acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Energy-Based Generative Planning for Autonomous Driving

Abstract

The central goal of autonomous driving is to combine human-level driving performance with reliable decision-making under multiple safety and behavioral constraints. In this paper, we introduce **EnergyDrive**, an energy-based generative planning framework for end-to-end autonomous driving that supports interpretable planning, flexible sampling, and compositional control. EnergyDrive learns an explicit, scene-conditioned trajectory energy landscape from expert demonstrations, rather than time-dependent transport fields typically learned by diffusion- and flow-based generative planners. This provides a shared representation for trajectory generation and objective composition, with repulsive sampling to explore diverse driving trajectories. At inference time, the learned driving prior and modular energies for target speed, drivable-area compliance, and collision avoidance jointly define the planning objective. EnergyDrive outperforms the compared imitation-learning baselines on the NAVSIM v2 *navhard* and HUGSIM. Qualitative results demonstrate flexible sampling over driving behavior through energy composition. Energy landscape visualizations show the interpretability and reveal how learned preferences and individual constraints shape the resulting plans. Our website is available at https://iclr2027-16699-author.github.io/

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
energy-based models, autonomous driving

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 32%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.50 over 4 reviews, above 68% of the others.
Reviewer_L9mcOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

EnergyDrive learns a scene-conditioned energy function to generate and rank driving trajectories. It starts from Gaussian noise, refines candidates through energy-gradient updates, and selects a trajectory using the learned energy and additional driving objectives.

Critical strengths

Using the same energy function for generation and evaluation is intuitive. The framework is easy to motivate, and the results on NAVSIM v2 and HUGSIM are promising.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper does not clearly show whether lower energy leads to better trajectories throughout sampling.
  2. Results on NAVSIM v1 would also help establish broader applicability. The main figure could distinguish generation and final selection more clearly.
Questions for authors
  1. Could you show intermediate trajectories and driving-quality metrics across sampling steps? Does lower energy consistently mean better planning?
  2. How does the number of sampling steps affect performance and latency?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal by Authors

We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and for recognizing the intuitive use of a shared energy function for generation and evaluation, as well as the promising benchmark results. Below are our point-by-point responses and the corresponding revisions added to the manuscript and our website.

  1. Relation between energy value and driving performance. We thank the reviewer for the question. Our energy-landscape visualization (Fig. 1 and the project website) illustrates how the composed energy assigns lower values to trajectories satisfying the modeled driving objectives, while penalizing undesirable trajectories such as off-road or collision-prone paths with higher energy values. Additionally, we have added intermediate trajectory sampling visualizations across five driving scenarios, including left turns, straight driving, and right turns. For each example, we visualize the trajectory evolution alongside its energy value and driving-quality score (EPDMS) throughout the optimization process. As sampling progresses, trajectories evolve from initial noise toward plausible driving paths, with energy decreasing by approximately 50% and EPDMS improving from 0 to 0.87–0.99 (0-1 scale) by the final step. We have added these visualizations and clarified the relationship between energy optimization and planning quality in the Appendix D.5 in the revised manuscript and on the website.

  2. Evaluation on NAVSIM v1. Following the reviewer's suggestion, we additionally evaluate EnergyDrive under the official NAVSIM v1 protocol. While NAVSIM v2 navhard remains our primary benchmark due to its more challenging pseudo-closed-loop evaluation, NAVSIM v1 provides complementary evidence of planning performance.

    MethodNC ↑\uparrowDAC ↑\uparrowTTC ↑\uparrowC ↑\uparrowEP ↑\uparrowPDMS ↑\uparrow
    LTF98.095.693.8100.081.887.1
    DiffusionDrive98.396.094.7100.080.887.3
    MeanFuser98.197.694.2100.083.389.0
    EnergyDrive (Ours)98.697.995.1100.081.488.8

    EnergyDrive achieves the highest NC, DAC, and TTC scores among the compared methods, with an overall PDMS of 88.8, outperforming LTF and DiffusionDrive and remaining close to MeanFuser (89.0). These results further support the effectiveness of the safety-aware planning framework. These results are reported in Appendix D.6 (Table D.4).

    Clarifying generation and selection in the main figure. We have also revised the main framework figure (Fig 2) to explicitly distinguish the two stages of our default inference pipeline: (1) repulsive trajectory generation under the learned driving energy, and (2) final trajectory selection using the composed energy objective. This clarifies that modular safety energies guide candidate selection in the default configuration, while direct gradient-based composition is evaluated separately.

