acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

SCOPE: Sibling-Contrast Procedural Evolution for Self-Evolving Power Grid Planning

Abstract

Large Language Model (LLM) agents can use external simulators to verify proposed actions in power grid planning, but turning the resulting search experience into reusable planning knowledge remains a challenge. We introduce Sibling-Contrast Procedural Evolution (SCOPE), a self-evolving framework for secure power grid reinforcement planning that learns reusable planning strategies from verified search experience. Within each episode, SCOPE generates complementary candidate plans guided by diagnostic evidence, investment cost, and security requirements, and evaluates their physical consequences from the same grid state. It then performs plan fusion by selecting and recombining actions from the candidates before selecting an improved plan. Across episodes, SCOPE maintains two external memory banks: an episodic bank that stores concrete precedents from previously solved scenarios, and a procedural bank that consolidates verified planning trajectories into reusable planning strategies that guide future tasks. We evaluate SCOPE on 100 operating scenarios of an augmented IEEE 118-bus system using 24-hour AC power flow checks and peak hour N-1 contingency analysis. Results show that SCOPE can continuously improve its power planning strategies across episodes and provide better plans for future scenarios.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Self-Evolving agents, Large Language Model Agents, experience consolidation, Power Grid Reinforcement Planning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.25 over 4 reviews, above 49% of the others.
Reviewer_RUB2OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The problem addressed in this paper is power grid planning. The approach leverages LLMs to generate candidate updates which contain instantiated actions. These updates are structured into three categories, each focused on a different criterion (such as diagnostic evidence, investment cost and security requirements). A heuristic search is used to find an improved plan with no optimality guarantees. An empirical evaluation is presented where a few variations of the system at hand are compared against each other (full version versus partial versions), with no external baseline included.

Critical strengths

The problem addressed is important. Leveraging LLMs is an interesting and worth-of-being-study approach.

Critical weaknesses

No baseline approaches are included in the evaluation. This makes it difficult if possible at all to understand how the SCOPE approach compares to the state of the art. The presentation of the technical approach in the main paper is not sufficiently specific. An example and more details on how each step works would help. Only one grid topology, namely IEEE 118 is used in experiments. More topologies would add breadth and possibly new insights not visible in the one topology considered.

Questions for authors

What baseline methods would be appropriate for a comparison?

2 comments

Response to Reviewer RUB2

We thank the reviewer for the review and for recognizing the importance of the problem and the interest of an LLM-based approach. We address each weakness and the question below.

Weaknesses

W1. No baseline approaches.

We added two established, non-LLM planning baselines that use the same candidate actions, costs and pandapower verifier: VeraGrid, which searches candidate investments with a genetic algorithm, and particle swarm optimization (PSO). Over three seeds on all 100 scenarios, both secure every scenario, at a mean investment cost of USD 60.80M (VeraGrid) and USD 60.90M (PSO) (non-LLM baseline comparison table). SCOPE also secures every scenario in all three runs, at a mean investment cost of USD 48.76M ± 0.12, about 20% lower than both baselines; its run time is somewhat longer (11.5 vs. 9.1 minutes per scenario), as it includes LLM inference.

W2. The technical approach is not sufficiently specific.

We added to the revised manuscript a worked example of one complete planning round.

W3. Only one grid topology.

The current study focuses on the planning method and evaluates it on one topology, the IEEE 118-bus system, which is large enough that security-constrained reinforcement is non-trivial while every candidate can be verified with full AC power flow and N-1 analysis. We now state this scope explicitly in the revised manuscript, and discuss extending SCOPE to further power systems as future work.

Question

Q1. What baseline methods would be appropriate for a comparison?

Appropriate baselines include security-constrained expansion planning with mathematical optimization, metaheuristics such as genetic algorithms and particle swarm optimization, and simple heuristics based on the verifier's diagnostics. We added VeraGrid (genetic algorithm) and particle swarm optimization, both using the same pandapower verifier as SCOPE (non-LLM baseline comparison table).

Thank you once again for your thoughtful feedback. We appreciate the time you have dedicated to reviewing our work.

To summarize our rebuttal:

  • W1 & Q1: We added two non-LLM baselines, VeraGrid’s genetic algorithm and particle swarm optimization, using the same candidate actions, costs, and physical verifier as SCOPE. Across three runs on all 100 scenarios, all methods achieve 100% secure completion. SCOPE achieves approximately 20% lower investment cost, with somewhat longer runtime (11.5 vs. 9.1 minutes per scenario).
  • W2: We added a worked example of one complete planning round to make the technical approach more concrete.
  • W3: We clarified that the current evaluation covers one topology, the IEEE 118-bus system, and discussed evaluation on additional power systems as future work.

