- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper looks at whether segmentation models can generate rough object masks and thereby make human-like judgments in physical reasoning tasks involving concave shapes.
Critical strengths
It's a concrete, well-controlled behavioral alignment pipeline. It turns model masks into predictions for the exact same TTC and change-detection stimuli that humans saw, and it also feeds in the true velocity so you can isolate how much of the effect comes from the representation itself. So it's testing a precise geometric hypothesis rather than relying on generic segmentation metrics or eyeballing the masks.
Critical weaknesses
I just have one small concern: Section 5's conclusion interprets the intermediate checkpoints and the smaller or less-trained models as evidence that resource limits give rise to human-like bodies, and that scaling effects lead to a growing representational gap between humans and machines. But the actual intervention is really just evaluating standard segmentation learners at different training steps and capacities — it never explicitly sets up a trade-off between physical prediction quality and quantified resource cost, complexity measures, or compute budget.
Questions for authors
See weakness.
3 comments
Thank you for your reply, my main concern has been solved. Because the maximum score is 4, I cannot increase my score any further. I believe this is a very good piece of work and deserves to be accepted at ICLR.
Thank you for your support of our work and for the thoughtful review.
Response to Reviewer wAPw: Clarifying Resource Rationality and Scope
We thank Reviewer wAPw for their positive review and insightful comment. We incorporate the suggestion into our work as follows:
We have removed the resource rationality claims from the abstract and conclusion, and revised Section 5 to present it as a possible interpretation, distinct from our empirical findings. We have also narrowed our claims about human-model divergence and scaling to the specific behavioral effects studied here.
These changes in sections 5-6 are marked in magenta in the revised PDF. We sincerely thank Reviewer wAPw for their positive review and hope to have addressed their main concern. We remain available for any further clarifications.