acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Looped Reasoning Finishes Earlier Than You Think

24 views

Abstract

Looped reasoning with dynamic depth can be viewed as relaxation toward solution attractors in a learned dynamical landscape. In practice, however, latent trajectories often oscillate, cycle, or drift rather than cleanly converge to stable fixed points. How these non-stationary dynamics contribute to reasoning and constrain convergence remains unclear. We show that slowly decaying oscillatory modes can impose their convergence rate on coupled latent dynamics, creating a bottleneck. Yet damping these modes indiscriminately can disrupt the reasoning computation they support. This tension motivates an architectural approach: introducing rotational degrees of freedom along which symmetry-generated rotational motion leaves the reasoning-relevant quotient dynamics unchanged by construction. We propose QRR (Quotient Recurrent Reasoner), a gauge-equivariant recurrent architecture with an exact per-token phase-rotation symmetry. Motion along these symmetry directions leaves the quotient representation unchanged and is dynamically decoupled from reasoning-relevant dynamics. Empirically, QRR achieves stable and faster convergence to solution roots in quotient space, without forming a dominant slow oscillatory bottleneck, while matching or surpassing recent recurrent reasoning models on Sudoku, Maze, and Mini-ARC.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Looped Reasoning, Looped Transformer, Reasoning, LLM, Quotient-Space Dynamics, Gauge-Equivarience

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_tDyWOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how oscillatory latent dynamics affect convergence in recurrent reasoning models. A local spectral analysis shows that a slowly decaying oscillatory mode can impose its convergence rate on complementary latent coordinates. Controlled interventions in FPRM and HRM test these predictions, while early suppression experiments demonstrate that oscillations can remain computationally useful. The proposed Quotient Recurrent Reasoner (QRR) introduces token-local phase symmetry, equivariant updates, and invariant readouts, enabling convergence and halting in quotient space. Validation includes spectral analyses, architectural ablations, and accuracy, halting, and runtime comparisons on Sudoku, two maze benchmarks, and Mini-ARC. The paper presents a coherent and reasonably comprehensive study connecting theoretical analysis, architectural design, and empirical validation.

Critical strengths
  1. Section 3 produces explicit intervention-response predictions without fitting subsequent trajectories. Testing these predictions in the original nonlinear FPRM and HRM recurrences, across alternating and spiral dynamics, provides quantitative evidence that the identified modes affect local convergence. The early-versus-late suppression experiment further demonstrates why oscillatory motion should not be treated as uniformly dispensable.

  2. QRR structurally ensures that the ignored phase motion does not affect predictions or future quotient states, providing a principled basis for quotient-based halting. Results on Maze-Unique and Mini-ARC provide additional support beyond the main benchmark.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Section 3 establishes a local mechanism in existing models, while QRR’s symmetry guarantees only that gauge motion cannot drive quotient dynamics. Why training yields a faster quotient spectrum remains an empirical question.

  2. Table 1 combines different checkpoint sources and native inference budgets, with a substantial gap between official and reproduced FPRM Sudoku accuracy (91.5% versus 83.7%). Halting statistics also condition on different coverage.

Questions for authors

Overall, I have no major concerns about the paper and would appreciate clarification on the following experimental details:

  1. Which FPRM checkpoints and evaluation settings are used in Tables 1–2 and the runtime comparison? What explains the gap between official-checkpoint and reproduced Sudoku results?

  2. How were halting thresholds calibrated, and were runtime statistics measured over all test examples, including those reaching the cap? Can accuracy–coverage–runtime comparisons be provided under explicitly matched evaluation conditions?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer tDyW

We thank the reviewer for recognizing QRR’s contributions and for providing constructive feedback that has helped us improve our work. We address each point below.

1. Structural symmetry versus learned convergence speed (W1)

We thank the reviewer for raising this key distinction. We agree that gauge equivariance guarantees decoupling from slow gauge motion, but does not by itself guarantee a faster learned quotient spectrum. As an empirical verification, we trained a symmetry-breaking control on Sudoku-Extreme by introducing a non-gauge perturbation to the G-SwiGLU value branch.

