acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Hypergraph-Grounded Rollout Search for Multi-Constraint LLM Planning

Abstract

While large language models (LLMs) have made significant strides in handling complex reasoning tasks, existing planning methods still face substantial challenges with multiple fine-grained constraints. Fundamentally, relying on unstructured textual context to track dynamic resources and global constraints makes resource selection difficult to audit and failures hard to localize. We propose HyperPlan, which introduces an instance-level directed heterogeneous hypergraph as a formal, structured planning representation. Through explicit operator families, the hypergraph integrates constraints, actual candidate resources, temporal states, and partial plans, capturing high-order dependencies and multi-step state transitions. Rather than generating the final plan, the LLM serves as a semantic interface, parsing open-ended requests into formal entities and n -ary relations. These elements enable hypergraph-based Monte Carlo rollouts and lexicographic feasibility assessment. Failed simulations are attributed to specific hypergraph elements; bounded failure memory guides later search without overriding hard constraints. On the TravelPlanner test set, HyperPlan achieves 100.00% delivery and 82.40% final pass rate with GPT-4-Turbo. With the same backend on NATURAL PLAN, it achieves 75.00% exact match on Trip Planning, 100.00% accuracy on Meeting Planning, and 62.00% solve rate on Calendar Scheduling. The system boundary is clear: the LLM handles language parsing, while explicit hypergraph search makes verifiable decisions.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
Large Language Models, Constraint-Aware Planning, Hypergraph, Monte Carlo Simulation, Agent Reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_emYZOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes HyperPlan, a planning framework that separates language understanding from decision-making. Given a natural-language request, an LLM extracts entities and relations and represents them using an directed heterogeneous hypergraph. The system then performs hypergraph-based Monte Carlo rollouts to construct candidate plans, applies feasibility-first evaluation to enforce hard constraints, and maintains bounded failure memory to guide subsequent search. The framework is evaluated on TravelPlanner and NATURAL PLAN. The reported results demonstrate a 100% delivery rate on TravelPlanner and competitive performance across several planning tasks. However, the test results reveal a substantial gap between plan delivery and final constraint satisfaction.

Critical strengths
  1. The method is reasonable and complete. It uses the LLM to understand the request and graphs to guide decision-making, leveraging the strengths of LLMs in semantic understanding and graphs in relational modeling.
  2. Experiments on TravelPlanner and NATURAL PLAN provide an assessment of the proposed architecture's transferability across different planning domains.
Critical weaknesses

1.The framework appears to be a combination of established techniques, including LLM-based semantic parsing, typed graph representations, and Monte Carlo search. The paper does not sufficiently demonstrate its contributions in method.

2.The paper lacks theoretical guarantees establishing that the search procedure can reliably identify feasible plans within a finite rollout budget.

3.The paper does not fully describe hyper-edge construction, rollout selection, termination conditions, or the implementation of global constraint checking.

4.The paper presents bounded failure memory as an important component, but does not include an ablation study. All of the experiments do not report variance across multiple random seeds.

5.Figures 1 and 2 are not presented clearly, making it difficult to understand the framework and the main workflow.

Questions for authors

1.What is the essential novelty of the proposed method? The framework appears to the combination of established techniques.

2.How robust are the results across repeated runs? Can the authors report standard deviations over multiple random seeds?

3.Could the authors provide theoretical analysis on whether the search procedure can identify feasible plans within a finite rollout budget?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 3: Novelty, Robustness, and Search Guarantees

Thank you. We clarify the contribution, reproducibility details and feasibility limits below.

  1. Essential novelty (Q1). Semantic parsing, typed graphs and Monte Carlo sampling are established techniques. Our contribution is their implementation around explicit joint resource composition, feasibility-first ranking and inspectable resource/constraint dependencies. We will narrow hypergraph novelty claims: factor graphs, CSPs and classical operators can encode these dependencies, and prior systems such as FormalVerify already provide formal solving and failure diagnosis.

