- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses compact feed-forward 3D Gaussian Splatting from streaming, unposed image sequences. It argues that existing online methods predict dense Gaussians for every frame and then compress them, so the number of Gaussians keeps growing with the number of views. The proposed PersistSplat processes the stream in overlapping sliding windows with a frozen AnySplat backbone. The geometry of each window is aligned to a global coordinate system through Sim(3) alignment and a learned correction, and its features are corrected using the existing Gaussians as reference. Each Gaussian maintains a fixed anchor feature and a bounded set of historical observations. For regions of an incoming view already covered by existing Gaussians, the new observations are stored and used to refine those Gaussians, while new Gaussians are generated only for uncovered regions. The authors report that the method achieves rendering quality comparable to AnySplat with fewer Gaussians, and outperforms existing online methods on longer input sequences.
Critical strengths
-
The design of adding new Gaussians only in regions not covered by previous observations is reasonable for streaming inputs. Under this design, regions that have already been reconstructed are refined rather than repeatedly regenerated, so the representation grows only with newly observed content instead of with every incoming frame.
-
The authors conduct extensive experiments. They compare against a range of offline and online feed-forward methods on two datasets, under different numbers of input views and sequence lengths, and provide numerous qualitative comparisons.
Critical weaknesses
-
Reconstruction from streaming inputs is a meaningful problem, but the reviewer finds that the setting adopted in this paper does not reflect the conditions under which streaming is actually needed, such as a number of views beyond the capacity of offline methods, real-time requirements or limited memory. The paper does not identify which of these it targets, leaving it unclear what problem the method actually aims to solve. The experimental setting further reflects this ambiguity: at most 150 views at 224×224 on small static scenes, which offline methods such as AnySplat can already handle, whereas the settings where streaming becomes necessary, such as long sequences of large-scale scenes like the kilometer-scale KITTI and Waymo sequences used in VGGT-Long [1], or dynamic scenes, are not covered.
-
The reviewer considers the novelty of the method to be limited, as its main components closely follow existing designs. Adding new Gaussians only where the current map does not yet cover the scene, determined by rendered coverage and depth consistency, has been explored in online Gaussian reconstruction such as SplaTAM [2]; this paper mainly brings this strategy into a feed-forward setting. Maintaining a persistent memory associated with 3D locations and updating it with new observations has been explored in streaming reconstruction such as Point3R [3], and projecting existing Gaussians into the incoming view to decide how they are updated is similar to LongSplat [4]. The global geometry alignment follows the overlapping-chunk Sim(3) alignment in VGGT-Long [1], adding only a learned residual correction. The paper neither discusses these relationships nor compares with the corresponding designs, so the specific contribution beyond combining them remains unclear.
-
The reviewer has concerns about the experimental design and the fairness of the comparisons. Except for AnySplat, the backbone of the proposed method, the baselines perform well below the results reported in their original papers, and some even rank differently relative to AnySplat. The reported Gaussian counts of some baselines are also inconsistent with the stated 224×224 resolution. In addition, offline methods are only compared with short inputs, where offline processing is already feasible, and are excluded from the long-sequence comparison, which also omits LongSplat [4]. Comparisons with AnySplat at a matched number of Gaussians and on runtime and memory are also missing. Several claims, such as the convergence of the Gaussian count and the stable performance over long sequences, are not supported by the reported results.
-
The reviewer finds that the paper is not clearly written, and many essential details are missing. In the method section, the architectures of the learned modules, including the geometry correction, the feature correction and the Gaussian head, are not described, nor is it stated which components are trained and which are inherited from the frozen backbone. The training setup is also unclear, such as which views are rendered for supervision, how many windows are unrolled during training and how many training steps are used. The experimental section has similar problems. It does not describe how the input views are sampled, which frames are used as target views, how target poses are obtained for pose-free methods, or under what settings the baselines are run. As a result, the method and results cannot be reproduced or properly assessed from the paper. The paper also contains numerous grammatical errors and typos.
[1] K. Deng, Z. Ti, J. Xu, J. Yang, and J. Xie. VGGT-Long: Chunk it, Loop it, Align it — Pushing VGGT's Limits on Kilometer-scale Long RGB Sequences. ICRA, 2026.
[2] N. Keetha, J. Karhade, K. M. Jatavallabhula, G. Yang, S. Scherer, D. Ramanan, and J. Luiten. SplaTAM: Splat, Track & Map 3D Gaussians for Dense RGB-D SLAM. CVPR, 2024.
[3] Y. Wu, W. Zheng, J. Zhou, and J. Lu. Point3R: Streaming 3D Reconstruction with Explicit Spatial Pointer Memory. arXiv:2507.02863, 2025.
[4] G. Huang, R. Wang, X. Gao, C. Sun, Y. Wu, S. Gao, and Y. Jia. LongSplat: Online Generalizable 3D Gaussian Splatting from Long Sequence Images. AAAI, 2026.
Questions for authors
-
Were the baselines evaluated with their official checkpoints or retrained, and at which resolution was each of them run? Could the authors explain why their results are substantially lower than those reported in the original papers?
-
Could the authors provide evidence that local geometric distortions remain after Sim(3) alignment, for example residual maps on overlapping views before and after the learned correction, or pose errors such as ATE?
-
Could the authors evaluate the method in scenarios that genuinely require streaming input, rather than on RE10K and DL3DV, for example continuously captured driving sequences such as the KITTI and Waymo sequences used in VGGT-Long [1]? How do the Gaussian count, rendering quality, runtime and memory behave as frames keep arriving in such settings?
-
The method relies heavily on the frozen AnySplat backbone for features, pointmaps and poses. Can the proposed framework be applied to newer backbones with different architectures and output formats, and do its benefits persist with a stronger backbone? If the gains are tied to AnySplat, the significance of the contribution would be limited.
[1] K. Deng, Z. Ti, J. Xu, J. Yang, and J. Xie. VGGT-Long: Chunk it, Loop it, Align it — Pushing VGGT's Limits on Kilometer-scale Long RGB Sequences. ICRA, 2026.