acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Balancing Reference Guidance and Free Generation in Trajectory Rollouts for Reasoning RL

Abstract

A verified reference solution provides a correct trajectory for training a reasoning model. Alternatively, a prefix of the reference can guide the model in generating a trajectory of its own. How much reference guidance should we provide? We study this question through prefix continuation, where the model continues from a reference prefix and keeps the resulting trajectory if it passes verification, falling back to the reference otherwise. Since both procedures produce correct trajectories, we compare their distributions with the ideal distribution, the model's own distribution conditioned on successful verification. For one continuation, we derive the KL divergence in closed form, which, up to a bounded term, decreases with the product of the probability of generating a different correct trajectory and the reference surprisal, the negative log probability of the reference suffix given the prefix. Since a longer prefix tends to raise the former but lowers the latter, continuation success alone does not determine the preferred amount of guidance. From this analysis, we learn a prefix selector shared across training questions from continuation outcomes, without estimating success probabilities or additional generation. The resulting Adaptive Reference Guidance (ARG) constructs correct trajectories within a fixed generation budget, and we apply it to all-failure groups in Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO). Experiments on Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B across five mathematical reasoning benchmarks show that ARG achieves the highest aggregate pass@12 among the evaluated methods with competitive average sampled accuracy.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
Large Language Models, Reinforcement Learning with Verifiable Rewards, Mathematical Reasoning, Reference-Guided Generation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_1WCcOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

To solve the problem of all-zero reward groups in RL, the paper derives an approximate criterion relating the accepted completion distribution to the policy’s own correct-answer distribution, suggesting that prefix choice should balance completion success probability against the surprisal of the remaining reference suffix. A shared prefix selector is then trained and used within GRPO when the original group contains no successful samples. Experiments on Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B report improvements in pass@12 over several reference-guidance and resampling baselines.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper identifies a real operational problem about how to obtain the useful trajectories from all-zero RL groups.
  2. The matched-budget comparisons against direct reference insertion and unguided resampling are useful.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Somehow relative to existing method about regerence-guided exploration, not outlining a sufficiently new conceptual insight.
  2. The evidence for the final conclusion about the learned selector is weak. Evaluation uses small test sets and the gains over strongest baseline is small.
Questions for authors
  1. How does the learned selector compare with prospectively fixed prefix fractions, uniform random prefix selection, and a simple success-rate heuristic under identical sampling and compute budgets?
  2. Please clarify the closest prior reference-prefix or guided-completion methods and identify which empirical behavior your criterion predicts that those existing methods do not.
6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 1WCc (1/2)

We thank Reviewer 1WCc for the constructive feedback and for recognizing the practical problem that we study and the matched-budget comparisons.

W1 & Q2: Closest prior methods, the new insight, and predicted behavior

Closest prior methods. The closest methods reveal a part of the reference and let the model generate the rest. R$^3$ [1], Prefix-RFT [2], and QuestA [3] fix the revealed amount in advance or follow a schedule over training. BREAD [4], AdaBack [5], and G$^2$RPO-A [6] adapt it to the rewards of the model, revealing more when the model fails and less when it succeeds. BREAD is the closest to ARG, both applying to the same all-failure groups of GRPO.

Differences and the new insight. ARG differs in three aspects.

  1. The criterion. In the methods above, the prefix is a way to obtain a correct trajectory, and its length is set by a schedule or by success. We show that a prefix should also be judged by how much of the resulting correct trajectory is the model's own. Intuitively, a longer prefix makes success more likely but leaves less of the solution to the model. The preferred prefix balances the two, and thus success alone does not determine it.
  2. The theory behind it. The methods above set the amount with a designed rule, whereas ARG derives it. The ideal trajectory to learn from is a correct response that the model generates entirely by itself, and Theorem 1 gives in closed form the distance between this ideal and the trajectory obtained through a prefix. The distance decreases with dtStd_tS_t, where dtd_t is the probability that the continuation succeeds and StS_t is the surprisal of the part of the reference that the model replaces.
  3. One selector learned across questions. BREAD and AdaBack decide the amount separately for each question, through a search with extra rollouts [4] or a record of its past rewards [5]. Theorem 2 shows that our criterion can be learned from the continuations that training already generates. ARG thus learns one selector shared across questions, without a search or a schedule set by hand.