As shown in Figure 11 in Appendix A.4 in revised manuscript, symmetry breaking substantially changes the learned dynamics and spectral structure. The leading transverse spectral rate increases from 0.989 to 1.283, shifting from contracting to expanding dynamics. Meanwhile, gauge-to-quotient coupling (Proposition A.2 in Appendix) increases from numerical zero to 0.16. Consequently, 89/96 QRR trajectories settle, whereas none of the 96 control trajectories do. Despite achieving 90.6% full-cap accuracy (which is comparable to our FPRM reproduction), the symmetry-breaking control fails to halt under either QRR's native gauge-aligned residual criterion or FPRM's full latent residual criterion (this is mainly because, unlike FPRM, the control has no explicit adaptive damping controller). These results provide empirical evidence that QRR's gauge-equivariant architecture actually affects the learned spectrum of quotient dynamics, beyond enabling quotient-based halting.


2. Baseline results and reproducibility (W2 / Q1)

We thank the reviewer for highlighting this omission. We now added Appendix A.6 (Baseline Setup) in the revised manuscript, documenting task-specific training and inference configurations for all baselines.

We additionally conducted 3-seed reproducibility checks on Sudoku-Extreme. We identified a configuration mismatch in our initial FPRM reproduction (83.7%). We used non-official FPOPT decay/patience settings (0.99/5 instead of 0.997/10 in official setup). We corrected this mismatch and repeated full training following the official setup, obtaining 88.50% on average (now updated in Table 1 in revised version). Both released and reproduced checkpoints were evaluated using the same protocol, with a rollout cap of 35,000, residual threshold of 0.1, FPOPT decay/patience of 0.997/10, and minimum step size of 10−310^{-3}.

ModelSeed typeSeed 0Seed 1Seed 2MeanStd.
EqR releasedEvaluation89.3389.2089.0589.190.14
FPRM releasedEvaluation91.0990.9390.9891.000.08
FPRM reproducedTraining88.4188.5288.5888.500.09

3. Halting calibration, coverage, and runtime under matched setup (W2 / Q2)

We thank the reviewer for pointing out the missing threshold calibration protocol and runtime analysis details. We clarify how halting thresholds are calibrated and report full accuracy-coverage-runtime comparisons under matched conditions, including instances that reach the rollout cap.

Halting threshold calibration. For each trained model, we perform full-cap inference rollouts on a randomly held-out 10% of training examples and select the threshold that enables the earliest halting while keeping accuracy within a predefined margin of the full-cap accuracy.

Runtime comparison under matched conditions. The runtime comparison in Table 1(b) did not include cap-reached examples. Here, we provide a full accuracy-coverage-runtime comparison, both for halted instances and for all instances, including those reaching the rollout cap. Except for halting criteria, both models are evaluated on the same 4,228 held-out set of Sudoku-Extreme, with the same seed, maximum depth (35k steps), GPU (A100-40GB), and batch size (256). As a result, QRR achieves higher accuracy, substantially fewer false halts, and lower runtime under matched conditions.

ModelAcc at halt (%)Coverage (%)False halt (%)Halt step p50 / p95Runtime per board (ms), p50 / p95
Halted instances
FPRM (Mean)91.7998.988.21175 / 3,6497.7 / 158.5
FPRM (SD)1.150.831.1520 / 7460.9 / 32.5
QRR (Mean)99.8797.330.1326 / 6063.3 / 76.5
QRR (SD)0.210.630.211 / 1880.1 / 24.7
All instances
FPRM (Mean)91.7998.988.21184 / 4,7808.1 / 207.6
FPRM (SD)1.150.831.1528 / 5761.2 / 25.1
QRR (Mean)99.8797.330.1327 / 1,2673.4 / 159.4
QRR (SD)0.210.630.211 / 2690.1 / 34.0

Thank you for the additional experiments and clarifications, which substantially alleviate my main concerns. It would be helpful to report overall test accuracy, including cap-reached instances, and specify which FPRM checkpoint was used for the runtime comparison. I encourage the authors to include these details in the main results table or its caption.

Thank you for recognizing our efforts to address your concerns and for your constructive feedback. We will include the overall test accuracy, including cap-reached instances, and clarify the FPRM checkpoint used for the runtime comparison in the revised manuscript.

Reviewer_9SdwOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary

This paper asks whether oscillations in the latent trajectories of looped reasoners help with reasoning or merely slow convergence. Near a solution, the state splits into a slowly decaying oscillation (a flip in FPRM, a spiral in HRM) and everything else. The oscillation leaks into the rest, which keeps moving as long as the oscillation does, delaying any halting rule that waits for stillness. This is demonstrated for the linearized dynamics and confirmed in the trained models: removing the oscillation once near a solution causes the model to settle earlier by the predicted amount, yielding the same answer. But damping it throughout the run, before the answer forms, reduces FPRM accuracy by ~6 points, so oscillations cannot simply be suppressed.

