acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

HyperPlan: Modeling High-Order Task Relations with Constraint Hypergraphs for LLM Planning

Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong performance on various reasoning tasks but still struggle with complex planning problems, such as travel planning, which require long-horizon reasoning under multiple hard constraints. Existing planning methods primarily focus on effectively decomposing a complex planning objective into simpler subtasks and solving them step by step. However, they often overlook high-order relations induced by shared constraints across multiple subtasks, which constitute a fundamental challenge that distinguishes complex planning from traditional reasoning tasks. To bridge this gap, we propose HyperPlan, a novel LLM planning framework that explicitly models high-order relations among tasks using a constraint hypergraph. First, HyperPlan induces a query-specific constraint hypergraph from the parsed query semantics. Decision-oriented task nodes represent planning subtasks, while constraint hyperedges with normalized types capture complete constraint scopes through hierarchical scope binding. Second, HyperPlan serializes the hypergraph in a constraint-centric form and performs constraint-aligned task reasoning under intra-node and inter-node consistency guidance. The coordinated task solutions are then composed into the final plan. We further theoretically characterize when explicit constraint scopes reduce LLM planning uncertainty. Experiments demonstrate that HyperPlan achieves state-of-the-art performance among planning methods with LLMs as reasoners, improving success rates by up to 28.9% over strong planning baselines across diverse planning settings.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Hypergraph, LLM Planning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_QCbqOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

HyperPlan addresses LLM planning with constraints shared across multiple decisions. It induces a constraint hypergraph from the query, with decision-oriented task nodes and hyperedges representing the complete scopes of constraints. The graph is serialized to guide task reasoning and the generation of a coordinated plan through explicit consistency instructions. The paper also gives an information-theoretic sufficient condition for reducing conditional planning uncertainty. Validation spans TravelPlanner, Trip Planning, Meeting Planning, and Mystery Blocksworld, with multiple LLM backbones, structural and scope ablations, serialization comparisons, a manual induction-quality audit, and API-cost analysis. For example, Gemini 2.5 Flash reaches 59.44% TravelPlanner success, compared with 31.11% for HTP.

Critical strengths
  1. Explicit constraint scopes provide a clear and useful account of why individually plausible subplans can fail jointly. The representation makes shared dependencies accessible to the reasoner, and the incidence-removal ablation provides evidence that this information matters. This is a concrete contribution to structuring constraint-rich planning prompts.

  2. The empirical evaluation is comparatively broad. Improvements across four planning tasks and multiple backbones, together with component ablations and an induction-quality audit, support usefulness beyond a single application or model. This breadth is the main reason for my positive overall recommendation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The evidence establishes the usefulness of explicit scope information more strongly than a distinctive advantage of the hypergraph formulation. Removing incidence information is not equivalent to comparing against an information-matched constraint table or annotated tree. Moreover, the entropy theorem is conditional on assumptions that are not verified experimentally and does not imply higher decoding accuracy for a particular LLM. The structural and theoretical claims should therefore be narrower than a general explanation of the observed success-rate gains.

  2. Important comparison details remain insufficiently documented. Search branching, depth, call and output limits, retry policies, and repetitions are not fully specified for the baselines. This is especially relevant to smaller improvements, whose stability cannot be assessed from point estimates alone. More complete configurations and paired per-instance results would strengthen confidence in the reported rankings without requiring a redesign of the method.

Questions for authors
  1. Clarification of the claimed advance. Is the intended contribution the explicit organization of constraint scopes and consistency reasoning, or an advantage specific to hypergraphs over other encodings of the same information? What existing results distinguish these interpretations? Please also clarify whether the entropy result is intended only as a design rationale rather than a guarantee for actual model decoding.