  3. Sampling steps, performance, and latency. We thank the reviewer for this question. We conduct an additional ablation using the same final checkpoint and inference configuration while varying the number of optimization steps. We report the resulting planning performance and latency, together with vocabulary-based selection as an efficient alternative:

    Sampling StepsMean latency (ms) ↓\downarrowEPDMS ↑\uparrow
    1 step18.038.9
    2 steps22.2830.9
    5 steps36.6632.7
    8 steps53.2139.7
    10 steps64.6944.2
    Vocab 204819.3640.3

    The results show that increasing the number of optimization steps improves planning performance across the tested settings, at the cost of higher latency. The 10-step setting achieves the highest EPDMS in this ablation. Alternatively, EnergyDrive supports vocabulary-based selection using explicit energy evaluations without iterative trajectory optimization. This achieves 40.3 EPDMS at 19.36 ms, offering a substantially more efficient inference option with competitive planning performance. We have added this trade-off analysis to the Appendix B.5 in the revised manuscript.

Overall, we appreciate the reviewer's suggestion, and we have updated them in the revised manuscript. We appreciate your constructive feedback on both the evaluation and presentation.

Thank you for providing this information. Considering the experimental results provided and the contributions of the paper, I believe it is appropriate to maintain the original score.

Reviewer_zcLrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2(−1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This work introduces an energy-based generative approach for end-to-end autonomous driving applications. The key idea lies on modeling a driving scene using an energy function and optimizing the rollouts towards a direction of lower energy. While the idea of energy models has been explored in the past across different strategies and under classical approach from potential fields for robotics applications, the work presents some interesting perspective on how it can be combined with a learning approach. Some important feedback provided below.

Critical strengths
  • The close-loop performance is competitive across most metrics on the S2 split of NAVSIM
  • The multi-modality show cased qualitatively is evident and easy to follow; the different mission level commands such as left, right, straight translate to meaningful rollouts. The compositional components are also a good property
Critical weaknesses
  • Collision avoidance section does not discuss how object velocities (i.e. moving cars) are factored into the cost. The ego trajectory rollout is velocity dependent but also the energy is a function across time.
  • Equation 6 captures the deceleration profile; but does not mention acceleration profile.
  • Progress energy promotes small changes in displacement. This is context dependent: it seems like the policy will be penalized during regular driving behaviors. Also, w_prog is defined but not used in the formulation of the equation.
  • Repulsive sampling appears to be an integral part of the text to be introduced by only one term and moved to the appendix. More details should be discussed in the text as it is not easy to follow.
  • Table 1 shows that on average EnergyDrive performs better than the other compared methods. However, there are cases where the method significantly under performs. EP is significantly lower across all methods compared. The average reported conceals some of these limitations by only making the average in bold.
Questions for authors
  • What is the intuition behind S1 and S2 improvement gap?
  • Is there a reason behind lower episode progress compared to other baselines in table 1?
6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal by Authors [1/2]

We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and for recognizing the meaningful multimodal rollouts, compositional capabilities, and competitive Stage-2 results. We address each concern below and indicate the corresponding revisions in the manuscript and our project website.

  1. Dynamic obstacles and motion-aware collision guidance. We thank the reviewer for this concern. We agree that our current collision energy is constructed from static BEV predictions and does not explicitly model the future motion of surrounding agents. To investigate this limitation, we introduce a motion-aware collision energy using future agent-motion predictions from SparseDrive. The predicted obstacle positions at successive planning steps are used to construct a corresponding collision penalty, which can directly guide trajectory generation through gradient-based optimization. This demonstrates that EnergyDrive can incorporate future motion information through modular energy composition without retraining its learned driving energy model. We provide side-by-side visualizations comparing sampling under static and motion-aware collision energies. The examples illustrate how incorporating predicted agent motion can alter generated trajectories to better account for moving obstacles. We also added it into the Appendix D.2 in the revised manuscript.