As the discussion phase is drawing to a close, we would be grateful if you could revisit our responses. Your feedback on whether these additions address your concerns would be very valuable to us. If you feel that our responses have adequately addressed your concerns, we would appreciate it if you could consider updating your scores accordingly.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Reviewer_QYnoOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

SCOPE is an LLM agent for transmission reinforcement planning that reuses experience without updating model parameters. It proposes complementary candidates from the same retained plan and evaluates them using AC power flow and peak-hour N-1 contingency checks. A further candidate combines actions from these sibling plans and is verified separately. The agent stores concrete planning precedents and derives procedural strategies, conditioned on the planning state, from candidate outcomes. In a five-fold evaluation on 100 synthetic scenarios from an augmented IEEE 118-bus network, with memories frozen during testing, the authors report 100% completion under the specified security screen. The method also uses less online planning time and fewer output tokens than the same search without memory. The paper includes component ablations and examines further cost reductions after the security requirements have been met.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper brings LLM search and experience reuse into a framework for transmission reinforcement planning, with physical checks on the proposed plans. Complementary candidates and separately verified action fusion are sensible choices when reinforcement decisions affect one another. The framework reuses experience across related scenarios without updating model parameters.

  2. The held-out evaluation, with memories frozen during testing, shows that experience from other scenarios can reduce online planning effort. Compared with the same search without memory, the full method reduces median online time by about 52% and median output tokens by about 58%. The component comparisons and examples of both successful and unsuccessful reuse help explain the benefits and limitations.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The evaluation leaves the contribution of sibling-contrast learning unclear. Existing methods such as ExpeL and ReasoningBank/MaTTS already extract reusable guidance from successful and failed experiences, including through trajectory comparisons. As the paper discusses, SCOPE differs in its use of physically verified sibling outcomes. The experiments do not establish how much this difference contributes to the gains beyond the general benefits of retrieved precedents and procedural guidance.

  2. The results support faster online planning, but the overall trade-off between investment cost and computational effort is less clear. The cost-refinement comparison does not establish that actual planning budgets are comparable for individual scenarios. Single runs and aggregate results also leave the consistency of the additional gains from procedural memory uncertain. The evidence is therefore insufficient to judge how reliably the full framework improves on simpler configurations or whether the benefit justifies the added complexity.

Questions for authors
  1. What evidence shows that learning from physically verified sibling outcomes adds value beyond existing procedural memory methods? A comparison with a representative method in the same planning framework would help establish this contribution.

  2. Do the reported gains in planning efficiency and investment cost persist under comparable actual computational budgets, when completion rates and investment costs are assessed together?

  3. How consistent are the gains from procedural memory over episodic memory alone? In particular, how much do these gains vary across scenarios, and how sensitive are they to randomness in the planning process?

  4. How many subsequent planning tasks would be needed for the online savings to offset the cost of building the memory banks, relative to the same search without memory?

  5. Appendix F includes both beneficial and unsuccessful reuse. What patterns across the evaluated scenarios explain when procedural memory helps or causes regressions? Which changes are most likely to make reuse more reliable in those cases?

  6. The experiments use memories built offline and frozen during testing. What conclusions about self-evolution does this evaluation support, and what remains to be tested when memories are updated repeatedly?

4 comments

Response to Reviewer QYno (Part 1/2)

We thank the reviewer for the precise and constructive review, and for recognizing the held-out evaluation and the component comparisons. We address each weakness and question below.

Weaknesses

W1. Contribution of sibling-contrast learning relative to ExpeL and ReasoningBank.

SCOPE differs from these methods in that its guidance is extracted from sibling candidates evaluated from the same grid state by a physical verifier, so differences in outcome can be attributed to the candidates' actions rather than to differences in state or to an LLM's own judgment. To measure what this contributes, we implemented ExpeL and ReasoningBank inside the same SCOPE planning loop, with the same LLM, the same source scenarios and the same episodic memory, so that only the way procedural guidance is extracted and retrieved differs. Each method was run three times on all 100 scenarios (procedural-memory comparison table). SCOPE reaches a lower investment cost than both: USD 48.76M, compared with USD 56.26M for ExpeL (-13.3%) and USD 54.79M for ReasoningBank (-11.0%). It also needs fewer planning rounds (1.45 vs. 1.69 and 2.16), less time (11.5 vs. 15.2 and 15.3 minutes per scenario) and fewer output tokens (29% and 46% fewer), and it secures all 100 scenarios in every run. Procedural guidance extracted from physically verified sibling outcomes therefore adds value that general experience-extraction methods do not provide in this setting.

Procedural memory methods inside the same SCOPE planning loop (Qwen3.5-9B, 100 scenarios). Mean ± standard deviation over three runs.

Procedural memorySecure (%)Cost (USD M)RoundsTime (min)Output tokens
ExpeL99.33 ± 1.1556.26 ± 0.361.69 ± 0.0515.22 ± 0.5115,909 ± 536
ReasoningBank98.67 ± 0.5854.79 ± 0.522.16 ± 0.0315.33 ± 0.2020,838 ± 546
SCOPE100.00 ± 0.0048.76 ± 0.121.45 ± 0.0611.54 ± 1.0511,244 ± 155

W2. Trade-off between investment cost and computational effort; single runs.