  2. Clarification of the comparisons. Can you provide the exact configurations and repetition counts for the strongest planning baselines, together with paired per-instance outcomes for the smaller gains? This would materially affect my confidence in the claim of consistent superiority.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer QCbq Part (1/3)

Dear Reviewer QCbq:

We thank the reviewer for their positive assessment of our evaluation and for raising thoughtful questions. We address the concerns in detail as follows. We will include the results reported in this response in the revised manuscript.


Clarification of the Claimed Advance (W1, Q1 Part 1)

The reviewer said:

The evidence establishes the usefulness of explicit scope information more strongly than a distinctive advantage of the hypergraph formulation.

We would like to clarify that explicit scope information is a structural benefit of the hypergraph formulation. These two things are NOT independent modules. The ablation results on explicit scopes therefore provide evidence for the role of the hypergraph structure in HyperPlan.

  • We first clarify that we use the hypergraph as a logical structure for understanding task–constraint relationships. A hyperedge captures how its incident nodes are linked and interact. In our setting, multiple task nodes are governed by the same constraint hyperedge and therefore need to be considered jointly. Modeling the relationship this way makes the scope of each constraint explicit. In this sense, an explicit constraint scope and its corresponding hyperedge are effectively equivalent in our formulation.

  • Secondly, we compare HyperPlan with the suggested constraint table and annotated tree using GPT-4o-2024-11-20 [1]. We keep the extracted task and constraint descriptions, the number of LLM calls, and the planning procedure fixed. The table lists the tasks and constraints, and the tree attaches constraints to task nodes or their common ancestors. Only the hypergraph includes complete incidence relations in this comparison.

    RepresentationTravelPlanner SR (%)Meeting Planning SR (%)
    Constraint table22.2237.60
    Annotated tree18.8941.20
    Constraint hypergraph33.8953.50

    The constraint hypergraph achieves the highest success rate on both tasks. By explicitly linking each constraint to all affected tasks, hypergraph incidence makes shared constraints available for joint reasoning. These results support the value of this structural information in HyperPlan.


References

  • [1] OpenAI. GPT-4o system card. CoRR, abs/2410.21276, 2024.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer QCbq Part (2/3)

Relationship Between Theorem 1 and the Constraint Scope Analysis (W1, Q1 Part 2)

The reviewer said:

The entropy theorem is conditional on assumptions that are not verified experimentally and does not imply higher decoding accuracy for a particular LLM. The structural and theoretical claims should therefore be narrower than a general explanation of the observed success-rate gains.

  • We clarify that our experiments were never intended to verify the theorem's assumption or establish that its condition holds. We believe the reviewer's concern may refer to the following sentence in Section 5.3:

    This finding agrees with Theorem 1, since assigning each constraint to its appropriate level narrows its possible scope candidates, thereby tightening the uncertainty bound.

    Here, we meant that the theorem shows when hierarchical scope binding lowers the upper bound on Scope Uncertainty, while the experiment shows that this module improves success rates. These results provide complementary theoretical and empirical support for the module. We did not claim that the experiment establishes the theorem's assumption.

  • Regarding the theorem itself, we explain below that the assumption δ > ε is easy to hold in a realistic planning setting.

    • δ measures the additional information that correct scopes provide about feasible plans beyond task decomposition. ε measures the uncertainty about those scopes remaining after observing the serialized hypergraph. The theorem applies when this additional information exceeds the remaining uncertainty, δ > ε.
    • In practice, constraints often state their scope directly, such as a daily budget or a trip-wide limit, and the serialized hypergraph explicitly lists the affected tasks. This makes the correct scopes easy to recover, so ε → 0. At the same time, these scopes determine which decisions must be coordinated, providing useful information beyond task decomposition and thus δ > 0. Together, these properties make δ > ε easily plausible in practice.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer QCbq Part (3/3)

Clarification of the Comparisons (W2, Q2)

  • We ensure fair comparisons by using either the configurations reported in the original papers or the best configurations identified through our tuning for the strong baselines. Each configuration is evaluated once on each benchmark following our strongest baseline HTP [3]. Below, we summarize the configurations and execution details.

