- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes VASC, a training-free sparse-attention method for feed-forward 3D reconstruction. The authors demonstrate on commonly used datasets in this area, including 7-Scenes and NRGBD, that the proposed method achieves an improved trade-off between computational efficiency and accuracy preservation.
Critical strengths
In addition to the main comparisons on reconstruction metrics, the authors provide experimental observations and analysis in Section 3, which constitute a valuable contribution.
Critical weaknesses
- The manuscript is unnecessarily verbose and insufficiently polished. Section 4 mainly enumerates implementation details and absolute numerical changes, with little meaningful analysis of the observed results and their causes. The repetitive and formulaic writing gives the impression of no adequate human revision.
- The proposed method mainly combines existing techniques from the sparse-attention area. The paper's overall methodological novelty therefore appears limited.
- Although the authors evaluate frame strides of 5 and 10, both still correspond to relatively small input intervals with substantial view overlap. The method should also be evaluated on the same datasets using large frame intervals. Otherwise, it remains unclear whether the reported improvements generalize to input settings with limited view overlap.
Questions for authors
- Please check the weaknesses.
- Please provide more substantive analysis of the experimental results.
- Please provide reconstruction comparison at larger frame intervals (20, 50, 100).