- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Overtone, the first Theory of Mind (ToM) benchmark based on vocal and pragmatic cues. It also proposes PEAR (Prediction-Error-Adaptive Reasoning), a training-free ToM reasoning method. Evaluation on Overtone shows current models' limitations in inferring mental states from vocal and pragmatic cues. Experiments also demonstrate the efficacy of PEAR.
Critical strengths
-
This paper studies an interesting but underexplored problem: ToM in voice and pragmatics. The proposed Overtone is the first benchmark on this topic. Most importantly, the benchmark evaluates how vocal expression can alter the social meaning of identical words, which cannot be explored by a text-only dataset. Experiments in Figure 4 present such an analysis.
-
The experiments are comprehensive. They compare multiple types of baselines, apply the proposed PEAR to multiple backbone models, and conduct extensive analysis, particularly on audio gains.
Critical weaknesses
-
The novelty of the proposed PEAR is not significant, as it is more engineering-oriented.
-
The proposed Overtone lacks a shortcut audition. [r1] raises the point that many existing ToM benchmarks suffer from the shortcut issue. The authors may follow their examination framework to audit the proposed benchmark.
Overall, the target problem and the proposed dataset are important and novel. My rating is weak acceptance at this stage. My final recommendation would depend on the rebuttal.
[r1] Zhong, Jike, et al. "From Shortcuts to Reasoning: Robust Post-Training of Theory of Mind with Reinforcement Learning." ICML, 2026.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
(Minor) 1. The font sizes in the figures are too small. Furthermore, the language and sentence patterns of this paper are too AI-generated.
(Minor) 2. Missing discussion of several recent related ToM works, such as [r2, r3].
[r2] Zhang, Shunchi, et al. "Mindzero: Learning online mental reasoning with zero annotations." ICML, 2026.
[r3] Zhang, Chunhui, et al. "Overcoming multi-step complexity in multimodal theory-of-mind reasoning: A scalable bayesian planner." ICML, 2025.
5 comments
Replies to Reviewer rMk9 ——Weakness 2–part (1)
Thank you for your time, careful review of our paper. Here are our detailed responses:
W2 Shortcut audition of Overtone.
Thank you for your expert advice and the reference you provided; These have been crucial in advancing research in ToM field. We have carefully read this paper, learnt from their shortcut audition method, and applied it to Overtone. The detailed methodology and results are as follows:
We use scripts as the basic unit of classification; In each round, we select 6 scripts from each of the 8 ToM task dimensions, perform 12 random restarts per round, with 2,500 steps of local swap steps each time, and remove the scripts selected in each round from the candidate pool for the next round.
Table A: Round-wise Sampling and Ability Distribution of the Discovery Set.
| Round | Scripts | Audio Recordings | Questions | Questions per Each of the 7 ToM Abilities | Scenarios |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 48 | 54 | 216 | 29–33 | 42 |
| 2 | 48 | 51 | 204 | 26–32 | 38 |
| 3 | 48 | 59 | 236 | 30–37 | 38 |
| Total | 144 | 164 | 656 | — | 81 distinct |
We first use 164 audio recordings to idnetify rules, then we exclude those scripts and recordings sharing scenes with them. The remaining 1162 recordings are used to evaluate the extracted vocal-cue rules. We use Gemini 3.7 Flash to assessment, we formulate five types of vocal-cue rules based on professional framework for vocal perception( Juslin & Laukka (2003); Anikin & Persson (2018); Bryant (2023); Liebenthal et al. (2016) ), as detailed below:
Table B: Rules for Vocal-Cue Shortcut Auditing.
| Rules | Cues |
|---|---|
| Emotion | Whether positive, negative, neutral, or uncertain vocal labels match the corresponding emotional attitude terms in the answer. |
| Non-verbal Vocalizations | Whether laughter, sighs, and hesitation correspond to options such as joking, disappointment, or uncertainty, respectively. |
| Irony | When irony is identified, whether the model directly selects an option corresponding to a discrepancy between literal meaning and intended meaning. |
| Cue Integration | Summing the matching of the above emotion, non-verbal vocalization, and irony cues. |
| Non-literal Communication | When the literal meaning of an utterance is positive but the vocal expression is negative or ironic, prioritizing options indicating surface agreement but underlying dissatisfaction. |
Experiment A: LLM-guided Rule Discovery.
Results: Under these rules, no obvious shortcuts for Overtone have been detected.
Table C: Accuracy of Vocal-Cue rules on Overtone.
| Rules | Accuracy | Gain |
|---|---|---|
| Emotion | 29.69% | +1.68 pp |
| Non-verbal Vocalizations | 26.89% | −1.12 pp |
| Irony | 28.06% | +0.04 pp |
| Cue Integration | 31.00% | +2.99 pp |
| Non-literal Communication | 32.64% | +4.63 pp |
In the 4,648 questions following the isolation scenario, the baseline was 28.01%. Even though these showed an improvement, they fell far short of the 20% threshold specified in the paper. In summary, Overtone passed the shortcut audition.
Experiment B: Lexical Association.
Results: We also calculated the normalized mutual information between surface features and the correct answer. The isolated scenario validation set comprises 4,648 questions and 18,592 candidate options; features include option length, lexical overlap between options and the background, question stem or target sentence, as well as negation, contrast, cognitive and emotional words. The average score across the 11 features was 0.00912, which is below the 0.15 reference threshold proposed in the paper.