    • ToT [4] uses a maximum search depth of 10, a search width of 3, two evaluations per candidate, and greedy selection. RAP [1] uses 20 MCTS iterations and a reward weight of α = 0.5. The depth limit is the number of trip days for TravelPlanner, cities for Trip Planning, people for Meeting Planning, and 20 for Mystery Blocksworld. EvoAgent [2] uses three evolutionary iterations. HTP [3] uses width 5 and depth 10.

    • Shared settings. HyperPlan and the six planning baselines use temperature 0. The per-call output cap is 8,000 tokens for GPT-4o and 20,000 for GPT-5-mini, Gemini 2.5 Flash, and Qwen3-235B-A22B. The larger budgets include reasoning tokens. We only allow retries after API or network errors.

    • API call counts can vary by method and instance. The table below reports the observed average number of calls per instance for each method on TravelPlanner with GPT-4o.

      MethodOne-shotCoTToTRAPEvoAgentHTPHyperPlan
      Mean API calls per instance1168119433
  • For paired per-instance outcomes, we paired outcomes by instance ID for all main-table comparisons in which HyperPlan leads the strongest baseline by at most 5% in success rate. All three compare HyperPlan with HTP [3] using GPT-4o.

    TaskOnly HyperPlan succeedsOnly HTP succeedsBoth succeedBoth fail
    Trip Planning10753537903
    Meeting Planning7442461423
    Mystery Blocksworld33925433

    The paired outcomes show that the two methods solve partly different sets of instances. Among instances solved by only one method, the split favors HyperPlan on all three tasks and is most pronounced on Mystery Blocksworld.


References (cited in this response)

  • [1] Hao, S., Gu, Y., Ma, H., Hong, J. J., Wang, Z., Wang, D. Z., & Hu, Z. (2023). Reasoning with language model is planning with world model. EMNLP 2023, 8154–8173.
  • [2] Yuan, S., Song, K., Chen, J., Tan, X., Li, D., & Yang, D. (2025). EvoAgent: Towards automatic multi-agent generation via evolutionary algorithms. NAACL 2025, 6192–6217.
  • [3] Gui, R., Wang, Z., Wang, J., Ma, C., Zhen, H., Yuan, M., Hao, J., Lian, D., Chen, E., & Wu, F. (2025). HyperTree Planning: Enhancing LLM reasoning via hierarchical thinking. ICML 2025, PMLR 267, 20694–20722.
  • [4] Yao, S., Yu, D., Zhao, J., Shafran, I., Griffiths, T., Cao, Y., & Narasimhan, K. (2023). Tree of thoughts: Deliberate problem solving with large language models. NeurIPS 2023.
Reviewer_oVfeOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper argues that decomposing a planning query into subtasks can leave shared constraints, such as a total trip budget, implicit. HyperPlan parses the query into semantic units, constructs decision-oriented task nodes, binds constraints to the task nodes they govern as hyperedges, and serializes this structure for an LLM. The model generates subtask solutions with prompts for within-task and cross-task consistency and then composes a plan. Evaluation covers TravelPlanner, Natural Plan's Trip and Meeting Planning tasks, and Blocksworld, using GPT-4o, Gemini 2.5 Flash, and GPT-5-mini as backbones. Table 1 reports higher success than the tested prompting and planning methods in each setting. Ablations and a manual inspection of induced hypergraphs provide further evidence about the components.

Critical strengths
  1. The formulation targets a real coordination failure. A task hierarchy can partition a trip into hotels, meals, and activities while obscuring a budget that spans all three. Hyperedges can represent overlapping scopes without forcing those scopes into a tree. The method's decision-oriented nodes, explicit incidence relations, and inter-node consistency guidance give the LLM concrete information about which decisions must agree. This is a plausible reason to expect better joint feasibility than decomposition alone.