We agree that comparing configurations after the same number of rounds does not fix their actual computation. We now report secure completion and investment cost together with planning rounds, wall-clock time and output tokens for every configuration, averaged over three runs (main-results table). SCOPE reaches the lowest cost with the fewest rounds, and uses fewer output tokens than every configuration except the single-candidate search, which is far more expensive. Under an equal budget, given only SCOPE's own run time on each scenario, the two fastest configurations (single and siblings) secure most scenarios but their plans cost 14-42% more than SCOPE's on the same scenarios. The original cost-refinement comparison did not fix the planning budget, so we repeated it with a matched total budget of ten planning rounds, in which each configuration keeps refining its secure plan until the budget is used (cost-refinement table). SCOPE's plan is the cheapest at every budget, and its first secure plan (USD 48.8M after one round) is already cheaper than what any other configuration reaches after ten rounds (at best USD 49.9M, for episodic memory alone).

Mean investment cost (USD M) after a given total number of planning rounds, with refinement continuing after the plan is secure (Qwen3.5-9B, 100 scenarios).

Configuration1 round2 rounds4 rounds6 rounds8 rounds10 rounds
Single------83.0980.9679.31
Siblings--56.0755.1053.9152.9051.96
+ Plan fusion--55.0153.4952.1551.1650.30
+ Episodic--54.4552.9251.6850.7149.92
SCOPE (full)48.7648.3147.7147.1846.7246.38

Response to Reviewer QYno (Part 2/2)

Q1. Evidence that learning from physically verified sibling outcomes adds value beyond existing procedural memory methods.

We implemented ExpeL and ReasoningBank inside the same SCOPE planning loop, with the same LLM, source scenarios and episodic memory, so that only the way procedural guidance is extracted and retrieved differs (procedural-memory comparison table). Over three runs, SCOPE reaches a lower investment cost than both (USD 48.76M, compared with USD 56.26M for ExpeL and USD 54.79M for ReasoningBank), with fewer planning rounds, less time and fewer output tokens, and it secures every scenario.

Q2. Do the gains persist under comparable computational budgets, with completion rates and investment costs assessed together?

Yes. Assessed together, SCOPE secures every scenario in all three runs at the lowest investment cost, with the fewest planning rounds and fewer output tokens than every configuration except the single-candidate search (main-results table). Given only SCOPE's own run time on each scenario, no other configuration secures every scenario, and on the scenarios they do secure their plans cost at least 14% more than SCOPE's; the same holds under an equal output-token budget.

Q3. Consistency of the gains from procedural memory over episodic memory alone.

Across three runs, SCOPE's mean investment cost is USD 48.76M ± 0.12, compared with USD 54.03M ± 0.66 for episodic memory alone (main-results table); the difference of USD 5.27M is far larger than the variation between runs. SCOPE also needs fewer planning rounds (1.45 vs. 2.06) and 29% fewer output tokens.

Q4. How many planning tasks are needed for the online savings to offset the cost of building the memory banks?

We rebuilt both memories from smaller, condition-balanced subsets of each fold's 80 source scenarios (10 and 40 scenarios), with the same construction code (memory-size table). Performance degrades gracefully with less experience: a memory built from 40 scenarios costs USD 1.07M more per scenario than the full memory, and one built from 10 scenarios USD 3.84M more, while all sizes keep 100% secure completion and short searches.

The source runs are ordinary planning runs that also produce plans for their own scenarios, so the only additional cost of building the memory is consolidation, 27 minutes per fold. SCOPE saves about 1.7 minutes per scenario compared with plan fusion without memory (11.5 vs. 13.2 minutes, main-results table), so consolidation is recovered after roughly 16 new scenarios. Because run time varies between runs, this is an approximate figure; the saving in output tokens is more stable, at about 5,900 fewer tokens per scenario.

SCOPE with memories built from different numbers of source scenarios (Qwen3.5-9B, 100 scenarios), and the time to build each memory per fold. The full memory is SCOPE as in the main results (mean of three runs); the smaller memories are one run each. Source planning is the wall-clock time of the source runs, from their logs; consolidation for the 10-scenario memory includes one retried attempt on a shared GPU, so it is an upper bound.

Memory built fromSecure (%)Cost (USD M)RoundsSource planning (min)Consolidation (min)
10 scenarios10052.571.33256
40 scenarios10049.801.3710912
80 scenarios (full, SCOPE)10048.761.4521527

Q5. Patterns that explain when procedural memory helps or causes regressions, and how to make reuse more reliable.

Across the 100 scenarios, adding procedural memory to episodic memory lowers the mean investment cost by USD 5.27M per scenario, from USD 54.03M to USD 48.76M, with fewer planning rounds (main-results table). Procedural memory helped most when a day required many coordinated upgrades, as on summer, heat-wave and storm days and when base-case violations were present from the start, and caused regressions when a lightly stressed day had only a few moderate overloads that episodic memory alone had already sized leanly, which happened in about 6 episodes and by at most USD 1.7M.

Q6. What conclusions about self-evolution does the frozen-memory evaluation support?

In our framework, the procedural strategies are consolidated every 50 scenarios. With 100 scenarios split into five folds, repeated updates during evaluation would allow only a single consolidation step, so we built the memories once and froze them for a clean held-out comparison. The frozen evaluation therefore supports the conclusion that verified experience from other scenarios can be reused to plan new scenarios more efficiently without updating model parameters. Repeated memory updates over a longer stream of scenarios remain to be tested, and we now state this in the revised manuscript.

