acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Can Speech Foundation Models Represent Meaning Through Prosody? Evaluating Production and Perception

Abstract

Modern speech foundation models can process and generate fluent speech, but spoken meaning is not determined by words alone. We ask whether these models can use prosody to convey and recover meaning when lexical content is held constant. Using syntactically ambiguous sentences whose interpretations can be disambiguated by prosodic phrasing, we evaluate the same communicative contrasts bidirectionally. In perception, speech-capable models infer intended interpretations from human productions; in production, models generate the same sentences for specified interpretations, and target-blind human listeners report the meanings they recover. Human listeners recover intended meanings reliably, whereas current speech models perform substantially worse and exhibit strong interpretation and response-position biases. Diagnostic analyses reveal distinct failure modes: models may respond to prosodic variation without reliably grounding their analyses in the acoustic signal, recover informative acoustic cues without mapping them consistently to linguistic structure, or verbalize appropriate prosodic knowledge without using it functionally. In production, measurable acoustic differentiation and naturalness likewise do not guarantee successful communication, while realizations more aligned with human phrasing tend to support better meaning recovery. Together, these results show that representing prosody requires more than preserving acoustic information or producing prosodic variation: acoustic realization, prosodic organization, linguistic structure, and communicative meaning must be functionally aligned.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
speech foundation models, prosody, communicative meaning, speech generation, speech understanding, human evaluation, multimodal evaluation, speech representation learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_oJ8sOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper evaluates prosody-dependent meaning transmission and recovery using five syntactically ambiguous English sentences with fixed lexical content. Models interpret human recordings in perception, while target-blind listeners interpret model-generated speech in production. Acoustic, behavioral, and rationale analyses, together with answer-order reversal, characterize model performance and response biases. The results motivate evaluating acoustic discriminability and naturalness separately from successful meaning transmission.

Critical strengths
  1. Holding lexical content fixed enables controlled evaluation of both perception and production. Target-blind human interpretation directly tests the communicative function of prosody.
  2. Acoustic discriminability, alignment with human timing patterns, naturalness, and meaning recovery are measured separately. This distinguishes detectable acoustic changes from changes that listeners can interpret meaningfully.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The evaluation uses only five English sentences. While these provide controlled contrasts, it is unclear whether they sufficiently support broader conclusions about model-level prosodic competence beyond these particular stimuli.
  2. Section 3.2 does not specify the actual production inputs, leaving unclear whether systems receive meaning descriptions, explicit boundary instructions, or example speech. These conditions test different combinations of interpretation and prosodic control. The knife prompt mismatch in Table 2 also requires clarification: does it affect only human–model alignment, or also the correspondence between generation targets and evaluation labels? The latter could affect meaning-recovery accuracy independently of model capability.
  3. A low pause–report correlation does not rule out reliance on duration or F0. Describing Grok’s correlation of 0.025 as “almost no acoustic grounding” therefore appears too broad. The diagnosis should be restricted to pause–report alignment, as for OpenAI in Table 4, or supported by evidence covering other cues. Narrowing the claim may resolve this concern without additional experiments, but the paper’s contribution should then be assessed within that narrower scope.
Questions for authors
  1. As a possible extension, how could this evaluation be adapted to other languages?
  2. Could the actual inputs for each production system be provided? In particular, does Grok STS receive speech already carrying the intended prosody?
  3. Which interpretations were mismatched for the knife sentence in Table 2, and how were this item and its labels handled in Figures 2–3? If the mismatch affected those results, do the conclusions hold after correction?
  4. Figure 3(b) appears to show approximately 68% human meaning recovery, whereas Section 4.2 reports 90%. Are both values correct under different evaluation conditions? Please clarify the recordings, listener groups, trial counts, and aggregation procedures underlying each result.
  5. How were boundary reports coded and validated? Do the grounding profiles refer specifically to pause–report alignment or to acoustic evidence more broadly?
Reviewer_qSTbOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The authors address if the representation carried in prosody, where mere transcriptions cannot represent, can be matched to syntactic, communicative understanding to utilize in perception and production (i.e., generation) in speech language models. The authors conclude that models can perceive acoustic cues, but fails to relate them to information

Critical strengths
  1. The research question of whether models can relate prosodic properties both in perception and production (generation) is appropriately defined in the high-level direction.
  2. The linguistic viewpoint is well reflected throughout the paper, including (a) terminology (e.g., using production rather than generation) choices, (b) the frames used for problem definition (e.g., acoustic realization ↔ prosodic structure ↔ syntactic structure ↔ communicative interpretation part.) and (c) experimental designs. In the current situation where lots of interpretability is more taken in mechanistic viewpoints, such a viewpoint looks refreshing.
Critical weaknesses

Despite the strengths of the paper which are mainly about the high-level direction, the technical depth and details remain limited in terms of its experimental setup and rigorous scientific methodology.

Dataset

  1. The scale of the datasets used in the experiments (described in Table 1), which is 5, is too little to be considered valid.
  2. The description of the dataset quality, such as example how the prosodic properties are measured, remain less addressed.

Experiments & Methods

  1. Overall, the methodology applied in the work is not par on the current research landscape. The authors use prompting to attribute the models acoustic perception. However considering the fact that (1) the faithfulness of CoT is disappointing, and (2) the speech language models are not perfect at understanding acoustic signals, looking into model internals in causal manner is required. For example, probing or other mechanistic interpretability techniques, to localize the components or what concepts are being used from acoustic signals, are additionally needed to make meaningful contribution.

Misc

  1. The models used are not described clearly (e.g., Model names such as gpt-4o-mini-tts is better than OpenAI )

  2. Some of the values in Figure 5 has low visibiiity.

Questions for authors

Could you answer how you controlled the prosody variations to the stimuli?

Reviewer_s1vdOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper evaluates whether speech foundation models can express and interpret meaning through prosody. Using five ambiguous sentences with two intended interpretations each, it combines speech generation, model perception, human listening tests, and acoustic analysis. The results suggest that natural speech generation and plausible explanations of prosody do not necessarily imply reliable prosodic understanding.

Critical strengths
  1. Keeping the words fixed while varying the intended meaning provides a useful setup for studying prosody. Evaluating both production and perception gives a more complete picture of model behavior.

  2. Human listening tests directly assess whether generated speech conveys the intended meaning. This is a meaningful complement to acoustic measurements and model-based evaluation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The evaluation is too narrow to support broad conclusions. All experiments rely on only five sentences. Repeated generations and listener judgments improve estimates for these examples but do not establish generalization across sentence structures or contexts. The acoustic classifiers also do not test generalization to unseen sentences.

  2. The analysis remains mostly descriptive. Acoustic separability and correlations between explanations, pauses, and answer choices do not establish how models use prosody. The study does not sufficiently distinguish failures in acoustic perception, syntactic interpretation, and answer selection. This limits the depth of the contribution and is a main reason for my rejection recommendation.

Questions for authors
  1. Do the existing per-sentence results show consistent trends, or are the main findings driven by particular sentences?

  2. One sentence is excluded from Table 2 because of a mismatch in the production prompts. Does this issue affect other analyses or the main conclusions?

  3. Beyond the reported correlations, what evidence supports distinguishing acoustic perception failures from interpretation or answer-selection failures?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.