  2. The empirical evidence goes beyond one benchmark or one component comparison. Table 1 shows gains across three backbones and four planning tasks, including strong increases in TravelPlanner hard-constraint pass rates. Table 2 removes consistency guidance, incidence relations, constraint hyperedges, type guidance, and the staged induction procedure. These analyses support the relevance of structure, even though they do not completely isolate its mechanism.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The comparison does not completely separate hypergraph structure from richer prompting. HyperPlan uses several LLM stages and explicit instructions to produce rationales for consistency. Removing incidence relations retains constraint text, but changes the resulting prompt organization; removing consistency guidance changes a separate, powerful instruction. A baseline given the same extracted tasks and constraints, the same number of calls, and comparable tokens in a simple list or table would test whether hypergraph incidence itself is essential. The reported cost plots are useful but do not replace such a controlled content-and-budget comparison. Without it, the results show that the full pipeline works better, but support a weaker claim about why.
Questions for authors
  1. In the 180 manually inspected TravelPlanner cases, which induction errors are most frequent: omitted tasks, omitted constraints, wrong incidence, or incorrect types/descriptions? How do these categories relate to final success?
  2. With the extracted task and constraint descriptions held fixed, how does an equally budgeted flat list or table prompt compare with the hypergraph serialization?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer oVfe

Dear Reviewer oVfe:

We thank Reviewer oVfe for the constructive comments and questions. Below we provide additional controlled comparisons and a fine-grained analysis of hypergraph induction errors.


Controlled Comparison with Information Matched Encodings (W1, Q2)

The reviewer asks:

With the extracted task and constraint descriptions held fixed, how does an equally budgeted flat list or table prompt compare with the hypergraph serialization?

We compare a table prompt with a constraint hypergraph while keeping the task and constraint descriptions fixed and the inference budgets comparable. Both use GPT-4o-2024-11-20 [1], the same number of LLM calls, and the same planning procedure. They differ in structural organization, and only the constraint hypergraph includes hypergraph incidence. This additional information necessarily makes its input token count slightly higher than that of the table prompt. Nevertheless, their input token budgets remain comparable.

RepresentationTravelPlanner Success RateTravelPlanner Input TokensMeeting Planning Success RateMeeting Planning Input Tokens
Table Prompt22.22%2,13037.60%2,587
Constraint Hypergraph33.89%2,27453.50%2,688

The table prompt contains the complete task and constraint information but does not explicitly encode the full scope of each constraint. In contrast, the constraint hypergraph explicitly associates each constraint with all task nodes related to it. This explicit hypergraph incidence makes each constraint scope directly accessible to the LLM, helping it coordinate task solutions under shared constraints. The constraint hypergraph therefore achieves the highest success rate on both tasks under comparable token budgets.


Fine-Grained Analysis of Hypergraph Induction Errors (Q1)

The reviewer asks:

In the 180 manually inspected TravelPlanner cases, which induction errors are most frequent: omitted tasks, omitted constraints, wrong incidence, or incorrect types/descriptions? How do these categories relate to final success?

We thank the reviewer for highlighting our appendix analysis of the relationship between induction correctness and final success. In response to this question, we provide the following category-level breakdown for the 180 manually inspected TravelPlanner instances as well as our analysis.

Induction ErrorError CountFinal-Success Count
Omitted tasks30
Omitted constraints162
Wrong incidence103
Incorrect types/descriptions133
  • Firstly, omitted constraints are the most frequent induction error (16 cases). One possible reason is that constraints are expressed in diverse and sometimes ambiguous ways across user queries, making them harder to extract completely.

  • Secondly, no clear overall relationship is observed between induction error type and final success. With only a few final-success cases, final success appears slightly less common after omission errors (omitted tasks and omitted constraints) than after incidence or description errors. This slight difference may be because incidence or description errors preserve more usable information for downstream reasoning, although LLM randomness may also contribute.


References

  • [1] OpenAI. GPT-4o system card. CoRR, abs/2410.21276, 2024.

