- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PADM, i.e., Process-Aware Relative Distribution Matching. It decouples the roles of intermediate progress magnitude and direction. It leverages progress magnitude to construct a residual-preserving gradient surrogate that reweights segment-level optimization, and utilizes progress direction to adaptively temper the reference policy to shape the target distribution. Meanwhile, it introduces a group-relative consistency objective across trajectories sampled for the same prompt to align policy probabilities with the target distribution. Experiments on six mathematical reasoning benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of PADM.
Critical strengths
- Through counterfactual continuation experiments, this work verifies the sensitivity of high-entropy forks to downstream answer confidence. It also highlights the coexistence of local improvements and deteriorations in both correct and incorrect trajectories, as well as the high concentration of progress in key segments.
- This work proposes PADM and designs a stop-gradient segment-weighting surrogate while preserving the distribution-matching residual. It also proves that the group-relative objective recovers the target distribution under exact zero matching error.
- Across both 1.7B and 4B model scales, PADM achieves performance gains on multiple benchmark datasets.
Critical weaknesses
-
Several existing works [1–4] have explored the same problem and proposed similar solutions, such as leveraging high-entropy tokens as reasoning forks for selective reinforcement learning, utilizing counterfactual theory for reasoning step evaluation, and measuring process progress via changes in the ground-truth answer log-likelihood to guide credit assignment. Compared to these methods, what are the unique advantages of PADM?
[1] Beyond outcome reward: Decoupling search and answering improves LLM agents; [2] Beyond the 80/20 rule: High-entropy minority tokens drive effective reinforcement learning for LLM reas; [3] Towards Generalizable Reasoning: Group Causal Counterfactual Policy Optimization for LLM Reasoning; [4] Reason-KE++: Aligning the Process, Not Just the Outcome, for Faithful LLM Knowledge Editing.
-
The definition of segment progress relies on the policy model's log-likelihood evaluation of the ground-truth final answer. While this setup is viable in scenarios with deterministic, short numeric labels (such as math problems), tasks involving long-form solutions, code generation, or open-ended reasoning rarely provide a unique gold-standard string for direct forward log-probability computation. How does this method adapt to these broader settings? Confining applicability solely to mathematical scenarios is insufficient.
-
The paper selects the top 20% highest-entropy tokens along each trajectory with enforced minimum spacing as boundaries. However, reasoning models often produce non-semantic entropy spikes on formatting tokens or rare symbols; conversely, high-level shifts in algorithmic strategy can occur within continuous low-entropy spans. Directly equating local token entropy to a "reasoning decision boundary" lacks sufficient validation regarding its generalizability across different tasks and prompts.
-
The method introduces a downstream persistence term . During training, if a trajectory contains segments, does computing this term require running a complete forward pass targeting for every intermediate segment ? Furthermore, the empirically constructed weighted gradient constitutes a non-conservative vector field, whose update direction may not strictly correspond to a scalar loss function.
-
At each training step, PADM not only generates rollouts but also dynamically calculates token entropies, filters top-20% forks, and computes ground-truth log-likelihoods and subsequent consistency terms for each segment. Compared to standard GRPO and FlowRL, what is the computational and memory overhead of PADM? Given that improvements on many datasets are less than 1%, what are the standard deviations and statistical characteristics to ensure the performance gains do not stem from randomness? Additionally, small models differ significantly from large models in reasoning divergence and entropy distributions; evaluating solely on models at or below 4B is insufficient to support the claimed effectiveness.
Questions for authors
Please see the weaknesses.
8 comments
Dependence on a verified reference answer
[W2] Dependence on a verified reference answer.
We appreciate your comment. In our current work, the central goal is to study how to achieve effective credit assignment across diverse reasoning paths leading to the same verified final answer. Mathematical reasoning is particularly well-suited to this problem because it combines verifiable final answers with multiple valid reasoning trajectories. This motivates our evaluation on six challenging mathematical benchmarks. Our current progress estimator requires a verified reference answer during training. This requirement concerns the reference-based progress estimator, and the distribution-matching framework itself does not require a unique answer string. We agree with the reviewer that the application of our current work to general reasoning tasks (e.g., with multiple answers in coding tasks) and non-verifiable reward settings is meaningful, but it is beyond the scope of the current work. Motivated by your comment, we provide a detailed discussion below to indicate a potential direction for extension and reflect this discussion in our updated manuscript in Section 4.1.