Predicted behavior. The criterion predicts that more successful continuations do not by themselves give better training. We examine it on the methods that we trained.

  1. Success as the selector signal. On Qwen3-8B, a continuation from α=14\alpha=\tfrac14 (the longest prefix) succeeds twice as often as one from α=12\alpha=\tfrac12 (40.2% vs. 19.1% over the whole run). However, it replaces less of the reference, and its mean feedback, which estimates dtSt/S0d_tS_t/S_0, is lower (0.075 vs. 0.081). Our criterion therefore prefers α=12\alpha=\tfrac12, whereas success prefers α=14\alpha=\tfrac14. The surprisal weighting ablation in the paper trains the same selector with each signal. Following success gives accepted continuations in more groups, yet a lower pass@12 and avg@12. |Selector signal (Qwen3-8B)|Preferred level at the end of training|Groups with an accepted continuation|pass@12|avg@12| |-|-|-|-|-| |Success alone|α=14\alpha=\tfrac14 (86.4%)|64.8%|64.00|31.89| |Success weighted by surprisal (ARG)|α=12\alpha=\tfrac12 (49.0%)|60.2%|70.00|42.28|

  2. BREAD, the closest baseline. For each all-failure group, BREAD searches over prefix lengths until the model succeeds from one of them. Its prefix is thus set by success. The table below compares its training process with ARG. BREAD obtains a correct continuation in more groups and spends more than 3.6 times as many rollouts on them, yet ARG reaches a higher pass@12 and pass@32 on both models. |Method|Extra rollouts per all-failure group|Groups with a correct continuation|pass@12|pass@32| |-|-|-|-|-| |BREAD|29.0 / 29.3|81.1% / 79.4%|66.67 / 67.33|69.33 / 74.67| |ARG|8 / 8|66.0% / 60.2%|67.33 / 70.00|73.33 / 76.67|

  3. The whole reference. Measured by success, the whole reference is the best choice because it is always correct. Under our criterion it is the worst, since the model generates nothing by itself (St=0S_t=0). Indeed, inserting it into the all-failure groups gives 56.67 pass@12 on Qwen3-4B (Table 3(a)), below every run that inserts continuations instead (60.00 to 67.33).

The revised PDF adds this comparison to Section 6, and the selector results are in Section 5.3 and Appendix G.

[1] Xi, Zhiheng, et al. "Training large language models for reasoning through reverse curriculum reinforcement learning." ICML 2024.

[2] Huang, Zeyu, et al. "Blending supervised and reinforcement fine-tuning with prefix sampling." ICML 2026.

[3] Li, Jiazheng, et al. "Questa: Expanding reasoning capacity in llms via question augmentation." ICLR 2026.

[4] Zhang, Xuechen, et al. "Bread: Branched rollouts from expert anchors bridge sft & rl for reasoning." NeurIPS 2025.

[5] Amani et al. "RL for Reasoning by Adaptively Revealing Rationales." ICLR 2026.

[6] Guo, Yongxin, et al. "G2rpo-a: Guided group relative policy optimization with adaptive guidance." ACL 2026.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 1WCc (2/2)

W2 & Q1: Learned selector vs. fixed levels, uniform sampling, and a success-rate heuristic

We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We compare the learned selector with every alternative that the reviewer lists on Qwen3-4B, and it outperforms all of them under an identical budget.

Setting. Each run keeps the training setting of ARG and changes only how the guidance level is chosen. Every all-failure group still receives eight continuations, with the same acceptance rule, reference fallback, training steps, and evaluation. The selector of ARG learns from these same eight continuations without extra generation. Therefore, the sampling and compute budgets are identical across the rows. For the success-rate heuristic, we train the selector of ARG on success alone (Table 3(b) of the revised PDF), and it thus moves toward the levels with a higher observed success rate.