Our new controls use the same 180 recovered-input TravelPlanner validation cases, resources, checks, seed 13 and 128 rollouts, without LLM hints. Hypergraph, ordinary incidence graph (relation nodes plus binary arcs), and flat-pool representations yield identical plans and 94.44% final pass. Disabling joint stay-block hotel selection gives 76.67%. The 17.78-point drop supports joint composition, not graph expressivity or superiority over independent CSP/SMT planners.

  1. Repeated runs and memory ablation (Q2). With fixed recovered inputs and 128 rollouts, seeds 7/13/21/42 produce: Setting Final pass by seed (%) Mean +/- sample SD Memory off 94.44 / 94.44 / 94.44 / 93.33 94.17% +/- 0.56 pp Memory on, K=16 91.67 / 93.33 / 93.33 / 91.67 92.50% +/- 0.96 pp

Memory reduces the mean by 1.67 percentage points. We withdraw claims of a search benefit and keep it off in the primary setting. These runs measure search randomness on 180 validation cases, not repeated LLM extraction, full-test variance or NATURAL PLAN variance; we will not generalize the SDs to those settings.

  1. Finite-budget analysis (Q3). The implementation is a bounded heuristic, not a complete solver. Let N=M-1 be the stochastic rollouts after the greedy first rollout. If, conditional on every preceding failure history, each rollout generates a feasible plan with probability at least p>0, then

P(no feasible plan generated in N rollouts) <= (1-p)^N.

This follows by multiplying conditional failure probabilities; independence is not required. For 0<p<1 and 0<delta<1, N >= ceil(log(delta)/log(1-p)) suffices for success probability at least 1-delta. This bounds generation, not acceptance or retention by an imperfect checker.

Crucially, we have not established a positive uniform p for our implementation. Top-k truncation, resource filtering and fixed operators can exclude every feasible plan, giving p=0. Thus we claim neither guaranteed finite-budget success nor probabilistic completeness over the original problem space. Failure within M rollouts does not certify unsatisfiability. Empirically, budgets 1/16/32/64/128/256 achieve 77.78/86.67/91.11/92.78/94.44/94.44% on the same validation protocol (seed 13); this is evidence of budget sensitivity, not a theorem.

  1. Construction, rollout policy and checking. For TravelPlanner, typed nodes encode queries, constraints, resources/pools, day slots, partial states and final plans. Directed hyperedges record extraction, retrieval, daily composition, transitions and checking. Procedural operators read these objects; the implementation is not a generic hyperedge interpreter or MCTS. Constraint recovery currently uses deterministic field/query parsing with optional LLM hints; we will correct the overstated LLM role.

Each rollout selects a route, stay lengths, transport policy, block hotels and daily resources, then scores the complete plan. The first is greedy; later ranked choices sample up to 16 candidates with weights proportional to 1/(rank+1). Cities use resource-count weights; attractions sample uniformly from up to 32 unused name-sorted candidates. Missing resources incur losses; least-violating hotel choices may remain infeasible. There is no complete backtracking.

Candidates minimize (delivery, hard, soft, normalized cost) lexicographically. Checks aggregate missing fields/transfers, route count, hotel capacity/rules/minimum stays, transport restrictions, cuisine coverage and total budget across the plan. Default M=128 exhausts the budget and returns the best candidate, possibly infeasible; optional early stopping requires zero internal delivery/hard loss. Memory is an instance-local FIFO that penalizes attributed resource IDs, chiefly reranking hotels; it provides no certified pruning. We will include pseudocode and exact settings. Delivery of a plan, internal acceptance and official final pass are distinct: 100% delivery is not 100% constraint satisfaction.

  1. Figures. We will redraw Figure 1 as a numbered pipeline with a node/relation legend, and Figure 2 as a worked rollout showing joint hotel selection, global checks and optional memory. Larger labels will distinguish dependency records from executed operators and show the stopping rule.
Reviewer_TyhTOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes HyperPlan for solving natural language planning tasks that involve multiple constraints, such as travel planning and conference scheduling. The core idea is to let LLM be responsible for semantic parsing and hand over the actual planning decisions to structured search: LLM parses user requests into entity, resource, and constraint relationships. 2. Use directed heterogeneous hypergraphs to represent candidate resources, time states, partial plans, and multiple dependencies. 3. Search for candidate solutions through Monte Carlo rollouts, prioritize integrity and hard constraints, and then consider preferences and costs. 4. Attributing failures to specific nodes and hyperedges, and adjusting subsequent searches through bounded failure memory.

