- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a human motion editing framework based on Structured Motion Descriptions (SMD). An LLM edits the joint-level descriptions according to natural language instructions, and a flow-matching model reconstructs the edited motion. The authors further use supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and GRPO to improve editing accuracy. Experiments on MotionFix show improvements over several existing motion-editing methods. However, the methodological novelty over existing structured motion-editing approaches remains unclear, and the current experiments do not fully establish the necessity of the proposed design.
Critical strengths
1.The paper addresses an important problem in motion editing: modifying the requested parts while preserving the rest of the motion. 2.SMD provides an interpretable representation of joint-level changes and their temporal locations. 3.The method achieves competitive results on MotionFix and includes experiments on motion preservation and reconstruction accuracy.
Critical weaknesses
1.Limited methodological novelty. CoMo already explores LLM-based editing of structured pose codes, while Iterative Motion Editing with Natural Language uses structured editing programs to modify motions. The paper should clarify what new capability is provided by SMD-based editing beyond these approaches. 2.Insufficient comparison with related methods. Although the paper discusses related work, it does not directly compare with CoMo or Iterative Motion Editing with Natural Language. A more detailed comparison would help establish the contribution of the proposed framework. 3.Preservation after decoding is not fully established. Unchanged SMD entries do not necessarily guarantee unchanged joint trajectories after flow-matching decoding. The reported mean leakage of 2.99° in the single-joint perturbation experiment also suggests that changes may affect other joints.
Questions for authors
1.What is the main technical difference between the proposed method and CoMo or Iterative Motion Editing with Natural Language? 2.Can the authors provide a direct comparison with these structured motion-editing approaches, or a more systematic analysis if direct evaluation is not feasible? 3.How well does the flow-matching decoder preserve unedited joint trajectories and temporal intervals? 4.How much of the performance gain comes from GRPO rather than SMD or SFT? 5.Does the implementation of Preservation Error use absolute angular differences or signed differences?