- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
HyperPlan addresses LLM planning with constraints shared across multiple decisions. It induces a constraint hypergraph from the query, with decision-oriented task nodes and hyperedges representing the complete scopes of constraints. The graph is serialized to guide task reasoning and the generation of a coordinated plan through explicit consistency instructions. The paper also gives an information-theoretic sufficient condition for reducing conditional planning uncertainty. Validation spans TravelPlanner, Trip Planning, Meeting Planning, and Mystery Blocksworld, with multiple LLM backbones, structural and scope ablations, serialization comparisons, a manual induction-quality audit, and API-cost analysis. For example, Gemini 2.5 Flash reaches 59.44% TravelPlanner success, compared with 31.11% for HTP.
Critical strengths
-
Explicit constraint scopes provide a clear and useful account of why individually plausible subplans can fail jointly. The representation makes shared dependencies accessible to the reasoner, and the incidence-removal ablation provides evidence that this information matters. This is a concrete contribution to structuring constraint-rich planning prompts.
-
The empirical evaluation is comparatively broad. Improvements across four planning tasks and multiple backbones, together with component ablations and an induction-quality audit, support usefulness beyond a single application or model. This breadth is the main reason for my positive overall recommendation.
Critical weaknesses
-
The evidence establishes the usefulness of explicit scope information more strongly than a distinctive advantage of the hypergraph formulation. Removing incidence information is not equivalent to comparing against an information-matched constraint table or annotated tree. Moreover, the entropy theorem is conditional on assumptions that are not verified experimentally and does not imply higher decoding accuracy for a particular LLM. The structural and theoretical claims should therefore be narrower than a general explanation of the observed success-rate gains.
-
Important comparison details remain insufficiently documented. Search branching, depth, call and output limits, retry policies, and repetitions are not fully specified for the baselines. This is especially relevant to smaller improvements, whose stability cannot be assessed from point estimates alone. More complete configurations and paired per-instance results would strengthen confidence in the reported rankings without requiring a redesign of the method.
Questions for authors
-
Clarification of the claimed advance. Is the intended contribution the explicit organization of constraint scopes and consistency reasoning, or an advantage specific to hypergraphs over other encodings of the same information? What existing results distinguish these interpretations? Please also clarify whether the entropy result is intended only as a design rationale rather than a guarantee for actual model decoding.
-
Clarification of the comparisons. Can you provide the exact configurations and repetition counts for the strongest planning baselines, together with paired per-instance outcomes for the smaller gains? This would materially affect my confidence in the claim of consistent superiority.
3 comments
Response to Reviewer QCbq Part (2/3)
Relationship Between Theorem 1 and the Constraint Scope Analysis (W1, Q1 Part 2)
The reviewer said:
The entropy theorem is conditional on assumptions that are not verified experimentally and does not imply higher decoding accuracy for a particular LLM. The structural and theoretical claims should therefore be narrower than a general explanation of the observed success-rate gains.
-
We clarify that our experiments were never intended to verify the theorem's assumption or establish that its condition holds. We believe the reviewer's concern may refer to the following sentence in Section 5.3:
This finding agrees with Theorem 1, since assigning each constraint to its appropriate level narrows its possible scope candidates, thereby tightening the uncertainty bound.
Here, we meant that the theorem shows when hierarchical scope binding lowers the upper bound on Scope Uncertainty, while the experiment shows that this module improves success rates. These results provide complementary theoretical and empirical support for the module. We did not claim that the experiment establishes the theorem's assumption.
-
Regarding the theorem itself, we explain below that the assumption δ > ε is easy to hold in a realistic planning setting.
- δ measures the additional information that correct scopes provide about feasible plans beyond task decomposition. ε measures the uncertainty about those scopes remaining after observing the serialized hypergraph. The theorem applies when this additional information exceeds the remaining uncertainty, δ > ε.
- In practice, constraints often state their scope directly, such as a daily budget or a trip-wide limit, and the serialized hypergraph explicitly lists the affected tasks. This makes the correct scopes easy to recover, so ε → 0. At the same time, these scopes determine which decisions must be coordinated, providing useful information beyond task decomposition and thus δ > 0. Together, these properties make δ > ε easily plausible in practice.