Critical strengths
  1. Constraints such as budget, resource availability, accommodation days, and time conflicts are indeed not suitable for relying solely on natural language context maintenance. Using LLM for requirement analysis and assigning explicit search and checker responsibility for decision-making is a reasonable engineering approach.
  2. The handling of hard constraints and soft preferences is relatively clear. The method clearly stipulates that cost or preference scores cannot compensate for violations of hard constraints. This is more in line with practical planning needs than simply weighting all requirements into one reward. Linking failures to resources and constraints also has the potential to assist in debugging and auditing.
  3. The absolute success rate of the report is attractive and attempts to cover different tasks. According to the author's report, the weaker GPT-3.5-Turbo backend can also achieve a 78.6% success rate in TravelPlanner testing; The results of meetings, schedules, and calendar tasks also preliminarily reflect the scope of application of this architecture. However, its relative advantage is still affected by the following experimental issues.
Critical weaknesses
  1. There is a verifiable inconsistency in baseline comparison, which is the most direct experimental issue. (1) PMC: Presentation in current submission: The corresponding scores are placed in tables labeled as 180 questions in the validation set and 1000 questions in the test set The setting in the original paper: The same score comes from the validation set of 60 questions and the test set of 308 questions, and the "With Unconventional Hint" setting is used (2) SwarmAgentic: Presentation in current submission: Label Trip/Meeting/Calendar 13.1/56.0/82.0 as GPT-4-Turbo Setting in the original paper: This set of results is labeled GPT-4o

  2. The description of the core algorithm is not complete enough and difficult to reproduce. Section 3 provides abstract definitions of hypergraphs, sets of valid actions, utility functions, and failure memory, but lacks details that determine actual behavior: -How to construct hypergraphs from parsing results and resource pools, and how to execute operation hyperedges; -How to sample candidate actions, handle dead ends, and update search strategies for rollouts; -How to match the current state, reduce weight, eliminate, or trigger pruning for failed memory; -Rollout quantity, memory capacity, utility weights, stopping rules, and random seeds. There is no complete algorithmic pseudocode in the entire text, and the appendix is mainly a case study. Section 4.4 even lists key configurations such as roll out budget as content that needs to be supplemented. This has already affected whether the method is fully defined, not just whether replicating the experiment is convenient.

  3. The unique value of hypergraphs compared to existing symbol planning methods has not been fully demonstrated. There is a clear precedent for LLM to analyze requirements and external solvers to complete planning and verification. FormalVerify not only uses constraint solvers, but also identifies unsatisfiable constraints and provides reasons for failure, so structured representation and error localization alone are not sufficient to establish novelty. ACL Anthology This article emphasizes that hyperedges can represent multiple dependencies, but does not fully explain what new search capabilities, efficiency benefits, or expressive advantages this representation brings compared to factor graphs, constraint satisfaction problems, or classical programming operators. The existing formulas are mostly used to describe planning problems and have not yet reflected the unique algorithmic mechanisms of hypergraphs.

Questions for authors

The same as weaknesses.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 2: Baseline Corrections, Algorithm Details, and Contribution Clarification

Thank you. We agree that baseline provenance and execution details require correction.

1. Baseline corrections. PMC's original Table 1 reports 60 validation/308 test instances with "Unconventional Hint," not our 180/1,000-instance protocol. Its GPT-4+PMC final-pass rates are 33.33%/42.68%. We apologize for the misleading captions. We withdraw matched-comparison claims and will separate PMC into a literature table with counts, backbone, hints and source, without shared maxima. HyperPlan uses gold-field validation and recovered-constraint test inputs; we will label this difference.

