- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses time-series classification under data-quality-induced distribution shifts and limited labels. It proposes a two-stage framework that combines anomaly injection, reconstruction-based contrastive learning, and prototypical few-shot classification. Experiments on Steel Frame, IASC-ASCE, and Z24 datasets show consistent improvements over ten self-supervised baselines, supported by ablation study and t-SNE analysis.
Critical strengths
-
Representation learning on data with quality issues is a real need.
-
The balance between contrastive learning and the reconstruction information loss is plausible and reasonable.
Critical weaknesses
-
The writing of the Related Work is quite confusing. "self-supervised time series representation" (subsection 2.1) and "contrastive representation learning" (subsection 2.2) are somewhat overlapping. For example, TNC and T-Loss in 2.1 also fail to the category of contrastive representation learning, while TS2Vec can also be seen as a self-supervised time series representation method. This will cause readers outside the relevant literature to be quite confused.
-
There are quite a few places where conflicts arise between one another. Please refer to Questions 1 to 3.
-
The Ablation is too rough. The authors should also prove the effectiveness of their detailed designs, like positive/negative pair selection strategy, anomaly injection, etc.
Questions for authors
-
In subsection 3.3, the phrase "neighbouring windows" conflicts with the following formula whose meaning is to choose 'all' windows except j, but not limited to neighbouring ones.
-
In subsection 3.3, the author mentioned "This ensures that samples affected by data-quality-induced distribution shifts yield representations similar to those of their original classes.". However, if the original time-series and the anomaly-injected ones were considered as negative pairs, the result should be as "This ensures that samples affected by data-quality-induced distribution shifts yield representations dissimilar to those of their original classes.", as anomaly injection transforming the original series to low-quality ones.
-
In subsection 4.1, the samples are categorized into four states. But if the aim is to get a data-quality-invariant representation, as the title of this paper suggests, there should only be two categories: healthy or damaged.
-
If a shift occurs in the neighbouring window, using them as positive pairs will not be reasonable. This has been discussed in detail in TS2Vec. Can you give me the rationale behind your positive pair selection strategy?
-
In the supplemental material, I can only see the Appendix. Can I have a look at the code? This will strengthen the reproducibility and will make the experimental details clearer to reviewers.