- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes RaNTFields, a physics-informed neural framework for asymmetric motion planning based on Randers geometry. The method learns drift-aware travel-time fields through self-supervision, without requiring trajectory supervision. The fields can then be used to compute paths that navigate the robot to the goal, in the presence of obstacles and directional environmental factors (e.g., gravity, flows). The experiments demonstrate strong agreement with numerical Ordered Upwind Method (OUM) solutions and reduced peak torque in robotic arm planning.
Critical strengths
- The paper tackles an interesting problem in robot motion planning, dealing with the case where the motion plan depends on asymmetric environmental factors, including flows, gravity, and directional dynamics.
- The proposed formulation is relatively simple and elegant: add a drift term that introduces asymmetries and learn a physics-informed network that can learn the time-travel fields in a self-supervised manner.
- The presentation is very clear and provides required preliminaries before introducing the contribution.
- The experiments are convincing and include results on a real robot.
Critical weaknesses
- It is unclear if the result in Section 4.1 (in particular, eq (5)) is a novel/non-trivial result. I understand this is simply obtained by replacing the Mahalanobis norm in (3) with a Randers metric, but the first sentence of Section 4.1 hints to the fact that there is more to the derivation. If so, I suggest formalizing the result in a theorem/proposition.
- I understand that G, S*, f are given and are not learned. In practice, how should one set G and f (I guess S* is the same as eq (2)).
- In practice, would one need to retrain the network every time an obstacle changes?
- The UR5e experiments compare RaNTFields against Neural Eikonal, Neural Riemannian, RRT, and RRT*, but none of these baselines explicitly optimizes actuator torque. Since reducing peak torque is a central experimental claim, comparisons against torque-aware trajectory optimization methods would strengthen the evaluation. One potential baseline is Crocoddyl (Mastalli et al., Crocoddyl: An Efficient and Versatile Framework for Multi-Contact Optimal Control, ICRA 2020), which supports optimal control formulations with actuation-related costs. Collision avoidance could be incorporated using Colmpc (https://github.com/agimus-project/colmpc).
- Missing architectural ablation studies: The proposed architecture combines Interval Quasimetric Embedding (IQE) with a residual MLP, but the contributions of these components are not evaluated separately. Since a standard MLP can already represent asymmetric travel-time functions, it is unclear whether IQE provides substantial benefits. I suggest comparing against a vanilla MLP trained with the same Randers PDE loss, as well as IQE-only and residual-only variants, to isolate the contributions of each architectural component.
- The current experiments are relatively simple, consisting primarily of synthetic 2D flow fields and a 5-DoF robotic arm with a single spherical obstacle. It remains unclear how well RaNTFields generalizes to more challenging environments (including multiple obstacles and narrow passages) and higher-dimensional systems. Evaluating such scenarios would better demonstrate the method's robustness and practical applicability.
Minor weaknesses:
- Several grammatical errors should be corrected: Page 1, Introduction: "provide strong theoretical guaranties" should be "provide strong theoretical guarantees.". Page 7, Section 5.1.1: "These results are consistent among the three flow environments and they demonstrate that…" should be "These results are consistent across the three flow environments and demonstrate that…". Page 6, Section 4.3: "such that we recover the identitity riemannian metric with there is no elevation" should be "such that the identity Riemannian metric is recovered when there is no elevation."
- Unclear definition of active torque. The definition of "Active torque" in Table 3 is not sufficiently clear. The authors should explicitly explain how this metric is computed and how it differs from mean and peak torque.
- Insufficient implementation details for baselines: The paper does not clearly specify which codebases or implementations were used for the baseline methods, or whether these baselines were reimplemented by the authors. Providing implementation details, source-code references, and relevant hyperparameters would improve reproducibility and help ensure fair comparisons.
Questions for authors
- how is eq (5) obtained? why is it a nontrivial replacement of the Mahalanobis norm in eq. (3)?
- I understand that G, S*, f are given and are not learned. In practice, how should one set G and f?
- Would one need to retrain the network every time an obstacle changes?
- can you add a comparison against torque-aware baselines for the UR5e experiment?
- did you perform any ablation experiments on the proposed architecture?
