- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces a structured flow-matching planner that predicts Bézier control points for heading and speed, then reconstructs positions through differentiable kinematic integration. Tangent matching and optional warm starting encourage continuity, while training combines trajectory-level flow matching with auxiliary losses. Evaluation includes nuPlan closed-loop planning, trajectory smoothness analysis, and an additional adaptation to VaVAM
Critical strengths
- Generating positions from predicted heading and speed directly addresses internal trajectory inconsistency. The lateral-velocity and rollout analyses provide evidence that this design improves alignment under the chosen integration model.
- The paper includes baseline retraining, reactive and non-reactive evaluations, ablations, and an additional architecture adaptation. Reporting the mixed results helps establish the method’s current limitations.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited demonstrated benefit of the incremental parameterization. The base model underperforms the retrained FlowPlanner on all six aggregate closed-loop scores. Its Val14 reactive comfort score also decreases from 86.05 to 81.22, while the VaVAM variants worsen both prediction error and comfort. The central practical benefit therefore remains insufficiently established.
- Evaluation protocol and attribution concerns. Appendix D.2 selects guidance weights on Test14-hard, compromising its independence as a test set. Additionally, expert-trajectory-based route filtering is introduced without an equivalently conditioned FlowPlanner comparison, making the source of the final gains unclear.
- The method builds on FlowPlanner and combines established curve-based representations with differentiable kinematic rollout. Its novelty primarily lies in this specific integration, whose advantages over simpler structured alternatives are not sufficiently isolated through ablations. Moreover, the mixed closed-loop results and degraded comfort in the VaVAM experiments limit the demonstrated significance of the contribution.
Questions for authors
- Can you provide results with guidance weights selected exclusively on validation data and evaluated on an independent test set?
- Does the +Route variant use future expert trajectory information during evaluation? How does FlowPlanner perform with the same route conditioning?
- Why do improved predicted smoothness distributions not consistently improve closed-loop comfort? Please clarify whether these analyses measure planned or actually executed trajectories.
2 comments
Thank you for the additional experiments and clarifications. These updates address some of my concerns, but several remain:
- It remains unclear whether +Route uses future expert trajectory information during evaluation, and a FlowPlanner comparison with identical route conditioning is still missing.
- Closed-loop improvements remain modest and mixed. The explanation for the degraded VaVAM results is speculative and does not explain the relative disadvantage against its baseline.
- The added related-work discussion clarifies the contribution, but the distinct benefits of Bézier parameterization over simpler alternatives, and separately from warm starting, remain insufficiently established.
I therefore maintain my rating.
Thank you for your feedback. There is considerable overlap between your comments and that of reviewer tYAM and 3CQG so please refer to our replies there.
Please refer to our comments to reviewer tYAM for discussion on comfort.
We have corrected the mistake of performing the guidance sweep over Test14-hard and have updated all values using guidance weights chosen based on Val14 as done in the other works, so Test14-hard and Test14 are independent of the selection. With the updated guidance sweeps the base Bezier Planner scores above the re-trained Flow Planner on NR-Val14 (86.89 compared to 86.57) and NR-Test14 (87.11 compared to 85.88), and below it on the remaining four splits.
Please see comments to 3CQG about the route filtering. We have edited the text to make the distinction clearer and added additional comparison in the appendix between the filtered routes. We have not yet evaluated Flow Planner under the same route conditioning.
Regarding novelty, please see our response to reviewer tYAM.