Choice of guidance level (Qwen3-4B)pass@12avg@12
Fixed α=12\alpha=\tfrac1264.0035.06
Fixed α=14\alpha=\tfrac1464.0038.78
Uniform sampling64.6735.94
Success-rate selector63.3334.67
ARG (learned selector)67.3341.11

A fixed level has to be chosen before training, and finding the best one takes a full training run per level and per model, whereas ARG needs a single run. Moreover, ARG keeps sampling every level, and thus a part of its accepted trajectories comes from a shorter prefix or from no prefix at all, which a fixed α=14\alpha=\tfrac14 never provides. The success-rate selector is also below ARG on Qwen3-8B (64.00 vs. 70.00 pass@12, Table 3(b)).

W2: Size of the test sets and gains over the strongest baseline

We thank the reviewer for raising this point. Each of the five benchmarks is a complete competition set of 30 questions, and Table 1 uses all 150 questions with 12 responses per question. To further strengthen the evidence, we evaluate the same models with more responses per question and on a larger test set.

More responses per question. Table 1 draws 12 responses per question, which determine pass@k for every k≤12k \le 12 (n=12, where nn is the total number of responses). For larger kk, we draw 20 more responses per question and pool them with the 12 of Table 1, giving 32 responses per question and 4,800 responses per model (n=32). We compute pass@k from each pool with the standard unbiased estimator [7] and average over the five benchmarks. The same kk can give slightly different values in the two pools because the n=32 value averages over more responses. pass@12 with n=12 is the value of Table 1.

ModelMethodpass@8, n=12pass@12, n=12pass@8, n=32pass@12, n=32pass@16, n=32pass@32, n=32
Qwen3-4BGRPO61.9664.0061.2863.9165.4968.67
SAGE60.0762.6761.5964.8967.0272.67
LUFFY62.2164.6763.2965.6166.9569.33
BREAD64.3266.6763.7965.9267.2069.33
ARG (ours)64.8767.3364.5667.5169.3673.33
Qwen3-8BGRPO59.3962.6758.7061.7563.7468.67
SAGE63.0066.0063.5366.6068.6772.67
LUFFY63.3367.3363.8067.0969.2874.00
BREAD65.2767.3366.1368.8170.5674.67
ARG (ours)66.6970.0065.8569.1271.3476.67

With 32 responses, ARG has the highest pass@k for every k≥12k\ge 12 on both models, and its margin over BREAD, the strongest baseline of Table 1, grows with kk. A larger kk rewards a model that can reach a correct solution in more ways, which is what ARG trains by learning from the correct continuations that the model itself generates.

A larger test set from other domains. We evaluate the same models, without further training, on 300 questions drawn uniformly at random from the 13 non-math categories of the MMLU-Pro test set, with 12 responses per question (pass@12, %).

ModelBaseGRPOSAGELUFFYBREADARG (ours)
Qwen3-4B83.3381.3380.6782.6780.3384.67
Qwen3-8B85.6785.3385.3386.6786.6787.00

ARG is the only method that improves over the base model on both models.

Cost. These gains come at a small cost. On Qwen3-4B, ARG adds 32 s (10%) to a GRPO update of 318 s, compared with 78 s (25%) for BREAD. The table below reports the wall-clock time of one training update, as a mean over the 200 updates. All runs use two H100 GPUs and the same 32 questions with eight responses per question.

MethodAdditional time per updateRelative to GRPO (318 s)pass@12
GRPO––64.00
LUFFY1 s+0%64.67
SAGE127 s+40%62.67
BREAD78 s+25%66.67
ARG (ours)32 s+10%67.33

The revised PDF includes the selector table in Section 5.3 and the pass@k and cost tables in Appendix F.

[7] Chen, Mark, et al. "Evaluating large language models trained on code." arXiv preprint arXiv:2107.03374 (2021).

Thank you for the detailed response. I agree that the theoretical motivation is interesting, and the new fixed, uniform, and success-only comparisons strengthen the case for the learned selector. My main concern is still the robustness and generality of the empirical evidence. AIME and HMMT are small, closely related competition-math benchmarks: with roughly 30 questions per set, one additional solved problem changes accuracy by about 3.3 percentage points. Given the relatively small gains, your enlarged table doesn't show that ARG has much performance gain. Besides, evaluation on a larger held-out set, or on other verifiable domains such as logic, code, or agentic tasks, would substantially strengthen the claim. Otherwise, I believe the paper should narrow its conclusions to the current competition-math setting. I appreciate the authors’ effort, and if the method has impressive performance gain on other tasks then I will raise my rating.

