- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper augments a Riemannian latent metric with a learned directional term to construct a Randers geometry for interpolation and extrapolation. The direction is learned from an ordered scalar attribute, and the method is evaluated on synthetic phantoms and plant images. The main concern is that the experiments do not isolate the contribution of the geometry or sufficiently establish the quality of the resulting extrapolations.
Critical strengths
- The construction provides a modular way to incorporate local ordering information into existing latent space metrics.
- Comparisons across several base metrics and ablations of label noise and sampling choices help characterize the behavior of the framework.
Critical weaknesses
- The main comparison changes both the metric and the directional sampling procedure. Randers extrapolation repeatedly samples around the learned direction, while the symmetric baselines do not receive the same guidance. The Wasserstein comparison uses a different trajectory construction, leaving the benefit of Randers geometry over an equally guided symmetric method unresolved.
- The extrapolation metrics measure monotonicity and change in the supervised attribute, while quantitative image quality is evaluated only for interpolation. The qualitative examples provide some support, but the plausibility of extrapolated images has not been independently quantified at comparable amounts of scalar progression. The practical significance of the reported gains therefore remains uncertain.
- The conversion from the learned direction to the asymmetric cost is not consistently specified: the ordering loss uses the base metric in its pairing, while the asymmetric cost does not. The dual expression also needs reconciliation with the stated pairing convention. These discrepancies should be resolved against the implementation so that the dynamics used to produce the reported results are unambiguous.
- The main tables do not clearly define what the reported variability summarizes. Several extrapolation results show substantial dispersion in the magnitude of scalar change, but the analysis does not establish how representative the mean changes are of typical trajectories. This limits conclusions about how consistently the method provides useful exploration.
- The results tables extend beyond the text width, and their numbered citations are difficult to reconcile with the unnumbered bibliography. These inconsistencies reduce readability and make the references for the compared methods harder to trace.
Questions for authors
- How does Randers extrapolation compare with a symmetric method using the same learned direction and repeated sampling procedure?
- How does the plausibility of extrapolated images compare when methods achieve similar amounts of scalar progression?
- Which formulations of the ordering loss, asymmetric cost, and dual norm are implemented, and how are they made consistent?
- What does each reported ± value summarize, and what accounts for the large variation in extrapolation magnitude?
4 comments
Thank you for your response.
My main concerns regarding the distinct contribution of the asymmetric geometry and the consistency of the mathematical formulation still require verification through the revised experiments and manuscript.
Unfortunately, I am also unable to open the revised PDF, as noted by another reviewer. Could you please re-upload the manuscript so that I can properly assess the additional results and revisions?
I will reconsider my assessment once the revised version is accessible.
Dear reviewer,
Sorry for the previously corrupted file. We have reupdated the file. It seems to load fine now.
Note that the experiments of appendix H.3 are still running as we had to retrain . They will be ready for the camera ready version. We expect the conclusions that we drew previously to still hold.
Best,
I thank the authors for their thoughtful rebuttal and clarifications. After considering the points raised in the response, my final assessment remains unchanged, so I will maintain my original score.
We hope these additions and corrections resolve the reviewer’s concerns about the sampling controls and the reporting, and we remain available for any further clarification.