SwarmAgentic's Table 3 attributes Trip/Meeting/Calendar 13.1/56.0/82.0 to GPT-4o (executor GPT-4o-0806), not GPT-4-Turbo. The local manuscript label is corrected. We withdraw same-backbone claims; its calendar score exceeds our 62.0%. Our own scores are unchanged.

2. Executed algorithm and reproducibility. This specifies TravelPlanner; NATURAL PLAN uses task-specific operators. The builder creates typed query, constraint, resource/pool, day, partial-state and final-plan/check nodes. Hyperedges record extraction, retrieval, composition, transitions and checking. Constraint recovery uses deterministic field/query parsing and optional LLM hints; we correct the overstated LLM role. Procedural operators read typed objects, without generic hyperedge execution or MCTS updates.

Read/index constraints and resources; reset memory; best = NONE
Seed RNG with s + sum(j*ord(ch_j)) over record ID, j starting at 1
For i = 0,...,M-1:
  Choose route, stay lengths, transport policy and block hotels
  Compose daily resources, tracking used venues and total cost
  Score candidate; update failure memory if enabled
  Retain candidate only if strictly better lexicographically
  If early_stop and internal delivery=hard=0: break
Return best candidate and violation diagnostics

Defaults: M=128, top-k=16, s=13, memory off, early_stop=false. The first rollout is greedy. Ranked choices use probability proportional to 1/(rank+1), with stage-specific constraint/preference/cost keys, name tie-breaking and stable input order. Cities use resource-count weights without replacement; transport policy has at most three choices; attractions are sampled uniformly without replacement from the first 32 name-sorted unused candidates. Hotels use the least-violating pool for the actual stay duration, which may still be infeasible. Empty pools produce missing fields/transfer placeholders and losses. There is no complete dead-end backtracking; the next rollout restarts. Budget exhaustion returns the best plan even if infeasible.

The objective is lexicographic (delivery, hard, soft, normalized cost), with earlier candidates retained on ties. Delivery counts missing fields/transfers and route-count mismatch; hard loss counts hotel/transport/cuisine violations plus 1+relative budget overage when over budget; soft loss counts unmet hints. Cost is divided by positive budget. Internal zero loss does not guarantee official-evaluator acceptance.

Optional memory is an instance-local FIFO (K=16). Records contain route/hotel signatures, check families and resource IDs, but lookup uses resource IDs, not state-conditioned signatures. Summed penalties are capped at 3; family weights are budget 1, hotel 1.5, transport 1, cuisine 0.5, completeness 0.25, connectivity/route 0.75 each. Penalties chiefly affect hotel ranking; transport ranking does not read them. There is no certified pruning, candidate deletion or learned value function. A common positive cost multiplier cannot change rankings. On 180 recovered-input validation cases, seeds 7/13/21/42 give memory-off 94.17% +/- 0.56 versus memory-on 92.50% +/- 0.96 (sample SD in percentage points). We therefore claim no memory benefit and keep it off.

3. Contribution boundaries. FormalVerify already combines SMT solving with Z3 unsatisfiable-core diagnosis/repair. Factor graphs, CSPs and classical operators can encode the same dependencies; our evidence establishes neither greater expressivity nor completeness or speed superiority.

Matched controls use the same 180 recovered-input cases, resources, checks, seed 13 and M=128, without LLM hints. Hypergraph, ordinary directed incidence graph (relation nodes plus binary arcs), and flat pools all achieve 94.44% and identical plans. Disabling joint stay-block selection gives 76.67%. The 17.78-point drop supports the joint operator, not a unique representational advantage. These shared-solver controls are not an independent CSP/SMT comparison.

Our contribution is an inspectable typed resource/dependency representation with joint composition and finite-budget search. Failure attribution diagnoses candidates; it is not an unsatisfiability certificate. We will narrow novelty claims; stronger claims require independent solver and matched-runtime comparisons.

