- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This work couples FEM and PINN with a Robin-Neumann interface exchange, and argues that the Robin weight control only whether and how fast the exchange converges, but not where it converges. The experiments check this on fixed random-feature solvers and on retrained PINNs. The paper also builds high frequency interface problems where all runs pass the stopping test with different errors, and track the coupled error by frequency.
Critical strengths
- The writing is technically sound, and all the claims are well supported by formal proofs and experiments.
- It compares against classical inexact solvers (CG), so it is fair to present inexactness in neural solvers.
- The setup for experiments are measurable: with manufactured solutions and exact references.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty is limited. The main results follows from standard inexact fixed-point theory: no Robin weight can move the fixed point.
- The "learning-specific" claim is overstated, since a coarse-mesh FEM solver can also settles on a wrong solution.
- Although the paper can diagnoses failures in accuracy with manufactured solution or exact references, in real applications there is no such so there is no validated way to detect it.
- For experiments, no retrained PINN runs on high-frequency problems, and the probes in section 4.3 are not linked to any coupled error.
Questions for authors
- In section 4.3, the probes are Dirichlet problems, but in the coupling the PINN solvers a Neumann problem. So how can a network trained with Neumann condition solves a Dirichlet problem?
- How does the learned solver’s error floor differ from a coarse-mesh FEM subsolver?
- Do Dirichlet-probe responses predict the Neumann-mode sensitivity L of the trained PINN?
Response to Reviewer cfDF
Thank you. Your coarse-FEM point was correct and improved the paper.
1. Novelty. We agree the theorem specializes classical inexact-solve analysis (F48x, point 1).
2. Coarse FEM (W2, Q2). The structure is identical: a coarse-mesh Neumann solver gives an α-free limit equal to Eq. (7) (≤7×10⁻⁸) and settles at up to 20% error. The difference is controllability: its trace bias falls about 4× when the mesh size is halved (24.3 → 5.8% at mode 8) and the global error returns to the reference on the reference mesh (20.4 → 7.3 → 3.56%, reference 3.57%), whereas a learned solver has no knob with a known rate: the restart policy alone changes Adam's error 3–4×, and training budget helps with no predictable rate. The claim is reworded accordingly.
3. Detection without a reference (W3). The held-out residual score needs no reference: on 214 settled runs it flags 130/132 inaccurate ones (33 false alarms in 82). We also show what it cannot see, a wrong interface flux (obDj, point 4).
4. Retrained PINNs at high frequency (W4). 120 runs: at mode 8 every run passes the update test at 100% trace error (77.7% global vs 3.57% FEM) for every α, flagged by the loss and the score; at mode 4 the runs never settle and their error grows with α; mode 1 and mode 4 with contrast 10 stay within 2.4× and 1.4× of FEM.
5. Probes (Q1, Q3). Each probe trains its own network per mode, so no network solves both problems. The Dirichlet responses predict the Neumann sensitivity only qualitatively (≈4× miss); the full measured L predicts the coupled limit exactly for fixed solvers.