Thanks for the additional experiments and explanations. The comparisons with ExpeL and ReasoningBank, the repeated runs, and the matched-budget results have addressed several of my main concerns. I am raising my score from 2 to 3.

I still have two questions:

  1. How does the one-round result in the refinement table relate to the average of 1.45 rounds in the main table? It would help to show how many scenarios have finished at each budget and which ones contribute to the reported cost.

  2. The estimate of about 16 tasks makes sense when the source planning runs would have happened anyway. How many tasks would be needed to recover the cost if those source runs were carried out specifically to build the memory?

Thank you for raising your score, and we address both your questions below.

Q1. The refinement table places each configuration at its mean number of rounds to security, rounded to a whole round. For SCOPE, 1.45 rounds is rounded to one round. The table below shows how many scenarios each configuration secures within a given number of rounds:

Configuration1 round2 rounds4 rounds6 rounds8 rounds10 rounds
Single163758768792
Siblings336089999999
+ Plan fusion335587999999
+ Episodic496593100100100
SCOPE5598100100100100

Scenarios secured (of 100) within each planning-round budget.

Q2 In that case, building the full memory costs both the source planning and the consolidation, about 215 + 27 = 242 minutes per fold. At SCOPE’s saving of about 1.7 minutes per scenario, this is recovered after roughly 140 new scenarios.

Reviewer_VAY2OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Planning power systems upgrades under security constraints and considering AC power flow is a challenging problem due to its highly non-convex nature and large number of constraints. Leveraging the comparative speed of AC power flow simulation, this work proposes a novel optimization approach for power system planning that repeatedly calls an LLM to propose power system upgrades after observing simulation outputs (i.e., constraint violations). Specifically, the algorithm targets each 24-hour scenario (i.e., an episode) independently and makes planning decisions in rounds, with each round consisting of three "sibling" proposals (targeting precedence, cost, and security), simulations of the corresponding candidate systems, synthesizing the sibling proposals to create a new candidate plan, and selecting among the four candidates based on a domination criterion. During a memory-building phase, each rounds' plans and associated outcomes are stored in memory and used to develop explicit planning strategies, which are then recalled in the evaluation phase. The paper applies their algorithm to the IEEE 118-bus test system with 100 synthetic scenarios and compare obtained costs, feasibility, output token count, and runtime for variants of their proposed algorithm.

Critical strengths

The paper's main strength is the novelty of its approach, particularly the construction and synthesis of sibling proposals targeting different objectives as well as learning planning strategies from both accepted and rejected candidates. Moreover, the approach seems easily implementable (the code is released and built on an open model and simulator) and quite general, and I can imagine it being used to address hard-to-optimize or subjective considerations in planning, such as equity/justice or ambiguous, hard-to-quantify constraints, though the current selection rule is purely numerical. The paper’s secondary strength is its writing quality and organization, particularly in explaining the algorithm itself.

Critical weaknesses

The paper has several significant limitations that must be addressed for it to warrant acceptance. The first is its restriction to planning for individual 24-hour scenarios, rather than a single plan for a set or distribution of operating conditions, which is typically assumed in long-term power system planning. As a result, each plan is only verified for the scenario it was built for, and the reported costs do not correspond to an actual investment decision. The second limitation is the lack of baselines beyond ablations of the proposed method. Established planning approaches such as MILP formulations for DC-OPF based approximations as well as optimization metaheuristics (e.g., genetic algorithms, particle swarm optimization) have been applied to transmission expansion planning previously, and even a simple greedy heuristic (e.g., one based on the verifier’s diagnostics) would help contextualize the results. Without such comparisons or an optimality reference, the results do not demonstrate that the proposed algorithm produces better planning outcomes than standard methods.

Questions for authors
  1. Am I correct in understanding that each 24-hour scenario is planned independently? If so, have the authors evaluated how the final plans perform on other scenarios (e.g., other days of the same or different condition), and could the framework be extended to produce a single plan that performs well across a distribution of scenarios?

  2. Could the authors show how quickly violations are reduced across rounds and how investment cost evolves across rounds? In particular, plotting these quantities against wall-clock time or tokens, in addition to rounds, would help illustrate the ability of the LLM-based approach to improve plans within episodes.

  3. How non-trivial are the learned procedural strategies? The example in Appendix E largely recommends upgrading the most heavily loaded lines when N−1 thermal violations remain, which a simple diagnostic heuristic would also do. Could the authors provide further examples of learned strategies that encode less obvious planning knowledge?

5 comments

Response to Reviewer VAY2

We thank the reviewer for the thorough review and for recognizing the novelty of the complementary sibling proposals and their synthesis. We address each weakness and question below.

W1. Planning for individual 24-hour scenarios rather than a distribution of operating conditions

The current formulation addresses scenario-conditioned reinforcement planning: each episode seeks a low-cost plan that satisfies 24-hour AC power-flow checks and peak-hour N-1 contingency checks for one operating scenario. It does not optimize a single investment plan across a distribution of future operating conditions. We now state this scope explicitly in the revised manuscript.

