- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a time-series self-supervised learning method. The authors' motivation is that the time-series can be noisy and current pretext tasks can favor the noisy part and learn that. The proposed method, FACETS, learns the representation primarily by the agreement among frequency components of the same sequence. Authors conducted experiments on five datasets and showed that the proposed method increases the linear probe performance by 10%.
Critical strengths
The overall motivation and criticism against the forecasting and reconstruction based SSL methods are valid. The drawbacks of these techniques are well-motivated. The evaluated datasets also fit the purpose to show the claims, for example Sleep-EDF is noisy. And, the SSL pretext task should learn the features that are not noisy but informative for the sleep stage classification.
Critical weaknesses
The paper falls down after the motivation. The presentation of the method is not clear. The evaluation and comparison are also not extensive. The authors do not compare with one of the recent works in the same direction [1]. The datasets can also be extended. The propositions and theory part of the work are very hard to follow. The notations are not clear and some of them are never explained.
[1] Learning Without Augmenting: Unsupervised Time Series Representation Learning via Frame Projections. NeurIPS 2025.
The ablations are also very weak. The critical choices of wavelet design is not motivated. There is so much whitespace in the main manuscript while most figures can be presented better. The authors did not do a good job for presenting their evidence.
I believe the current version of the work needs a major revision. The experiments with baselines and ablations should be extended.
Questions for authors
1-How do the authors choose the wavelet parameters? Are they application specific? Are the chosen hyperparameters robust? How much the performance changes with the chosen number of wavelet level?