  2. Acceleration in the target-speed energy. We thank the reviewer for pointing this out. The current reference-speed profile limits deceleration when approaching a lower target speed but does not explicitly bound acceleration toward a higher target speed. We agree that both should be considered for driving comfort. The reference profile can be extended to incorporate both bounds: vˉt=vˉt−1+clip⁡(v⋆−vˉt−1,−adecΔt,aaccΔt).\bar v_t = \bar v_{t-1} + \operatorname{clip} \left( v^\star- \bar v_{t-1}, -a_{\mathrm{dec}}\Delta t, a_{\mathrm{acc}}\Delta t \right). Here, aacca_{\mathrm{acc}} and adeca_{\mathrm{dec}} specify the acceleration and deceleration limits. The same quadratic target-speed energy can then be applied to this bounded reference profile. We have clarified this extension in Sec 3.2 in the revised manuscript.

  3. Interpretation and weighting of the progress energy. We thank the reviewer for this question. The progress energy measures cumulative trajectory travel distance, while its weight controls the preference for cautious versus aggressive driving. A positive weight penalizes longer travel and favors more conservative trajectories, whereas a negative weight encourages greater progress. We agree that this preference is context-dependent and may reduce progress during normal driving. Our sensitivity analysis (Appendix Fig. C.1 and project website) illustrates this trade-off: increasing the positive progress weight generally improves safety metrics while reducing ego progress. The coefficient wprogw_{\mathrm{prog}} appears in the composed planning objective (Eq. B.6), rather than in the definition of the individual energy (Eq. 7). We use wprog=0.1w_{\mathrm{prog}}=0.1 on navhard and zero on navtest and HUGSIM. Importantly, EnergyDrive still achieves 40.2 EPDMS without the progress term (Tab. 3), exceeding the strongest compared baseline at 37.8. We have clarified the weight convention and its effect in the revision.

  4. Repulsive-sampling details. We agree that the main text should provide a clearer explanation of our sampler. Our method computes pairwise repulsion using an RBF kernel over low-frequency trajectory-position descriptors. The resulting interactions are projected orthogonally to the learned descent direction and lifted back into smooth trajectory updates. Their magnitudes are bounded relative to the learned gradient, and their strengths gradually decay during sampling. This encourages diversity while limiting interference with the learned driving field. We have expanded the sampler description in the main text (Sec. 3.3), with implementation details in Appendix B.4. We also add a controlled ablation showing that repulsion increases average endpoint spread from 0.038 m to 3.029 m and improves EPDMS from 31.4 to 44.2 within the ablation setting, supporting its role in generating useful, diverse proposals:

    Repulsion ForceAveraged endpoints spread(m)16 low-energy endpoints spread(m)DAC (S1/S2) ↑\uparrowNC (S1/S2) ↑\uparrowEPDMS ↑\uparrow
    0 (independent)0.0380.02486.2 / 70.096.1 / 85.431.4
    0.50.8980.53588.4 / 75.696.1 / 88.736.7
    1.02.1071.34993.3 / 80.197.2 / 92.742.0
    1.53.0291.82594.9 / 85.297.6 / 94.744.2
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal by Authors [2/2]

  1. Trade-off across driving criterions. We thank the reviewer to point this out. We agree that EnergyDrive does not outperform the baselines on every driving criterion. In particular, EnergyDrive achieves lower ego progress in both stages, and lower extended comfort in Stage 1. Meanwhile, it achieves substantially stronger safety performance, especially in Stage 2, where DAC reaches 85.2 versus the best baseline's 72.1, and NC reaches 94.7 versus 87.2. The reported EPDMS follows the official NAVSIM evaluation protocol, combining safety-related penalties with other driving criteria. Our claim is therefore stronger aggregate benchmark performance and improved safety metrics, rather than uniform superiority across all driving criteria. We have made this distinction more explicit in the revised manuscript.

  2. Stage 1 and Stage 2 performance difference. NAVSIM-v2 navhard evaluates driving in two stages. Stage 1 evaluates the planner from the original observations, while Stage 2 evaluates precomputed follow-up scenarios with different ego states, including perturbed positions and speeds. Stage 2 therefore places greater emphasis on planning robustness under deviations from the original driving state. We hypothesize that EnergyDrive's compositional safety objectives are particularly beneficial in these challenging situations, as they allow the planner to explicitly consider drivable-area and collision constraints when selecting trajectories. This is consistent with the stronger improvements in Stage 2, where EnergyDrive exceeds the best compared baseline by 13.1 points in DAC and 7.5 points in NC. We have added this interpretation to the revised manuscript.

