acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Socratic Skill Learning: Interleaving Teaching and Practice for Transferable Agent Skills

Abstract

Agent Skills improve LLM agents by making task knowledge reusable across sessions. Learning transferable Skills requires evidence about a procedure and its conditions of use, which a successful task attempt can leave untested. We introduce Socratic Skill Learning (SSL), which interleaves expert teaching with Student practice. An Educator guides investigation while the Student remains the sole environment operator and Skill author, able to question, test, and adapt advice. To test reuse beyond the learning task, we construct SkillTransferBench, with 35 task families and 408 executable cases, pairing public variation specifications with held-out evaluation in fresh solver sessions. On the main 22-family, 155-case cohort, Fixed-Window SSL reaches 0.801 utility, versus 0.723 without a Skill, 0.761 for adapted Trace2Skill (trajectory distillation), and 0.751 for adapted SKILL-KD (contrastive distillation). Across three model pairs on shared families, interleaved guidance outperforms expert authoring and post-hoc teaching. Process analysis links guidance to Student writing and package revision; a case study shows the Student testing and refining a proposed procedure for later reuse. As demand for new lessons falls, the cost of fixed-window review grows. Issue-Guided SSL tracks unresolved questions across Skill revisions to select and focus review, reaching 0.805 utility with 61.7% fewer Educator tokens and 16.9% fewer total acquisition tokens than Fixed-Window SSL on the main cohort.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Large Language Model Agents, Agent Skills, Agent Learning, Learning from Experience, Interactive Teaching, Skill Acquisition

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_t5HoOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces Socratic Skill Learning (SSL), a framework for acquiring transferable agent skills through interleaved expert guidance and student practice. Unlike existing approaches that primarily distill execution trajectories or provide feedback after task completion, SSL allows an Educator to guide the Student during task execution, while the Student remains responsible for interacting with the environment and constructing the Skill. The authors propose two variants: Fixed-Window SSL, which provides expert feedback at regular intervals, and Issue-Guided SSL, which selectively invokes the Educator based on unresolved learning issues. The paper also introduces SkillTransferBench, a benchmark containing 35 task families and 408 executable cases to evaluate skill transfer. Experiments across three model pairs demonstrate improvements over several baselines. In particular, Issue-Guided SSL maintains comparable performance while substantially reducing Educator token consumption.

Critical strengths
  1. Learning transferable skills from agent execution experience is an important and practical problem. The paper investigates how external guidance can improve skill acquisition, which is relevant to the development of more capable and efficient LLM agents.

  2. The authors construct a benchmark with 35 task families and 408 executable cases and evaluate their methods across multiple model pairs. The experiments include comparisons with existing skill-learning methods, different teaching protocols, and analyses of token efficiency. The reported improvements are encouraging, particularly the reduction in Educator token consumption achieved by Issue-Guided SSL.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The writing and conceptual framing could be substantially improved. I found several parts of the paper unnecessarily difficult to follow, with abstract terminology that obscures relatively straightforward ideas. For example, the connection to Socratic learning seems somewhat overstated. The proposed approach mainly involves interleaving expert feedback with Student execution, while the two variants primarily differ in when expert feedback is triggered. It is unclear what makes this specifically a Socratic learning approach rather than a conventional interactive teacher–student framework. The paper does not clearly formalize Socratic questioning or establish its distinction from direct instruction or critique-based feedback.

  2. Insufficient ablation studies to identify the sources of improvement. While the overall experimental results are promising, it remains unclear which components are primarily responsible for the performance gains. For example, the improvement might come from receiving feedback during execution, additional opportunities for revision, or the stronger Educator model, rather than from the proposed Socratic learning mechanism itself. The existing comparisons do not fully isolate these factors. Similarly, Issue-Guided SSL changes both the review-triggering mechanism and the context provided to the Educator, making it difficult to determine which design choice contributes most to the efficiency improvement. More controlled ablations would strengthen the paper's methodological claims.

Questions for authors
  1. What specifically distinguishes SSL from conventional interactive teacher–student learning?
  2. How much of the improvement can be attributed to the timing of expert intervention? For example, how would SSL compare against a Student that performs additional self-refinement or verification under a comparable token budget?
  3. Which components of Issue-Guided SSL are responsible for its efficiency gains? In particular, could the authors separately evaluate issue-based review triggering, focused context selection, and the persistent learning-issue structure?
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer t5Ho

Thank you for asking us to clarify the teaching design and separate the sources of its benefits. Section and table numbers below refer to the revised manuscript.