Response to Reviewer QCbq Part (3/3)
Clarification of the Comparisons (W2, Q2)
-
We ensure fair comparisons by using either the configurations reported in the original papers or the best configurations identified through our tuning for the strong baselines. Each configuration is evaluated once on each benchmark following our strongest baseline HTP [3]. Below, we summarize the configurations and execution details.
-
ToT [4] uses a maximum search depth of 10, a search width of 3, two evaluations per candidate, and greedy selection. RAP [1] uses 20 MCTS iterations and a reward weight of α = 0.5. The depth limit is the number of trip days for TravelPlanner, cities for Trip Planning, people for Meeting Planning, and 20 for Mystery Blocksworld. EvoAgent [2] uses three evolutionary iterations. HTP [3] uses width 5 and depth 10.
-
Shared settings. HyperPlan and the six planning baselines use temperature 0. The per-call output cap is 8,000 tokens for GPT-4o and 20,000 for GPT-5-mini, Gemini 2.5 Flash, and Qwen3-235B-A22B. The larger budgets include reasoning tokens. We only allow retries after API or network errors.
-
API call counts can vary by method and instance. The table below reports the observed average number of calls per instance for each method on TravelPlanner with GPT-4o.
Method One-shot CoT ToT RAP EvoAgent HTP HyperPlan Mean API calls per instance 1 1 68 11 9 43 3
-
-
For paired per-instance outcomes, we paired outcomes by instance ID for all main-table comparisons in which HyperPlan leads the strongest baseline by at most 5% in success rate. All three compare HyperPlan with HTP [3] using GPT-4o.
Task Only HyperPlan succeeds Only HTP succeeds Both succeed Both fail Trip Planning 107 53 537 903 Meeting Planning 74 42 461 423 Mystery Blocksworld 33 9 25 433 The paired outcomes show that the two methods solve partly different sets of instances. Among instances solved by only one method, the split favors HyperPlan on all three tasks and is most pronounced on Mystery Blocksworld.
References (cited in this response)
- [1] Hao, S., Gu, Y., Ma, H., Hong, J. J., Wang, Z., Wang, D. Z., & Hu, Z. (2023). Reasoning with language model is planning with world model. EMNLP 2023, 8154–8173.
- [2] Yuan, S., Song, K., Chen, J., Tan, X., Li, D., & Yang, D. (2025). EvoAgent: Towards automatic multi-agent generation via evolutionary algorithms. NAACL 2025, 6192–6217.
- [3] Gui, R., Wang, Z., Wang, J., Ma, C., Zhen, H., Yuan, M., Hao, J., Lian, D., Chen, E., & Wu, F. (2025). HyperTree Planning: Enhancing LLM reasoning via hierarchical thinking. ICML 2025, PMLR 267, 20694–20722.
- [4] Yao, S., Yu, D., Zhao, J., Shafran, I., Griffiths, T., Cao, Y., & Narasimhan, K. (2023). Tree of thoughts: Deliberate problem solving with large language models. NeurIPS 2023.
Response to Reviewer QCbq Part (1/3)
Dear Reviewer QCbq:
We thank the reviewer for their positive assessment of our evaluation and for raising thoughtful questions. We address the concerns in detail as follows. We will include the results reported in this response in the revised manuscript.
Clarification of the Claimed Advance (W1, Q1 Part 1)
The reviewer said:
We would like to clarify that explicit scope information is a structural benefit of the hypergraph formulation. These two things are NOT independent modules. The ablation results on explicit scopes therefore provide evidence for the role of the hypergraph structure in HyperPlan.
We first clarify that we use the hypergraph as a logical structure for understanding task–constraint relationships. A hyperedge captures how its incident nodes are linked and interact. In our setting, multiple task nodes are governed by the same constraint hyperedge and therefore need to be considered jointly. Modeling the relationship this way makes the scope of each constraint explicit. In this sense, an explicit constraint scope and its corresponding hyperedge are effectively equivalent in our formulation.
Secondly, we compare HyperPlan with the suggested constraint table and annotated tree using GPT-4o-2024-11-20 [1]. We keep the extracted task and constraint descriptions, the number of LLM calls, and the planning procedure fixed. The table lists the tasks and constraints, and the tree attaches constraints to task nodes or their common ancestors. Only the hypergraph includes complete incidence relations in this comparison.
The constraint hypergraph achieves the highest success rate on both tasks. By explicitly linking each constraint to all affected tasks, hypergraph incidence makes shared constraints available for joint reasoning. These results support the value of this structural information in HyperPlan.
References