The paper proposes QRR, a recurrent reasoner with an exact per-token phase symmetry. Motion along these symmetry directions is defined as irrelevant to the task state, so convergence and halting are measured in the quotient space that ignores it. The architecture builds gauge-equivariant attention, input injection, and feed-forward layers on an FPRM-style trunk and adds a momentum-based recurrent update.

On Sudoku-Extreme, Maze-Hard, Maze-Unique, and Mini-ARC, QRR reports the highest accuracy on three of four tasks and, on Sudoku-Extreme, reaches solution roots and halts much earlier than FPRM with far fewer false halts, giving faster end-to-end rollouts despite a higher per-step cost.

Critical strengths
  1. Earlier work had noticed that looped models oscillate. Near a solution, the paper predicts from the model's local linear behavior how much a slowly fading oscillation delays settling. It checks this in trained FPRM and HRM. It shrinks or removes the oscillation once, lets the model run unchanged, and the settling gains match the predictions. A random direction is used as a control. Another experiment damps FPRM's oscillation for the rest of the run. If it starts before the answer has formed, this hurts the accuracy. Damping a non-oscillating direction of the same size has no significant effect, and damping after the answer has formed does nothing. So the oscillation is a measured cost near the end (about 25% of FPRM's settling time and 12% of HRM's), but it can only be removed safely once we know the answer is formed. This is a standalone contribution, independent of QRR.

  2. On Sudoku-Extreme, QRR halts at a median of 27 steps instead of 122, with 0.1% false halts instead of 8.9% (Table 2b). A key reason it can halt this early is that it checks for convergence after ignoring per-token phase motion. QRR's raw state keeps moving long after its phase-free state has converged, so a rule that waits for the raw state to stop would keep running. The ablation with one shared phase for all tokens (Table 3) shows that the accuracy drops to 91%, but the model never halts, because a single phase cannot absorb the leftover motion.

Overall, the paper makes a clear and well-supported case, with the main open question being how far beyond these puzzle tasks and this one architecture the results hold.

Critical weaknesses

QRR's convergence and halting are measured in quotient space, after discarding gauge motion, while baselines are measured on the raw latent state. The quotient is justified for QRR by construction, but the paper's own results show FPRM also carries latent motion that does not change its decoded output (Sec. 3.2, A.4.4, Table 4), and that this motion is what delays its halting (Sec. 4.2). The paper does not report how long after output stabilization FPRM halts. Fig. 5c suggests most of the gap is in the test, not the dynamics; once FPRM's slow mode is factored out, it settles about 15% later than QRR, yet it halts about 4.5x later. The system-level comparison is fair, but the paper attributes the gain to the symmetry, and two things changed at once: the architecture and the convergence test. The paper already identifies when FPRM's output stabilizes (A.4.4); reporting how long FPRM runs past that point, or halting both models on a common readout-level rule, would show how much of the gap is the architecture.

Questions for authors

Some baseline numbers in Table 1 differ from what the baselines' own papers report (e.g., EqR: 89.9% versus its single-trajectory value of 93.0% at D=64). The paper provides only the rollout caps for the matched evaluations and no hyperparameters for the reproductions; FPRM's accuracy, in particular, is known to depend on its step-size controller settings. Could you state, for each baseline, the checkpoint or training configuration used, the inference settings (depth or cap, halting threshold, and controller parameters), and how these compare to the original papers, so the Table 1 numbers can be reproduced?

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 9Sdw

We thank the reviewer for recognizing the contributions of QRR and providing constructive feedback to further improve our work. We address each point below.

1. Architecture vs Stopping Criterion (W1)

We thank the reviewer for pointing out the confounding effects of architecture and halting criteria on practical effectiveness of QRR. To disentangle the two effects, we conducted two analyses using FPRM (released checkpoint) and QRR on 4,228 Sudoku-Extreme held-out instances, comparing the halting statistics under both native stopping criteria and a common stopping rule based on output stabilization (35k cap).

We define τout\tau_{\mathrm{out}} as the first step after which the decoded output remains unchanged until the cap, and measure Δτ=τhalt−τout\Delta\tau=\tau_{\mathrm{halt}}-\tau_{\mathrm{out}} for instances halting after stabilization. QRR halts much closer to output stabilization step than FPRM, with shorter delays at both p50 (12 vs 23 steps) and p95 (16 vs 304 steps). QRR also halts before final output stabilizes much less frequently (0.07% vs. 6.1%), demonstrating more reliable solution convergence.

