- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes UKAD, a deformable KAN encoder-decoder for medical image segmentation, addressing the limitation that existing KAN-based U-Nets evaluate learnable activation functions on the encoder's fixed downsampled grid. The primary contribution is the KAD bottleneck block, which predicts a content-adaptive displacement grid, resamples the bottleneck features on that grid, and applies low-degree group-rational activation functions whose parameter count does not scale with channel width. Furthermore, UKAD reuses this rational activation across skip-connection gates and a hybrid decoder, accompanied by an uncertainty-gated boundary refinement head. Under a unified training and splitting protocol, the authors retrain fourteen baseline models on four public 2D medical image segmentation benchmarks for comparison.
Critical strengths
- Instead of copying metrics from previous literature, the authors rigorously retrained fourteen mainstream and recent baseline models under a unified codebase, shared data splits, and identical training hyperparameters, complemented by paired statistical significance tests and bootstrap confidence intervals, providing substantial empirical reference value.
- Adopting low-degree Padé-style rational functions shared across channel groups requires only 48 additional parameters per layer, effectively addressing the quadratic parameter explosion and initialization instability inherent in conventional B-spline KANs.
Critical weaknesses
- The two-by-two ablation in supplementary Table 22 shows that the default UKAD-B combining both deformable displacement and group-rational activation achieves a four-dataset mean IoU of 82.59%, which is lower than using rational activation alone 82.69% and lower than using displacement alone 82.67%, demonstrating that combining displacement resampling with KAN yields negative synergy and directly undermines the core empirical hypothesis.
- The primary experiments in Tables 1 and 2 report performance directly on the validation partition used for checkpoint selection, conflating model selection with unbiased evaluation and lacking independent held-out test sets to prove true generalization on three of the four datasets.
- Beyond the KAD bottleneck, the architecture stacks numerous confounding add-ons including dilated context branches, adaptive context mixers, a hybrid KAN decoder, and an uncertainty-gated boundary head, and Table 21 shows that removing these modules causes noticeable performance drops, making it difficult to disentangle whether the gains stem from the core KAN formulation or from extensive architectural engineering.
- Although the parameter count is constrained to 7.77M, spatial bilinear resampling and hybrid decoding incur a high computational cost of 74.46 GFLOPs, which is 8.5 times that of U-KAN, along with substantially higher latency on an A100 GPU, weakening its practical clinical utility.
Questions for authors
- How do the authors explain the negative interaction in supplementary Table 22, where combining deformable displacement with group-rational activation yields a lower average IoU than using either component individually?
- Why were strictly independent held-out test sets omitted for BUSI, CVC-ClinicDB, and GlaS, and how do the authors justify the potential optimistic bias of reporting metrics on the checkpoint-selection validation splits?
- What is the net performance gain of the deformable KAN bottleneck over a standard convolutional baseline when all confounding add-ons, including the boundary head, auxiliary losses, and context branches, are completely removed?
- Given that clinical medical imaging extensively relies on 3D volumetric scans, how can this 2D deformable grid sampling operator be practically generalized to 3D convolutions and anisotropic voxel resolutions?