Reviewer_sWYgOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Adaptive Reference Guidance (ARG), an approach to improve reasoning reinforcement learning on hard problems where the model is unable to generate correct responses. The proposed method uses prefixes from verified reference solutions to guide the model toward generating correct reasoning trajectories. The authors also provide a theoretical analysis of the trade-off between successful continuation and the amount of reference guidance, and propose a learned prefix selector based on continuation success and reference surprisal. The method is integrated into GRPO to provide learning signals, and the experiments on two Qwen3 models across five mathematical reasoning benchmarks show that ARG outperforms GRPO and other baselines.

Critical strengths
  1. The main motivation for balancing reference guidance and the model's own generation is intuitive. The theoretical analysis provides useful explanation of the approach and motivates the proposed surprisal weighted prefix selection.

  2. The experimental evaluation is decent, including comparisons with several relevant baselines. The authors also provide useful ablations and the results show improvements in pass@12 for both model sizes.

Critical weaknesses

My main concern is the reliability of the experimental improvements. Although ARG achieves the highest aggregate pass@12, the gains over the strongest baseline are relatively small, particularly on Qwen3-4B. Furthermore, the evaluation uses only 30 questions per benchmark, and the authors do not report variance across independent training runs. Without multiple training seeds and a larger evaluation set, it is difficult to determine whether these improvements are consistent.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors evaluate ARG across multiple training seeds and report the mean and variance of the results?

  2. Can the authors better justify whether the relatively small improvements over the strongest baseline (e.g. on Qwen3-4B) are meaningful? A comparison of performance and computational costs would also be useful.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer sWYg

We thank Reviewer sWYg for the constructive feedback and for recognizing the motivation of the method, the theory behind the surprisal-weighted selection of prefixes, and the baselines and ablations. Below we answer the weakness and questions with additional experiments and clarifications.

Weakness & Q1: Multiple training seeds

We thank the reviewer for raising this point. We train GRPO, LUFFY, and ARG on Qwen3-4B with two more seeds, while keeping the setting and evaluation of Table 1. The table below reports the mean ±\pm standard deviation over the three seeds.

Method (Qwen3-4B)pass@12avg@12
GRPO62.44 ±\pm 2.1435.89 ±\pm 2.47
LUFFY64.89 ±\pm 1.6839.35 ±\pm 0.95
ARG (ours)66.22 ±\pm 1.0239.63 ±\pm 1.97

The improvement of ARG holds across training seeds, with the highest mean in both metrics.

Weakness & Q2: Size of the test sets, meaning of the gains, and computational cost

We thank the reviewer for this question. We first clarify that each AIME and HMMT benchmark contains only 30 questions in total. Therefore, Table 1 uses every question of the five benchmarks, without any selection. Below we further support the gains of ARG with more responses per question, a larger test set, and the computational cost.

More responses per question. We evaluate with more responses to test how pass@k changes with a larger kk. Table 1 uses 12 responses per question, which fix pass@k for every k≤12k \le 12 (n=12, where nn is the total number of responses). For larger kk, we draw 20 more responses per question and pool them with the original 12 samples, which gives 32 responses per question (n=32). We compute pass@k from each pool with the standard unbiased estimator [1] and average over the five benchmarks. The same kk can give slightly different values in the two pools because the n=32 value averages over more responses. In the table below, pass@12 with n=12 is the value of Table 1.

ModelMethodpass@8, n=12pass@12, n=12pass@8, n=32pass@12, n=32pass@16, n=32pass@32, n=32
Qwen3-4BGRPO61.9664.0061.2863.9165.4968.67
SAGE60.0762.6761.5964.8967.0272.67
LUFFY62.2164.6763.2965.6166.9569.33
BREAD64.3266.6763.7965.9267.2069.33
ARG (ours)64.8767.3364.5667.5169.3673.33
Qwen3-8BGRPO59.3962.6758.7061.7563.7468.67
SAGE63.0066.0063.5366.6068.6772.67
LUFFY63.3367.3363.8067.0969.2874.00
BREAD65.2767.3366.1368.8170.5674.67
ARG (ours)66.6970.0065.8569.1271.3476.67

ARG consistently outperforms the baselines at larger kk, and its margin over BREAD, the strongest baseline of Table 1, grows with kk, which indicates a meaningful improvement.

