acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Verify In-Sample, Withhold, Distill: Three Insights for LLM Skill Learning

Abstract

Skill learning has become a popular approach to improving LLM agents: for each training instance, a model reflects on the policy's prediction against the ground truth and writes one natural-language lesson; these lessons are then consolidated into reusable skills that the policy consults at inference time. Some recent work draws a productive analogy with backpropagation. But the two also differ in fundamental ways, and these differences give rise to three insights. 1) Verify in-sample}: a lesson is worth keeping only if it fixes its own training sample. It is common to verify a lesson on a validation set, but that is an out-of-sample test, measuring generalization rather than whether the lesson repairs the sample it was derived from. Verifying in-sample is critical: unlike a sufficiently small gradient step, which by construction reduces the loss on the sample it is computed from, a lesson offers no such guarantee. A lesson should therefore be iteratively fed back to the policy and revised until it fixes its own training sample, and discarded otherwise. 2) Skill learning overfits far less than backpropagation. A gradient step fits whatever reduces the loss; an individual lesson can overfit its own sample too, but this overfitting is largely suppressed if the ground truth is withheld: the reflection is told whether the prediction was correct and the direction of its error, never the answer itself. Consolidating lessons into skills further discards whatever instance-specific detail remains. Skills learned this way improve performance even from a handful of samples, without the overfitting that few-shot backpropagation exhibits, and gain more as samples grow. 3) Lessons, not only skills, are worth distilling into smaller models. Most prior work neglects both; the few recent exceptions internalize only the skills into a smaller policy, leaving the lessons unused. Yet the instance-specific detail that consolidation discards, of no use at inference time, is a denser training signal than the skill itself: a self-generated trace of how the policy erred and corrected itself. We give a simple baseline that distills both. Each insight is simple, yet all three are routinely overlooked; in our experiments, acting on them consistently improves skill learning and surpasses prior state of the art.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Large Language Models, LLM Agents, Skill learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_GyW2OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This work proposes a new pipeline for learning skills from training samples, as well as a skill distillation method based on lessons and skills. The skill learning pipeline involves retrying failed samples while providing teacher-generated hints until the policy succeeds. Each trajectory is then consolidated into a lesson, and lessons are consolidated into a reflection skill. This is motivated by the fact that lessons generated from more iterations are higher quality, and that learning skills from a few samples is less at risk of overfitting than standard SFT. The authors then propose a simple distillation method, which consists in (1) training a small policy with SFT on trajectories and lessons generated from a stronger model, (2) deriving a reflection skill from the fine-tuned small policy via iterative revision, (3) further training with GRPO and additional SFT on samples that first fail but succeed after retries with the reflection skill. Experiments show the proposed skill pipeline improves performance compared to baselines on document-QA tasks, ALFWorld, and multimodal benchmarks. The distillation method is validated on ALFWorld and WebShop.

Critical strengths
  1. The proposed iterative refinement before aggregating into lessons is sound.
  2. The methods show good empirical performance compared to baselines.
Critical weaknesses
  1. I have concerns about the novelty of the work. The main addition compared to prior works appears to be the iterative revision before extracting lessons, which seems rather incremental. The discussion and results around the analogy with gradient descent do not add much to the argument as most skill learning pipelines similarly derive lessons and skills from a few samples. The distillation baseline proposed is a standard SFT+RL finetuning pipeline, with some additional fine-tuning on samples that succeed after retrying with the reflection skill in context.
  2. Experimental results do not establish whether the comparison with baselines is fair. The manuscript just states that all baselines and the proposed method share the same tool sets and tool descriptions (l.308), but provides very little details about the implementations of each baseline, how the compute/search budget is set to ensure a fair comparison between baselines and the proposed method, how the train/test split is done for each benchmark, etc. The Appendix only provides the prompts used for ALFWorld but no additional details on the experimental setup. Since the code is not provided either, this raises concerns about the reproducibility of the work.
Questions for authors
  1. Regarding the iterative refinement phase, the model solving a sample is not deterministic: different rollouts can succeed or fail despite having the same context. How do you take this into account to distinguish a real improvement from a lucky rollout when iteratively refining the lesson?
  2. To what tokens is the CE loss applied in Eq.1? Only to the generated tokens or also to the inserted reflection skill?
Reviewer_rT4EOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper focuses on an important question: skill learning. This paper proposes three insights. 1)Verify in-sample: a lesson is worth keeping only if it fixes its own training sample. 2) Withhold ground truth to suppress overfitting. 3) Lessons, not only skills, are worth distilling into smaller models.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper focuses on an important problem.
  2. The paper proposes simple but useful methods.
  3. The paper is evaluated across diverse settings and show good improvement.
Critical weaknesses
  1. I think some claims are not fully supported. For example, skill learning overfits less. Figure 3(b) shows SFT is worse than the base policy. However, test performance alone does not diagnose overfitting. I think showing both training and test performance is needed.

  2. For Several key comparisons, I think the comparison is not inference-compute matched.

  3. The success-skill representation includes a “Boundary”, but positive trajectories don't identify where the procedure ceases to apply. I'm curious why it's designed like this and how well it works. I feel like both success and reflection are needed.

  4. Answer withholding is an important setting. I think the implementation needs to be described more precisely. I think details are missing. What information the teacher sees, what is passed to the policy? A more detailed ablation is needed, for example compare full-answer feedback, diagnostic-only feedback, and feedback generated without access to the reference answer.

  5. The sensitivity to sample and lesson ordering is not clearly evaluated. But I think it's important. I'm curious whether the resulting skill depends on which examples appear first or last, how similar examples are processed, or which lessons are omitted when the context becomes long.

  6. I think several comparisons are not really fair. In the in-context experiments, the proposed method may use longer context than the baselines.

Questions for authors

see weakness

Reviewer_F1Z5OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a skill-learning pipeline by three insights: Verify in-sample, Withhold answers and Distil, that iteratively revises failed attempts on training samples and consolidates lessons from successful corrections into reusable skills. Experiments covertext-based and multimodal tasks. The method achieves leading reported results among the evaluated baselines, with additional analyses examining the contributions of skill components and distillation.

Critical strengths
  1. The targeted problem is valuable. The paper addresses important challenges in skill learning and proposes targeted modifications to address potential weaknesses.

  2. Practical pipeline and strong results. The paper proposes a useful pipeline for skill-learning, achieving leading results across multiple benchmarks against several evaluated baselines.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited novelty. Several pipeline components build on existing work, while comparison and discussion of the closest approaches remain insufficient to clearly establish the incremental contribution.

  2. Insufficiently justified insights. The insights are relatively intuitive that lack sufficiently detailed discussion and analysis. The backpropagation analogy alone does not adequately justify the proposed conclusions.

  3. Lack of withholding ablation. Insight 2 attributes reduced overfitting partly to withholding reference answers, but no direct ablation establishes whether withholding itself produces this benefit.

  4. Missing budget controls. Without comparisons under matched computational budgets, fairness is difficult to assess. Also the gains cannot be clearly separated from the effects of additional rollouts, teacher feedback, and inference computation.

Questions for authors

Please see weakness.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.