Qwen results: 22 families, 155 held-out cases, three repeats unless specified. Utility is family-macro averaged; intervals are paired family-bootstrap 95% CIs.


W1 + Q1. What the Socratic design adds

In SSL, the Student examines the guidance itself, not just the task solution. The Educator looks for gaps in the Student’s understanding, including procedures that work on the anchor but may fail under variation. The Student is instructed to explain its understanding or disagreement, test when evidence would help, and decide what to retain. Its response informs later teaching; the Educator can also correct its own advice. “Socratic” refers to this reciprocal examination of reasoning through practice.

Table 4 shows why accepting an expert suggestion is not the end of learning. An Educator-suggested arithmetic search flagged multiple financial entries without locating the error. The Student inspected the output and replaced the search with financial consistency relations that isolated the faulty entry. It retained the revised procedure in the Skill, which a fresh solver used on an unseen cash-flow report (App. G.1).

The revision makes this process explicit: the introduction presents Socratic inquiry as inspiration, and §§4.1–4.2 describe the Student as the sole Skill author and show how its responses shape subsequent review.


Q2. What the comparisons establish about feedback during practice

Fixed-Window improves on Post-hoc with fewer acquisition tokens. The controls address three explanations for the gain:

Acquisition protocolUtility (0–100)Acquisition tokens (M)
Student-only75.753.81
Post-hoc Teaching74.778.50 est.
Fixed-Window SSL80.087.40 est.

Tokens: mean acquisition usage including anchor evaluation. “est.” = tokenizer-estimated; otherwise recorded (Apps. C.3, D.4).

  1. How guidance is organized matters. Both teaching protocols allow testing and revision, with the same models, three practice rounds, and anchor feedback. Fixed-Window gains 5.31 pp [2.34, 9.09] with 12.9% fewer tokens. Post-hoc’s lower performance therefore cannot be explained by having fewer tokens or no opportunity to revise. This compares the full review schedules: timing, frequency, and follow-up (§5.2, App. D.4).
  2. The gain extends beyond giving the Student practice and feedback. Student-only can already test and revise over the same rounds with the same anchor feedback; Fixed-Window adds 4.33 pp [1.40, 7.79]. This matches practice opportunities, not token use.
  3. The benefit does not require a stronger model. A Plus Educator guiding a Plus Student also gains 3.05 pp [0.03, 6.60] over Student-only (Table 2).

Interleaving turns a test result into input for the next intervention. In XLSX, a Student repair still produced zero values. The next review located the remaining faulty read, and the Student verified the corrected output. Guidance can thus redirect an investigation while the procedure is being developed.


Q3. Where Issue-Guided saves Educator tokens

Issue memory maintains the learning question; gates select further review. Simple Event retains revision/failure triggers, recent-work selection, models, three rounds, and Educator history. It substitutes chronological lessons for issues and removes issue-state gates.

Review policyUtility (0–100)Educator tokens (M)Total acquisition tokens (M)
Simple Event77.951.2597.405
Issue-Guided80.500.949 est.5.856 est.

A revision is assessed against the issue it should resolve. Its focus, criterion, and revision history persist. Evidence-backed resolution can skip review; contradictory feedback can reopen the issue. Together, these mechanisms improve utility by 2.55 pp [0.25, 4.94] while reducing Educator tokens by 24.7% and total tokens by 20.9%. Tracking learning progress thus outperforms reacting to changes alone (§5.4, App. F.2).

Against Fixed-Window, the design reduces both how often and how much the Educator reviews.

Review cost, 66 acquisitions eachFixed-WindowIssue-GuidedReduction
Reviews64732849.3%
Tokens/review incl. follow-ups (K, est.)261.5190.927.0%
  • When: unresolved issue transitions determine whether another review is needed.
  • What: review focuses on the active issue and recent work; further teaching awaits another transition instead of an immediate follow-up.

Fewer reviews and less work per review together save 63.0% of Educator tokens (App. F.1).

Thank you again for your thoughtful review. As the discussion period draws to a close, we wanted to ask whether our response addressed your concerns. If any questions remain, we’d be happy to discuss them further.

Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments. I appreciate the authors' efforts, particularly the new Student-only and Simple Event comparisons, which provide useful evidence for the effectiveness of the proposed framework. However, my main concerns remain:

  • I am still not convinced that the proposed approach is meaningfully distinguished from conventional interactive teacher–student feedback. The explanation and case study help clarify the motivation, but do not establish what is specifically Socratic about the method.

  • While the additional experiments strengthen the empirical results, they still do not fully isolate the contributions of the key mechanisms. In particular, the benefits of feedback timing remain confounded with interaction frequency and structure, while the Issue-Guided comparison changes multiple components simultaneously.

Therefore, I will maintain my original score.

Reviewer_TJ1eOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces Socratic Skill Learning (SSL), a framework in which a stronger Educator guides a Student during skill acquisition, while the Student remains responsible for environment interaction, verification, and skill authoring. The authors propose two variants: Fixed-Window SSL, which provides feedback at regular tool-call intervals, and Issue-Guided SSL, which tracks unresolved learning issues to selectively trigger reviews. The paper also introduces SkillTransferBench, consisting of 35 task families and 408 executable cases, where skills are acquired from a single anchor task and evaluated on held-out variants using fresh solver sessions. On the main Qwen evaluation cohort, Fixed-Window SSL improves transfer utility from 0.723 without skills to 0.801, outperforming Expert Authoring, Post-hoc Teaching, and adapted skill induction baselines. Issue-Guided SSL achieves comparable utility while reducing Educator token consumption by 61.7%.

Critical strengths

1. Transfer gains under a controlled evaluation protocol.

Frozen Skills are evaluated by fresh solvers on held-out family members, with private tests kept outside agent workspaces (Sec. 3, App. B). This helps distinguish held-out Skill reuse from repeated execution of the acquisition task. Under this protocol, Fixed-Window SSL improves over No Skill by 7.75 pp on the Qwen main cohort and outperforms adapted Trace2Skill and SKILL-KD by 3.99 pp (95% paired family-bootstrap CI [1.45, 6.49]) and 4.99 pp ([1.79, 8.48]), respectively (Sec. 5.1, App. D). The comparison with Expert Authoring (0.728 vs. 0.801) also shows a substantial difference between acquisition protocols, although it does not isolate the effect of Student authorship.

2. Reduced external supervision cost through selective review.

The paper identifies an inefficiency in fixed-interval review: the share of regular reviews producing a lesson falls from 73.0% to 16.1% across rounds, while tokens per review increase 5.3-fold (Fig. 4, Sec. 5.3). Issue-Guided SSL reduces Educator tokens by 61.7% on the Qwen main cohort while maintaining comparable utility (0.805 vs. 0.801). Similar reductions in Educator tokens are observed for DeepSeek and Kimi (63.8% and 77.4%), suggesting that selective review can substantially reduce external supervision overhead across different model pairs.

Critical weaknesses

1. It is unclear what actually drives the transfer gains.

The paper motivates SSL by arguing that solving one task does not guarantee that the learned procedure will transfer to other tasks. However, this mixes the problem of skill generalization with a particular way of addressing it. Socratic feedback may help, but it does not necessarily require a separate, stronger Teacher. A Student could also question its own assumptions, test procedures, and iteratively refine its Skills.

In the proposed setup, the Teacher cannot interact with the environment or access held-out cases (App. C.1–C.2). Both models have access to the public family specification, which already describes the variations that the Skill should handle (Table 6). The stronger Teacher may provide better prior knowledge or reasoning, but it is unclear how much this contributes beyond the Student's own exploration and refinement.

Several factors are not separated in the experiments: (i) the family specification provided during acquisition, (ii) the stronger Teacher model, without a same-model feedback control, and (iii) Student-owned skill authoring and iterative refinement. In particular, there is no Student-only baseline using the same three-round acquisition and verification process, or a setup where the Student model provides Socratic feedback to itself. The comparison with Expert Authoring also changes both who writes the Skill and how feedback is delivered.

Without these ablations, the results show that the overall SSL pipeline improves transfer, but do not clearly explain whether the gains come from Socratic interaction, stronger-model knowledge, the provided task specifications, or Student-side refinement.

2. The evaluation is limited, and some baseline comparisons are difficult to interpret.

All experiments are conducted on the authors' own benchmark, with the main cohort restricted to 22 of the 35 families based on No-Skill screening. Existing benchmarks such as SkillLearnBench already evaluate skill learning and transfer, including a Teacher Feedback method discussed in the paper (Table 4), but SSL is not evaluated there. This makes it difficult to assess how well the findings extend beyond the proposed benchmark.