  3. Lower ego progress. We thank the reviewer points out this. We attribute the lower ego progress primarily to the planner's more conservative behavior under composed safety objectives. When selecting among trajectory proposals, drivable-area and collision energies can favor safer but less progressive trajectories. Additionally, the positive progress-energy weight used on navhard explicitly introduces a preference for shorter travel. This trade-off is also reflected in our progress-weight sensitivity analysis (Appendix Fig. C.1), where increasing the positive progress weight improves safety metrics while reducing ego progress. While EnergyDrive achieves higher aggregate EPDMS, we acknowledge that its current planning objective can be overly conservative, and further improving the safety–progress balance remains an important direction.

Thank you again for recognizing the strengths of the framework and for the detailed suggestions. We have included all of the points in the revised manuscript.

Thank you for the response. The visualizations showcase some differences between predicting static scenes and predicting dynamic scenes; however, it is not clear if the other agents' dynamics are used as condition. For example, are you embedding velocities of other agents or observations from previous timesteps as part of the input conditions? In one of the videos shown, a parked vehicle is predicted to be moving highlighting that the model is unable to predict if a vehicle is parked or moving from a single frame observation.

Reviewer_9nS2OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes EnergyDrive, a framework that models autonomous driving end-to-end. This framework unifies the trajectory forecasting and rule-based composition in an interpretable energy landscape. Main idea is from Energy Equilibrium Matching. The planner selects from the proposal trajectories based on learned energy and collision, drivable area, and progress costs. Qualitative demonstrations explore energy composition and speed/direction control. Extensive evaluation has done on dataset NAVSIM-v2 and HUGSIM.

Critical strengths
  • The energy-based planner shows strong gains over two evaluation settings.
  • Under a unified setting by modeling energy landscape, the sampling can be every flexible. The paper provides useful controls and composition rules.
Critical weaknesses
  • The effectiveness of repulsive sampler is unclear to me. I think there is no controlled ablation on this element.
  • The additional compositional control capabilities are not carefully validated. The benchmark results evaluate learned-energy generation followed by composed selection. Figure 3 uses composed OR gradients, but its shared DA/NC constraints only mark which candidates pass instead of changing the trajectory distribution. Figure 5 shows two target-speed examples without reporting errors of generated velocity comparing with the actual one or feasibility across scenes.
Questions for authors
  1. What is the benefit of repulsion? Can you provide the EPDMS of a pool of 65 independent proposals comparing to the one with repulsion and K=64?
  2. Can the demos be evaluated on one testing scene set and report how accurately the plans follow the requested behaviour and how often they satisfy safety constraints? (evaluation in terms of including final achieved speed, safety compliance, feasible commands coverage etc...)
3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal by Authors

We thank the reviewer for recognizing the benchmark results, flexible sampling, and compositional controls. Below, we present the additional evidence and clarify the scope of the evaluation, and the corresponding revisions added to the manuscript and our website.

  1. Role of repulsive sampling. We thank the reviewer for the question. The goal of repulsive sampling is to improve the diversity of useful trajectory proposals within a fixed sampling budget. Without repulsion, independently optimized trajectories may converge to similar solutions, limiting the candidate diversity available for composed-energy selection. Our sampler introduces interactions between proposals while preserving the learned driving field that guides them toward plausible trajectories. Related proposal redundancy has also been observed in the diffusion adaptation studied by DiffusionDrive. We conduct the requested controlled ablation comparing 65 independent proposals against our default setting of 64 repulsive proposals and one independent proposal, using the same checkpoint, sampling configuration, and composed-energy selection objective. We also vary the repulsion strength:

    Repulsion ForceEndpoints spread(m)Top-16 endpoints spread(m)DAC (S1/S2) ↑\uparrowNC (S1/S2) ↑\uparrowEPDMS ↑\uparrow
    0 (independent)0.0380.02486.2 / 70.096.1 / 85.431.4
    0.50.8980.53588.4 / 75.696.1 / 88.736.7
    1.02.1071.34993.3 / 80.197.2 / 92.742.0
    1.53.0291.82594.9 / 85.297.6 / 94.744.2

    The results show that repulsion substantially improves proposal diversity, including among low-energy candidates. This translates into stronger safety metrics and higher EPDMS, demonstrating the benefit of repulsion beyond independent multi-start optimization. We have added this ablation and the corresponding discussion to the Sec 4.4 and Appendix D.3 in the revised manuscript.