Table D: Surface Feature Association Analysis.
| Surface Feature | Normalized Mutual Information |
|---|---|
| Option Word Count | 0.01070 |
| Option Character Count | 0.01122 |
| Option–Context Word Overlap | 0.02319 |
| Option–Question Stem Word Overlap | 0.00287 |
| Option–Target Utterance Word Overlap | 0.00190 |
| Contains Negation | 0.00690 |
| Contains Contrastive Words | 0.03935 |
| Contains Cognitive Words | 0.00242 |
| Contains Emotion Words | 0.00098 |
| Contains Certainty Words | 0.00077 |
| Mentions Speaker | 0.0000013 |
| Avg | 0.00912 |
Due to space constraints, the remainder part of Weakness2 will be continued in the next comment. Thank you for your patience in reading this.
Reference.
[1] Juslin P N, Laukka P. Communication of emotions in vocal expression and music performance: Different channels, same code?
[2] Anikin A, Bååth R, Persson T. Human non-linguistic vocal repertoire: call types and their meaning.
[3] Bryant G A, Colston H L, Gibbs R W. Vocal strategies in verbal irony.
[4] Liebenthal E, Silbersweig D A, Stern E. The language, tone and prosody of emotions: neural substrates and dynamics of spoken-word emotion perception.
Replies to Reviewer rMk9 ——Weakness 2–part (2)
Thank you for your time, careful review of our paper. Here are our detailed responses:
W2 Shortcut audition of Overtone-part (2)
Experiments A and B demonstrate that Overtone passed the shortcut audition proposed in this paper. Furthermore, we also implemented rigorous data design and quality control measures during the construction of Overtone to mitigate potential shortcut risks. Specifically:
1. Semantically neutral design: Both the background context and target utterances are design in semantically neutral phrasing, avoiding explicit emotional word or direct mental-state cues, thereby preventing the model from directly inferring the answer based solely on emotional keywords in the text. All options are designed to be plausible within the given scenario, such that the correct answer can only be selected based on the voice. See Section 3, lines 154–156 and 208–209.
2. Controlled voice comparison: We designed shared scripts, strictly maintaining consistency in textual content and social context whilst varying only the voice performances recorded by human. This prevents textual differences from serving as a direct basis for distinguishing mental states, thereby testing whether the model can genuinely infer character’s mental state from vocal information. See Section 3, lines 202–205.
3. Expert-guided design and review: To avoid templated patterns introduced by LLM-generated content, we had experts in psychology and pragmatics manually construct the scenario families and review the scripts. We also conducted manual listening review of the recordings to ensure rigorous quality control throughout benchmark construction. See Figure 2 (b), Section 3, lines 197–200, and Appendix C.
Furthermore, the results of the Shared Pairs experiment in Table 2 demonstrate that the model is unable to draw correct inferences based on changes in vocal expression; this sharp decline also highlights the diagnostic value of the Overtone, revealing limitations in vocal-cue utilization that may be obscured by overall accuracy. These findings further reveal that the complex patterns underlying human vocal expression are difficult to capture and reproduce through simple, fixed rules.
Replies to Reviewer rMk9 ——Weakness 1
Thank you for your time, careful review of our paper. Here are our detailed responses:
W1 Novelty of PEAR.
We thank for this thoughtful comment. We fully understand your concern. We would like to clarify the motivation behind PEAR and contributions by drawing on the core challenges revealed in this study.
As mentioned at the end of the second paragraph and the third paragraph in Chapter 1, Introduction, line 53 to line 91, recent studies have shown that audio LLMs remain strongly biased toward lexical semantics, often relying on verbal content even when vocal expression conveys conflicting information (Chen et al., 2026; Corrêa et al., 2026). At the same time, as shown in Experiment 1&2, our extensive experiments on Overtone involving 16 state-of-the-art speech LLMs and Omni LLMs revealed limitations in their ability to utilize vocal cues, mental-state consistency, and integrate multimodal information.
Inspired by the above, we cannot help but wonder how the human brain integrates and utilizes multimodal information cues to perform ToM reasoning, and whether a mechanism that simulates the human brain’s ToM reasoning process could be used to address these shortcomings. To this end, we propose PEAR.
In the process of ToM reasoning in the human brain, neural information processing is not a passive response to external stimuli, but rather a dynamic predictive coding process. Based on the current context, the brain forms predictions about others’ potential mental states and their likely behaviors; the mismatch between these predictions and observations creates a prediction error, which serves as a signal for adjusting the current mental interpretation, thereby enabling dynamic inference about others’ mental states (Koster-Hale & Saxe, 2013).
While PEAR does not introduce a new model architecture, our goal is to draw inspiration from the way the human brain engages in ToM reasoning, thereby offering a new perspective on how Omni models can integrate information to achieve ToM reasoning. We hope this research will contribute to advancing this field. In future research, we will also explore how to model the human brain and incorporate cognitive mechanisms into model architecture and training objectives.
This response was written word for word with sincerity; it reflects our true motivations and ideas behind proposing the PEAR methodology. This is why our response is somewhat lengthy. Thank you for your patience in reading this; We hope it addresses your concerns. We will provide detailed responses to the remaining questions one by one later. Thank you once again for your valuable feedback.
Reference
[1] Jingyi Chen, Zhimeng Guo, Jiyun Chun, Pichao Wang, Andrew Perrault, and Micha Elsner. Do audio LLMs really LISTEN, or just transcribe? measuring lexical vs. acoustic emotion cues reliance.
[2] Pedro Corrêa, João Lima, Victor Moreno, Lucas H. Ueda, and Paula Dornhofer Paro Costa. Evaluating emotion recognition in spoken language models on emotionally incongruent speech.
[3] Jorie Koster-Hale and Rebecca Saxe. Theory of mind: A neural prediction problem.