Reviewer_MEWhOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents HyperPlan, a framework for multi-constraint LLM planning that separates language understanding from planning decisions. An LLM extracts typed entities and n-ary relations, which are grounded in an instance-level directed heterogeneous hypergraph. Feasibility-aware Monte Carlo rollouts construct plans, while lexicographic checks and bounded failure memory guide subsequent search. On the TravelPlanner test set, HyperPlan achieves an 82.40% final pass rate with GPT-4-Turbo; on NATURAL PLAN, it reports 75.00% Trip Planning exact match, 100.00% Meeting Planning accuracy, and 62.00% Calendar Scheduling solve rate.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear separation of semantic parsing and constraint-aware planning. The framework explicitly represents resources, time states, and joint constraints, while keeping hard feasibility checks outside unconstrained LLM generation. This is a sensible design for improving auditability and diagnosing invalid planning choices.
  2. Broad evaluation with informative component analysis. The paper reports both a 1,000-instance held-out TravelPlanner test set and three NATURAL PLAN subtasks. HyperPlan substantially improves over the listed direct-generation and PMC baselines on TravelPlanner.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient evidence for the distinctive contributions of the hypergraph and failure memory. The w/o Hypergraph ablation does not establish whether the proposed representation outperforms a comparably equipped ordinary graph or constraint-based planner under matched conditions. Moreover, the failure-attribution memory lacks a dedicated ablation, leaving its contribution to search effectiveness unclear.
  2. Insufficient specification and efficiency evaluation of the rollout search. Although the paper describes feasibility-aware Monte Carlo rollouts, it does not clearly specify how admissible successors are selected or how failure memory influences subsequent search decisions, making the proposed algorithm difficult to reproduce. Furthermore, the lack of search-budget, runtime, and repeated-run variance analyses limits the assessment of its effectiveness and computational trade-offs.
  3. Limited comparisons with contemporary planning methods and LLM backbones. The experiments rely exclusively on GPT-3.5-Turbo and GPT-4-Turbo, without evaluating more recent models. The baselines also omit closely related 2026 methods, including ATLAS, HiMAP-Travel, and SCOPE, making it difficult to assess HyperPlan's competitiveness against recent planning approaches under comparable settings.
  4. Limited analysis of held-out generalization and residual planning failures. On TravelPlanner, the GPT-4-Turbo final pass rate drops from 99.44% on validation to 82.40% on test, below FormalVerify's 90.20% test result. The paper does not sufficiently disentangle semantic parsing errors, incomplete constraint checks, and search failures, leaving the causes of the substantial performance gap unclear.
Questions for authors

Q1. Isolating the contributions of hypergraph structure and failure memory. Could the authors compare HyperPlan with an ordinary graph or constraint-based representation using the same extracted entities, candidate resources, and feasibility checks under comparable computational budgets? Additionally, could the authors include a dedicated memory-off ablation to quantify the contribution of failure memory to planning performance?

Q2. Rollout search implementation and computational efficiency. Could the authors clarify how admissible successors are selected during rollouts and how failure memory influences subsequent search decisions? Please also provide the rollout budget, stopping criteria, and runtime or token costs, ideally with performance comparisons across different search budgets.

Q3. Comparisons with recent planning methods and LLM backbones. Could the authors explain why the experiments are restricted to GPT-3.5-Turbo and GPT-4-Turbo, and evaluate HyperPlan with more recent LLMs? Comparisons with recent planning methods, such as ATLAS, HiMAP-Travel, or SCOPE, under matched evaluation settings would also help establish the competitiveness of the proposed approach.

Q4. Understanding the generalization gap and residual failures. Could the authors provide a breakdown of test-set failures into semantic parsing errors, incomplete constraint checks, and search failures? An analysis of disagreements between the internal checker and the official evaluator would help explain the substantial validation-to-test performance gap.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 1: Additional Experiments and Clarifications

Thank you for the constructive feedback. We clarify the implementation and report additional controls below.

Q1. Hypergraph and memory contributions.

We replaced each hyperedge with an auxiliary relation node and binary edges. On 180 recovered-input validation instances, with identical entities, candidates, checks, joint operators, seed 13, 128 rollouts and no hints, this ordinary incidence graph produces identical plans to the hypergraph: both achieve 94.44%. A matched flat pool does likewise. Disabling joint stay-block selection yields 76.67%. The 17.78-point reduction is an operator effect, not an expressive limitation of ordinary graphs. We withdraw the representation-only interpretation of the submitted ablation. This is not an independent CSP/SMT solver comparison.