  2. Validation of compositional control. We thank the reviewer for the questions. We agree that quantitative evaluation would provide stronger evidence of controllability beyond individual visualizations. We therefore extend our evaluation of safety composition and target-speed control. Safety composition. We perform gradient-based trajectory sampling directly under the composed safety energies and provide side-by-side visualizations on held-out scenes, with four examples each for drivable-area and collision guidance. On a challenging subset of NAVSIM navtest, we further measure safety compliance across the generated trajectory pools. Adding drivable-area energy increases the on-road ratio from 80.4% to 91.4%, while jointly composing drivable-area and collision energies improves the ratio satisfying both constraints from 73.4% to 84.7%:

    Sampling Energy LandscapeOn RoadNo CollisionBoth Safety
    EbaseE_{\mathrm{base}}80.4%92.3%73.4%
    Ebase+EDAE_{\mathrm{base}} + E_{\mathrm{DA}}91.4%92.1%83.8%
    Ebase+ENCE_{\mathrm{base}} + E_{\mathrm{NC}}79.6%94.2%74.6%
    Ebase+EDA+ENCE_{\mathrm{base}} + E_{\mathrm{DA}} + E_{\mathrm{NC}}90.6%93.6%84.7%

    Target-speed control. We additionally report the actual average speeds of the planned trajectories in the two target-speed demonstrations, comparing them against the requested speeds:

    CasePlain SamplingTarget 2 m/sTarget 3 m/sTarget 4 m/sTarget 5 m/sTarget 6 m/s
    Case 15.08 m/s2.59 m/s2.81 m/s3.88 m/s4.33 m/s5.47 m/s
    Case 23.83 m/s2.31 m/s2.91 m/s3.49 m/s4.47 m/s4.85 m/s

    The planned speeds generally follow the requested targets. Together, these results provide quantitative evidence that energy composition can influence both safety compliance and driving behavior without retraining the learned model. We also added it to the Appendix D.1 and Appendix D.4 (Tab D.3) in the revised manuscript.

Overall, we appreciate the reviewer's suggestion, and we have revised the manuscript accordingly. We hope the controlled ablation and additional controllability evidence address your concerns, and would appreciate if you would be willing to increase your assessment.

Thank the authors for their detailed response. However, the safety ablation raises further concerns: adding collision avoidance energy only marginally improves collision-free compliance (92.3% to 94.2%), while combining both energies improves joint safety by 0.9 percentage points over drivable-area guidance alone. These gains leave the effectiveness of energy composition insufficiently demonstrated. I therefore maintain my original rating. I appreciate the value of this work and hope the authors will consider incorporating the points discussed in future manuscript.

Thank you for the follow-up and for considering our additional experiments. We would like to clarify the magnitude of the collision-avoidance improvement and provide further evidence from our standard planning evaluation.

  1. The collision-avoidance improvement represents a meaningful reduction in the remaining violations. From the additional results, the collision-free compliance increases from 92.3% to 94.2% with a gain of 1.9 percentage points. It corresponds to a reduction of colliding trajectories from 7.7% to 5.8%, which is a 24.7% relative reduction. For a safety-critical objective such as collision avoidance, reducing approximately one quarter is meaningful. With the drivable-area guidance active, adding the collision energy can also improve collision-free compliance from 92.1% to 93.6%, corresponding to a 19.0% relative reduction in the collision violations (from 7.9% to 6.4%).

  2. Collision energy improves performance significantly under our standard planning setting. The additional experiment above evaluates direct gradient-based sampling under composed energies, demonstrating that the composition can help the trajectory generation. Our standard planner uses repulsive sampling with composed-energy selection, whose benchmark ablation in Table 3 provides complementary evidence on NAVSIM-v2 navhard standard benchmark:

    SettingNC ↑\uparrow (S1 / S2)DAC ↑\uparrow (S1 / S2)EPDMS ↑\uparrow
    Base96.6 / 85.686.7 / 70.334.5
    Base + DA96.6 / 85.392.9 / 75.336.7
    Base + DA + collision98.2 / 88.791.8 / 73.939.3

    Comparing the two composition settings isolates the contribution of adding collision energy to drivable-area energy: NC improves by 1.6 in S1 and 3.4 in S2, and the overall EPDMS increases from 36.7 to 39.3. This benchmark result demonstrates that collision energy contributes meaningfully to overall planning performance.

We thank the reviewer again for the constructive feedback, and have incorporated these results and clarifications into the revised manuscript. We would appreciate it if you could reconsider the above evidence and if you could increase the assessment.