A larger test set from other domains. Considering generalizability to reasoning tasks beyond math, we evaluate the same models, without further training, on 300 questions drawn uniformly at random from the 13 non-math categories of the MMLU-Pro test set, with 12 responses per question (pass@12, %).

ModelBaseGRPOSAGELUFFYBREADARG (ours)
Qwen3-4B83.3381.3380.6782.6780.3384.67
Qwen3-8B85.6785.3385.3386.6786.6787.00

ARG achieves the highest pass@12 on both models.

Cost. The table below reports the wall-clock time of one training update on Qwen3-4B. All runs use two H100 GPUs and the same 32 questions with eight responses per question, and the times are means over the 200 updates. For the baselines, the additional time is the difference from the update time of GRPO. ARG shares the rest of the update with GRPO, and we report the measured time of its additional stage, which consists of the continuations, their verification, and the update of the selector.

MethodAdditional time per updateRelative to GRPO (318 s)pass@12
GRPO––64.00
LUFFY1 s+0%64.67
SAGE127 s+40%62.67
BREAD78 s+25%66.67
ARG (ours)32 s+10%67.33

The additional stage of ARG is small because it runs only on the all-failure groups. Per update it generates 19.3 continuations, compared with the 256 responses of GRPO (7.5% more responses). Most of them start from a prefix of the reference and are short, adding only 1.8% to the generated tokens. The selector learns from these same continuations and needs no further generation. In comparison, the search of BREAD generates 79.1 extra rollouts per update. ARG therefore obtains the highest pass@12 at less than half of the additional time of BREAD, the strongest baseline. The revised PDF includes the pass@k and cost tables in Appendix F.

[1] Chen, Mark, et al. "Evaluating large language models trained on code." arXiv preprint arXiv:2107.03374 (2021).

Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments. I appreciate the multiple-seed evaluation, extended pass@k analysis, and computational cost comparison.

However, my main concern regarding the reliability of the performance improvements is only partially addressed. The new three-seed evaluation excludes BREAD, which is the strongest baseline in Table 1. If BREAD outperforms the proposed approach over multiple seeds which is likely, the authors should also honestly report those numbers here. Furthermore, the improvements over the strongest baselines remain relatively small in several settings. Could the authors clarify why BREAD was excluded from the multiple-seed evaluation and provide thse numbers as well?

I will then provide my final rating.

Thank you for the follow-up. Below we address the remaining concern.

Why BREAD was not in the multi-seed table. At the time of our first response, we had not trained BREAD with additional seeds, and no multi-seed result of BREAD was intentionally excluded. With limited computing resources, we first ran additional seeds for ARG, for GRPO as the standard baseline, and for LUFFY because of its shorter training time, and we shared these results early to leave time for discussion. We have now trained BREAD with two additional seeds under the same training and evaluation protocol in the paper, and we report the results below.

Main three-seed results. The table below adds BREAD to the multi-seed table of our first response (Qwen3-4B, 200 training steps, three seeds, mean ±\pm standard deviation). ARG remains the best method on both metrics.

Method (Qwen3-4B, 200 steps)pass@12avg@12
GRPO62.44 ±\pm 2.1435.89 ±\pm 2.47
BREAD63.56 ±\pm 2.7838.76 ±\pm 4.08
LUFFY64.89 ±\pm 1.6839.35 ±\pm 0.95
ARG (ours)66.22 ±\pm 1.0239.63 ±\pm 1.97

We also observed that advantage of ARG over BREAD is even larger earlier in training. At 100 steps, ARG already exceeds the mean pass@12 that BREAD reaches after 200 steps, indicating a faster performance gain and convergence.