Dear Reviewer oVfe,

Thank you for your careful review and constructive suggestions. We hope the controlled table comparison and analysis of hypergraph induction errors have addressed your questions.

With the discussion period coming to a close, we would sincerely appreciate your feedback on our responses. Please let us know if there is anything we could clarify further.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Best, Authors

Reviewer_vTG2OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

HyperPlan is a LLM-based planning framework that models high-order relations among tasks using constraint hypergraphs as an intermediate layer to solve planning problems. The constraint hypergraphs can help decompose complex tasks into subtasks in a hierarchical way to eventually solve the problem problem as a coordinated subtasks.

Critical strengths
  1. A hypergraph of constraints is a valid way to model the connections of different subtasks when solving complex planning problems
  2. The paper formally describes the formulation of constraint hypergraphs as a way to guide the reasoning process in LLMs.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The major issue of the work is that it cannot demonstrate the strength of hypergraphs in LLM-based planning. There are many different ways of solving planning problems with LLMs. Some use agents to call external tools, some use external verifiers and checkers, and others, like this paper, introduce intermediate layers to guide reasoning. Regardless of the approach, the final goal is to solve complex planning problems described in natural language. In this sense, the paper cannot demonstrate its strength because existing works, even from two years ago, demonstrated better results in the same domain.
  • For example, Hao et al (2025) already solved TravelPlanner using GPT-4 with a macro success rate of >90%, while this work still stays at 50%-70% using more recent models.
  1. The authors may argue that work like Hao et al. (2025) uses external solvers, but this work does not. However, the reviewer wants to argue that the difference is the reasoning at different levels of abstraction. If the problems are shown to be almost solved by LLM-agents using external solvers, why would constraint hypergraph be needed.
  2. The other concern is that all planning domains in this paper from 2023 or 2024. It is unclear how much of the solution in those domains have been learned in the latest models.
Questions for authors
  1. Can you find planning domains that external solvers just cannot handle and for which a constraint hypergraph is needed?
  2. Can you show results in much more recent planning domains and demonstrate convincing advantage of HyperPlan over SOTA LLM-based planning methods, regardless of what external solvers they are calling?
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer vTG2 Part (1/3)

Dear Reviewer vTG2:

We thank Reviewer vTG2 for the insightful and focused comment. Below we summarize our main clarifications and further analysis in three parts.


Comparison with Solver-Based Planning Methods - Part 1 (W1)

1. We emphasize that our paper clearly defines its comparison scope, which follows established practice in the literature.

  • In both the Abstract and the Introduction, we explicitly state:

    HyperPlan achieves state-of-the-art performance among planning methods with LLMs as reasoners.

    Our claim therefore does not extend to methods in which an external solver produces the final plan.

  • LLM-as-reasoner methods generally do not compare against LLM-assisted external-solver methods. Representative studies instead compare primarily with other prompting, reasoning, or agent methods [1][2][3]. On TravelPlanner, LRPLAN [4] explicitly states that external-solver methods are not directly comparable with LLM-as-reasoner methods. It therefore excludes all external-solver methods from its evaluation. Recent literature also explicitly distinguishes LLM-as-planner from LLM-as-formalizer as two planning methodologies [5].

2. Nevertheless, following the reviewer's suggestion, we directly compare HyperPlan with Hao et al. (2025) [6], the solver-based state-of-the-art method on TravelPlanner.

  • HyperPlan offers a substantial efficiency advantage on TravelPlanner. We evaluated Hao et al.'s official implementation and HyperPlan on all 180 validation queries. All experiments reported in this response use GPT-4o-2024-11-20 [7] (the GPT-4 model used in Hao et al.'s original paper is no longer available) as the backbone.

    MethodSuccess RateAPI Cost per QueryWall-Clock Time per Query
    Hao et al. (2025)78.33%$0.09267140.09 s
    HyperPlan33.89%$0.0553620.91 s

    Despite the accuracy gap, HyperPlan reduces API cost by 40.26% and is 6.70× faster, demonstrating its value as a lightweight, solver-free alternative.

