- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Lead-Field Low-Rank Correction (LF-LoRA), a subject-specific framework for aligning EEG-derived functional connectivity (FC) with fMRI-derived FC. The method introduces a learnable low-rank correction to the anatomically derived EEG lead-field matrix and optimizes it by minimizing the discrepancy between EEG-reconstructed parcel-level covariance and fMRI-derived functional connectivity. The authors further extend the framework with a linear temporal operator to incorporate lagged covariance information.
Experiments are conducted on the LEMON dataset with 203 subjects. The proposed method achieves an average cross-state EEG–fMRI FC correlation of approximately 0.63, outperforming conventional source reconstruction and EEG connectivity estimation methods. Additionally, the method improves subject fingerprinting performance, increasing verification AUC from 0.912 to 0.950. The paper also presents temporal alignment experiments and visualizations of the learned corrections to investigate their spatial and temporal characteristics.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses an important challenge in multimodal neuroimaging by leveraging fMRI-derived functional connectivity to calibrate EEG lead-field models. This provides a promising direction for improving EEG-based brain connectivity analysis.
-
Experiments on 203 subjects from the LEMON dataset demonstrate substantial improvements in EEG–fMRI functional connectivity alignment over conventional baselines. The method also improves subject fingerprinting performance, increasing verification AUC from 0.912 to 0.950.
Critical weaknesses
critical weakness:
-
All real-data experiments are conducted on a single dataset (LEMON), with evaluations restricted to eyes-open and eyes-closed resting-state conditions. Although the study includes 203 subjects, the lack of validation across different datasets, cognitive tasks, and acquisition settings limits the evidence for the generalizability of the proposed method. Furthermore, despite introducing a temporal dynamics modeling component, the paper does not evaluate it on simultaneously acquired EEG–fMRI data or provide independent validation of lagged covariance prediction. These limitations weaken the experimental support for the method's broader applicability and temporal modeling capabilities.
-
The proposed method is primarily compared against conventional approaches such as MNE and eLORETA, which do not receive the same fMRI supervision as LF-LoRA. Consequently, it remains unclear whether the reported improvements arise from the proposed low-rank lead-field correction or simply from the additional cross-modal supervision. Moreover, the paper lacks systematic comparisons with alternative learnable linear mappings under matched supervision, as well as comprehensive ablation studies examining the contributions of anatomical initialization, low-rank constraints, and the temporal operator. The existing hyperparameter ablations are conducted on only 30 subjects with a single random seed, without sufficient evaluation of experimental stability. These limitations make it difficult to establish the necessity and distinct advantages of the proposed framework.
Questions for authors
-
Improved FC alignment does not necessarily indicate a more accurate physical lead-field model. How do the authors demonstrate that the learned corrections are physically meaningful rather than simply fitting fMRI connectivity patterns?
-
Appendix D indicates that cross-state FC alignment performance is used for checkpoint selection. How do the authors prevent potential selection bias in the final evaluation?
-
EEG and fMRI in LEMON were not acquired simultaneously and exhibit different temporal characteristics. How do the authors justify the lagged covariance alignment and validate the physiological significance of the temporal operator?
-
What are the advantages of applying low-rank corrections to the lead-field matrix rather than directly learning an EEG-to-parcel mapping? Could the authors provide comparisons under equivalent supervision?