MetricFPRMQRR
τhalt\tau_{\mathrm{halt}} p50/p95120 / 3,66327 / 886
τout\tau_{\mathrm{out}}, p50/p9516 / 12,34415 / 1,960
Δτ\Delta\tau, p50/p9523 / 30412 / 16
Halted after stabilization93.9%97.7%
Halted before stabilization6.1%0.07%

We further isolate and assess the architecture-driven benefit of QRR by applying identical stopping criteria to both models, independently of their native stopping rules. The common rule applied is defined as the first step tt that satisfiy  y^t−W+1=⋯=y^t\,\hat y_{t-W+1}=\cdots=\hat y_t, where y^t\hat y_t denotes the entire decoded Sudoku grid and persistence window W∈{6,24,128}W\in\{6,24,128\}.

RuleFPRM Acc (%)FPRM Halt step p50/p95QRR Acc (%)QRR Halt step p50/p95
Native91.23120 / 3,66397.7327 / 886
W=6W=691.1321 / 3,61197.7820 / 876
W=24W=2491.5139 / 6,48097.7838 / 894
W=128W=12891.65143 / 9,13597.78142 / 998

Under a common stopping rule, QRR' s median halting-time advantage largely disappears (4.44×→1.01−1.05×4.44\times\rightarrow 1.01-1.05\times). Crucially, QRR retains a substantial advantage in harder instances with longer tail (7.25×7.25\times at W=24W=24) while achieving higher accuracy, providing evidence that its benefit is not solely due to stopping-rule efficiency and extends to faster reasoning output stabilization, especially for more challenging instances.


2. Baseline results and reproducibility (Q1)

We thank the reviewer for highlighting this omission. We now added Appendix A.6 (Baseline Setup) in the revised manuscript, documenting task-specific training and inference configurations for all baselines. We additionally conducted 3-seed reproducibility checks on Sudoku-Extreme. The small deviations across seeds indicate stable evaluation results for the released checkpoints and consistent training outcomes for our FPRM reproduction.

  • EqR: We evaluated the released checkpoint with a single trajectory at D=64D=64. Using the official evaluate.py on the full test set, we obtained 89.19%, consistent with our reported 89.9% but below the original paper' s 93.0%.

  • FPRM: We thank the reviewer for pointing out this discrepancy, which helped us identify a configuration mismatch in our initial reproduction (83.7%). We used non-official FPOPT decay/patience settings (0.99/5 instead of 0.997/10 in official setup). We corrected this mismatch and repeated full training following the official setup, obtaining 88.50% on average (now updated in Table 1 in revised version). Both released and reproduced checkpoints were evaluated using the identical protocol, with a rollout cap of 35,000, residual threshold of 0.1, FPOPT decay/patience of 0.997/10, and minimum step size of 10−310^{-3}.

ModelSeed typeSeed 0Seed 1Seed 2MeanStd.
EqR releasedEvaluation89.3389.2089.0589.190.14
FPRM releasedEvaluation91.0990.9390.9891.000.08
FPRM reproducedTraining88.4188.5288.5888.500.09

Thank you for the response and for running the new analyses.

On the halting question, I think the new results mostly confirm what I suspected. Once both models are stopped by the same readout rule, they halt at almost the same step at the median (FPRM 21, QRR 20), and FPRM loses essentially no accuracy. So at the median, the gap reported in the paper (QRR 27 vs FPRM 122) stems from how convergence is tested, not from the dynamics. Since QRR is about 1.5x more expensive per step, FPRM would actually be faster in wall-clock time at the median under the same rule.

I agree QRR still looks better in the tail, but I’m not sure that reflects faster reasoning. FPRM gets about 9% of boards wrong, so its 95th-percentile board is probably one it never solves. QRR gets only about 2% wrong, so its 95th-percentile board is almost certainly one it does solve. The p95 gap may therefore just be the accuracy gap showing up again. Could you report the tail only on boards that both models solve? It would also be good to see these tables in the paper, an FPRM row with the readout rule in Table 1(b), and the “faster convergence” wording adjusted to match. It would help to say what quotient halting buys over simply checking the readout.