  • HyperPlan also offers a much higher degree of automation. We treat any prompt content that must be rewritten for a new task as task-specific and obtain the following statistics.

    MethodTotal Prompt CharactersTask-Specific CharactersTask-Specific Proportion
    Hao et al. (2025)51,63447,30391.61%
    HyperPlan8,4013,74944.63%

    Hao et al. place task-specific solver-code examples directly in the prompt, whereas HyperPlan only requires a general description of the hypergraph schema and therefore uses only about 8% of the task-specific prompt content required by Hao et al.


References

  • [1] Hao, S., Gu, Y., Ma, H., Hong, J. J., Wang, Z., Wang, D. Z., & Hu, Z. (2023). Reasoning with language model is planning with world model. EMNLP 2023, 8154–8173.
  • [2] Yuan, S., Song, K., Chen, J., Tan, X., Li, D., & Yang, D. (2025). EvoAgent: Towards automatic multi-agent generation via evolutionary algorithms. NAACL 2025, 6192–6217.
  • [3] Gui, R., Wang, Z., Wang, J., Ma, C., Zhen, H., Yuan, M., Hao, J., Lian, D., Chen, E., & Wu, F. (2025). HyperTree Planning: Enhancing LLM reasoning via hierarchical thinking. ICML 2025, PMLR 267, 20694–20722.
  • [4] Karthikeyan, T., Dehlan, O., Mausam, & Gupta, M. (2025). LRPLAN: A multi-agent collaboration of large language and reasoning models for planning with implicit & explicit constraints. Findings of EMNLP 2025, 8280–8310.
  • [5] Huang, C., & Zhang, L. (2025). On the limit of language models as planning formalizers. ACL 2025, 4880–4904.
  • [6] Hao, Y., Chen, Y., Zhang, Y., & Fan, C. (2025). Large language models can solve real-world planning rigorously with formal verification tools. NAACL 2025, 3434–3483.
  • [7] OpenAI. GPT-4o system card. CoRR, abs/2410.21276, 2024.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer vTG2 Part (2/3)

Comparison with Solver-Based Planning Methods - Part 2 (W2, Q1)

1. We further compare HyperPlan with Hao et al. (2025) [1] on AdaPlanBench [2], directly addressing the reviewer's Question 1:

Can you find planning domains that external solvers just cannot handle and for which a constraint hypergraph is needed?

  • HyperPlan gains a clear advantage on AdaPlanBench, where success relies heavily on LLM commonsense rather than a fully specified solver formulation. Tool Pass Rate and Preference Pass Rate concern explicit requirements that external solvers can directly enforce. Rubric Pass Rate, however, measures open-ended quality that requires LLM reasoning rather than external solvers. Success Rate requires all three to pass.

    MethodSuccess RateTool Pass RatePreference Pass RateRubric Pass Rate
    HyperPlan43.32%98.04%75.00%64.82%
    Hao et al. (2025)35.83%100.00%81.76%55.05%

    As expected, Hao et al.'s framework achieves higher Tool Pass Rate and Preference Pass Rate, both of which concern formalizable requirements. However, external solvers cannot automatically assess the open-ended qualities measured by Rubric Pass Rate, such as physical plausibility, effectiveness, and safety, whereas HyperPlan's Constraint-Aligned Task Reasoning enables the LLM to reason about them. Consequently, HyperPlan achieves a 9.77% higher rubric pass rate and a higher overall success rate (43.32% vs. 35.83%).

  • These results show that open-ended requests are difficult for external solvers to handle directly. In such requests, goals, options, or evaluation criteria depend on semantic judgment, whereas external solvers require a closed set of variables, candidate solutions, and formal constraints. Real-world user requests are often more diverse and open-ended than benchmark instances, providing the practical foundation for HyperPlan and this line of research.