For seeds 7/13/21/42, memory-off scores are 94.44/94.44/94.44/93.33%; FIFO memory-on (K=16) scores are 91.67/93.33/93.33/91.67%. Means and sample SDs are 94.17 +/- 0.56% versus 92.50 +/- 0.96%, a paired change of -1.67 percentage points. These results do not support a benefit from the implemented memory. Feedback remains off in the primary setting.

Q2. Search policy and efficiency.

Each rollout selects a route, stay lengths, transport policy, block hotels and daily resources, then scores the plan. Rollout 1 is greedy. Later ranked choices sample the top k<=16 with normalized weights 1/(rank+1); names break resource-score ties. Cities use resource-count weights, transport policy uses up to three alternatives, and attractions sample uniformly without replacement from the first 32 unused name-sorted candidates. Hotels use the least-violating pool; missing resources incur losses. This is procedural rollout search, not MCTS or generic hyperedge traversal.

The RNG seed is s + sum(j*ord(character_j)) over the record ID, starting j at 1. Candidates minimize (delivery, hard, soft, cost) lexicographically; ties retain the earlier candidate. Default search exhausts M=128 and returns the best candidate even if infeasible. Optional early stop requires zero internal delivery/hard loss, not official acceptance.

Memory resets per instance, stores failed signatures/checks/resource IDs, and applies capped node penalties (3.0) through ranking, chiefly affecting hotels. It neither relaxes checks nor deletes candidates. Signatures are not state-matching pruning rules. The cost-only multiplier scales all candidate costs equally and cannot alter rank sampling.

For M=1/2/4/8/16/32/64/128/256, validation final pass is 77.78/75.56/77.78/81.67/86.67/91.11/92.78/94.44/94.44%. At M=128, recorded mean/median/p95 planning wall time is 1.476/0.952/3.756 s per instance in worker processes, excluding extraction and evaluation. Early stop averages 11.1 rollouts and 0.126 s, with 93.89% final pass. Internal/official checker disagreement permits non-monotone official success. The GPT-4-Turbo test hint cache averages 2,953 prompt and 222 completion tokens per instance; rollouts make no LLM calls. Counts exclude unlogged retries.

Q3. Recent backbones and methods.

We extended the historical backends with Gemini-2.5-Pro: 170/180 validation instances pass (94.44%), versus ATLAS's published 44.44% with the same named backbone. This is not a matched rerun: ATLAS uses tool search; we use an offline candidate pool.

Gemini testing completed only the first 783 instances before quota exhaustion: 744 pass (95.02%). The official 1,000-row submission contains 217 empty plans, giving 78.30% delivery and 74.40% final pass. All omitted cases are hard, so 95.02% is not a full-test estimate. Published test results include ATLAS 35.00%, HiMAP-Travel/Qwen3-8B 52.65%, and SCOPE/GPT-4o 93.10%. SCOPE reports original benchmark metrics with explicit environment rules. These are contextual comparisons; matched method/budget reruns remain necessary.

Q4. Generalization and failures.

The original 99.44% validation versus 82.40% test comparison mixes gold constraint fields with query-recovered inputs. Correcting deterministic constraint recovery raises the archived GPT-4-Turbo test score to 93.20%; this does not isolate every cause of the gap or establish budget-matched superiority over FormalVerify (90.20%).

On 180 validation instances with recovered constraints, fixed candidates/checks/seed/budget and no hints, old versus corrected recovery yields 70.00% versus 94.44%. Internal-pass/official-fail cases fall from 47 to 3: two have cuisine/house-rule extraction mismatches, and one has a cost-check disagreement. Seven further failures lack required information; without feasible witnesses, these are not proven search misses. Hidden test labels preclude a causal per-instance partition. The corrected test report contains 45 completeness, 14 budget, 6 cuisine, 3 room-type, 3 sandbox and 2 attraction-diversity failure events; these overlap and must not be summed as distinct failed plans.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.