On the baselines, thanks for updating the manuscript to show the task-specific training and inference configurations.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to Follow-up Questions from Reviewer 9Sdw

Thank you for this constructive follow-up. Your suggestions helped us better understand where QRR's gains actually come from. To address the further concern that QRR's tail advantage just reflects FPRM's higher error rate taking longer computation, we restricted the comparison to instances correctly solved by both models and compare their halting times under native and identical output-based stopping rules.

To ensure a more comprehensive and reliable comparison, we extended the analysis from the original 10% held-out subset (4,228) to the entire test set (42,279), evaluating both models on the same instances. The number of boards that are correct by both FPRM and QRR is 38,318 (90.63%) in this extended analysis.

PercentileNative (FPRM / QRR)W = 6 (FPRM / QRR)W = 24 (FPRM / QRR)
p50103 / 25 (4.12×)21 / 18 (1.17×)39 / 36 (1.08×)
p75239 / 49 (4.88×)73 / 43 (1.70×)91 / 61 (1.49×)
p90459 / 174 (2.64×)443 / 168 (2.64×)461 / 186 (2.48×)
p95984 / 464 (2.12×)882 / 378 (2.33×)900 / 413 (2.18×)

QRR solves around x10 times more instances than FPRM (3,074 QRR-only vs 344 FPRM-only), while having far fewer false halts (0.09% vs. 9.03%). This itself is a key benefit of QRR's reasoning dynamics and quotient residual halting.

Even when restricting to 38,318 both-correct boards and applying identical output-stabilization criteria, QRR requires 2.48–2.64× fewer steps at p90 and 2.18–2.33× at p95. Thus, its tail advantage cannot be explained solely by FPRM's higher error rate or different effectiveness in stopping criteria.

While median halting times are comparable under a output-based rule, the benefit of faster convergence is more consequential for harder instances requiring substantially longer reasoning trajectories (roughly 5–10× longer at p90, p95 than at the median). In this regime, QRR's 2–3× reduction in tail computation can outweigh its ~1.5× higher per-step cost, yielding approximately 1.45–1.76× wall-clock speedup (31–43% less runtime).

Reviewer_6QHqOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates the convergence dynamics of looped reasoning models, identifying that slowly decaying oscillatory modes can impose their decay rate on coupled latent dynamics, creating a convergence bottleneck. To address this without disrupting reasoning computation, the authors propose QRR (Quotient Recurrent Reasoner), a gauge-equivariant recurrent architecture with exact per-token phase-rotation symmetry. This symmetry renders motion along gauge directions irrelevant to the quotient representation, allowing convergence and adaptive halting to be defined modulo the symmetry. Experiments on Sudoku-Extreme, Maze-Hard, Maze-Unique, and Mini-ARC demonstrate that QRR achieves faster convergence in quotient space and reliable adaptive halting while matching or surpassing recent baselines.

Critical strengths
  1. Rigorous Dynamical Diagnosis: The paper provides a precise mechanistic explanation for slow convergence in recurrent reasoners through Sylvester decomposition and causal intervention experiments (Figure 2, Figure 6). The quantitative agreement between local linear predictions and nonlinear rollout responses is exceptionally strong and offers genuine insight into test-time compute dynamics.
  2. Principled Architectural Solution: Rather than ad-hoc damping, QRR introduces gauge symmetry as an inductive bias that structurally decouples irrelevant rotational motion from reasoning-relevant quotient dynamics (Proposition A.2). This is theoretically cleaner and empirically safer than suppressing oscillations that may still support computation (Appendix A.4.4).
  3. Effective Adaptive Halting: The quotient residual-based halting criterion dramatically reduces false halts (0.1% vs. 8.9% for FPRM on Sudoku-Extreme) while cutting median end-to-end inference time by 2.8×. This demonstrates practical value beyond theoretical elegance.
  4. Honest Experimental Design: The authors acknowledge the limitation of multi-solution tasks by introducing Maze-Unique alongside Maze-Hard, and provide comprehensive ablations (Table 3) showing that each architectural component (token-local symmetry, momentum, gauge-equivariant trunk) is necessary.
Critical weaknesses
  1. W1: Fragile theoretical foundation under non-isolated solution geometries. The entire theoretical framework (Theorem 3.2, Sylvester decomposition, Proposition A.2) assumes an isolated solution root with a well-defined local Jacobian satisfying spectral separation ρ(A)<r\rho(A) < r. However, complex Transformer recurrences in realistic reasoning tasks frequently admit continuous solution manifolds, degenerate equilibria, or multiple attractors. The authors implicitly acknowledge this by restricting clean convergence analysis to Maze-Unique and Sudoku-Extreme (both guaranteed unique solutions). When the solution set is a manifold, the Jacobian has unit-modulus eigenvalues along tangent directions, violating the spectral gap condition and invalidating the rate-inheritance theorem. No theoretical or empirical analysis is provided for how QRR behaves when this foundational assumption fails.