Method (Qwen3-4B, 100 steps)pass@12avg@12
BREAD56.89 ±\pm 3.6729.78 ±\pm 3.87
ARG (ours)64.89 ±\pm 5.3936.65 ±\pm 6.73

Results on extended benchmarks. To make the comparison more reliable, we also evaluate all three seeds of ARG, GRPO, and BREAD at 200 steps on two larger benchmarks that are not from competitions, following our response to Reviewer 1WCc. Minerva Math [1] has 272 university science and engineering problems, and TheoremQA [2] has 747 text-only questions on theorems from math, physics, computer science, and finance. Together with the five competition benchmarks in the paper, the evaluation covers seven benchmarks and 1169 questions. We keep the evaluation setting and, as in our response to Reviewer 1WCc, report pass@12 (mean ±\pm standard deviation over three seeds) on each new benchmark, on the five competition benchmarks, and on average over all seven benchmarks.

Method (Qwen3-4B, 200 steps)Minerva MathTheoremQA5 competition benchmarksAverage of 7 benchmarks
Qwen3-4B44.1253.5538.6741.57
GRPO47.55 ±\pm 0.5659.62 ±\pm 0.9162.44 ±\pm 2.1459.91 ±\pm 1.48
BREAD47.06 ±\pm 0.7458.63 ±\pm 0.5863.56 ±\pm 2.7860.50 ±\pm 2.14
ARG (ours)50.37 ±\pm 0.7460.60 ±\pm 0.7466.22 ±\pm 1.0263.15 ±\pm 0.87

ARG has significant performance improvements over the baselines, achieving the highest pass@12 on every benchmark group and on the average of all seven benchmarks.

Results on another domain (tool use). Following the suggestion of Reviewer 1WCc, we also train ARG and BREAD on ToolAlpaca [3], a tool-use benchmark. ARG outperforms BREAD at every k, and the gap grows as more attempts are allowed. Hence ARG solves more distinct tasks, which is the behavior ARG is designed for. This result also shows a significant performance gain over the baselines.

Methodpass@4pass@8pass@12pass@16
Qwen3-4B61.0261.7662.5063.24
GRPO62.7163.6364.2664.71
BREAD63.5466.1667.8769.12
ARG (ours)66.2672.7076.5979.41

We hope that these results, obtained under limited computing resources, address the concern about the improvement over BREAD. We will include these results in the final revision.

[1] Lewkowycz, Aitor, et al. "Solving quantitative reasoning problems with language models." NeurIPS 2022.

[2] Chen, Wenhu, et al. "TheoremQA: A theorem-driven question answering dataset." EMNLP 2023.

[3] Tang, Qiaoyu, et al. "ToolAlpaca: Generalized tool learning for language models with 3000 simulated cases." arXiv:2306.05301, 2023.

Reviewer_MfhTOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the problem setting of using a reference solution in GRPO rollouts for learning signal guidance. However, the dilemma is how to balance the rollouts' on-policy properties and the reference solution's learning signals. Such a balance has been formulated empirically as a factor d_t applied to the nll S_t. To avoid solving such a difficult problem, this paper further transforms the problem into a prefix selection method. The evaluation has been done on reasoning benchmarks compared to GRPO baselines.

Critical strengths
  1. This paper has a good formulation of the preference continuation problem and the problem is clearly stated and motivated.
  2. Extensive baselines have been compared.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The critical notation \delta_r is mentioned in Line 114, but it is referred to without being defined. This could immediately impact the readability and understanding of Theorem 1 (eq. 5).

  2. Equation (11) has been introduced a bit too abruptly, which fails to directly link to Theorem 2. Justifications are needed for the direct instantiation of Equation (11) of Equation (6). An empirical gap in the methodology design may be derived from this instantiation, which may need more experiments to validate.

  3. The empirical evaluations are limited in mathematical reasoning.

  4. Only pass@12 has been reported everywhere. To examine the exploration and exploitation abilities of the proposed method, larger and smaller K values may be valuable for better understanding.

Questions for authors

Please refer to weaknesses.

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer MfhT (1/2)

We thank Reviewer MfhT for the constructive feedback and for recognizing the formulation and motivation of the problem and the breadth of the baselines. Below we answer each weakness with clarifications and additional results.