- how would the 5-dof robot arm experiment generalize to a more complex environment? how does RaNTfields scale to higher-dimensional systems?
- what is the definition of active torque in Table 3?
We thank the reviewer; see also the general response.
Q1. How Eq. (5) is obtained, and why it is more than a norm swap
It is the stationary HJB equation of the Zermelo problem q̇ = f(q) + u, uᵀG(q)u ≤ 1, with running cost 1/S(q):
0 = min over uᵀGu ≤ 1 of [1/S + ∇Tᵀ(f + u)].
The minimum of a linear function over the G-unit ball is −√(∇TᵀG⁻¹∇T), which gives Eq. (5): √(∇TᵀG⁻¹∇T) − fᵀ∇T = 1/S (see App. A.1). Three things make it more than a norm replacement:
This is now Proposition 1 in Sec. 4.1, with the proof in App. A.1-A.2.
Q2. How to set G and f
G sets how costly motion is in each direction; f sets the preferred direction. In our experiments:
In every case the feasibility condition fᵀGf < 1 holds everywhere: flow speeds are chosen below 1, and terrain and arm drifts are scaled once (max 0.9 and 0.95).
Q3. Retraining when obstacles change
Yes. Like NTFields and TD-NTFields, a field is trained per environment. Our change is the PDE, so environment generalization is orthogonal: conditioning the field on an environment encoder (e.g. a PointNet++ embedding of the obstacle point cloud) with a larger backbone is a natural route. This is future work, and the paper now states it as a limitation.
Q4. Torque-aware baseline (Crocoddyl + Colmpc)
We ran Crocoddyl with Colmpc constraints on all 23 arm spheres, on the same 100 pairs, with RaNTFields' dynamics model and time to goal, tracked in the same MuJoCo harness.
The two methods solve different problems. Crocoddyl is dynamics-aware (over q, q̇ and τ) and minimizes torque directly. RaNTFields is a kinematic, first-order travel-time field over q: inertia only shapes G and gravity only sets f. We also solved RaNTFields' own objective exactly (kinematic OCP, same constraints) and executed it with our controller.
On the same pairs (revised paper, Table 10): RaNTFields 92% success, 75.0 N·m peak torque, ~4.3 ms per query; Crocoddyl + Colmpc 100%, 47.3 N·m, 6.9 s median per solve; kinematic OCP 98%, 75.1 N·m, 35-79 s per solve.
The exact optimum of our kinematic objective gets the same torque as RaNTFields, so the gap to Crocoddyl is not due to the quality of the learned field, but to the different problem it solves. RaNTFields is a real-time field encoding a preferred direction, not a torque optimizer; its torque reduction over the Eikonal field comes from G, not f (general response, Sec. 3). We revised the torque claims accordingly (Sec. 5.2, App. A.6.5).
Q5. Ablation
Yes: IQE-only, residual-only and a vanilla MLP on the same Randers loss, capacity-matched, plus the TD-NTFields metric network (general response, Sec. 1). Both branches are needed; IQE gives a modest gain over a symmetric distance.
Q6. Harder environments and higher dimensions
We added a 2D two-corridor scene with opposing currents (general response, Sec. 2). We also tried a 6-DoF UR5e in a cluttered cabinet-shelf scene. Without the drift, our pipeline reaches 74% success (TD-NTFields' Eikonal recipe: 82%). With the gravity drift on the same backbone, success drops to ~51%, so learning the drift, not clutter, is a bottleneck. Possible directions for scaling to higher dimensions and clutter are giving the network f(q) as an input feature, an environment encoder (as in Q3), and a more expressive architecture. The paper now states the difficulty as a limitation and adds these directions as future work.
Q7. Active torque
Active torque = √(∫(τᵀq̇)² dt), the root-integrated-square of mechanical power (torque that does work). All torque metrics are now defined in App. A.5.
Minor points
We fixed the three typos. Baselines: N-Eik. and N-Riem. use our exact pipeline (data, network, controller and gains); N-Eik. sets f = 0 and G = I, N-Riem. sets f = 0. RRT and RRT* are OMPL's implementations (2 s planning budget, the same collision checker). These details are now in App. A.5; the code will be released with the camera-ready version.