  2. W2: Pure latent-space reasoning is misaligned with current scalable reasoning paradigms. QRR performs all reasoning in an opaque complex-valued latent space without generating any chain-of-thought tokens. This fundamentally conflicts with the dominant test-time compute scaling paradigm (e.g., DeepSeek-R1, OpenAI o1), which relies on explicit reasoning traces for process supervision, self-correction, and interpretability. The evaluation is confined to closed-form symbolic tasks (Sudoku, Maze, Mini-ARC) where answers are verifiable by exact match without intermediate justification. There is no evidence that QRR can handle tasks requiring explanatory reasoning, natural language generation, or integration with process reward models, severely limiting its relevance to the broader LLM reasoning community.

  3. W3: Quotient representation may collapse semantically distinct intermediate states. The gauge symmetry identifies all states on the same U(1)SU(1)^S orbit as equivalent, but this equivalence is defined solely by readout invariance, not semantic faithfulness. During multi-step reasoning, there may exist intermediate states that are semantically distinct (e.g., different partial assignments in Sudoku, different hypothesized rules in Mini-ARC) yet happen to lie on the same gauge orbit. The quotient map would collapse these into a single point, potentially destroying information necessary for correct reasoning. The paper provides no metric or experiment verifying that the quotient representation preserves semantic injectivity along reasoning trajectories, nor analyzes whether the chosen U(1)SU(1)^S symmetry accidentally aligns with task-relevant structure in ways that cause harmful representational collapse.

  4. W4: Supervised training with exact-match targets limits applicability to real-world reasoning. QRR is trained with exact sequence accuracy against ground-truth solutions (Section A.5.1), requiring complete labeled trajectories. This precludes application to settings where only outcome-level rewards are available (e.g., RLHF, GRPO) or where reasoning paths are not uniquely determined. Combined with W2's lack of CoT, this means QRR cannot leverage the vast majority of modern reasoning training infrastructure. The paper does not discuss how the gauge-equivariant architecture interacts with reinforcement learning objectives, reward shaping, or self-play, leaving its compatibility with scalable post-training entirely unexplored.

Questions for authors
  1. Q1 (Corresponds to W1): Can you provide theoretical or empirical analysis of QRR's behavior when the solution set is non-isolated (e.g., a continuous manifold or discrete multi-solution set)? Specifically, does the spectral separation condition ρ(A)<r\rho(A) < r hold in such cases, and if not, what guarantees remain for quotient convergence and halting reliability? Have you analyzed the local Jacobian spectrum at certified roots in Maze-Hard (which admits multiple optimal paths) rather than only Maze-Unique?

  2. Q2 (Corresponds to W2): How do you envision QRR being integrated with or contributing to the dominant CoT/process-supervision paradigm for scalable reasoning? Is there a pathway to decode quotient-space trajectories into interpretable reasoning steps, or to use QRR as a latent "thinking" module within a larger CoT-generating system? Without such a connection, what is the intended deployment scenario for pure latent reasoning in 2027?

  3. Q3 (Corresponds to W3): What evidence exists that the quotient representation preserves sufficient semantic discrimination during multi-step reasoning? Have you measured whether distinct intermediate reasoning states (e.g., different partial Sudoku assignments or different Mini-ARC rule hypotheses) are ever collapsed onto the same quotient point? Could you propose and compute a metric for semantic injectivity of the quotient map along reasoning trajectories?

  4. Q4 (Corresponds to W4): How does the gauge-equivariant architecture interact with non-exact-match training objectives, such as outcome-level RL rewards or process reward models? Have you attempted training QRR with any form of reinforcement learning or self-play, and if so, what challenges arose from the combination of gauge symmetry and non-differentiable or sparse reward signals?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 6QHq (Part 1/2)

We thank the reviewer for careful reading of our work and for providing constructive feedback, which motivated us to re-examine our theoretical assumptions and further explore QRR's applicability to more generalized reasoning settings. We address each point below.