W1: Definition of δr\delta_r

We thank the reviewer for pointing this out. δr\delta_r is the Dirac (point-mass) distribution on the reference rr, defined as δr(y)=1\delta_r(y)=1 if y=ry=r and 00 otherwise. It is the distribution of the accepted trajectory when the model is trained on the reference alone. Hence DKL(δr∥ν)=−log⁡ν(r)=log⁡pπ(r)D_{\rm KL}(\delta_r\|\nu)=-\log\nu(r)=\log\frac{p}{\pi(r)}, the first term of Eq. (5), is the distance of training on the reference alone, and Theorem 1 states how much a prefix of length tt reduces this distance. The leading term of this reduction is dtStd_tS_t, the probability of a successful replacement times the surprisal of the replaced suffix. This product therefore comes from Theorem 1 itself, and it is the quantity that the selector learns to maximize. The revised PDF states this definition where δr\delta_r first appears and again before Theorem 1.

W2: Link between Theorem 2 and Eq. (11)

We thank the reviewer for this comment. Eq. (11) follows from Eq. (6) and Theorem 2 in three steps.

  • Form. In Eq. (6), the selector is one distribution over the level set AA, shared by all questions. Thus, J(ϕ)=∑α∈Aρϕ(α)μαJ(\phi)=\sum_{\alpha\in A}\rho_\phi(\alpha)\mu_\alpha, where μα\mu_\alpha is the mean feedback of level α\alpha. By Theorem 2, a larger JJ means a smaller distance to the ideal distribution, and the gradient of JJ can be estimated from the feedback for every differentiable ρϕ\rho_\phi with positive probabilities. Eq. (11) is a simple kind of such selectors, which features a softmax over the levels with a lower bound εsel/∣A∣\varepsilon_{\rm sel}/|A| on every probability. It represents every distribution pp over AA above this bound (take ϕα=log⁡(p(α)−εsel/∣A∣)\phi_\alpha=\log(p(\alpha)-\varepsilon_{\rm sel}/|A|)). Therefore, the lower bound is the only constraint that Eq. (11) adds to Eq. (6).
  • Lower bound. The mean feedback changes as the model trains. The lower bound keeps every level sampled, which lets the selector return to a level whose feedback becomes the largest later in training. By Proposition B.3, it lowers the best reachable JJ by εsel(max⁡αμα−1∣A∣∑αμα)\varepsilon_{\rm sel}(\max_\alpha\mu_\alpha-\frac{1}{|A|}\sum_\alpha\mu_\alpha), which is only 3.4% (Qwen3-4B) and 1.3% (Qwen3-8B) of the best reachable JJ for the level means measured below.
  • Update. Eq. (12) is Eq. (10) with the expectation replaced by the continuations of the batch. For Eq. (11), ∂J/∂ϕα=(1−εsel) qϕ(α)(μα−∑α′qϕ(α′)μα′)\partial J/\partial\phi_\alpha=(1-\varepsilon_{\rm sel})\,q_\phi(\alpha)\big(\mu_\alpha-\sum_{\alpha'}q_\phi(\alpha')\mu_{\alpha'}\big), where qϕq_\phi is the softmax term. The update therefore raises the logit of a level exactly when its mean feedback is above the current average, and the selector moves toward the levels with larger dtSt/S0d_tS_t/S_0, the quantity that reduces the distance in Theorem 1.

Validation. We further check the training dynamics of ARG and show this behavior:

α=1\alpha=1α=12\alpha=\tfrac12α=14\alpha=\tfrac14
4B: mean feedback WW over training0.05340.05880.0754
4B: final selection probability8.8%9.9%81.3%
8B: mean feedback WW over training0.07010.08070.0753
8B: final selection probability16.4%49.0%34.6%

For both models, the final selection probabilities are ordered exactly as the mean feedback. Over the whole Qwen3-8B run, α=14\alpha=\tfrac14 succeeds twice as often as α=12\alpha=\tfrac12 (40.2% vs. 19.1%), but its continuations replace less of the reference, and its feedback is lower. The selector prefers α=12\alpha=\tfrac12, as Eq. (10) states.

