- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a new method for zero-shot anomaly detection (unfortunately, the method is not named). The method is based on the analysis that abnormal features and normal features have different “angles”/”directions” in the latent space. The model learns these angles during training. To increase diversity, these angles are also perturbed using a vMF sampler. The model is evaluated on standard industrial datasets.
Critical strengths
- The analysis showcasing the separation of anomalous and normal features is well thought out
- The idea behind this method is simple and works well
Critical weaknesses
Major Weaknesses:
- AnomalyVFM outperforms the method when using the RADIO backbone. I do not see a reason to use only DINOv3 as a backbone; the main goal is to improve zero-shot anomaly detection overall, not just some backbones. What is the performance of the proposed method using the RADIOv2.5 ViT-L backbone? The supplementary material has only C-RADIOv3 ViT-L results.
- The method is evaluated only on industrial datasets, neglecting medical ones.
Minor Weaknesses:
- As far as I know, the maximum is non-differentiable. Is the residual alignment score (Equation 10) derived differently during training? Or how do you bypass this non-differentiability?
Questions for authors
- How does the method perform with RADIOv2.5 ViT-L backbone in comparison to AnomalyVFM with the same backbone?
- How does the method perform on medical datasets?
- How do you make Equation 10 differentiable?