- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies nonparametric instrumental variable regression for mean, expectile, and quantile estimation under a unified minimax framework. Two DNNs are used to represent the structural function and the critic. The authors establish bounds for adversarial moment risk and derive structural () convergence rates under additional assumptions. The paper also includes simulation studies and a real-data application.
Critical strengths
- The paper extends NPIV estimation beyond the standard mean regression setting to expectile and quantile regression. In particular, handling the nonlinear expectile score and the smoothing error in quantile estimation adds some technical interest to the theoretical analysis.
- The authors explicitly distinguish moment-risk convergence from structural recovery, which is important in ill-posed inverse problems.
Critical weaknesses
-
The theoretical assumptions seem strong to me. In particular, the structural convergence result in Theorem 4.2 relies on the localization condition , where imposes spectral regularity restrictions on the estimation error. The paper does not establish why the proposed estimator should satisfy this localization condition. Therefore, the applicability of the structural convergence guarantee remains unclear.
-
The experimental evaluation is limited. The simulations mainly show that estimation errors decrease as the sample size increases. There are no direct comparisons with existing neural IV methods or other nonparametric IV estimators.
Questions for authors
-
The theoretical motivation for using DNNs. The DNN approximation and covering number bounds in this paper are based on existing results. Moreover, the convergence rate in Theorem 4.1 still depends on the ambient dimension and does not appear to exploit potential advantages of DNNs under low intrinsic dimension. Could the authors explain why DNNs are particularly suitable for this problem and whether they offer theoretical advantages over traditional nonparametric estimators? Given the existing literature on minimax conditional moment estimation and structural recovery, what new mathematical difficulties arise when handling the expectile and quantile scores?
-
Could the authors include an ablation study on critic network complexity (e.g., width or depth) to examine how sensitive the proposed estimator is to the choice of critic class?
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of our technical contributions and for the constructive feedback. Below, we address your concerns point-by-point.
We hope these responses address your concerns.