- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
Motivation: Existing ZSAD methods typically rely on auxiliary-dataset training to learn transferable anomaly representations. However, frozen visual encoders may already possess cross-dataset anomaly-discriminative capabilities, potentially eliminating the need for additional training.
Contribution: The authors propose XPAD, which constructs normal and anomaly prototypes from an annotated auxiliary dataset and incorporates foreground–background separation and aggregation-degree calibration. The framework enables zero-shot anomaly detection without textual prompts, gradient-based training, or target-domain data.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is reasonably well organized, and the overall framework is straightforward to understand. The motivation and methodological components are presented in a relatively clear manner.
-
XPAD explores a relatively less-studied training-free yet annotation-dependent ZSAD paradigm. By leveraging cross-dataset prototype statistics without gradient-based learning, the work offers an alternative perspective on anomaly knowledge transfer and provides some useful insights for future training-free anomaly detection research.
Critical weaknesses
-
The "training-free" claim is potentially misleading, and its practical significance remains questionable. Although XPAD does not involve gradient-based optimization or model fine-tuning, it relies on an annotated auxiliary dataset to construct normal and anomaly prototypes. In particular, the anomaly prototype cannot be established without pixel-level anomaly annotations, indicating that the framework still depends on supervised anomaly knowledge. This differs from more conventional zero-shot approaches, such as WinCLIP, which do not require annotated anomalies for their zero-shot inference. Therefore, XPAD is more accurately characterized as a gradient-free, annotation-dependent cross-dataset transfer method rather than a fully supervision-free approach. The authors should clarify this distinction and better justify the practical advantages of the proposed paradigm, particularly considering the cost of acquiring pixel-level anomaly annotations.
-
The central motivation lacks sufficient logical justification and empirical validation. In Sec. 3.1, the authors infer the existence of a shared, transferable anomaly-discriminative direction from the observed similarities among dataset-level normal and anomaly prototypes. However, this inference is not sufficiently justified. First, high within-class prototype similarities across datasets do not necessarily establish consistent normal-to-anomaly discriminative directions. Second, dataset-level prototype separation does not directly imply effective anomaly discrimination at the patch level. The current analysis does not adequately examine either of these assumptions. The authors should provide more direct evidence, such as pairwise cosine similarity analysis of cross-dataset normal-to-anomaly difference vectors and patch-level discrimination experiments, to substantiate the central motivation underlying XPAD.
Questions for authors
-
How do the authors justify the "training-free" characterization of XPAD given its dependence on pixel-level anomaly annotations from an auxiliary dataset? While the method avoids gradient-based optimization, constructing anomaly prototypes still requires explicit supervised anomaly information. What are the practical advantages of this paradigm over existing training-free approaches, such as WinCLIP, that do not require annotated anomaly samples?
-
What evidence supports the claim that dataset-level prototype similarities imply a shared, transferable anomaly-discriminative direction? High within-class similarities do not necessarily guarantee consistent normal-to-anomaly directions across datasets or effective patch-level discrimination. Could the authors provide additional analyses of cross-dataset normal-to-anomaly difference vectors and patch-level discriminative performance to substantiate this central claim?
A Gentle Reminder: About One Day Left in the Discussion Period
Dear Reviewers,
This is a gentle reminder that approximately one day remains in the discussion period. Please review the authors' responses and other reviewers' comments, and engage in the discussion to clarify which concerns have been addressed and which remain unresolved.
Thank you for your time and effort.
Best,
AC