Reviewer_KKQMOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces EnergyDrive, an energy-based generative planner that learns an explicit, scene-conditioned energy landscape over trajectories. The method employs gradient-based optimization and repulsive sampling to generate a diverse set of candidate trajectories, integrating the learned energy with various modular objectives—such as obstacle avoidance, adherence to drivable areas, speed control, and task progression. The learned energy landscape is further refined through contrastive learning using negative trajectory samples. Experimental results on NAVSIM v2 and HUGSIM demonstrate strong performance.

Critical strengths
  1. The explicit energy landscape provides a unified representation for trajectory generation, scoring, and visualization.

  2. With intuitive qualitative examples, different driving requirements can be combined during inference without the need for retraining.

  3. EnergyDrive achieves strong results on NAVSIM-v2 and HUGSIM, with ablation studies confirming the effectiveness of its individual components.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main contribution has overlaps with existing energy-based planning approaches.

Concepts such as "Composable Energy Policies," "Potential-Based Diffusion Motion Planning," and "Equilibrium Matching" have already explored energy-based motion generation, gradient-based optimization, and objective composition. While EnergyDrive applies these principles to autonomous driving, its core theoretical framework largely builds upon existing precedents.

  1. The argument regarding "compositional generation" lacks direct validation under safety constraints.

Although the paper provides visualizations of energy, Figure 3 primarily illustrates sampling based on an instruction-level "OR" logic; the safety constraint component merely flags violations without altering the trajectory coordinates. Figure 4 demonstrates the re-ranking of an existing pool of candidate trajectories, rather than the generation of trajectories directly guided by safety constraints. Consequently, the core claim—that "combined safety energies can directly guide trajectory generation"—lacks sufficient qualitative and quantitative validation.

  1. The modeling of collision energy has limitations when handling dynamic interactions.

Collision energy relies on predicted Bird’s-Eye-View (BEV) semantic probabilities, which remain static throughout the entire planning horizon. The approach fails to explicitly model time-varying occupancy or interactions with moving agents, which may constrain its effectiveness in dynamic traffic environments.

  1. Significant trade-offs persist between computational efficiency and driving performance.

The full EnergyDrive system has an inference latency of approximately 92.7 milliseconds with iterative sampling—substantially slower than the baseline methods. While overall safety scores show improvement, the method underperforms in terms of "ego progress" on the NAVSIM Stage 2 benchmark and yields lower comfort scores in HUGSIM evaluations.

Questions for authors
  1. Beyond "Equilibrium Matching" and existing compositional energy-based motion planning methods, what are the specific technical innovations of this approach?

  2. When collision energy and drivable-area energy are incorporated into a gradient-based trajectory generation process—rather than being used solely for filtering candidate trajectories—can the authors provide a clear visualization and quantification of the resulting changes to the trajectories?

  3. How does this method handle dynamic obstacles and time-dependent occupancy?

  4. Given a fixed computational budget, could the authors provide a more detailed comparison regarding safety, driving progress, and latency?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal by Authors [1/2]

We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and for recognizing the unified energy representation and its flexibility for inference-time composition. We address each concern below and indicate the corresponding revisions in the manuscript and project website.

  1. Novelty and contribution. We agree that our work builds upon established foundations, including EqM and energy composition, just as diffusion-based planners such as DiffusionDrive build on existing generative modeling techniques. Our main contribution is a unified energy-based generative planning framework for autonomous driving, supported by several technical designs: (1) scene-conditioned explicit energy learning with energy-level anchoring; (2) trajectory-aware repulsive sampling and modular energy composition for flexible inference-time planning; and (3) contrastive energy learning from model-generated driving failures. Together, these designs enable interpretable, compositional, and controllable driving behavior (Figs. 3-5), and outperforming the compared imitation-learning baselines on driving benchmarks (Tabs. 1, 2). We have clarified this contribution in the final contribution paragraph of the Introduction in revised manuscript.