The baseline comparisons are not fully controlled. For example, SKILL-KD stops updating its Skills after successfully solving the anchor, while SSL continues refining them even after success (App. C.3.1, E.3). This may put SKILL-KD at a disadvantage when evaluating transfer to unseen tasks. Fixed-Window SSL and Post-hoc Teaching also differ in how frequently feedback is provided, rather than just when it is provided. In addition, Fixed-Window SSL uses more acquisition tokens than Expert Authoring (6.89M vs. 4.95M), making the performance differences harder to attribute to the proposed method alone.

The cross-model results are also less conclusive than the main Qwen experiments. DeepSeek and Kimi are evaluated on only 10 families with one repeat. While SSL achieves higher average scores than Expert Authoring across all three model pairs, the reported confidence intervals include zero (Table 13). Therefore, the evidence for consistent improvements across different models is still limited.

Questions for authors

1. Student-only learning and the role of the Educator. How does SSL compare with (a) the Student learning alone under the same three-round acquisition and anchor-feedback setup, and (b) the Student model acting as its own Educator? Beyond the case studies and feedback statistics, can the authors provide a qualitative analysis of what the stronger Educator contributes to the final Skills, particularly which improvements could not be achieved through Student self-refinement? These comparisons would help clarify whether the gains come from Socratic interaction, stronger-model knowledge, or additional refinement.

2. Teacher–Student compatibility. Would Teacher-authored Skills perform better when consumed by the Teacher itself rather than by the weaker Student? This would help distinguish whether Expert Authoring performs poorly because the generated Skills are ineffective or because they do not transfer well to the downstream Student.

3. Role of the family specification. How much does the public family specification contribute to transfer performance? Since it already describes the variation axes of held-out cases (Table 6), does SSL still outperform other acquisition methods when the specification is removed for all methods?

4. Baseline setup and fairness. Do adapted Trace2Skill and SKILL-KD receive the same family specification, and what models and acquisition budgets do they use? Given that SKILL-KD does not update its rules after anchor success (App. C.3.1), how would it perform if allowed to continue refining, as SSL does?

5. Existing benchmarks and generalization. What evaluation capability does SkillTransferBench provide beyond existing benchmarks such as SkillLearnBench? Can the authors evaluate SSL on SkillLearnBench, including its Teacher Feedback baseline, to assess whether the improvements extend beyond the proposed benchmark?

6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer TJ1e (1/2)

Thank you for asking us to clarify the sources of transfer gains and test their generality. Section and table numbers below refer to the revised manuscript.

Qwen results: 22 families, 155 held-out cases, three repeats unless specified. Utility is family-macro averaged; intervals are paired family-bootstrap 95% CIs.


W1 + Q1. Guidance with the same model and with a stronger Educator

A stronger Educator is not required for the transfer gain. The new controls use the same Plus Student and solver, specification, Student authorship, three practice rounds, and anchor feedback. Plus and Max Educators work in separate sessions with the same review schedule (§5.2, Table 2).

Learning conditionUtility (0–100)Gain over Student-only (95% CI, pp)
Student-only75.75—
Fixed-Window, Plus Educator78.80+3.05 [0.03, 6.60]
Fixed-Window, Max Educator80.08+4.33 [1.40, 7.79]

Adding review helps even with model capability held fixed. The Plus control establishes this directly. Upgrading the reviewer to Max gives a further mean gain of 1.28 pp [−0.59, 3.11], so stronger-model knowledge is not the prerequisite for the observed benefit.

External review can expose a defect that successful anchor execution bypasses. In SQLite, Max identified a flaw in a packaged recovery routine even though the anchor had already been solved through another code path. The Student tested the repair and retained it in the Skill. Fixed-input replay recovered eight data rows instead of seven. The contribution here was directing verification toward the reusable routine, beyond checking whether the current task succeeded.


Q2. Whether Expert Authoring depends on who uses the Skill

Expert Authoring already receives feedback from its intended Student. Fresh Plus solvers test its Skill on the anchor, allowing the expert to revise for that user (App. C.3). Fixed-Window still gains 7.29 pp [3.62, 11.44] when Plus evaluates both methods on identical held-out cases.

Teacher-as-solver evaluation has not been run. For the target Student, the comparison favors developing the Skill through its own practice over having an expert author it using Student feedback.


