- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Not sure! The paper wasn't written clearly enough for me to follow. Even in the abstract there's a lot of undefined notation and unclear claims.
Critical strengths
Not sure! The paper wasn't written clearly enough for me to follow. Even in the abstract there's a lot of undefined notation and unclear claims.
Critical weaknesses
I was unable to follow this paper. Maybe the other reviewers will have more luck! But for me, before I can evaluate this positively, the paper would need to be completely rewritten for clarity.
Questions for authors
Sorry, but due to the clarity issues noted above I can't suggest any concrete questions here.
Response to 16vh: The problem and contribution through a concrete example
Thank you for pointing out that the difficulty began in the abstract. Optimal sampling frequencies alone do not determine stopping cost: legal routes can allow or prevent correction of random evidence imbalance. We now introduce this distinction through a concrete example, then explain the criterion and policy it leads to.
1. Same frequencies, different stopping costs [W1: Problem and motivation]
We study sequential tests in which choosing an experiment changes which experiments can be performed next—for example, by moving a sensor or reconfiguring an instrument.
Consider two experiments, each supplying evidence against a different alternative. The test needs enough evidence against both. Our matched example has two ways to organize access:
Both systems have the same observation laws, optimal sampling frequencies, and best average information rate. If one evidence score falls behind, Split can devote the next cycle to it. Coupled's complete cycles always sample both.
For evidence threshold b, first-order analysis predicts b divided by that shared rate. The excess is the expected number of observations beyond this prediction. Its optimal value stays bounded in Split but grows on the b scale in Coupled. Routing alone creates this growing penalty.
2. What the criterion tells us to do [W1: Meaning of the main claims]
The general result asks which access systems permit such correction. An exact cost identity identifies two sources of growing excess: evidence accumulated ahead of the weakest score, and information lost along the sampling path.
Edges used by first-order-optimal flows form the critical graph. Its cycles preserve the optimal weighted information rate. The rank test examines their relative evidence drifts: can these legal cycles correct every direction of imbalance?
Under the assumptions of Theorem 4, full rank supplies a correcting cycle for every imbalance. The policy repeats that cycle enough to offset the effect of the connecting paths, achieving O(logb) excess. A missing direction with unavoidable noise instead forces square-root excess even for the best policy. These results also extend to identification without knowing the true hypothesis: one procedure attains the corresponding upper bounds, and the lower bounds cover every procedure meeting the error guarantee.
3. Where the presentation has changed [W1: Abstract, definitions, and organization]
Revision: The revised manuscript now gives the reader the following route:
We hope these revisions and the concrete example above make clearer why access constraints matter for stopping costs and what our results establish.