- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a quantile regression model that prevents quantile crossing in conditional quantile estimation. Its core strategy models nonnegative increments between quantile values, an approach previously used to ensure non-crossing quantile estimates. Although the proposed approach is reasonable, it offers little methodological novelty.
Critical strengths
-
The direction and strategy described in this paper are consistent with those of existing studies.
-
Comparative experiments were conducted across a variety of datasets.
Critical weaknesses
-
The use of nonnegative increments and integral formulations, as advocated in this paper, is not new.
-
Although the paper provides theoretical proofs, its poorly defined notation makes them nearly impossible to follow. Page 6 even uses symbols before they are properly defined, making the intended arguments difficult to discern. For example, and , introduced on line 296, appear to characterize the smoothness of a function class, but they are explained only in the appendix. The paper also fails to explain how this smoothness relates to Theorem 1. Similarly, , used around line 298 on page 6, appears to be introduced to calculate the complexity of the function class, yet it is used without a definition. These issues make the theoretical discussion very difficult to follow.
Questions for authors
-
Do the results in Theorem 1 establish a non-asymptotic bound for the proposed method? If not, how do they help demonstrate the method’s effectiveness?
-
Beyond the evaluation metrics reported in the simulation study, are there any comparative results using additional calibration metrics?