Our new cross-day evaluation supports the reviewer’s concern: plans optimized for individual days have limited coverage of other days. The most expensive plans cover more days but require substantially higher investment. We report the results under Q1 below and discuss joint planning across operating conditions as future work.

W2. Lack of baselines and of an optimality reference

We added the two metaheuristic baselines suggested by the reviewer: a genetic algorithm implemented through VeraGrid and particle swarm optimization (PSO). Both use the same candidate actions, costs, and pandapower verifier as SCOPE, including 24-hour AC power flow and peak-hour N-1 analysis.

MethodSecure (%)Cost (USD M)Time (min/scenario)
VeraGrid (genetic algorithm)100 ± 060.80 ± 0.049.10 ± 0.02
Particle swarm optimization100 ± 060.90 ± 0.079.11 ± 0.03
SCOPE (Qwen3.5-9B)100 ± 048.76 ± 0.1211.54 ± 1.05

Values are mean ± standard deviation over three runs on all 100 scenarios.

All methods secure every scenario in every run. SCOPE achieves approximately 20% lower investment cost, with longer runtime: 11.54 versus approximately 9.1 minutes per scenario. These comparisons provide empirical optimization baselines, but do not establish a global optimum or a certified optimality gap.

Q1. Is each scenario planned independently? How do plans perform on other scenarios, and can the framework produce a single plan for a distribution?

Yes, each 24-hour scenario is planned independently.

For each of the five operating conditions, we selected the cheapest, median-cost, and most expensive SCOPE plans among its 20 scenarios. We evaluated each selected plan on the other 19 days of that condition using the same AC power-flow and N-1 checks.

ConditionCheapest planMedian-cost planMost expensive plan
Normal0/198/1913/19
Cloudy0/199/1919/19
Storm0/197/1916/19
Heat wave2/199/1913/19
Summer0/199/1919/19
Total2/95 (2.1%)42/95 (44.2%)80/95 (84.2%)
Mean selected-plan cost (USD M)35.0048.8268.76

Almost all transfer failures arise from N-1 contingencies. On the other days they secure, median-cost plans cost an average of USD 6.2–16.4M more than those days’ own SCOPE plans, depending on the condition. The corresponding premium for the most expensive plans is USD 19.9–29.4M.

These results show that single-day performance does not establish security across operating conditions. Producing one plan for a distribution requires explicitly considering multiple profiles during planning and verification. We discuss this extension and the investment-versus-coverage trade-off in the revised manuscript.

Q2. Violations and investment cost across rounds, wall-clock time, and tokens

We added plots for a representative scenario showing remaining violations and investment cost against planning rounds, wall-clock time, and output tokens for each configuration.

In heat_wave_09, SCOPE removes most violations in its first round and becomes secure after two rounds at USD 66.8M, the lowest investment cost among the configurations. Only the single-candidate and sibling searches finish sooner, at 17–19% higher investment cost. This example illustrates the trade-off between online computation and investment cost.

Q3. How non-trivial are the learned procedural strategies?

We agree that the example in Appendix E resembles a diagnostic rule. To test whether the learned guidance contributes beyond such a rule, we replaced it with a fixed, hand-written heuristic in the same format, keeping everything else unchanged.

The heuristic instructs the planner to upgrade the most heavily loaded branches under the worst contingencies, add reactive support at the lowest-voltage buses, fix base-case violations first, and prefer upgrades over new lines.

With this replacement, plans are more expensive in all 99 scenarios it secures, by USD 7.46M on average (15%), require more planning rounds, and perform no better than episodic memory alone. This supports the value of the learned strategies beyond the tested diagnostic heuristic.

Thank you for your response. I appreciate the authors' effort in addressing my questions. However, the approach’s restriction to planning for a single 24-hour scenario at a time limits the practical relevance of the work, and as the authors note in their response, the cross-day evaluations support this concern. While I think the work would also benefit from a more thorough comparison with other baseline methods (i.e., beyond metaheuristics), my main concern is that the approach does not account for inter-scenario variability, which is standard in power system planning applications. I believe that accounting for this variability is a core requirement for any long-term planning method rather than an extension that can be deferred to future work. As such, I choose to maintain my current score.

Thank you for your reply. This is an easy extension, we just replace our one input with k inputs, for example k daily operating profiles instead of one. The verifier then checks each plan against all k profiles, and the rest of the framework stays the same.

Reviewer_TGGtOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper describes SCOPE, a self-evolving LLM agent for secure transmission reinforcement planning. SCOPE combines verifier-grounded search with reusable memory. In this case, for each scenario, a model generates three complementary candidate plans from the same retained state, verifies them via 24-hour AC power-flow and peak-hour N-1 screening, and then constructs a constrained and reverified fusion plan from their actions. Experimental results across 100 scenarios for an augmented IEEE 118-bus system show that SCOPE achieves secure completion while reducing the number of planning rounds and time/tokens compared to similar search procedures without memory.