To illustrate, we provide a brief code generation example demonstrating a possible extension to tasks with multiple valid answers. Code generation admits functionally equivalent programs with different implementations. We therefore replace the single reference with a fixed set of test-passing programs and aggregate their length-normalized log-likelihoods using log-mean-exp:
\log\left( \frac{1}{G}\sum_{j=1}^{G} \exp\left( \frac{1}{|y_j^{\ast}|} \log\pi_\theta(y_j^{\ast}\mid x,z_{\leq k}) \right) \right), \qquad \Delta C_k=C_k-C_{k-1}.$$ Here, we use $G=4$, denoting the number of reference programs. Each problem's reference pool remains fixed across reasoning boundaries and rollouts. This illustration demonstrates the feasibility of constructing multi-reference coding progress. Validating its alignment with reasoning quality and its benefits for code generation remains future work. Tasks without trusted reference answers or reliable outcome verification require further design and validation and lie beyond the scope of the current study. We provide three examples from a seed-42 pool with DeepCoder coding data, with four reference programs generated by Qwen3-4B and four rollouts generated by Qwen3-1.7B-Base as below. More details are included in the revised manuscript. | **Problem** | **Outcome** | $\Delta C_1$ | $\Delta C_2$ | $\Delta C_3$ | $\Delta C_4$ | | :--- | :--- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | | Pairwise bitwise-AND sum (5700-R4) | Pass | $-0.00084$ | $+0.01225$ | $-0.00243$ | $-0.02539$ | | Sequential substring reversals (6192-R2) | Fail | $+0.00204$ | $+0.00724$ | $-0.00388$ | — | | Date difference (6228-R3) | Fail | $+0.01725$ | $+0.00489$ | $-0.01839$ | — |Entropy-based boundaries and the 20% threshold
[W3] Entropy-based boundaries and the 20% threshold.
We appreciate the reviewer's comments. As stated in our paper, our 20% selection ratio and the definition of reasoning forks follow the cited Beyond the 80/20 Rule [1]. Their ablation report (Figure 6) states that retaining the top-20% highest-entropy tokens provides an effective balance between exploration and training stability. We therefore adopt this empirically motivated default. The 20% ratio is not a contribution or a universally optimal choice claimed by PADM, and our segment-level optimization is not restricted to these selected tokens.
More importantly, our ablations support the empirical utility of this partitioning heuristic in our setting. Table 2 compares entropy-based partitioning with uniform and random partitioning under matched segment counts. Entropy-based partitioning achieves the highest average accuracy, supporting its effectiveness for the PADM algorithm. Our counterfactual continuation analysis (Observation I) provides complementary evidence of sensitivity to downstream answer confidence. Nevertheless, we agree that entropy is an imperfect proxy. These experiments establish practical effectiveness rather than semantic correctness or completeness of every boundary. Following your suggestion, we have revised the wording in Section 4, “Effectiveness of decision-aware segmentation,” to describe these positions as candidate process-sensitive boundaries and avoid equating them with semantically partitioned reasoning steps.
[1] Beyond the 80/20 rule: High-entropy minority tokens drive effective reinforcement learning for LLM reasoning (Wang et al., 2026).
Relationship to existing methods
Dear Reviewer wrSj, we appreciate your valuable comments and insightful feedback. We address each comment point by point below.
We thank the reviewer for pointing out these works. In fact, our work differs fundamentally from these existing works in its distinct organization of process information within relative distribution matching. Following your comment, we have added [1,3,4] to the revised “Related Work” section and expanded the discussion of [2] to make these differences in task setting, supervision, and optimization explicit. In the following, we make a detailed comparison with these existing works and indicate the significant differences between our work and theirs.
[1] Beyond Outcome Reward (DeSA) addresses a different problem setting. DeSA addresses search-augmented question answering, where agents must learn to retrieve external evidence before answering. PADM's evaluated setting concerns verifiable mathematical reasoning without requiring external retrieval. Therefore, we study a different problem in process-aware reasoning optimization.
[2] Beyond the 80/20 Rule has a different optimization framework and usage of entropy. PADM uses entropy only to identify candidate segment boundaries, and optimization is not restricted to the selected fork tokens. Conversely, [2] restricts policy-gradient loss terms to selected high-entropy tokens. We study a process-aware relative distribution matching framework, whereas [2] uses a policy-gradient objective. We explicitly attribute the entropy-based fork insight to [2], which is already cited in our manuscript.
[3] GC2PO considers different optimization framework. Our counterfactual continuation experiments are diagnostic analyses of boundary sensitivity, and we do not construct counterfactual rewards. GC2PO incorporates counterfactual process rewards into token-level advantages and optimizes a GRPO-style clipped policy-gradient objective. PADM instead minimizes group-relative log-density matching for a process-aware target distribution, which is a framework-level distinction.
[4] Reason-KE++ has a different problem setting and framework. The task setting and optimization framework are both distinct. PADM addresses verifiable reasoning through relative distribution matching. In contrast, Reason-KE++ targets faithfulness to edited knowledge in multi-hop question answering and uses cold-start SFT followed by PPO with stage-aware rewards.
[1] Beyond outcome reward: Decoupling search and answering improves LLM agents (Wang et al., 2025).
[2] Beyond the 80/20 rule: High-entropy minority tokens drive effective reinforcement learning for LLM reasoning (Wang et al., 2026).
[3] Towards Generalizable Reasoning: Group Causal Counterfactual Policy Optimization for LLM Reasoning (Wang et al., 2026).
[4] Reason-KE++: Aligning the Process, Not Just the Outcome, for Faithful LLM Knowledge Editing (Wu et al., 2026).