Q3. What the family specification supplies

SSL also achieves higher mean transfer performance without our family variation specifications. On SkillLearnBench, the adapter supplies a seed-task scope notice but no additional variation axes. SSL reaches 64.72% task-group mean pass rate versus 51.76% for Teacher Feedback (Q5; App. D.5, Table 17). This is an external test without our specifications, rather than a within-SkillTransferBench removal experiment.

The specification states what must generalize, not how to solve it. All methods receive it (Table 7, App. C.3), so access to this information is shared. For example, XLSX requires sorting by evaluated values without supplying a solution for uncached formulas. Student tests exposed zero outputs; further review located the faulty read, and the Student verified and retained the repair.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer TJ1e (2/2)

W2. Added controls and clarified cross-model conclusions

  1. The gain persists with an independent No-Skill baseline. The 22-family main cohort selects from 35 families using at least five verified held-out cases and two non-perfect screening outcomes (§3.2). In an additional comparison against three Plus No-Skill repeats independent of screening, Fixed-Window gains 8.38 pp [4.17, 13.32]. Q5 separately tests transfer on SkillLearnBench, including Teacher Feedback.

  2. Costs are now aligned to the runs behind the reported scores. The earlier 6.89M came from an older run aggregate; reconstruction for the scored runs gives 7.40M (App. C.3). Fixed-Window uses more tokens than Expert Authoring and the adapted external baselines, so those comparisons are not token-matched (Table 9). Q1 tests guidance under matched practice and anchor feedback.

  3. More acquisition compute does not ensure better transfer. Against Post-hoc, Fixed-Window gains 5.31 pp [2.34, 9.09] with 12.9% fewer tokens. Both allow revision; §5.2 compares their full schedules, with timing, frequency, and follow-up specified in App. D.4. Q4 addresses SKILL-KD’s stop rule.

  4. Cross-model claims now describe the observed mean ordering. On the shared 10 families, Fixed-Window has higher mean utility than Expert Authoring for all three model pairs. Their paired intervals include zero (Table 14); DeepSeek and Kimi have one repeat each. The abstract, §5.2, and conclusion now describe cross-model results as higher mean utility.


Q4. Baseline inputs, budgets, and the SKILL-KD stop rule

Both adapted baselines receive the same specification and use Plus for held-out evaluation. Their acquisition settings and actual usage are:

MethodAcquisition settingsMean acquisition tokens
Trace2SkillThree Plus rollouts; Max analyzes successes/failures and evolves the Skill1.26M tokenizer-estimated
SKILL-KDPlus Student, Max Teacher/critic; three visits, up to three adaptive rounds per visit1.94M recorded

We preserved SKILL-KD’s released update rules for the method comparison. Initial success ends a visit; after failure, candidate edits are accepted only following a fully successful Student rerun, with failed candidates rolled back (App. C.3.1). We have not evaluated a version that continues after success.

Continued autonomous refinement is tested by Student-only. It has the same three practice rounds and anchor feedback as SSL, and Fixed-Window still gains 4.33 pp [1.40, 7.79] (Q1).

Table 9: means over 66 acquisitions, including anchor evaluation and excluding held-out inference. Trace2Skill combines recorded rollouts with estimated analysis/evolution usage (App. C.3).


Q5. What SkillTransferBench adds and where the evidence applies

SSL achieves higher mean transfer performance on SkillLearnBench as well. We evaluated 18 task groups and 73 scored held-out cases, with three repeats per method. Both teaching methods use Qwen3.7-Plus as Student/solver and Qwen3.7-Max as Educator.

MethodTask-group mean pass rate
No Skill28.43%
Teacher Feedback51.76%
Fixed-Window SSL64.72%

Against Teacher Feedback with the same model pair, SSL gains 12.96 pp; against No Skill, it gains 36.30 pp. This tests the learning approach beyond our family construction, including against the existing benchmark’s teaching baseline (App. D.5, Table 17).

SkillTransferBench makes the intended scope of reuse explicit. Each family declares invariants and permitted changes before learning (Table 7). For example, database schemas and conditions vary while the recovery objective stays fixed. Held-out evaluation then tests whether the learned procedure handles those changes.

Thank you for the detailed response and substantial new experiments. The Student-only and Plus-Educator controls address W1/Q1, the SkillLearnBench results address W2/Q5, and the clarified baseline setup, independent No-Skill comparison, and revised cross-model claims are also helpful.