Critical strengths
  • The paper combines a plan fusion mechanism and verified fused strategies.
  • The dual-level memory strategy is interesting for differentiating between episodic and procedural strategies, leveraging both accepted and informative-rejected actions grounded in simulations.
  • The proposed strategy is interesting for generating new power-grid operation scenarios, including extreme ones, and for safely handling them with some guarantees.
Critical weaknesses
  • This paper assumes equal costs for topological actions, such as adding a new power line, redispatching, and curtailment. This may explain the model's bias toward proposing new power lines. Adding a new power line is challenging in practice due to the financial cost and various physical and regulatory constraints.
  • The paper mentions renewable power sources but lacks a description of how they are managed, the actions taken, and the results. They are usually a source of stochasticity to the power grid, as they cannot be easily controlled.
  • The paper lacks comparison with non-LLM power grid management methods, including RL-based and traditional approaches.
  • The analysis section primarily describes the results presented in the tables, without further discussion of their practical implications (e.g., operational costs) or even the stability of those results.
  • The experiments are limited to a single LLM model, without an ablation study of the impact of the chosen operational planning window and prompt strategy.
Questions for authors
  1. Are there any results that analyze the quality of the proposed actions to illustrate the limitations of the LLM-based scenarios?
  2. Is there any sensitivity analysis of the results to episodic and procedural retrieval metrics?
  3. What are the results for configurations with different renewable power sources and different operational time windows?
4 comments

Response to Reviewer TGGt (Part 1/2)

We thank the reviewer for the detailed review and for finding the plan fusion mechanism and dual-level memory interesting. We address each weakness and question below.

W1. Equal costs for topological actions; bias toward new lines

SCOPE does not assume equal action costs. Each action type has its own cost function (Appendix B.3):

  • Line upgrade: USD 2.0M plus USD 0.05M per added MVA.
  • Transformer upgrade: USD 2.5M plus USD 0.035M per added MVA.
  • Reactive support: USD 0.5M plus USD 0.02M per MVAr.
  • New line: USD 20M plus USD 0.10M per MVA of rating.

The cost model therefore assigns new lines a substantially higher fixed cost, discouraging their unnecessary use. The action set contains no redispatch or curtailment actions. We agree that new lines face additional regulatory and physical constraints in practice, and we now note these limitations in the revised manuscript.

W2. Management of renewable sources

Each renewable site injects its available active power at zero reactive power and is not controlled by the planner. Renewable variability enters through the 24-hour profiles of each operating condition, including low wind on summer days and low solar on storm days. The current formulation does not model renewable forecast errors or renewable reactive-power control. We added this description to the revised manuscript.

W3. Comparison with non-LLM methods

We added two non-LLM baselines using the same candidate actions, costs, and pandapower verifier as SCOPE: VeraGrid’s genetic-algorithm investment search and particle swarm optimization (PSO). Verification includes 24-hour AC power flow and peak-hour N-1 contingency analysis.

MethodSecure (%)Cost (USD M)Time (min/scenario)
VeraGrid (genetic algorithm)100 ± 060.80 ± 0.049.10 ± 0.02
Particle swarm optimization100 ± 060.90 ± 0.079.11 ± 0.03
SCOPE (Qwen3.5-9B)100 ± 048.76 ± 0.1211.54 ± 1.05

Values are mean ± standard deviation over three runs on all 100 scenarios.

All methods secure every scenario in every run. SCOPE achieves approximately 20% lower investment cost, with longer runtime: 11.54 versus approximately 9.1 minutes per scenario. SCOPE’s runtime includes LLM inference.

W4. Practical implications and stability of the results

The revised main results report mean ± standard deviation over three independent trials. Within the evaluated setting, SCOPE produces a simulator-verified secure reinforcement plan in an average of 1.45 planning rounds and approximately 12 minutes per scenario. Mean investment cost is approximately USD 12M lower than the non-LLM baselines, with a standard deviation of USD 0.12M across runs.

These results concern scenario-specific plans under the modelled conditions. They do not establish implementability or security across untested operating conditions. We expanded the discussion of these practical implications and limitations.

W5. Single LLM; planning window and prompt strategy

We ran the full pipeline unchanged on two larger models from other model families, Mistral Large 4 and Muse Spark. For each model, episodic memory contained that model’s own solved trajectories from each fold’s training scenarios, and the model itself generated the strategy bank using the same prompts and validation procedure as Qwen.

ModelSecure (%)Cost (USD M)RoundsTime (min/scenario)Output tokens
Qwen3.5-9B100 ± 048.76 ± 0.121.45 ± 0.0611.54 ± 1.0511,244 ± 155
Mistral Large 4100 ± 052.89 ± 0.031.15 ± 0.0211.21 ± 0.4615,429 ± 90
Muse Spark100 ± 052.72 ± 0.071.28 ± 0.0211.44 ± 0.7617,416 ± 811

Values are mean ± standard deviation over three runs on all 100 scenarios.

All three models secure every scenario in every run. Qwen3.5-9B reaches the lowest investment cost, showing that the reported gains do not require either of the larger models tested.

The 24-hour window with peak-hour N-1 verification defines the planning problem studied here. We clarify this scope and include the revised prompts in the manuscript.