1. Clarification of the theoretical assumption and task robustness of QRR (W1 / Q1)

We start by clarifying that the existence of multiple solutions do not necessarily form a continuous manifold or prevent convergence to a fixed root. Each of the multiple solutions may correspond to distinct attracting fixed points, allowing individual trajectories to converge to one of them. If continuous fixed-points do form a manifold, its tangent directions form unit eigenmode, which violates the spectral regime ρ(A)<r≤1\rho(A)<r\leq1 in Theorem 3.2. However, this is a condition for the oscillatory rate-inheritance result, not a requirement for QRR's structural guarantee. QRR's gauge-to-quotient decoupling follows from differentiability and gauge equivariance (Proposition A.2), and is independent of the spectral condition ρ(A)<r\rho(A)<r in Theorem 3.2. QRR’s gauge non-forcing quotient dynamics remain valid regardless of whether this spectral ordering holds.

Taken together, neither solution multiplicity nor the broken spectral ordering invalidates QRR's structural guarantee. Whether Maze-Hard’s multi-solution setting gives rise to a latent convergence regime distinct from those of Sudoku-Extreme and Maze-Unique therefore remains an empirical question. To investigate this, we examined the root convergence and local Jacobian spectra of numerically identified roots on Maze-Hard.

ModelCertified rootsRoots reached (%)Acc. on-root (%)Acc. off-root (%)Overall acc. (%)τroot\tau_{\text{root}} median [IQR]
FPRM916/100052.6 (482/916)92.5 (446/482)80.6 (418/518)86.4192 [172–232]
QRR787/100093.0 (732/787)95.8 (701/732)58.6 (157/268)85.8166 [124–219]

From the table, QRR reaches identified roots more frequently than FPRM (93.0% vs 52.6%), with earlier median arrival (166 vs 192 steps) and higher accuracy upon reaching them (95.8% vs 92.5%). Notably, despite lower off-root accuracy for QRR, both models still produce correct solutions without reaching the identified roots (58.6% and 80.6%). This suggests that the root convergence can't fully characterize successful reasoning on Maze-Hard, consistent with the existence of alternative solutions. In addition, the local Jacobian spectral analysis (Figure 12 in Appendix A.4.) shows that QRR exhibits fewer leading oscillatory mode satisfying ρ(A)<r\rho(A) < r (15% for QRR vs 59% for FPRM). This suggests that rate dominance of slow oscillatory modes is less prevalent in QRR's quotient dynamics compared to FPRM.

We further assess whether QRR's effective halting remains valid in Maze-Hard. QRR achieves 25.9 percentage points higher halting coverage and a 1.43×1.43\times lower median halting step, with comparable exact and valid-shortest-path accuracy, demonstrating its task-robust effectiveness in this multi-solution setting of Maze-Hard.

ModelHalt coverage (%)Halt step median [IQR]p95Exact acc (halted) (%)Exact acc (%)Valid acc (%)
FPRM52.230 [22, 51]13488.9 (464/522)86.491.3
QRR78.121 [19, 25]5989.6 (700/781)85.891.1

2. Connection to CoT and language reasoning (W2 / Q2)

We respectfully clarify that QRR is not intended as a CoT-generation framework. CoT extends reasoning sequence by autoregressively generating reasoning tokens, while looped latent reasoning repeatedly refines the latent representations of a given full sequence. QRR follows the latter, a well-established line of recurrent latent reasoning models, including HRM [1], TRM [2], EqR [3], and FPRM [4], which are mainly evaluated on reasoning benchmarks like Sudoku, Maze, and ARC. In addition, CoT is not universally beneficial across all reasoning regime. Prior work has also pointed out limited gains of CoT prompting, especially in smaller models [5]. In this setting, looped reasoning offers a distinct advantage that supports more efficient reasoning through repeated latent refinement, without relying on explicit CoT generation.

While CoT and looped reasoning like QRR operate through fundamentally different mechanisms, the two approaches are complementary. Looped refinement can augment the internal representation used to generate subsequent intermediate tokens. This offers a potential way to combining QRR's structural benfit with explicit reasoning traces extended by CoT. This complementarity has already been explored in prior work, where additional internal iterations improve performance on GSM8K with CoT prompting [6].

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 6QHq (Part 2/2)

3. Preserving intermediate semantic distinctions (W3 / Q3)

We thank the reviewer for raising an insightful question that quotienting gauge motion can collapse semantic distinctions between latent states. By construction, QRR is only invariant to gauge-equivalent states, while preserving distinctions in semantically-relevant quotient representations. To further address the concern, we also verify this empirically through semantic separation and perturbation analyses. See Figure 10 in Appendix A.4 of the revised manuscript.