Remaining Concerns:

  • Specification contribution (W1, Q3). There is still no ablation of the family specification on the authors' own benchmark. The SkillLearnBench experiment provides useful indirect evidence, but does not isolate the specification's contribution on SkillTransferBench.
  • Budget matching (W2, Q4). With the corrected cost of 7.40M tokens per run, Fixed-Window SSL uses about 50% more tokens than Expert Authoring and roughly 4–6 times as many as SKILL-KD and Trace2Skill. These comparisons remain unmatched in acquisition budget. The Plus-Educator condition also introduces additional compute relative to Student-only.

New Concerns from the Rebuttal:

The paper frames SSL as Socratic teaching in which the Educator supplies external expertise, but the new results weaken the motivation for a stronger Educator: replacing Plus with Max adds only 1.28 pp (95% CI [-0.59, 3.11]). The results point more toward the benefit of adding a reviewer than toward stronger external expertise. Adding a review or critique step is already well established, both in self-critique methods such as Self-Refine [1] and Reflexion [2] and in Skill learning (e.g., HASP and SkillLearnBench's Teacher Feedback, both discussed in the paper). Moreover, the same-model reviewer's gain over Student-only is modest (+3.05 pp, CI lower bound 0.03) and not compute-matched.

The source of this gain is also not well isolated. Review covers both solving the anchor task and authoring the Skill, but there is no ablation separating task-level from Skill-level feedback. Although the paper categorizes feedback types, it remains unclear whether the transfer gains come mainly from better task debugging or guidance specifically aimed at Skill generalization. Without this distinction or a comparison with non-Socratic critique (e.g., direct feedback without dialogue), the specific contribution of Socratic interaction remains unclear.

Overall Assessment:

The experiments are thorough, the rebuttal makes the empirical results more convincing, and the paper provides useful benchmark and efficiency results. However, for the reasons above, the core idea remains relatively incremental. I therefore maintain my rating as a borderline paper, and I would not oppose acceptance if the other reviewers and the AC find the empirical contribution sufficient.

References

[1] Madaan et al., Self-Refine: Iterative Refinement with Self-Feedback, NeurIPS 2023. https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17651

[2] Shinn et al., Reflexion: Language Agents with Verbal Reinforcement Learning, NeurIPS 2023. https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.11366

Reviewer_N4BMOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents Socratic Skill Learning (SSL), where an expert provides guidance during student practice to help acquire transferable agent skills. The authors also introduce SkillTransferBench and an issue-guided review mechanism to reduce supervision costs. The results are encouraging, showing improvements over existing skill-learning methods and substantial savings in Educator tokens.

Critical strengths

The paper tackles an important problem: learning skills that generalize beyond individual task executions.

The benchmark is carefully constructed, and the evaluation covers multiple domains, baselines, and model pairs.

Critical weaknesses

Missing Student-only baseline. This is my main concern. The Student already performs exploration, testing, and skill refinement, so it is unclear how much additional benefit comes from the Educator. A baseline with the same acquisition rounds and verification feedback, but without expert guidance, would help clarify this.

Limited ablation of Issue-Guided SSL. Several components change together, including review scheduling, issue tracking, and context selection. I wonder whether simpler strategies, such as triggering reviews after skill revisions, could achieve similar savings without maintaining an issue tree.

The Socratic learning claim needs stronger evidence. The process analysis shows that teaching is associated with more skill revisions, but this does not necessarily imply that the Student critically evaluates or improves upon expert advice. It would be interesting to see how often advice is tested, corrected, or rejected, and whether these behaviors actually improve transfer.

Transfer is evaluated within predefined task families. This is a reasonable setting, but the conclusions about generalizable skills should be interpreted within this scope.

Questions for authors

How does SSL perform against autonomous Student skill learning under comparable practice and feedback budgets?

How much of Issue-Guided SSL's efficiency gain comes from issue tracking rather than simply reducing review frequency or context size?

Can the authors provide more direct evidence that the Student's critical engagement with expert advice improves transfer?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer N4BM

Thank you for identifying the missing control and asking for evidence that the Student tests advice before passing it on. Section and table numbers below refer to the revised manuscript.

Qwen results: 22 families, 155 held-out cases, three repeats unless specified. Utility is family-macro averaged; intervals are paired family-bootstrap 95% CIs.