2. The reviewer specifically asks in Weakness 2:

If the problems are shown to be almost solved by LLM agents using external solvers, why would a constraint hypergraph be needed?

We want to emphasize that Constraint hypergraphs and external solvers are compatible rather than mutually exclusive.

  • Our TravelPlanner and AdaPlanBench results show that high success rates on structured benchmarks do not mean that external-solver methods have fully solved these problems. Challenges remain in automation and efficiency, and their performance on open-ended problems remains limited.

  • These remaining challenges explain why constraint hypergraphs are still useful for external-solver methods. A constraint hypergraph enhances the LLM's understanding of a planning problem, regardless of whether the LLM generates the plan itself or formalizes it for an external solver. In the latter setting, it could structure the formalization prompt, potentially improving the automation and generalizability of the translation into the solver representation. We therefore consider this hybrid design an important direction for our future work.


References

  • [1] Hao, Y., Chen, Y., Zhang, Y., & Fan, C. (2025). Large language models can solve real-world planning rigorously with formal verification tools. NAACL 2025, 3434–3483.
  • [2] Liu, J., Qian, C., Wang, Z., Li, B., Liu, J., Wang, H., Kim, J., Wang, Y., Chen, X., Fung, Y. R., & Ji, H. (2026). AdaPlanBench: Evaluating adaptive planning in large language model agents under world and user constraints. arXiv:2606.05622.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer vTG2 Part (3/3)

Evaluation on a Recent Planning Benchmark (W3, Q2)

Can you show results in much more recent planning domains and demonstrate a convincing advantage of HyperPlan over state-of-the-art LLM-based planning methods, regardless of what external solvers they are calling?

Beyond the comparison with Hao et al. (2025) [1] in Part 2, we further evaluate CoT [2] and HTP [3] on AdaPlanBench [4]. The table below reports the overall success rates of all four methods, all using the same GPT-4o-2024-11-20 [5] backbone. Notably, AdaPlanBench was released in 2026, more than one year after this model version.

MethodSuccess Rate
HyperPlan43.32%
HTP37.79%
Hao et al. (2025)35.83%
CoT29.97%

This comparison directly addresses the reviewer's request to evaluate methods regardless of what external solvers they are calling. HyperPlan achieves the highest overall success rate among all four methods, including Hao et al.'s external-solver framework. These results also alleviate the reviewer’s concern about potential benchmark contamination.


References

  • [1] Hao, Y., Chen, Y., Zhang, Y., & Fan, C. (2025). Large language models can solve real-world planning rigorously with formal verification tools. NAACL 2025, 3434–3483.
  • [2] Wei, J., Wang, X., Schuurmans, D., Bosma, M., Ichter, B., Xia, F., Chi, E. H., Le, Q. V., & Zhou, D. (2022). Chain-of-thought prompting elicits reasoning in large language models. NeurIPS 2022.
  • [3] Gui, R., Wang, Z., Wang, J., Ma, C., Zhen, H., Yuan, M., Hao, J., Lian, D., Chen, E., & Wu, F. (2025). HyperTree Planning: Enhancing LLM reasoning via hierarchical thinking. ICML 2025, PMLR 267, 20694–20722.
  • [4] Liu, J., Qian, C., Wang, Z., Li, B., Liu, J., Wang, H., Kim, J., Wang, Y., Chen, X., Fung, Y. R., & Ji, H. (2026). AdaPlanBench: Evaluating adaptive planning in large language model agents under world and user constraints. arXiv:2606.05622.
  • [5] OpenAI. GPT-4o system card. CoRR, abs/2410.21276, 2024.

Dear Reviewer vTG2,

Thank you for your time and thoughtful feedback. We hope the solver-based comparisons and results on AdaPlanBench have addressed your concerns.

As the discussion period is nearing its end, we would greatly appreciate it if you could review our responses and let us know whether any questions remain. We would be happy to provide further clarification.

