- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper argues that direct time-series downsampling is a destructive projection that disrupts latent dynamics and collapses downstream performance. The paper proposes VARes, an auto-regressive generative framework that treats downsampling as active, distribution-aware synthesis. Experiments show VARes-synthesized data consistently outperforms traditional downsampling baselines.
Critical strengths
Even though concerns are raised, the experiment design is relatively sound, involving quantitative analysis and qualitative analysis of a variety of tasks and aspects.
Critical weaknesses
-
Terrible writing.
(a) The title does not clearly represent the method this paper proposes.
(b) There is little introduction to the method in the Abstract and Section 1.
(c) It says the proposed method is "inspired by the Visual AutoRegressive (VAR)", but VAR is discussed neither in the Related Work nor in Appendix I.
(d) Inconsistency in section numbering. Section 3 only has 3.1 and jumps directly to Section 4.
(e) Much of the section is spent on motivation and failed design choices rather than a formal definition of the proposed method. -
I do not reckon the problem the author is trying to address is a real challenge. The author mentioned that "The explosion of high-resolution (HR) time series data has created a paradoxical challenge in modern AI: while HR sequences offer granular insights, their immense computational footprint and storage requirements often render them impractical for large-scale deployment or long-term historical analysis". Compared to the data used in LM or VLM pretraining, typical time series data are not that large-scale. I do think the high-frequency time series data are too large to be used directly.
-
The experiment cannot fully demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
(a) The datasets used in the experiments are far from "large-scale", which do not meet the problem the author raised at the beginning of this paper. The high-frequency time series in these datasets can be used directly without the need for downsampling.
(b) The three backbone models used are all attention-/transformer-based models. Other types of models should be considered. -
The novelty of this paper does not meet the ICLR standard. It is more likely to be considered a naive combination of existing methods.
Questions for authors
- The method is tailored for "1D temporal data"/"univariate time series". But most of the datasets used in the experiment are multi-variate. What's the rationale for treating each channel independently and then transforming it to 2-D, but not using multi-variate time series directly as 2-D?
- Will the zero-padding in Delay Embedding introduce unnecessary jumps?
- Please refer to Weaknesses for other questions.