- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
EnergyDrive learns a scene-conditioned energy function to generate and rank driving trajectories. It starts from Gaussian noise, refines candidates through energy-gradient updates, and selects a trajectory using the learned energy and additional driving objectives.
Critical strengths
Using the same energy function for generation and evaluation is intuitive. The framework is easy to motivate, and the results on NAVSIM v2 and HUGSIM are promising.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper does not clearly show whether lower energy leads to better trajectories throughout sampling.
- Results on NAVSIM v1 would also help establish broader applicability. The main figure could distinguish generation and final selection more clearly.
Questions for authors
- Could you show intermediate trajectories and driving-quality metrics across sampling steps? Does lower energy consistently mean better planning?
- How does the number of sampling steps affect performance and latency?
2 comments
Thank you for providing this information. Considering the experimental results provided and the contributions of the paper, I believe it is appropriate to maintain the original score.
Rebuttal by Authors
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and for recognizing the intuitive use of a shared energy function for generation and evaluation, as well as the promising benchmark results. Below are our point-by-point responses and the corresponding revisions added to the manuscript and our website.
Relation between energy value and driving performance. We thank the reviewer for the question. Our energy-landscape visualization (Fig. 1 and the project website) illustrates how the composed energy assigns lower values to trajectories satisfying the modeled driving objectives, while penalizing undesirable trajectories such as off-road or collision-prone paths with higher energy values. Additionally, we have added intermediate trajectory sampling visualizations across five driving scenarios, including left turns, straight driving, and right turns. For each example, we visualize the trajectory evolution alongside its energy value and driving-quality score (EPDMS) throughout the optimization process. As sampling progresses, trajectories evolve from initial noise toward plausible driving paths, with energy decreasing by approximately 50% and EPDMS improving from 0 to 0.87–0.99 (0-1 scale) by the final step. We have added these visualizations and clarified the relationship between energy optimization and planning quality in the Appendix D.5 in the revised manuscript and on the website.
Evaluation on NAVSIM v1. Following the reviewer's suggestion, we additionally evaluate EnergyDrive under the official NAVSIM v1 protocol. While NAVSIM v2 navhard remains our primary benchmark due to its more challenging pseudo-closed-loop evaluation, NAVSIM v1 provides complementary evidence of planning performance.
EnergyDrive achieves the highest NC, DAC, and TTC scores among the compared methods, with an overall PDMS of 88.8, outperforming LTF and DiffusionDrive and remaining close to MeanFuser (89.0). These results further support the effectiveness of the safety-aware planning framework. These results are reported in Appendix D.6 (Table D.4).
Clarifying generation and selection in the main figure. We have also revised the main framework figure (Fig 2) to explicitly distinguish the two stages of our default inference pipeline: (1) repulsive trajectory generation under the learned driving energy, and (2) final trajectory selection using the composed energy objective. This clarifies that modular safety energies guide candidate selection in the default configuration, while direct gradient-based composition is evaluated separately.
Sampling steps, performance, and latency. We thank the reviewer for this question. We conduct an additional ablation using the same final checkpoint and inference configuration while varying the number of optimization steps. We report the resulting planning performance and latency, together with vocabulary-based selection as an efficient alternative:
The results show that increasing the number of optimization steps improves planning performance across the tested settings, at the cost of higher latency. The 10-step setting achieves the highest EPDMS in this ablation. Alternatively, EnergyDrive supports vocabulary-based selection using explicit energy evaluations without iterative trajectory optimization. This achieves 40.3 EPDMS at 19.36 ms, offering a substantially more efficient inference option with competitive planning performance. We have added this trade-off analysis to the Appendix B.5 in the revised manuscript.
Overall, we appreciate the reviewer's suggestion, and we have updated them in the revised manuscript. We appreciate your constructive feedback on both the evaluation and presentation.