Table 3(b) of the revised PDF tests this link directly. It keeps Eq. (11) and Eq. (12) and replaces only the feedback of Eq. (7) with the success indicator. The selector then no longer maximizes JJ, and pass@12 drops from 67.33 to 63.33 on Qwen3-4B and from 70.00 to 64.00 on Qwen3-8B.

We also train Qwen3-4B with fixed levels and with uniform sampling of the levels. Each run keeps the setting of ARG, with the same eight continuations per all-failure group, and changes only the choice of level:

Choice of guidance level (Qwen3-4B)pass@12avg@12
Fixed α=12\alpha=\tfrac1264.0035.06
Fixed α=14\alpha=\tfrac1464.0038.78
Uniform sampling64.6735.94
Success indicator as feedback (Table 3(b))63.3334.67
ARG (learned selector)67.3341.11

Fixed levels and uniform sampling are also distributions over AA in Eq. (6), only without learning. The selector of Eq. (11), learned with Eq. (12) from the feedback of Eq. (7), outperforms all of them in both metrics, which validates this instantiation.

The revised PDF introduces Eq. (11) in this way in Section 4.1 and adds the two tables above to Appendix B and Section 5.3.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer MfhT (2/2)

W3: Evaluation beyond mathematical reasoning

We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We evaluate the models of Table 1, which are trained only on mathematical questions, on MMLU-Pro without any further training. We draw 300 questions uniformly at random from the 13 non-math categories of the MMLU-Pro test set (law, engineering, physics, chemistry, business, psychology, biology, economics, health, computer science, philosophy, history, and other), and keep the same evaluation protocol of the paper with 12 responses per question. The table below reports pass@12 (%):

ModelBaseGRPOSAGELUFFYBREADARG (ours)
Qwen3-4B83.3381.3380.6782.6780.3384.67
Qwen3-8B85.6785.3385.3386.6786.6787.00

ARG achieves the highest pass@12 on both models.

W4: pass@k for smaller and larger k

We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. Table 1 uses 12 responses per question, which fix pass@k for every k≤12k \le 12 (n=12, where nn is the total number of responses). For larger kk, we draw 20 more responses per question and pool them with the 12 of Table 1, which gives 32 responses per question (i.e., n=32). We compute pass@k from each pool with the standard unbiased estimator [1] and average over the five benchmarks. The same kk can give slightly different values in the two pools because the n=32 value averages over more responses. In the table below, pass@12 with n=12 is the value of Table 1 in the paper.

ModelMethodpass@8, n=12pass@12, n=12pass@8, n=32pass@12, n=32pass@16, n=32pass@32, n=32
Qwen3-4BGRPO61.9664.0061.2863.9165.4968.67
SAGE60.0762.6761.5964.8967.0272.67
LUFFY62.2164.6763.2965.6166.9569.33
BREAD64.3266.6763.7965.9267.2069.33
ARG (ours)64.8767.3364.5667.5169.3673.33
Qwen3-8BGRPO59.3962.6758.7061.7563.7468.67
SAGE63.0066.0063.5366.6068.6772.67
LUFFY63.3367.3363.8067.0969.2874.00
BREAD65.2767.3366.1368.8170.5674.67
ARG (ours)66.6970.0065.8569.1271.3476.67

A small kk reflects how reliably a model solves a question (exploitation), and a large kk reflects how many questions it can solve within its attempts (exploration). ARG has the highest pass@8 and pass@12 with the responses of Table 1, and with 32 responses it has the highest pass@k for every k≥12k \ge 12 on both models. Moreover, its margin over BREAD, the strongest baseline of Table 1, grows with kk. A larger kk rewards a model that can reach a correct solution in more ways. ARG trains on the correct continuations that the model itself generates, and it therefore benefits when more responses are drawn. The revised PDF includes this table in Appendix F.

[1] Chen, Mark, et al. "Evaluating large language models trained on code." arXiv preprint arXiv:2107.03374 (2021).

Thanks for the response. I will maintain my rating.

Thank you for your constructive feedback and for taking the time to read our response! We will incorporate the clarifications and additional results into the final revision.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.