- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work aims to address the problem of missing modality information in electronic health record (EHR) tasks. The authors propose MEDUSA, a graph-conditioned generative framework for handling missing modalities in multimodal EHR data. MEDUSA combines patient similarity graphs with generative models and employs an EM-inspired alternating optimization procedure. Experiments are conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical strengths
- The research topic of addressing missing modalities in EHR data is practically relevant and has received considerable attention.
- Overall, this work is easy-to-follow.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty of this work appears limited and remains unclear. The proposed method combines patient similarity graphs and generative models to address missing modalities in EHR data. However, both techniques have been widely studied in related domains. The unique insights offered by this combination for the target task appear limited. The authors should clarify the fundamental differences between MEDUSA and existing approaches and highlight its novel contributions.
- The motivation should be enhanced. This works mainly combines the patient graphs and generative modeling to handle the missing modality issues in EHR. However, the motivation behind this combination is limited and unclear. The distinct advantages of this technical design are missing. The authors should clarify why these two components are complementary and explain how their integration addresses the limitations of existing methods more effectively than alternative approaches.
- The discussion for limitations of current methods should be enhanced. In current version, the discussion is unclear and lack strong supports. In line 42-43, the authors simply mentioned that "they primarily rely on graph aggregation, fusion, or representation alignment, and therefore do not explicitly model a distribution over the missing modality representations." However, the exact limitations for these methods are not clearly explained. Moreover, the rationale for explicitly modeling a distribution over missing modality representations remains unclear. The authors should provide a more rigorous analysis of the limitations of existing approaches and explain the unique advantages of distribution modeling in addressing missing modalities.
- The technical rationales should be enhanced. The authors did not clearly discuss their motivation for technical designs. For example, why are generative models suitable for addressing missing modalities in EHR data, and what advantages do they offer over alternative approaches? Furthermore, why is patient relational structure incorporated into the generative models, and what unique benefits does this integration provide? The authors should provide a clearer justification for these design choices and explain how each component contributes to the overall effectiveness of MEDUSA.
- The performance improvements achieved by MEDUSA over existing baselines appear limited and inconsistent. For example, Table 1 shows that MEDUSA achieves only marginal improvements over the strongest baselines in some settings, including an improvement of just 0.03 in AUROC for eICU-Readmission. More importantly, MEDUSA is substantially outperformed by baseline methods on eICU-Mortality. These results raise concerns about the effectiveness and robustness of the proposed method. In addition, statistical significance tests are missing, making it difficult to determine whether the observed improvements are statistically meaningful.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the Weakness seciton.