- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes LoG-VGGT, which uses sliding windows and Cross-Window Attention (CWA) to model local temporal information, followed by Global Camera Consistency Refinement (GCCR) to correct camera-pose drift in long sequences. It evaluates 3D reconstruction, video depth estimation, and camera pose estimation. The method outperforms the selected streaming baselines on some metrics while maintaining relatively stable inference speed.
Critical strengths
- The problem is important, addressing memory use and pose drift in long-sequence 3D reconstruction.
- The roles of CWA and GCCR are clearly separated, and the ablations indicate that both contribute.
- The method achieves competitive results on camera pose and some depth and reconstruction metrics.
- Inference speed varies relatively stably with sequence length.
Critical weaknesses
- The architecture figure does not clearly communicate the two main innovations of the paper.
- The main tables focus on accuracy and lack peak memory, total runtime, and a unified accuracy-efficiency comparison, so they do not sufficiently demonstrate the claimed memory advantage.
- The main tables do not compare StreamVGGT, which is discussed as an important baseline, or VGGT-Long and Stream3R cited in the paper. Overall accuracy gains over state-of-the-art methods are limited.
- The “StreamingVGGT (Ours)” label in the right part of Figure 4 may be incorrect. In Table 2, TTT3R and Ours both obtain 0.904 on Virtual KITTI for δ<1.25, but only Ours is boldfaced; the reporting rule should be made consistent.
Questions for authors
- Is “StreamingVGGT (Ours)” in the right part of Figure 4 the same model as LoG-VGGT? Why do the experimental tables not compare StreamingVGGT or other newer methods?
- Please add memory and FPS experiments to better support the paper's claims.
Initial Response to Reviewer MHfx
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the importance of long-sequence reconstruction, the complementary roles of CWA and GCCR, competitive reconstruction and pose performance, and stable inference speed. We also appreciate the constructive comments on presentation, evaluation coverage, and figure and table annotations. We address each point below.
W1. Clarity of the Architecture Figure
We will redraw Fig. 2 in the final version to highlight the two core pathways: CWA propagates overlapping-frame features at selected backbone layers, while GCCR refines camera representations through camera-to-register interactions. The figure will distinguish the current window, historical cache, and token types, indicate interaction directions, and separately illustrate the depth and camera prediction branches to clarify the roles and connections of both components.
W2 / Q2. Peak Memory, Runtime, and FPS
Existing Results: Appendix Table 9 reports 11.9, 8.2, and 5.4 FPS at 1000 frames for full-sequence GCCR, online GCCR, and InfiniteVGGT, respectively.
Additional Analysis: We will additionally report peak GPU memory usage in the main paper.
W3 / Q1. Baseline Coverage and Magnitude of Improvements
Additional Baselines: We evaluate VGGT-Long, LoGeR, VGGT-Motion, and Stream3R using the same 1,000-frame protocol on 7-Scenes and NRGBD. StreamVGGT ran out of GPU memory on our evaluation hardware at this sequence length, so we do not report its scores. See our response to Reviewer b63X (Part 2/2, W3, Table 1) for the evaluation protocol and comparison table.
Magnitude of Improvements: We agree that gains are not equally large across all metrics. In the original Table 1, the 1000-frame mean accuracy error on 7-Scenes decreases from 0.065 for InfiniteVGGT to 0.060 for our method. Our emphasis is the balance between this reconstruction-quality improvement and the throughput reported above, rather than large gains on every metric.
W4 / Q1. Figure Labels and Highlighting Rules
Fig. 4: Yes, "StreamingVGGT (Ours)" refers to LoG-VGGT and is a labeling error, not the external StreamVGGT baseline. We will consistently replace it with "LoG-VGGT (Ours)" in the final version. The additional StreamVGGT comparison is addressed in W3 above.
Table 2: Both TTT3R and our method report 0.904 for
delta < 1.25on Virtual KITTI and should receive identical highlighting. We will bold both entries and check all tables to apply a consistent rule for values tied at the displayed precision. We thank the reviewer for identifying these annotation issues.