including that it grows with the number of pixels and would be an obstacle for higher-dimensional signals. What it buys is measured in bits: about 2 dB above every other splat at equal stored rate (Figure 5), with the representation already ahead of or on par at matched parameters before coding (Table 1), and the gain located on the object outlines (Appendix D.2). That the margin comes from the representation and not from longer optimization is shown in Appendix B.2: IIHS on the Image-GS schedule stays within 0.11 dB of its full result, and every baseline on schedules five to twenty times its official one gains at most 0.23 dB and stays below IIHS.
  • W3/Q3. Boundary preservation in Figure 1; the parrot’s eye; edge maps. The stripes around the parrot’s eye are indeed sharper in JPEG 2000, and the revision shows it clearly. A new appendix figure (Appendix D.2) plots, under every decode of Figure 1, the decode’s absolute error minus that of IIHS, blue where IIHS is closer, with each decode’s edge F1 in its label: on kodim23 the red is confined to the stripes around the two eyes, while the bodies, the beaks and the foliage are blue, and over the whole image IIHS is 1.1 dB above JPEG 2000 and 2.5 dB above the best other splat at the same 0.03 bpp. A new figure in the main text (Figure 4) repeats the comparison for the splats at a matched number of sources without a coder, one image at each budget, with the same pattern and IIHS ahead on PSNR and edge F1 on both. The quantitative comparison is in Appendix D.2, over all 24 Kodak images: against JPEG 2000 at equal bits, IIHS has the higher edge-band PSNR and edge F1 at the low rates, and against the other splats at matched parameters, it has the highest edge-band PSNR and edge F1 at 196 sources and the highest edge F1 at 7,077. IIHS is the closest to the target along the edges and keeps the object outlines; what it does not resolve at 196 sources is high-contrast texture, and no splat does.
  • W4. Lanczos missing from the super-resolution table. We have added the Lanczos row (a = 3, Pillow) to Table 2 with its citation: 29.29 / 25.09 / 23.82 dB at 2× / 3× / 4×, on the same operator and scorer as every other row.
Reviewer_VhtDOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes IIHS, a 2D Gaussian-splat image representation in which each gaussian’s spatial extent is set by diffusion through an edge-insulating medium, not only by its covariance. Fitting IIHS is as follows

  1. Each Gaussian source stores the same 8 attributes as a regular Gaussian splat. First, they are fit regularly on the image to give a “free-space render” i.e a render that is not aware of the structure of the image

  2. Using an edge field derived from the image along with the learned splats a medium is defined. This mediums determines the manner if which the gaussians would diffuse to fit the structure of the image

  3. The gaussians are shrunk then re-expanded using the diffusion ‘field’ of the medium (Eqs 4 and 5 of the paper) while being regularized using a TV loss and fidelity to the original image (Eq 7)

The proposed method is a different way to represent and fit an image with Gaussians and quantitative and qualitative results show it is relatively at-par with prior work.

Critical strengths
  1. The method is a truly fresh take (as far as I know) on how to fit structured gaussians to images

  2. In some cases there are improvements over prior work.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The quantitative and qualitative results of the method offer seem to be relatively similar to prior work with minor improvements in some cases. I am unsure of what the adherence to structure helps with

  2. The paper is not written in a manner that is easy to follow. First, the use of encoder and decoder is misleading in my opinion as the default reader would assume parametric forms of it, while in this paper is is just used a structural term for the initialization of the gaussians and the decoder is the renderer of the Gaussian.

  3. Similar to 2) Figure 1 of the paper does a poor job of explaining now the method works. It should ideally be boxes that are numbered with each box clarifying the role in the overall pipeline (e.g Gaussian initialization, construction of the medium from the render and image, diffusing gaussians based on medium etc etc)

  4. Continuing from 3) if the main contribution of this method is how much better it is than prior work for some constant (and low) bits per pixel, the title, the writing and method needs to re-written to reflect that. Right now it requires multiple reads and a rather charitable re-interpretation of the paper for it to seem like that.

Questions for authors

NA

1 comment

We thank the reviewer for their time and feedback. We appreciate that the reviewer regards the method as a fresh take on fitting structured Gaussians to images, and for noting where it improves over prior work in compression and restoration. We answer questions next.

