- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses cross-generator generalization in AI-generated image detection and proposes Prompt Prototype Learning (PPL). The method uses a frozen text encoder to encode manually designed forensic prompts covering texture, boundary, and geometric cues. Class prototypes for real and generated images are constructed by normalizing individual prompt embeddings, averaging them, and normalizing the resulting vectors again. During training, a prototype-alignment loss and a binary classification loss jointly guide LoRA adaptation of the vision encoder. At inference, only the adapted vision encoder and a linear classification head are used. The paper reports strong generalization across multiple cross-generator benchmarks and a dataset containing images transmitted through social media, while using only generated images from four ProGAN object categories and their corresponding real images for detector training.
Critical strengths
1.Simple and task-relevant text supervision. The method aggregates prompts covering multiple forensic cues into class prototypes, providing richer textual supervision than individual class tokens. Normalizing each prompt embedding before averaging gives each prompt equal weight in prototype construction and reduces reliance on any single prompt. 2.Strong cross-generator generalization. The paper reports strong performance across multiple benchmarks containing unseen generators, as well as a dataset reflecting social-media transmission, while using only generated images from four ProGAN object categories and their corresponding real images for detector training. 3.Broad experimental coverage. The paper includes ablations on prompt content, prompt count, prototype normalization, and different vision backbones. Comparisons with and without PPL under the same backbone support its effectiveness. The evaluation also covers robustness to compression, blur, noise, and their combinations.
Critical weaknesses
1.The contribution beyond C2P-CLIP requires a more controlled comparison. The proposed method shares the overall framework of C2P-CLIP, including text-based supervision, LoRA adaptation of the vision encoder, joint contrastive and classification objectives, and vision-only inference. Its main methodological distinction is replacing per-image alignment with augmented captions by class-level alignment with prototypes constructed from multiple forensic prompts, alongside the adoption of a larger vision backbone. Although the paper includes ablations across backbones and prompt constructions, it lacks a direct comparison with C2P-CLIP under matched backbone and training configurations. This limits the assessment of the proposed supervision strategy’s incremental benefit over the existing framework. 2.The role of fine-grained forensic semantics lacks direct validation. The paper partly attributes its improvements to the texture, boundary, and geometric forensic knowledge encoded in the text prototypes. Ablations involving single class tokens, random captions, and different attribute groups support the effectiveness of the prompt design, but do not directly establish that these descriptions correspond to the visual attributes actually used by the detector. The current experiments do not clearly disentangle the effects of specific attribute semantics, real/fake class keywords, and the prototype constraint itself. Consequently, the empirical evidence supports the method’s effectiveness more strongly than its proposed semantic explanation.
Questions for authors
1.Could the authors directly compare PPL with C2P-CLIP using the same vision backbone and otherwise matched training settings, to isolate the contribution of class-level prototype supervision relative to per-image caption alignment? 2.How would performance change if the real/fake class keywords were retained but the forensic attribute descriptions were removed, or if prototypes were constructed using class identifiers unrelated to authenticity, such as “Trump/Biden”? With the training configuration, prompt count, and prototype aggregation procedure held constant, could these controls clarify whether the specific forensic descriptions provide benefits beyond generic class-discriminative signals?
3 comments
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for reviewing our rebuttal and for raising your score. We’d like to briefly address two points that may remain open.
Backbone vs. method contribution.
We acknowledge that Table R1 shows the backbone contributes substantially. In the revision, we will report C2P-CLIP and PPL under matched backbones in the main results table, so that the improvement attributable to prototype supervision (+3.4 ACC / +1.4 AP on PE-Core, +8.8 / +2.2 on CLIP-L) is stated explicitly and separated from backbone effects.
Forensic-semantics interpretation.
We will revise the text to present this explanation as consistent with, rather than established by, the controls, as discussed in our rebuttal.
If any other concerns remain, we would be glad to address them within the discussion period.
Best regards,
The Authors
Dear Reviewer vPfV,
Thank you for your constructive feedback and for engaging with our rebuttal. Under matched backbones and training, PPL outperforms C2P-CLIP (+3.4 ACC on PE-Core-G/14, +8.8 on CLIP-L/14), and the controls you suggested show that generic templates (90.8) and authenticity-neutral identifiers (91.7) both fall below the full forensic prompts (94.8).
We believe these results address all the concerns raised in your review. If any remain, we would be glad to clarify them before tomorrow's deadline; otherwise, we would be grateful if you would consider them in your final assessment.
Best regards, The Authors
Clarifications and rebuttal: matched C2P-CLIP comparison and role of forensic descriptions
We thank the reviewer for the precise and constructive suggestions. Both requested controls were run on all five benchmarks with PE-Core-G/14 and identical training.
W1/Q1: Matched comparison with C2P-CLIP.
We trained C2P-CLIP and PPL with the same backbone, data, and settings. Values are the average ACC / AP over UFD, AIGC, AIGB, AIGH, and TruFak:
Table R1. Matched C2P-CLIP vs. PPL. Avg ACC / AP (%).
With PE-Core, PPL leads on every benchmark, e.g., by +7.8 ACC on TrueFake. Since both methods share the LoRA adaptation, the joint objective, and vision-only inference, this isolates class-level prototype supervision against per-image caption alignment.
W2/Q2: Role of the forensic descriptions.
K=6, aggregation, and training are fixed throughout:
Keywords without descriptions:
Six generic templates (e.g., "a photo of a real/fake image") reach 90.8 ACC, no better than C2P-CLIP.
Descriptions without authenticity semantics:
Replacing every authenticity-related word (real, camera, genuine, authentic, natural, and their fake counterparts) with neutral identifiers yields 92.1 (Camera/Deepfake) and 91.7 (Biden/Trump). The two neutral variants differ by only 0.4 ACC, so the drop reflects the removed semantics rather than the class name. C2P-CLIP is nearly unaffected by the same keyword swap (91.4 → 91.1), indicating that its keywords act only as class identifiers. This gives a clear decomposition. Generic templates give no gain over C2P-CLIP. Forensic attribute descriptions without authenticity wording add about +1 ACC. Tying those attributes explicitly to authenticity adds a further +2.7 to +3.1 ACC. Neither component alone explains PPL; the gain arises from their combination. We agree that these controls show the forensic semantics matter without proving that the detector uses the specific visual attributes described. Grad-CAM (Fig. 5) offers partial support: with PPL, attention shifts from isolated high-frequency points to coherent structural regions. We will revise the text to present the semantic explanation as consistent with, rather than established by, these results.