- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ECPP, a few-shot adaptation method for biomedical vision-language models that combines text priors with visual class prototypes. It introduces an evidence handoff mechanism that shifts reliance from text to prototypes as more labeled images become available, together with text-path distillation to prevent the teacher from suppressing visual evidence. Experiments on 11 biomedical datasets show consistent improvements over BiomedCoOp with minimal additional parameters.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses an important problem in few-shot biomedical VLM adaptation: how to balance text priors and visual evidence under different support sizes.
- ECPP achieves consistent improvements over BiomedCoOp across 11 biomedical datasets while adding only one trainable scalar.
Critical weaknesses
- My main concern is the limited novelty. Several prior works already combine visual support evidence with CLIP text predictions, including Tip-Adapter, Proto-Adapter, and Proto-CLIP.
- Several design choices appear heuristic. In particular, a simple 0.5/K prior-weighting rule achieves 66.02% mean accuracy versus 66.04% for ECPP, raising questions about the necessity of the more complex uncertainty-aware weighting.
- The contribution of the text-path distillation is relatively limited. Although the proposed placement is well motivated, the ablation shows an average improvement of only 0.42 percentage points in few-shot accuracy, which makes its empirical impact modest compared with the other components.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors better justify the novelty of ECPP relative to existing prototype-based and text-visual fusion methods?
- Could the authors clarify the practical benefit of the proposed uncertainty-aware weighting, given that the simple 0.5/K rule achieves nearly identical performance in Table S8?