  2. Validation on directly safety constraint-guided trajectory generation. We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We agree that showing visualization and quantification evaluation on direct trajectory generation under composed energy landscape would provide stronger evidence of the framework's compositional capabilities. In our default inference setting, we generate candidate trajectories from the learned driving energy and then select the best candidate using the composed energy. To further validate the direct sampling with composition, we additionally perform gradient-based direct sampling on the composed energy landscape. We have added side-by-side visualizations to our project website, comparing repulsive sampling pool from the learned energy alone and from the composed energy. In (a), adding the drivable-area energy guides generated trajectories toward drivable regions; in (b), adding the collision-avoidance energy guides generated trajectories away from nearby obstacles. These examples directly illustrate how safety constraints modify the generated trajectories. We further conduct a quantitative evaluation on a challenging subset of held-out test scenes where the original learned-energy sampling pool contains unsafe trajectories (off-road or collision). We generate 64 trajectories per scene using repulsive sampling with the same hyperparameters across different energy compositions, and report the percentage of generated trajectories satisfying each safety criterion:

    Sampling Energy LandscapeOn RoadNo CollisionBoth Safety
    EbaseE_{\mathrm{base}}80.4%92.3%73.4%
    Ebase+EDAE_{\mathrm{base}} + E_{\mathrm{DA}}91.4%92.1%83.8%
    Ebase+ENCE_{\mathrm{base}} + E_{\mathrm{NC}}79.6%94.2%74.6%
    Ebase+EDA+ENCE_{\mathrm{base}} + E_{\mathrm{DA}} + E_{\mathrm{NC}}90.6%93.6%84.7%

    The results show that incorporating the drivable-area energy improves the on-road ratio from 80.4% to 91.4%, while combining both safety energies increases the proportion of trajectories satisfying both constraints from 73.4% to 84.7%. Together with the qualitative visualizations, these results demonstrate that modular safety energies can directly guide trajectory generation through gradient-based optimization, beyond their use in candidate selection. We have included further details in the Appendix D.1 in revised manuscript.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal by Authors [2/2]

  1. Dynamic obstacles and future-step-aware collision guidance. We thank the reviewer for highlighting this limitation. We agree that our current collision energy relies on static BEV predictions, which do not explicitly account for the future motion of surrounding agents. To investigate this limitation, we additionally experiment with trajectory sampling under a motion-aware collision energy. Rather than retraining the entire model with an additional prediction head, we use future agent-motion predictions from SparseDrive to construct a collision energy that accounts for predicted obstacle positions at different steps along the planning horizon. Thanks to EnergyDrive's flexible energy composition, this additional constraint can be incorporated into trajectory generation without retraining the learned driving energy model. We have added visualizations comparing trajectory sampling under static and motion-aware collision energies to our project website. The examples illustrate that static collision guidance may overlook the future movement of surrounding agents, potentially leading to undesirable trajectories, whereas motion-aware guidance can steer generated trajectories to account for their predicted motion. These results demonstrate the flexibility of our framework in incorporating dynamic obstacle information through modular energy functions. We also updated it in the Appendix D.2 in the revised manuscript.

  2. Computational efficiency and driving performance. We agree that a more detailed comparison of the trade-off between latency, safety, and driving progress would help clarify the practical benefits and limitations of EnergyDrive. Our explicit energy representation supports flexible inference strategies: iterative gradient-based sampling for stronger planning performance, or vocabulary-based trajectory selection for lower latency. We additionally evaluate different inference configurations alongside the baselines under a consistent GPU and FP32 timing protocol, reporting detailed safety, progress, and comfort metrics:

    MethodMean latency (ms) ↓\downarrowDAC (S1/S2) ↑\uparrowNC (S1/S2) ↑\uparrowEP (S1/S2) ↑\uparrowEC (S1/S2) ↑\uparrowEPDMS ↑\uparrow
    Ours (Vocab 256)14.3092.7 / 88.998.7 / 96.557.6 / 42.617.8 / 42.537.6
    Ours (Vocab 512)14.9794.2 / 89.398.6 / 96.158.0 / 42.718.2 / 38.937.7
    Ours (Vocab 1024)16.4395.3 / 89.498.4 / 96.757.9 / 44.120.0 / 42.739.2
    Ours (Vocab 2048)19.3696.4 / 91.498.9 / 97.256.7 / 39.016.9 / 46.940.3
    Ours (Sampling)64.6994.9 / 85.297.6 / 94.771.8 / 63.846.2 / 48.644.2
    LTF10.0985.3 / 66.996.1 / 85.584.7 / 93.077.3 / 42.933.7
    DiffusionDrive17.0587.3 / 72.197.9 / 87.182.8 / 91.963.6 / 28.635.9
    MeanFuser11.3391.8 / 67.297.6 / 87.284.4 / 94.080.4 / 42.637.8

    With vocabulary-based selection, EnergyDrive achieves 40.3 EPDMS at 19.36 ms, outperforming the compared baselines at comparable latency. Iterative sampling further improves EPDMS to 44.2 at 64.69 ms. The detailed metrics also reveal a clear trade-off: EnergyDrive achieves stronger drivable-area and collision-avoidance performance, but lower ego progress and some comfort scores. The overall EPDMS reflects the combined driving criteria rather than uniform improvements across all metrics. We have included these detailed comparisons and the latency–performance trade-off in the Sec 4.2 and Appendix B.5 in the revised manuscript.