Response to Reviewer TGGt (Part 2/2)

Q1. Quality of the proposed actions and limitations of the LLM-based approach

Every candidate plan is evaluated by an external verifier using 24-hour AC power flow and peak-hour N-1 contingency analysis before a commitment decision. Security is established by the simulator under these tested conditions, not by the LLM’s prediction. Intermediate plans may retain unresolved violations while satisfying the componentwise eligibility rules; only plans satisfying all five security requirements are considered solved. Verification does not establish economic optimality or practical implementability.

We added two failure cases, summer_18 and summer_15, in which the planner reaches a secure but expensive plan. In both cases, no candidate is secure after the first round, and SCOPE retains a larger, safer candidate for subsequent repair. Its final plan uses the same equipment as the cheapest plan found for that day in another run, but with slightly larger ratings and approximately 5% higher cost. These cases show that choosing the next plan by its remaining violations does not always lead to the cheapest final solution.

Q2. Sensitivity to episodic and procedural retrieval settings

We varied the number of retrieved episodes and strategies one at a time, keeping everything else unchanged:

Retrieved itemsSecure (%)Cost (USD M)Rounds
1 episode, 3 strategies (default)10048.761.45
2 episodes, 3 strategies9948.291.44
1 episode, 1 strategy10048.781.35

The default row reports the three-run mean; each alternative setting was evaluated once on all 100 scenarios.

Relative to the default mean, retrieving two episodes changes mean cost by USD 0.47M and rounds by 0.01, but secure completion drops to 99%. Retrieving one strategy changes mean cost by USD 0.02M and rounds by 0.10, while retaining 100% completion. These tests suggest modest sensitivity in cost and search length, but do not establish identical reliability across settings.

The additional retrieved context is small, and no call approached the context limit.

Q3. Different renewable sources and operational time windows

The present study evaluates how an LLM agent finds secure, low-cost reinforcement plans for one 24-hour operating day, with renewable sites injecting their available active power.

Within this setting, the five operating conditions include different renewable-output profiles, such as low wind on summer days and low solar on storm days. Thus, the evaluation covers variation in renewable availability, but does not test alternative renewable-control models or longer planning windows.

We now state these limits explicitly and discuss other renewable models and joint planning across longer or multiple operating windows as future work.

Thank you once again for your thoughtful feedback. We appreciate the time you have dedicated to reviewing our work.

To summarize our rebuttal:

  • W1: We clarified that actions have distinct cost functions, with a substantially higher fixed cost for new lines.
  • W2 & Q3: We clarified how renewable generation enters the operating profiles and explicitly stated the scope: 24-hour planning with peak-hour N-1 verification. Alternative renewable models and longer planning windows remain outside the current evaluation.
  • W3: We added VeraGrid’s genetic algorithm and particle swarm optimization using the same actions, costs, and physical verifier. All methods secure every scenario across three runs, while SCOPE achieves approximately 20% lower investment cost, with somewhat longer runtime.
  • W4: We now report results over three independent trials. SCOPE achieves a mean investment cost of USD 48.76M ± 0.12, approximately USD 12M below the non-LLM baselines.
  • W5: We evaluated the full pipeline with two additional model families, Mistral Large 4 and Muse Spark. Both secure every scenario in all three runs.
  • Q1: We added two failure cases illustrating how SCOPE can reach secure but unnecessarily expensive plans, distinguishing simulator-verified security from economic optimality.
  • Q2: We added sensitivity experiments varying the number of retrieved episodes and strategies. Cost and search length change modestly.

As the discussion phase is drawing to a close, we would be grateful if you could revisit our responses. Your feedback on whether these additions address your concerns would be very valuable to us. If you feel that our responses have adequately addressed your concerns, we would appreciate it if you could consider updating your scores accordingly.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

​​I appreciate the authors' clarifications. However, I do not see the new results and updates in the paper. Therefore, I maintain my earlier assessment. It is important to highlight that the provided code repository is empty: https://anonymous.4open.science/r/SCOPE-5BAD.

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of the responses to all reviewers

General response to all reviewers and the Area Chair

We thank the reviewers for their careful feedback. We appreciate their recognition of the complementary sibling proposals and their synthesis (VAY2), the simulation-grounded dual-level memory (TGGt), the held-out evaluation with frozen memories (QYno), and the importance of the problem (RUB2).

The reviews raise four main concerns. Below, we summarize the new experiments and clarifications addressing each concern. Detailed responses follow in the individual replies, and changes are marked in the revised manuscript.

1. Comparison with non-LLM methods (all reviewers)

We added two non-LLM baselines: VeraGrid’s genetic-algorithm investment search and particle swarm optimization (PSO). Both use the same candidate actions, costs, and pandapower verifier as SCOPE, including 24-hour AC power flow and peak-hour N-1 contingency analysis.

Each method was evaluated with three seeds on all 100 scenarios. Both baselines and SCOPE secure every scenario in every run. SCOPE achieves approximately 20% lower investment cost, with longer runtime: 11.54 minutes per scenario versus approximately 9.1 minutes for the baselines.