W1 + Q1. What the Educator adds under matched practice

Guidance adds value beyond autonomous practice and anchor feedback. Student-only already explores, tests, and writes its own Skill. All conditions use the same Plus Student and solver, public specification, three practice rounds, and independent anchor feedback.

Learning conditionUtility (0–100)Gain over Student-only (95% CI, pp)
Student-only75.75—
Fixed-Window, Plus Educator78.80+3.05 [0.03, 6.60]
Fixed-Window, Max Educator80.08+4.33 [1.40, 7.79]

The gain does not require knowledge from a stronger model. Plus–Plus improves the resulting Skill by assigning the same model a separate review role (§5.2, Table 2).

Solving the anchor is not the same as developing a transferable procedure. In the 19 families where both Student-only and Max-guided Fixed-Window reached perfect round-2 anchor scores in every repeat, Fixed-Window still led by 5.44 pp on held-out tasks [2.48, 9.13] (App. D.4). The advantage therefore persists beyond differences in anchor success: guidance helps the Student develop a Skill that works on new instances, not just complete its practice task.


W2 + Q2. What a simpler review policy would need to capture

Detecting a revision and deciding what still needs teaching are different jobs. Simple Event retains the revision/failure triggers, recent-work selection, practice setup, and Educator history. It replaces structured issues with chronological lessons and removes issue-state gates.

Review policyUtility (0–100)Educator tokens (M)Total acquisition tokens (M)
Fixed-Window (g=20)77.591.2566.613
Simple Event77.951.2597.405
Issue-Guided80.500.949 est.5.856 est.

Tokens: mean acquisition usage including anchor evaluation. “est.” = tokenizer-estimated; otherwise recorded (Apps. C.3, D.4).

Issue memory connects each revision to the concern it is meant to resolve. The retained focus and criterion give the next review a specific question to assess. Gates let an evidence-backed resolution proceed without another review, while contradictory feedback can reopen the issue. Against Simple Event, this joint design gains 2.55 pp [0.25, 4.94] with 24.7% fewer Educator tokens and 20.9% fewer total tokens (§5.4, App. F.2). The gain is therefore not bought by adding more review expenditure.

Reducing frequency alone also falls short. Against review every 20 tool calls, Issue-Guided gains 2.91 pp with 11.4% fewer acquisition tokens (Fig. 5, App. F.1). Both controls favor tracking unresolved learning needs over reviewing every revision or simply reviewing less often.


W3 + Q3. Evidence that tested advice reaches fresh solvers

Student tests can change the advice and the procedure passed to a fresh solver. We audited the main-cohort trajectories:

  • Testing: 122 of 266 Fixed-Window lesson windows contained tests aimed at the guidance.
  • Correcting advice: we verified three cases across three families where Student tests prompted the Educator to revise or withdraw advice.
  • Reuse: in 85 of those 122 tested windows, a fresh solver later executed a procedure the Student had added or revised.

Flask shows what actually transfers: reject Boolean values in numeric fields. After guidance, the Student tested Boolean account IDs and amounts, exposing a handler that accepted them and wrote transactions. Replay on identical inputs confirmed that the repair rejected them without writes while preserving valid transfers. The Student retained the rule in its Skill; a fresh solver applied and tested it on shopping-cart prices and quantities. The retained knowledge is an input-validation rule that applies beyond the original account-transfer task. Appendix E.2 now includes these window counts and the Flask example.

A SQLite replay likewise recovered eight data rows after repair versus seven before, using the same database and decoder. These checks establish specific improvements to the procedures; Q1’s Student-only control measures the overall transfer gain from guidance, +4.33 pp under matched practice and anchor feedback.


W4. What transfer within a family tests

Our transfer claim concerns unseen tasks within a specified family. Sections 3.1 and 4.1 define the declared variations and evaluate the frozen Skill in fresh solver sessions. The question is whether a procedure learned on the anchor remains useful when other instances vary within that scope.

Reviewer_N4BMOpenReview ↗

Reply from reviewer

Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments.

The new Student-only baseline addresses my main concern and provides convincing evidence of the Educator's added value. The Simple Event comparison also strengthens the justification for Issue-Guided SSL.

I appreciate the additional trajectory analysis and examples of the Student testing and refining advice. While the causal contribution of these behaviors to transfer remains less clear, the new evidence helps support the proposed mechanism.

Overall, the rebuttal has addressed my concerns and improved my assessment of the paper. I am inclined to maintain my current positive score.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.