We appreciate your constructive feedback, which helped us sharpen both the contribution and the supporting evidence. If the added experiments and clarifications address your main concerns, we would be grateful if you could increase your assessment.

We appreciate the detailed clarifications and have improved the rating to weak acceptance.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Acknowledgment by Authors

We sincerely thank the reviewer for your thoughtful feedback and for reconsidering the rating. We are glad that our clarifications addressed your concerns, and we greatly appreciate your recognition and support of our work.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Final Response by Authors

We thank all the reviewers for their detailed comments and constructive feedback. We are glad that the reviewers recognized EnergyDrive’s unified energy representation for trajectory generation, evaluation, and visualization (KKQM, L9mc); its flexible sampling, meaningful multimodal trajectories, and inference-time compositional control (KKQM, 9nS2, zcLr); and its strong performance across the evaluated driving benchmarks (KKQM, 9nS2, zcLr, L9mc).

In response to each reviewer’s questions and concerns, we conducted additional experiments and provided further analysis and clarifications. We believe these additions and revisions address all the concerns raised in the reviews and follow-up discussion. We have updated both the paper and our project website accordingly. Detailed experimental results and point-by-point explanations are provided in our individual responses to each reviewer.

We summarize the main additions as follows:

  1. Direct compositional generation and quantitative results (KKQM, 9nS2). We added visualizations and quantitative evaluations of trajectory generation directly guided by composed safety energies. On a challenging held-out subset, jointly composing drivable-area and collision energies improves joint safety compliance from 73.4% to 84.7%. Adding collision guidance alone reduces collision violations from 7.7% to 5.8%, a 24.7% relative reduction. In our follow-up response, we also highlighted complementary evidence from the standard planner: adding collision energy to drivable-area energy improves EPDMS from 36.7 to 39.3. We additionally quantified target-speed tracking in the two control demonstrations.

  2. Dynamic collision energy (KKQM, zcLr). We implemented a dynamic prediction module using the current frame and 3 historical frames, and incorporated its predictions into a time-dependent collision energy. We compared static, current-only dynamic, and history-conditioned dynamic energy. On the evaluated NAVSIM test subset, dynamic collision energy composition improves PDMS from 0.595 to 0.738 and reduces the collision rate from 12.0% to 5.1% relative to static collision energy. We have validated that it is a straightforward extension of EnergyDrive with minimal changes. We added these results to the revised paper and side-by-side visualizations to the website.

  3. Controlled validation of repulsive sampling (9nS2, zcLr). We added the requested comparison between 65 independent proposals and 64 repulsive proposals plus one independent proposal, using the same checkpoint and candidate budget. Repulsion improves both useful proposal diversity and planning performance, increasing EPDMS from 31.4 to 44.2 in this controlled ablation.

  4. Efficiency and driving performance trade-off (KKQM, zcLr, L9mc). We added comparisons across sampling steps and vocabulary-based selection under a consistent timing protocol. Vocabulary-based selection achieves 40.3 EPDMS at 19.36 ms, while iterative sampling achieves 44.2 EPDMS at 64.69 ms. We also explicitly discussed the trade-offs among safety, ego progress, and comfort, and clarified the interpretation of the Stage-1 and Stage-2 results.

  5. Additional benchmark and sampling analyses (L9mc). We added evaluation under the official NAVSIM v1 protocol, obtaining 88.8 PDMS, with the highest NC and DAC scores among the compared methods. We also added intermediate trajectory visualizations across five scenarios, showing how energy values and driving quality evolve during sampling.

We believe that these additional experiments, clarifications, and revisions address the concerns raised in the reviews and follow-up discussion. Following our response, Reviewer KKQM explicitly acknowledged the detailed clarifications and increased their rating to weak acceptance. Reviewer L9mc also confirmed their weak acceptance after considering the additional experimental results and contributions. We thank all the reviewers again for their time and constructive feedback.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.