MethodSecure (%)Cost (USD M)Time (min/scenario)
VeraGrid (genetic algorithm)100 ± 060.80 ± 0.049.10 ± 0.02
Particle swarm optimization100 ± 060.90 ± 0.079.11 ± 0.03
SCOPE (Qwen3.5-9B)100 ± 048.76 ± 0.1211.54 ± 1.05

Values are mean ± standard deviation over three runs.

2. Scope of the planning problem (TGGt, VAY2, RUB2)

SCOPE addresses scenario-conditioned reinforcement planning: each episode seeks a low-cost reinforcement plan satisfying 24-hour AC power-flow checks and peak-hour N-1 contingency checks for one operating scenario. The present evaluation uses one topology, the IEEE 118-bus system. It does not establish a single investment plan that is secure across a distribution of future operating conditions. We now state these limits explicitly.

To assess transfer across operating days, we added a cross-day evaluation. For each of the five operating conditions, we selected the cheapest, median-cost, and most expensive SCOPE plans and evaluated each on the other 19 days of that condition. Across the resulting 95 tests per selection category:

  • Cheapest plans secure 2/95 other days (2.1%).
  • Median-cost plans secure 42/95 other days (44.2%).
  • Most expensive plans secure 80/95 other days (84.2%).

The mean costs of these selected plans are USD 35.00M, 48.82M, and 68.76M, respectively. These results demonstrate limited cross-day coverage for plans optimized for individual days. Joint planning across multiple operating conditions remains an important extension.

3. Expanded experiments, repeated runs, and computational trade-offs (TGGt, QYno)

We revised the candidate prompts, made candidate generation sequential, and added individual-action AC power-flow evaluations to inform plan fusion. Learned strategies now include sizing rules, with up to three strategies retrieved per round. These changes and the updated prompts are documented in the revised manuscript.

The main results now report mean ± standard deviation over three independent runs:

ConfigurationSecure (%)Cost (USD M)RoundsTime (min/scenario)Output tokens
Single99.00 ± 1.0084.29 ± 1.595.38 ± 0.414.39 ± 0.356,743 ± 575
Siblings99.67 ± 0.5856.90 ± 0.622.60 ± 0.094.79 ± 1.6211,495 ± 565
+ Plan fusion100.00 ± 0.0055.20 ± 0.772.44 ± 0.0513.23 ± 3.8417,159 ± 209
+ Episodic memory100.00 ± 0.0054.03 ± 0.662.06 ± 0.0512.18 ± 3.4515,850 ± 121
SCOPE (full)100.00 ± 0.0048.76 ± 0.121.45 ± 0.0611.54 ± 1.0511,244 ± 155

Each successive component reduces mean investment cost and planning rounds. Relative to episodic memory alone, full SCOPE reduces mean cost from USD 54.03M to USD 48.76M, rounds from 2.06 to 1.45, and output tokens by 29%.

Plan fusion increases runtime because fusion and verification follow the verified sibling proposals. Memory partially offsets this overhead by reducing the number of rounds: full SCOPE takes 11.54 minutes per scenario, compared with 13.23 minutes for plan fusion without memory.

We also added:

  • Two additional LLMs: The full pipeline was evaluated with Mistral Large 4 and Muse Spark over three runs each. Both secure every scenario in every run, with mean investment costs of USD 52.89M and USD 52.72M, respectively.
  • Matched wall-clock comparisons: Given SCOPE’s runtime on each scenario, the other configurations secure 46–97% of scenarios. On the scenarios they secure, their plans cost at least 14% more than SCOPE’s.
  • Additional computational analyses: We report violations and investment cost across rounds, wall-clock time, and output tokens, together with cost refinement under a matched total planning-round budget.

4. Contribution of the memory components (QYno, VAY2, TGGt)

We implemented ExpeL and ReasoningBank within the same SCOPE planning loop, using the same LLM, source scenarios, and episodic memory. Across three runs, SCOPE achieves lower mean investment cost than both: USD 48.76M versus USD 56.26M for ExpeL and USD 54.79M for ReasoningBank, with fewer planning rounds and output tokens.

We also replaced the learned strategies with a fixed diagnostic heuristic while keeping the rest of the pipeline unchanged. This replacement removes the cost advantage over episodic memory alone, supporting the value of the learned guidance beyond the tested heuristic.

Additional experiments examine retrieval settings, memory size, construction cost, and cases where procedural memory helps or causes regressions. The tested retrieval settings produce modest cost changes, although retrieving two episodes yields 99% secure completion. Memories built from 10 or 40 source scenarios retain 100% completion but produce higher investment costs than the full memory. Consolidating the full memory requires approximately 27 minutes per fold, in addition to the source planning runs.

Finally, we clarify what the frozen-memory evaluation establishes: verified experience from other scenarios improves held-out planning without updating model parameters. Repeated memory updates over a longer stream remain to be evaluated.

Additional manuscript revisions

We clarified renewable-generation modelling and action-specific costs, added a worked example of a complete planning round, and expanded the discussion of limitations, cross-day transfer, and procedural-memory reuse.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.