  • Fig. 10(a) Semantic separation. Across 46,116 per-board Sudoku cell pairs, cell states that are close in quotient space make similar digit predictions at the current step and over the next 32 recurrent steps, while states with different predictions remain separated in quotient space. These results provide an empirical evidence against the collapse of reasoning-relevant distinctions in quotient space.

  • Fig. 10(b). Perturbation response. Gauge perturbations on states leave future predictions nearly unchanged, whereas transverse (non-gauge) perturbations induce substantial logit deviations and alter decoded outputs in 35–55% of states, showing that the QRR remains sensitive to changes outside the gauge orbit, while its predictions remain nearly unchanged under gauge motion.

Together, these results support that QRR' s quotient dynamics only removes task-irrelevant gauge motion while preserving semantic distinctions relevant to subsequent reasoning computation.


4. Compatibility with reward-based training (W4 / Q4)

We thank the reviewer for raising this point that help us generalize QRR's applicability to a Reinforcement Learning (RL) setup. QRR doesn't depend on a specific training objective and can be optimized using standard policy-gradient objectives. To assess compatibility with reward-driven training, we experimented QRR on the recently introduced Looped Actor framework [7], which directly adapts FPRM to PPO training that repeatedly refines latent states before selecting each action.

Specifically, we replaced Looped Actor's FPRM backbone with QRR and trained it on Rush Hour under the same PPO training and evaluation protocol. We compare success rates and the number of loops per action with the Looped Actor across three different seeds. QRR achieves comparable task success with fewer internal loops per action and more frequent early halting. These results support QRR's generalizability to reward-based PPO training and show that its practical benefits extend beyond supervised reasoning tasks.

ModelSuccess (%)Mean loops / actionEarly halt (%)
Looped Actor (FPRM [7])87.5±1.087.5 \pm 1.015.121.0
Looped Actor (QRR)88.2±0.188.2 \pm 0.114.3±0.014.3 \pm 0.030.2±0.130.2 \pm 0.1

We sincerely hope that we have addressed the concerns of the reviewer satisfactorily in the revised version and would kindly ask the reviewer to update their score accordingly.


References

[1] Wang et al., Hierarchical Reasoning Model, 2025.

[2] Jolicoeur-Martineau, Less is More: Recursive Reasoning with Tiny Networks, 2025.

[3] Huang et al., Equilibrium Reasoners: Learning Attractors Enables Scalable Reasoning, ICML 2026.

[4] Movahedi et al., Fixed-Point Reasoners: Stable and Adaptive Deep Looped Transformers, ICML 2026.

[5] Wei et al. Chain-of-Thought Prompting Elicits Reasoning in Large Language Models. NeurIPS 2022.

[6] Geiping et al. Scaling up Test-Time Compute with Latent Reasoning: A Recurrent Depth Approach. NeurIPS 2025.

[7] Rusch et al. Looped Actor: Depth-Recurrent Reasoning Models for Reinforcement Learning. arXiv preprint arXiv:2609.37432, 2026.

Dear Reviewer 6QHq, We would appreciate it if you could review our responses and let us know if any concerns remain. If your concerns have been addressed, we kindly ask you to consider updating your score accordingly. Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response to the Reviewers

We would like to thank all three reviewers for their careful reading and constructive feedback. We appreciate their recognition of our dynamical analysis on rate-inheritance of slow oscilloatory modes as “exceptionally strong” (6QHq) and a “standalone contribution, independent of QRR” (9Sdw). We also appreciate the recognition of QRR as a “principled architectural solution” (6QHq) that provides a “principled basis for quotient-based halting” (tDyW). We are glad that reviewer 6QHq highlighted its practical benefits, including fewer false halts and inference speedup, and appreciated our comprehensive ablations and evaluation across various reasoning tasks.

The reviewers’ suggestions helped us clarify the scope of our theoretical guarantees and strengthen our empirical evaluation. We further conducted analyses of semantic preservation and symmetry breaking effect in learned dynamics. We also reported full accuracy-coverage-runtime comparisons under matched conditions and clarified the baseline reproduction configurations and halting calibration protocol used. We answer the points raised by each of the reviewers individually in our comments below. Please note that all the references to page numbers, sections, figures, tables, equation numbers and references, refer to those in the revised version. We hope these clarifications and additional results address the reviewers’ concerns and encourage them to reconsider their assessments.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.