Thank you again for helping us improve the paper.

Best, Authors

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Summary

Dear Reviewers and Area Chair,

We sincerely thank all reviewers for their careful assessments and constructive feedback. During the rebuttal, we provided additional experiments and clarifications. Reviewer QCbq confirmed that they will maintain their positive score.

Across the reviews, the reviewers highlighted the following strengths:

  • Our formulation targets a real coordination failure caused by constraints shared across multiple decisions.
  • Constraint hypergraphs explicitly capture task relationships and constraint scopes, supporting consistency reasoning.
  • The broad empirical evaluation supports usefulness beyond a single application or model, providing a key basis for the positive recommendation.

We have carefully considered the reviewers’ concerns and provided additional experiments and clarifications in response. We summarize these efforts below and would be grateful for any further feedback.

Main IssueReviewers’ QuestionsOur Response
1. Comparison with Hao et al., an LLM-assisted external-solver method [1]vTG2: If external-solver methods nearly solve these planning problems, why are constraint hypergraphs needed? Can we identify problems where they remain useful?1. Our original claim concerns LLMs as reasoners, following established comparison practices in this research setting. 2. Against Hao et al. [1] on TravelPlanner, HyperPlan achieves lower success but is 6.70× faster, costs 40.26% less, and uses about 8% of its task-specific prompt content. 3. On an open-ended benchmark AdaPlanBench, HyperPlan achieves 43.32% success versus 35.83% for Hao et al. [1]. 4. Constraint hypergraphs can also support the problem understanding required for external-solver methods, making the two approaches compatible.
2. Value of constraint hypergraphs as a uniform planning representationvTG2 (further comment): Why is a hypergraph needed as the intermediate reasoning layer?1. Theoretical role: HyperPlan is the first LLM planning framework to explicitly model which tasks are jointly governed by each constraint through hypergraph incidence. Constraint hypergraphs naturally capture these relationships, providing a uniform representation that can enhance existing planning methods. 2. Solver-based evidence: Adding the constraint hypergraph to an external-solver pipeline raises its success rate from 76.11% to 85.56% and outperforms Hao et al. (78.33%), demonstrating HyperPlan's generalizability across different planning paradigms.
3. Contribution of hypergraph formulationoVfe, QCbq: With task and constraint descriptions held fixed, how does HyperPlan compare with a table or annotated tree under comparable inference budgets?We compared constraint table and annotated tree variants with comparable token budgets, holding call counts and downstream reasoning fixed. HyperPlan outperforms the constraint table and annotated tree by an average of 13.34% on TravelPlanner and 14.10% on Meeting Planning, supporting the value of hypergraph formulation.
4. Evaluation on a recent benchmarkvTG2: Can HyperPlan demonstrate an advantage on more recent planning benchmarks, including comparisons with methods using external solvers?On AdaPlanBench (2026), HyperPlan achieves 43.32% success, ahead of HTP (37.79%), the external-solver baseline [1] (35.83%), and CoT (29.97%). All use GPT-4o-2024-11-20, which predates the benchmark’s release. This alleviates the reviewer’s concern about potential benchmark contamination
5. Configurations and paired per-instance outcomesQCbq: Can we provide exact baseline configurations, repetition counts, and paired per-instance outcomes for the smaller gains?1. We reported baseline configurations, output limits, retry policies, observed average API calls, and one run per configuration. 2. We provided paired outcome summaries for all main-table gains within five percentage points of the strongest baseline.

[1] Hao, Y., Chen, Y., Zhang, Y., & Fan, C. (2025). Large Language Models Can Solve Real-World Planning Rigorously with Formal Verification Tools. In Proceedings of NAACL 2025 (Volume 1: Long Papers), pp. 3434–3483. Association for Computational Linguistics.

We will incorporate these results and clarifications into the revised manuscript. Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Best regards, The Authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.