  • W1. Results look similar to prior work; unclear how adherence to structure helps. At equal stored bits, IIHS is about 2 dB above every other Gaussian-splat representation at every rate on both Kodak-24 and DIV2K (Figure 5, Appendix D.1), and on super-resolution and inpainting it is the best fitted method with the lowest LPIPS of all methods, the classical references included (Table 2). This is the result of the paper, and the abstract and the introduction now state it first. Table 1 fixes the number of fp32 primitives before any coder to show that the structure costs nothing in fidelity; IIHS is ahead on PSNR and MS-SSIM there at both budgets as well. Adherence to structure is what produces the margin, and the revision shows it in three places. Decoding the same stored sources with and without the medium (Figure 8, Table 3) isolates its share, and Sec. 4.5 now states where it acts: on the object boundaries, where a free-space Gaussian leaks across. The error maps at a matched number of sources (Figure 4) and of the coded decodes (Appendix D.2) show the other splats losing along the outlines. The footprint tracking in Appendix A.1 (Figure 10) shows the mechanism: sources move onto edges during fitting, and the medium holds the ones that still straddle one.
  • W2. Misleading wording choice. We have revised the manuscript to use “fitting” for the optimization of the sources of one image and “rendering” for drawing the image from the stored sources, with one sentence in Sec. 3 stating that no network is trained.
  • W3. Pipeline figure structure Figure 2 is redrawn according to the review. The render chain is one row of numbered boxes: (1) sources, (2) free-space render, (3) medium derived from that render, (4) diffused render, which is exactly what a stored image is decoded with. Fitting wraps that row: the image and its innovations (0) above it, which seed the sources and supply the early walls, and below it the loss (5), written out with each incoming wire coloured like the variable it feeds, and the quantize-and-store step (6). Every box carries its number and its role in its header, and the caption states which steps run at decode and which only during fitting.
  • W4. If the contribution is the margin at low bits per pixel, the title, writing and method should say so. The contribution is the heat splat: a Gaussian source whose footprint is not its closed-form kernel but the result of heat flow through a medium that the renderer derives from its own render, at the bit cost of a plain Gaussian. The rate–distortion margin is how that contribution is measured, and the revision has now put more emphasis on that result.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

We thank all three reviewers and the AC for their time and feedback. We appreciate the reviewers’ recognition of the proposed method’s uniqueness and strengths, and we provide a consolidated response to address the questions highlighted across the reviews below:

  • Clarification on scope and contribution: IIHS introduces a new primitive, the heat splat: a Gaussian source whose footprint is shaped by heat flow through a medium that the renderer derives from the sources themselves, so image structure enters how a primitive is rendered on top of where it is placed, at no cost in bits or parameters. Its contribution is measured at equal stored bits, where IIHS is clearly ahead of every other Gaussian-splat representation on both benchmarks and at every rate (Sec. 4.3); the matched-parameter table is only the check that the representation gives nothing up before coding. Fitted through the forward operator, IIHS is also the best Gaussian-splat representation for super-resolution and inpainting and approaches the classical single-image methods, with the lowest LPIPS of all methods including them (Sec. 4.4).
  • Mechanism of the Performance Gain: We show that IIHS loses almost nothing on the baselines’ schedules, whereas the baselines gain little on ours (Appendix B.2), further reinforcing the role of the representation itself rather than the optimization process. The render is costlier because every source is diffused through the medium on the pixel grid; this is stated as a limitation (Sec. 6), with the breakdown against Image-GS in Table 1 and Appendix B.2; render time is independent of the number of sources, while fitting memory grows with it and with the pixel grid. With the same parameters per source and the same optimizer, the showcased performance margin can only come from what the primitive is.
  • Qualitative Assessments of Edge Enhancement: We provide evidence that the edge en- hancement is real and sits where the medium acts. We decode the same stored sources with and without the medium and isolate the medium’s share of the gain in the ablation (Sec. 4.5). The qualitative gains are shown through per-pixel error maps at a matched number of sources, one image at each budget, to the main text (Figure 4); furthermore, the same maps for the coded decodes against both the codecs and the other splats are provided in Appendix D.2. Across all of these, the gain of IIHS concentrates on the object outlines and the large regions, exactly where a medium that insulates at the edges should act.

In conclusion, the revision answers each question with evidence that is now in the paper, and we are glad to continue the discussion on any point. Every change prompted by the reviews is marked in blue in the revised manuscript. Below, we will provide specific responses to each reviewer’s questions.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.